Vulich v. Vulich CA5

CourtListener 10625966Calctapp9 de jul. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 7/9/25 Vulich v. Vulich CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

SHARON VULICH, Individually and as
Successor Trustee, etc., et al., F088070

Plaintiffs and Respondents, (Super. Ct. No. 20CECG03175)

v.
OPINION
NORMAN VULICH,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno County. D. Tyler
Tharpe, Judge.
Daniel L. Harralson Law Office, Daniel L. Harralson for Defendant and
Appellant.
Miles, Sears & Eanni, Lyndsie N. Russell for Plaintiffs and Respondents.
-ooOoo-
Norman Vulich shot and killed his brother Jerry Vulich. Jerry’s survivors sued
Norman and prevailed in a jury trial. Norman appeals arguing the trial court abused its
discretion in denying motions to continue the trial. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
One day on the family farm, Norman shot and killed his brother Jerry. Law
enforcement promptly arrested Norman. The Fresno County District Attorney filed
criminal charges against Norman.1
Meanwhile, Jerry’s survivors sued Norman in this civil case for wrongful death.
The matter proceeded to trial nearly three years later.2
In the interim, Norman was represented by three separate counsel. Norman’s
second counsel took over the case in May 2022. About one year later, that counsel
moved to withdraw citing an “ill[ness]” and inability “to practice law.” Norman’s third
and final trial counsel substituted in in July 2023.3
New counsel quickly moved to continue the trial scheduled to begin on August 7,
2023. Counsel also sought to reopen discovery. Jerry’s survivors opposed, specifically
claiming “there [was] no good cause for a continuance or the reopening of discovery.”
The trial court granted the continuance, setting a trial date of March 4, 2024. The
request to reopen discovery was denied without prejudice.4
At the end of February 2024, Norman’s trial counsel moved to stay or continue the
upcoming trial. