J.S. v. S.S. CA2/6

CourtListener 10657432Calctapp20 de ago. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 8/20/25 J.S. v. S.S. CA2/6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX

J.S., 2d Civ. No. B334820
(Super. Ct. No. 21FL01310)
Appellant, (Santa Barbara County)

v. ORDER MODIFYING
OPINION AND DENYING
S.S., REHEARING
[No Change in Judgment]
Respondent.

THE COURT:
It is ordered that the opinion filed herein on July 21, 2025,
be modified as follows:
1. On page 5, the first sentence of the last paragraph is
amended to read, “At the end of the hearing the court stated it
had ‘credibility issues with both these parties.’”
There is no change in the Judgment.
Appellant’s petition for rehearing is denied.

____________________________________________________________
YEGAN, Acting P. J. BALTODANO, J. CODY, J.
Filed 7/21/25 S.S. v. J.S. CA2/6 (unmodified opinion)

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

S.S., 2d Civ. No. B334820
(Super. Ct. No. 21FL01310)
Respondent, (Santa Barbara County)

v.

J.S.,

Appellant.

Appellant J.S.1 challenges the trial court’s denial of her
domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) request and its order
of joint legal and physical custody of minor child K. She contends
the trial court applied the wrong legal standard in denying her

1 We use initials to protect personal privacy in domestic

violence prevention appeals. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.90(b)(1).)
DVRO and declining to apply the Family Code section 30442
presumption against awarding custody to a parent who has
committed domestic violence in the previous five years. We
disagree and will affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
J.S. and S.S. were married seven years when they
separated in 2021. Their daughter M. was six, and their son K.
was four.
J.S. filed a request under the Domestic Violence Prevention
Act (DVPA) for a DVRO against S.S. (§ 6200 et seq.) She sought
an order for S.S. to move out of the family home, and an award of
sole legal and physical custody of M. and K. She supported her
DVRO request with a declaration alleging increasing patterns of
abuse by S.S. including sexual assault, stalking, harassment,
emotional, verbal, and physical abuse, and destruction of J.S.’s
personal property.
The trial court set a DVRO hearing and issued a temporary
restraining order (TRO) protecting J.S. and the children, giving
J.S. exclusive use of the home, and granting her temporary sole
legal and physical custody of M. and K. S.S. opposed J.S.’s DVRO
request, denied her accusations, and alleged she was using the
children against him.
J.S. was self-represented at the DVRO hearing and S.S.
was represented by counsel. The court, Judge Timothy Staffel,
examined J.S. regarding her DVRO request and the incident
prompting her to seek protection.
Judge Staffel made an “interim order without prejudice to
either party” dissolving the TRO, issuing temporary mutual non-

2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Family

Code.

2
CLETS3 stay away orders, ordering both parties to relinquish all
firearms to law enforcement and provide relinquishment receipts,
for J.S. and S.S. to limit communication to Our Family Wizard4,
and granting S.S. unsupervised visits with M. and K. every other
weekend.
Judge Staffel held an evidentiary hearing the following
month, at which both parties were represented by counsel, and
presented evidence and witness testimony regarding various
issues, including the allegations of domestic violence. At the end
of the hearing the court lifted the mutual stay away orders and
ordered the parties to conduct themselves “appropriately.” It
expanded S.S.’s unsupervised visits with the children and
admonished J.S. to support M.’s relationship with S.S. A
Findings and Order After Hearing (FOAH) memorializing these
orders was filed on November 3, 2021. It does not include a
finding of domestic violence nor apply section 3044.
Over the next two years, at least 23 hearings took place. In
September 2022, the matter was reassigned to Judge James
Rigali.
A four-day trial commenced February 23, 2023. On the
first day of trial J.S. asked to maintain the joint custody schedule
because K. was “doing extremely well . . . and he loves seeing his
father . . . .” On the second day of trial, J.S. asked the court to

3 “‘CLETS’ refers to the California Law Enforcement

Telecommunications System. Domestic violence restraining
orders (DVROs) are reported to law enforcement through this
system.” (In re Marriage of Reichental (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th
396, 399, fn.1 (Reichental).)

4 Our Family Wizard is an online platform designed to

facilitate coparenting communication.

3
make a finding of domestic violence and apply the section 3044
presumption. She conceded there was no pending domestic
violence restraining order but argued the court was not
prohibited from finding domestic violence occurred during the
marriage and making a finding under section 3044. S.S. objected,
arguing the issue was barred by res judicata.
The trial court chose to receive evidence of domestic
violence “to create a full record so that any reviewing court can
figure out what they think should be happening here.” The court
also indicated it would later decide how to address the issue.
After considering closing briefs and additional argument,
the court entered a judgment on reserved issues finding it “was
prevented from issuing a CLETS DVRO as requested by [J.S.]
against [S.S.] because of the dictates of ‘judicial canon’ and the
rule of ‘stare decisis,’” and thus “refused to rule on [J.S.’s]
request.” S.S. and J.S. were awarded joint legal and physical
custody of K. and a visitation schedule was set. The judgment
does not make a finding of domestic violence, nor does it apply
section 3044.
DISCUSSION
We review the grant or denial of a DVRO request for abuse
of discretion. (In re Marriage of G. (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 773,
780.) When we “‘review the trial court’s factual findings, we
apply a substantial evidence standard of review.’” (Ibid.) “We
draw all reasonable inferences in support of the court’s ruling
and defer to [its] express or implied findings when supported by
substantial evidence.” (J.M. v. G.H. (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 925,
935.) “‘Judicial discretion to grant or deny an application for a
protective order is not unfettered. . . . [W]hether a trial court
applied the correct legal standard to an issue in exercising its

