CourtListener 10661806•People v. Alvarez CA4/3
Texto completo
Filed 8/27/25 P. v. Alvarez CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G063734
v. (Super. Ct. No. BAF004654)
JAIME PEREZ ALVAREZ, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from a postjudgment order of the Superior Court of
Riverside County, Thomas Kelly, Judge. Reversed and remanded with
directions.
Kirstin M. Ault, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Laura G.
Baggett and Robin Urbanski, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* * *
In 2008, Jaime Perez Alvarez was sentenced to a term of 140
years to life. In December 2023, Alvarez appeared before the trial court
regarding his eligibility for recall and resentencing under Penal Code section
1172.75 (all undesignated statutory references are to this code). Alvarez
argued he qualified under section 1172.75 because his abstract of judgment
listed a commitment of five years for an enhancement under section 667.5,
subdivision (b). The parties disputed whether this five-year enhancement
listed on the abstract of judgment was mistakenly reported on the abstract as
being pursuant to section 667.5, subdivision (b), instead of section 667,
subdivision (a).
Without apparent access to the transcript of the original
sentencing hearing, the trial court ordered, on December 19, 2023, the
abstract of judgment to be corrected such that the five-year enhancement
imposed under section 667.5, subdivision (b) was corrected to be a five-year
enhancement imposed pursuant to section 667, subdivision (a). On our own
motion, we take judicial notice of the portion of the record in Alvarez’s prior
appeal that contains the reporter’s transcript from the original sentencing
hearing, which confirms the trial court properly corrected a clerical error on
the abstract of judgment. However, the December 19, 2023 minute order does
not accurately reflect what the trial court ordered at the December 19, 2023
hearing, and thus, we conclude the minute order should be corrected.
Additionally, by only ordering the correction of a clerical error,
the trial court effectively denied relief to Alvarez under section 1172.75. Yet
the transcript of the original sentencing hearing also reflects the sentencing
2
court imposed a one-year term under section 667.5, subdivision (b) and struck
the punishment. As the trial court and the parties do not appear to have had
the original sentencing transcript when addressing whether Alvarez is
eligible for recall and resentencing under section 1172.75, we reverse the trial
court’s denial of relief and remand to the trial court for further proceedings
regarding whether Alvarez is eligible for recall and resentencing under
section 1172.75.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
In 2007, Alvarez was convicted of six counts of violating section
288, subdivision (b)(1) (counts 1 through 6) and two counts of violating
section 269, subdivision (a)(5) (counts 7 and 8). The minute order from the
original February 29, 2008 sentencing hearing indicated the sentencing court
imposed consecutive terms of 25 years to life on counts 1 through 4 and
consecutive terms of 15 years to life on each count 7 and 8. The sentencing
court also imposed a term of 25 years to life on each count 5 and 6, which
were stayed pursuant to section 654, and the sentencing court imposed five
years on “Prior 1” and five years on “Prior 2.”1 Thus, the total sentence was
140 years to life. The March 4, 2008 abstract of judgment reflected this total
1 The information did not label priors as “Prior 1” or “Prior 2.”
The information alleged: (1) a “prior offense” of a prison prior under section
667.5, subdivision (b) based on a conviction for attempted murder; (2) a “first
serious prior offense” under section 667, subdivision (a) based on a conviction
of attempted murder; (3) a “second serious prior offense” under section 667,
subdivision (a) based on a conviction for assault with a deadly weapon; (4) a
“first special prior offense” under section 667, subdivisions (c) and (e)(2)(A)
and section 1170.12, subdivision (c)(2)(A) based on a conviction for attempted
murder; and (5) a “second special prior offense” under section 667,
subdivisions (c) and (e)(2)(A) and section 1170.12, subdivision (c)(2)(A) based
on a conviction for assault with a deadly weapon.
3
sentence, and relevant here, listed enhancements of five years for a “667(A)”
and five years for “667.5(B).”
Alvarez appealed the judgment, and a panel of this court
modified Alvarez’s sentence by staying counts 2 and 5, as opposed to counts 5
and 6, under section 654. (People v. Alvarez (2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 999,
1007.) The judgment was affirmed in all other respects. (Id. at p. 1002.) In
the statement of facts section of the opinion, the panel of this court noted the
sentencing court had “added 10 years for the two prior serious felony
convictions, under section 667, subdivision (a).” (Id. at p. 1003.)
