CourtListener 10661780•In re K.T. CA4/1
Texto completo
Filed 8/27/25 In re K.T. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
In re K.T. et al., Persons Coming D085582
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
SAN DIEGO COUNTY HEALTH (San Diego County
AND HUMAN SERVICES Super. Ct. No. J521505A,B)
AGENCY,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
E.T. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants,
M.T.,
Respondent.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Alexander M. Calero, Judge. Affirmed.
Leslie A. Barry, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendants and Appellants K.T. and L.T.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant E.T.
Linda Rehm, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Respondent M.T.
Claudia G. Silva, County Counsel, Lisa M. Maldonado, Chief Deputy
County Counsel, and Kristen M. Ojeil, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
K.T. and L.T. were removed from their mother E.T.’s care. The juvenile
court placed the children with their noncustodial father M.T. subject to the
continued jurisdiction of the court. K.T., L.T., and Mother contend the court
erred because placement with Father is detrimental to the children’s
emotional well-being. We conclude there was no error, and we affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Mother and Father married in 2009. In 2010, K.T. was born and in
2012, L.T. was born. In 2019, Father was arrested for domestic violence and
sustained a DUI. The following year, Mother and Father finalized their
divorce in New Jersey and split custody of the children 50/50. In 2021,
Mother and the children moved to San Diego.
In January 2024, San Diego County Health and Human Services
(Agency) received three referrals alleging abuse and general neglect by
Mother. The first referral included allegations that Mother drove “drunk and
high” with the children in her vehicle, that Mother did not feed the children,
that the home was unkept and dirty, and that she called the children names.
An investigation found insufficient information to substantiate the reports.
The second referral alleged Mother drove the children and a friend to the
mall while under the influence. Once K.T. realized Mother was drunk, she
called and asked her maternal aunt to pick them up. The referral was
evaluated out. The third referral in January alleged Mother was drunk and
engaged in a physical altercation with K.T. K.T. reported not feeling safe
2
with Mother and called her maternal aunt for help. The Agency determined
these allegations were inconclusive.
In February, the San Diego Police Department responded to a welfare
check after a third party called to report Mother left K.T. alone in the car for
over an hour outside of a fast-food restaurant. A police officer found Mother
at home drunk. That night, the children stayed with their maternal aunt.
The Agency concluded Mother was neglectful of the children.
In April, the Agency opened a voluntary services case to support
Mother with her substance use disorder, but she declined participation.
On October 16, L.T. found explicit text messages on Mother’s phone
between Mother and a neighbor. The messages consisted of several graphic
conversations in which Mother gave the neighbor permission to perform
sexual acts on her and her minor daughters and included revealing pictures
of then-thirteen-year-old K.T. and eleven-year-old L.T. K.T. and L.T.
reported feeling “scared, speechless, and grossed out.” The next day, K.T.
showed the maternal aunt the messages. The maternal aunt reported the
incident to the police.
On October 22, the Agency spoke with Father. He explained he had
believed Mother was back on track after the investigation relating to Mother
leaving K.T. in the car. Two days later, Father flew to San Diego and
expressed his desire to take the children to Delaware with him. He explained
he had a bedroom ready for them, made arrangements for them to start
therapy, and identified a school. Father created a safety plan with the
Agency, which included taking the children to his home. Father told the
Agency he was arrested for domestic violence allegations and for driving
under the influence several years earlier, but explained he took anger
management classes and received help for his drinking.
3
On October 25, the maternal aunt failed to produce the children at the
designated time and place for pickup by Father. Her husband confirmed she
left with the children, and he stated he did not know their whereabouts. The
Agency advised Father to call the police. On October 29, the Agency
informed the maternal aunt it had obtained a warrant to take the children
into protective custody, prompting her to return them. The next day, a family
court granted the maternal aunt temporary emergency custody of the
children.
On October 31, the Agency filed a petition under section 300,
subdivisions (b) and (d) of the Welfare and Institutions Code,1 alleging
Mother failed to protect the children from a substantial risk of sexual abuse.
(§ 300, subd. (b).)