4
discretion is a question of law [citation] requiring de novo review
[citation].’” (In re Marriage of F.M. & M.M. (2021) 65
Cal.App.5th 106, 116.)
J.S. contends Judge Rigali applied the wrong legal
standard in denying her DVRO based on an “erroneous belief the
DVRO had already been adjudicated.” S.S. contends the denial
was proper because J.S.’s DVRO request was denied by Judge
Staffel in 2021 and her 2023 request was an “attempt at a do-
over.” We conclude J.S.’s DVRO was fully adjudicated in
November 2021. Her failure to appeal that order precludes our
review.
On September 27, 2021 the court held a contested
evidentiary hearing addressing J.S.’s August 2021 DVRO request
and S.S.’s September 2021 Request for Order for sole custody of
the children due to parental alienation. Both parties examined
witnesses and introduced documentary evidence. J.S. was
examined by her attorney regarding her allegations of domestic
violence. S.S. testified regarding his claims of parental alienation
and his version of the abuse alleged by J.S. Counsel for both
parties made closing arguments.
At the end of the hearing the court stated it had “credibility
issues with both these parties,” and “the case started as an effort
to get an advantage of a family law case.” It ordered expanded
visitation for S.S. and said J.S. “should be encouraging that.” It
dissolved the mutual stay-away orders, said it needed to see a
“change in the attitude with the parties,” and ordered the parties
to behave “appropriately.” The court admonished J.S. to
facilitate visitation between M. and S.S. or else it would “rebound
back with respect to [J.S.].” The court did not indicate its orders
were interim or temporary, or that it was contemplating further

5
proceedings with respect to domestic violence. Written findings
and orders were made in November 2021 that did not find
domestic violence nor apply section 3044. This was a final
determination on the merits of J.S.’s DVRO request.5
J.S. contends Judge Staffel’s issuance of a temporary non-
CLETS stay-away order was error because only she requested
protection and “non-CLETS restraining orders are not allowed by
law.” But she did not appeal the court’s order. An order refusing
to issue a DVPA restraining order is appealable. J.S.’s failure to
file an appeal from that order precludes appellate review.
(Norman I. Krug Real Estate Investments, Inc. v. Praszker (1990)
220 Cal.App.3d 35, 46; Malatka v. Helm (2010) 188 Cal.App.4th
1074, 1082 [“an appellate court will not review earlier appealable
rulings”].)
J.S. alternatively argues she asserted “multiple new issues
that were not actually litigated and determined,” such as
evidence of litigation abuse and harassment, and these
allegations support the issuance of a restraining order and the
application of section 3044. But the court found otherwise. It
refused to issue a temporary restraining order. The final
judgment did not find any domestic violence nor did it apply
section 3044. (See, City and County of San Francisco v. H.H.
(2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 531, 541 [DVPA mandates application of

5 The parties’ subsequent conduct supports this was a final

ruling. Two years passed during which there were at least 23
contested hearings concerning child custody and property
division. J.S. filed five briefs identifying issues before the court
but none raised the DVRO request as an outstanding issue or
sought application of section 3044’s presumption. Interim child
custody findings and orders never applied section 3044.

6
the presumption upon any finding of domestic violence within the
previous five years].)
J.S. relies on select statements the court made after
hearing evidence suggesting it did or would have found domestic
violence occurred during the marriage. But the court never
indicated it found domestic violence based upon litigation conduct
or harassment and never stated section 3044 applied. Moreover,
“a judge’s comments in oral argument may never be used to
impeach the final order, however valuable to illustrate the court’s
theory they might be under some circumstances.” (Jespersen v.
Zubiate-Beauchamp (2003) 114 Cal.App.4th 624, 633.)
DISPOSITION
Judgment is affirmed. Respondent shall recover his costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

CODY, J.

We concur:

YEGAN, Acting P.J.

BALTODANO, J.

7
James F. Rigali, Judge
Superior Court County of Santa Barbara
______________________________

Ferguson, Case, Orr Paterson, John A. Hribar, for
Respondent.
Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, Lauren M. Blas, Gillian B.
Miller, and Kelsey Matevish; Family Violence Appellate Project,
Arati Vasan, Cory Hernandez and Jennafer Dorfman Wagner, for
Appellant.
Complex Appellate Litigation Group, Mary-Christine
Sungaila; Loyola Law School, Randee Barak, for Amicus Curiae,
California Women’s Law Center.

8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.