After the appeal, there were new abstracts of judgment issued,
dated March 9, 2010 and April 1, 2011. These abstracts continued to list the
enhancements as five years for “667(A)” and five years for “667.5(B).”
On December 1, 2023, the parties appeared before the trial court
as to Alvarez’s eligibility for recall and resentencing under section 1172.75.2
At the initial hearing that day, Alvarez’s attorney asserted he was eligible
under section 1172.75 because his most recent abstract of judgment included
an enhancement under section 667.5, subdivision (b), and the proper sentence
was 135 years to life once the five-year enhancement under section 667.5,
subdivision (b) was stricken. The prosecution, however, said the abstract only
needed to be corrected to show the sentencing court imposed five years for a
“nickel prior.” The trial court stated it will indicate any section 667.5,
subdivision (b) enhancement is stricken and found the sentencing court had
2 The Attorney General notes the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation had identified Alvarez as potentially eligible for resentencing
relief. This communication by the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation is not in the record on appeal.
4
wrongly imposed five years for that enhancement.3 Later that same day,
another hearing occurred before the trial court. The prosecution argued the
prior appeal indicated “the strike prior was not under” section 667.5,
subdivision (b) and was instead under section 667, subdivision (a). The trial
court set a hearing later that month.
On December 19, 2023, the parties again argued before the trial
court. The prosecution asserted there was a mistake in the abstract of
judgment and it should be corrected to reflect two enhancements were
imposed under section 667, subdivision (a). Alvarez’s counsel asserted the
abstracts of judgment, including the one that predated the appellate opinion,
continued to list a five-year enhancement under section 667.5, subdivision (b)
and Alvarez is serving a five-year sentence for a prison prior. The trial court
asked what the People’s position was, to which the prosecution said the trial
court “should order that the abstract be corrected to reflect 667(a), nickel
prior.” The trial court responded, “That will be the order.”
A December 19, 2023 minute order indicated it was a “Hearing
re: Recall / Resentencing [PC 1172.7(a)/1172.75(a)]” and there was an “[o]ral
motion by defense [r]e address prison prior,” which the “People do not
oppose.” The minute order noted “Motion/Petition granted” and “[s]entence
previously imposed is vacated as to Prior 01.” The minute order further
noted, inter alia: “Prior is vacated as it should reflect as [¶] a 667(A) PC”;
“[t]he court finds prior 3 should have been [¶] found true on [February 29,
2008]”; “Court finds Prior(s) 06 True”; “As to the Prior 06, the Court imposes
3 Alvarez’s counsel also noted “[w]e do not otherwise need a
resentencing date” because Alvarez “is ineligible for all other legal changes
that have occurred.”
5
[five] years”; “Prior 06 to run consecutive to sentence imposed in Count 1”;
and “Court orders amended abstract be issued.”
On December 29, 2023, an amended abstract of judgment was
issued, which now listed two enhancements of five years as “PC 667(A).”
DISCUSSION
Under former section 667.5, subdivision (b), trial courts were
instructed “to ‘impose a one-year term for each prior separate prison term or
county jail term’ served for a felony,” except “for a five-year period of freedom
from custody and felony offenses.” (People v. Rhodius (2025) 17 Cal.5th 1050,
1054 (Rhodius).) “Effective January 1, 2020, the Legislature eliminated these
one-year prior-prison-term enhancements except in cases involving prior
terms for sexually violent offenses. [Citation.] Two years later, the
Legislature made the change retroactive. [Citation.] In . . . section 1172.75,
the Legislature declared that, aside from enhancements imposed for sexually
violent offenses, ‘[a]ny sentence enhancement that was imposed prior to
January 1, 2020, pursuant to’ . . . section 667.5, subdivision (b) ‘is legally
invalid.’ [Citation.] In the same provision, the Legislature established a
mechanism for resentencing individuals ‘currently serving a term for a
judgment that includes’ such an enhancement.” (Id. at pp. 1053–1054.)
In his initial briefing on appeal, Alvarez asserts the abstract of
judgment listed an enhancement for five years under section 667.5,
subdivision (b), and thus, the trial court should have struck that five-year
enhancement. Alvarez contends the “2008 abstract of judgment contains an
error in its listing of the enhancements because the defendant cannot receive
a [five-year] sentence under” section 667.5, subdivision (b), but without a
transcript from the original sentencing hearing, it is not clear whether the
sentencing court intended to impose one enhancement under section 667.5,
6
subdivision (b) and one enhancement under section 667, subdivision (a), or
two enhancements under section 667, subdivision (a). Conversely, the
Attorney General argues the trial court appropriately corrected an error in
the abstract of judgment. The Attorney General argues the abstract’s
“reference to a prison prior under section 667.5, subdivision (b), is clearly an
error because imposition of a five-year term for that enhancement was not
permitted by law,” and instead, “the most reasonable interpretation of the
court’s original sentencing order is that it intended to impose five years for a
serious felony prior” under section 667, subdivision (a).