At the November 1 detention hearing, the juvenile court granted the
Agency’s petition, finding a prima facie showing had been made that
continued care in Mother’s home was contrary to the children’s welfare. The
juvenile court also noted that the family court granted custody of the children
to the maternal aunt, and that Mother and the children opposed placement
with Father. The Agency requested placement with Father. The court
observed Father had done nothing wrong and there was no evidence of
detriment. However, the court explained it would not yet place the children
with Father to avoid “moving them to the other side of the country overnight”
while awaiting the dispositional hearing.
During forensic interviews conducted in October 2024, L.T. recalled
Father drinking, fighting, and yelling with Mother but denied any other
concerns. She stated she did not know Father and did not want to leave San
1 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
4
Diego, but she agreed to visit with him. K.T. expressed similar concerns
about not knowing Father or his wife and not wanting to leave her friends,
but she denied feeling unsafe when visiting Father. Mother recounted past
domestic violence by Father and did not want the children to leave the state,
but she did not oppose him visiting the children.
Father’s adult son, T.T., denied any concerns about the children living
with Father and stated he “plan[ned] to help out as needed” because the
children “deserve a better life and consistency.”
Father’s wife, C.T., expressed no safety concerns with Father, stated
they do not keep alcohol in their home, and shared Father only drinks
occasionally at a restaurant or golf course. She explained Father’s job
requires drug and alcohol testing, and he had never had an issue. C.T.
denied any domestic violence with Father and stated she would not tolerate
it. She confirmed they were willing and able to care for the children and had
a bedroom set up for them since March. She also shared that the prior visits
with the children had gone well and there were no issues.
On November 8, K.T. was diagnosed with anorexia nervosa. A doctor
referred her to the emergency room out of concern “her heart would stop.”
K.T.’s psychologist recommended family based treatment to address her
eating disorder. The psychologist explained family based treatment requires
the caregiver to be in charge of “all feeding, meal plans, calorie intake, and
hydration.”
On November 11, social workers visited K.T. while she was in the
hospital. K.T. stated both Mother and Father had been “mean” to her. She
did not remember how Father would discipline her, but she recalled being
spanked by him a long time ago. K.T. explained Mother would take her
phone away or spank her if she got in trouble.
5
On November 13, social workers met with L.T. at the maternal aunt’s
home. L.T. stated she did not remember living with Father before moving to
San Diego. Nevertheless, L.T. stated Father “used to drink and hit” her, but
she would feel “fine visiting with him every day for a few hours as long as it
was in San Diego.” She explained she did not want to go live with Father
because her friends are in San Diego. L.T. shared that during their summer
visit to Delaware, they went to Six Flags and on T.T.’s boat. L.T. explained
she felt safe with the maternal aunt.
On November 19, a social worker met with Father. He expressed
concerns regarding the children living with the maternal aunt because “they
are too close to [Mother]” and referenced an incident in which the maternal
aunt hit K.T. in the nose. He believed he could provide a safe environment
for the children.
During a family meeting with K.T.’s doctors, the doctors explained the
proposed treatment plan included hospitalization, residential treatment, and
outpatient care. The psychologist stressed the importance of K.T. living in a
home “where there has been no abuse” for the treatment to be successful.
Father inquired about Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia (CHOP), and the
psychologist said it was a great program. During a later meeting between
the social worker and psychologist, the psychologist described the maternal
aunt’s “eating beliefs” as unhelpful, but noted she was open to learning.
Similarly, the psychologist explained Mother’s visits to K.T. were not in
K.T.’s best interests. She noted there had been mention of some negative text
messages relating to Father but described Father’s commitment to learning
about K.T.’s treatment and locating CHOP as a positive indicator.
6
The social worker conducted additional interviews with the children’s
adult half-siblings and a cousin, all of whom stressed they had no concerns
with the children living with Father and denied he was abusive.
On November 22, the juvenile court held a special hearing at the
Agency’s request to renew its petition under section 361.2, subdivision (a) for
the children to be detained with Father. The court declined to modify the
detention orders because the jurisdiction and disposition hearing was
scheduled for December 2. The court encouraged Father to have as much
visitation and contact with the children as possible.
On December 2, the juvenile court held the jurisdiction and disposition
hearing. Father agreed with the Agency’s recommendations, renewed his
request to have the children detained with him, and asked the court to
admonish the maternal aunt for interfering with his visits and
communication with the children. The children, through their attorney,
opposed placement with Father and expressed similar concerns regarding the
maternal aunt interfering with their time with Father. The court ordered an
extended visit with Father over winter break.
On January 6, 2025, K.T.’s therapist spoke with the social worker
about K.T. and Father’s therapy sessions. The therapist described the
sessions as “pretty emotional.” The therapist noted K.T. and Father did a
good job listening to each other, are committed to having a better
relationship, and K.T. ended the session by telling Father she loves him.
On January 29, the juvenile court held a pretrial status conference
during which it denied the maternal aunt’s request to be declared a de facto
parent.
In February, the juvenile court held the contested jurisdiction and
disposition trial. K.T. testified she was doing well in her residential
7
treatment for her eating disorder, but she was concerned moving to Delaware
would trigger a relapse. She reiterated her desire to remain in San Diego
with her aunt and friends while denying any safety concerns with Father.
L.T. expressed similar concerns about leaving her aunt, Mother, and friends
and had no safety concerns about Father. The Agency maintained its
recommendation for placement with Father based on the lack of safety
concerns and his ability to care for the children.
Acknowledging the children had been vocal about not wanting to leave
San Diego, the Agency explained the children had been referred to therapy to
help them work on the relationship with their father and paternal family.
The Agency explained it had considered the emotional impact on the children
and assessed no safety concerns if placed in Delaware. Father testified he
located a nearby school for the children to attend in Delaware, identified two
possible programs for K.T. to continue her eating disorder treatment,
identified a therapy provider for L.T., and confirmed his insurance would
cover all services for the children. Father explained C.T., T.T., and a cousin
were able to assist with the children.
The juvenile court removed the children from Mother’s custody and
ordered their placement with Father. The court further ordered a transition
plan that was to take into account the children’s input as to travel
accommodations, therapy, visitation, and continuing education.
At the April 2025 family maintenance review hearing, the juvenile
court ordered Mother and Father to family court services mediation, set a
8
pretrial status conference, and set subsequent contested review hearings
regarding Mother’s request for custody of the children.2
DISCUSSION
K.T., L.T., and Mother contend the placement with Father in Delaware
is detrimental to the children’s emotional well-being, pointing to a purported
lack of “relationships and rapport with Father . . . [and] their exposure to
Father’s alcohol use and violence.”
A. Guiding Principles
If a dependent child would be at substantial risk of physical or
emotional harm if left in parental custody, but there is a noncustodial parent
who is willing to assume custody, the court must “determine whether there is
a parent of the child[ren], with whom the child[ren were] not residing at the
time that the events or conditions arose that brought the child[ren] within
the provisions of Section 300, who desires to assume custody of the
child[ren].” (§ 361.2, subd. (a).) If such a noncustodial parent exists, the
court is required to place the child with the noncustodial parent unless it
finds that doing so would be “detrimental to the safety, protection, or physical
or emotional well-being of the child[ren].” (Id. subds. (a) & (b)(1); In re Maya
L. (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 81, 97–99.)
Mother and the children, as the parties opposing placement with the
noncustodial parent, bore the burden of proof. They were required to show
detriment to the “ ‘emotional well-being of the child[ren]’ ” ”by clear and
convincing evidence that the child[ren would] be harmed if [Father was]
given custody.” (In re C.M. (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1401.) “Clear and
2 The Agency’s unopposed request for judicial notice of the juvenile
court’s minute orders dated April 8, 2025, May 5, 2025, May 27, 2025, June
12, 2025, and June 13, 2025, is granted. (Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (d), 459.)
9
convincing evidence requires a high probability, such that the evidence is so
clear as to leave no substantial doubt.” (In re Patrick S. (2013) 218
Cal.App.4th 1254, 1262 (Patrick S.).)