The issue appears to stem at least in part from the parties not
having the transcript from the original sentencing hearing to determine
whether the earlier abstracts of judgment contained a clerical error or
reflected what the original sentencing court actually intended to impose. On
our own motion, we take judicial notice of the portion of the record in
Alvarez’s prior appeal case No. G040739 that contains the reporter’s
transcript of the February 29, 2008 hearing. (Evid. Code, § 459.)4 At the
original sentencing hearing, the sentencing court imposed a total sentence of
130 years to life for the substantive counts. Regarding the priors, the
sentencing court stated: “On the priors, under 667(a), there are two of them,
each of them carry a mandatory sentence of [five] years each. They must be
run consecutive to the time that the [c]ourt imposed and, also, to each other.
And so there’s an additional 10-year determinate term. So the actual total
aggregate term would be 140 years to life.”
4 At our invitation, the parties also filed supplemental briefing as
to what impact the transcript of the original sentencing court’s orders had in
respect to the issues on appeal.
7
Thus, the transcript confirms the earlier abstracts of judgment
contained a clerical error by listing a five-year term under section 667.5,
subdivision (b). Instead, the original sentencing court imposed two 5-year
terms under section 667, subdivision (a). At the December 19, 2023 hearing,
the trial court properly ordered the correction of the clerical error so the
abstract would reflect a five-year enhancement under section 667,
subdivision (a) instead of section 667.5, subdivision (b).5 (See People v.
Mitchell (2001) 26 Cal.4th 181, 185 [“[c]ourts may correct clerical errors at
any time”].)
The Attorney General contends, and we agree, the December 19,
2023 minute order does not accurately reflect what the trial court ordered at
the December 19, 2023 hearing. For example, the minute order refers to
granting Alvarez’s “Motion/Petition” and finding true a prior, which did not
occur at the hearing. The minute order should be corrected to reflect what the
trial court ordered at the December 19, 2023 hearing, which was the
correction of the clerical error so the abstract would reflect a five-year
enhancement under section 667, subdivision (a) instead of section 667.5,
subdivision (b).
5 In his supplemental brief, Alvarez appears to contend the trial
court could not have known it was correcting a clerical error at the time
because it did not have the original sentencing hearing transcript. However,
even if the trial court did not have the original sentencing hearing transcript
at that time, it reached the correct result of correcting a clerical error on the
abstract.
8
However, by only ordering the correction of the clerical error, the
trial court effectively denied relief to Alvarez under section 1172.75.6 Notably,
the transcript from the original sentencing hearing also shows the sentencing
court imposed a one-year term under section 667.5, subdivision (b) and struck
the punishment.7 This raises the potential issue of whether Alvarez is eligible
for resentencing under section 1172.75. (See Rhodius, supra, 17 Cal.5th at
p. 1066, fn. 2 [noting “appellate cases have addressed the application of
section 1172.75 where prior-prison-term enhancements were stricken and
where the punishment for the enhancements were stricken” but “[t]hese
issues [were] not before” the Supreme Court in that case].) As the trial court
and the parties do not appear to have had the transcript when addressing
whether Alvarez is eligible for recall and resentencing under section 1172.75,
we reverse the trial court’s denial of relief and remand to the trial court for
further proceedings regarding whether Alvarez is eligible for recall and
resentencing under section 1172.75.
DISPOSITION
The trial court is directed to prepare and file an amended minute
order of the December 19, 2023 hearing to correctly reflect the trial court’s
orders on December 19, 2023. The trial court’s denial of relief for Alvarez
6 Although the trial court did not expressly state it was denying
relief under section 1172.75, whether Alvarez was eligible for relief under
section 1172.75 is what brought the parties before the trial court.
7 The original sentencing court stated: “As far as the priors are
concerned, the prior under 667.5(b), the [c]ourt would impose one year. That
is stayed pursuant—and punishment stricken.”
9
under section 1172.75 is reversed and the matter is remanded to the trial
court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
MOORE, J.
SCOTT, J.
10
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.