We apply the substantial evidence standard to review a juvenile court’s
detriment finding under section 361.2, subdivision (a). (Patrick S., supra, 218
Cal.App.4th at p. 1262.) The question before us is “ ‘whether the record as a
whole contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable fact finder could
have found it highly probable that the fact was true.’ [Citation.] We view the
record in the light most favorable to the prevailing party and give due
deference to how the trier of fact may have evaluated the credibility of
witnesses, resolved conflicts in the evidence, and drawn reasonable
inferences from the evidence.” (In re M.V. (2022) 78 Cal.App.5th 944, 960.)
We do not reweigh evidence or reassess the credibility of witnesses; instead,
we review the record for evidence of reasonable, credible and solid value such
that a reasonable trier of fact could find as the juvenile court did. (In re K.B.
(2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 972, 979.)
B. Analysis
The children and Mother argue the children would suffer detriment
with Father due to past domestic violence incidents between Mother and
Father, substance use in Father’s home, trauma to the girls from negative
interactions in Father’s home, and the emotional impact of moving to an
unfamiliar place with a parent they have not lived with in years. The
juvenile court noted those same concerns and relied on In re C.M., supra, 232
Cal.App.4th 1394, to conclude that “while the child’s wishes, sibling bond,
and the child’s relationship with the non[-]custodial parent may be
considered . . . none of those factors are determinative.”
10
Father acknowledged he was arrested for domestic violence in 2019
after Mother accused him of threatening to kill her, but he denied any intent
to cause her actual harm. He also explained that she later retracted her
claim. Father’s alleged threat was not directed at the children, and his
arrest did not result in conviction. Notably, there have been no allegations of
violence or abuse by the children or Father’s wife, and he has since completed
anger management classes. Thus, the evidence relating to the domestic
violence allegations does not support a finding of detriment. (In re C.M.,
supra, 232 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1404 [detriment finding not supported when
there was “no evidence of any recent, much less current, domestic violence by
father”].)
Similarly, Father acknowledged he drank heavily in the past but now
only drinks socially. He did not drink when the children were visiting him
because he feared it “would probably trigger them.” He denied using drugs
and explained his employer performs random drug and alcohol testing. His
wife attested they did not keep alcohol in their home. The Agency reported
“[no] evidence of prior alcoholism” by Father. Taken together, this evidence
shows that Father and his wife are aware and mindful of the children’s
exposure to alcoholism and strive to keep alcohol out of their home and away
from the children.
As to the claim that Father’s home is unfamiliar and that the children
have not lived with him in years, the evidence shows that the children have
had multiple visits with Father and to his home. While Father had reduced
contact with the children after they moved to San Diego in 2021, visits and
communication increased in recent years. In March 2024, Father and C.T.
set up a bedroom for the children in their home. In June 2024, the children
spent one week with Father in Delaware. In response to the reports of abuse
11
by Mother, in October 2024, Father flew to San Diego to request custody of
the children and provide a safe home away from Mother. Over winter break,
L.T. spent over one week with Father in Delaware. In January 2025, Father
and his wife travelled back to San Diego with L.T. K.T. reported visits with
Father “went okay.” Throughout this time, Father maintained contact with
the children through phone calls and texts. Moreover, K.T.’s therapist noted
that sessions with K.T. and Father are “pretty emotional,” that they do “a
good job listening to each other,” and that “they both seem committed [to a
better relationship].” Thus, the evidence shows that Father is making strong
efforts to maintain contact and build relationships with his daughters.
Although K.T. and L.T. do not want to move to Delaware with Father,
they have consistently denied any current safety concerns with him. Mother
does not account for the fact that the children’s hesitation to living with
Father is narrowly focused on potential social isolation, not because of Father
himself. As the trial court explained, the children’s wishes are important,
but they are not determinative. (In re C.M., supra, 232 Cal.App.4th at p.
1402; John M., supra, 141 Cal.App.4th at p. 1570 [14-year-old’s wishes not
sufficient].)
Mother, K.T., and L.T. did not meet their burden of proof. Considering
the totality of the circumstances, the record contains substantial evidence
supporting the court’s findings and orders.
12
DISPOSITION
The Superior Court’s orders are affirmed.
McCONNELL, P. J.
WE CONCUR:
O'ROURKE, J.
IRION, J.
13
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.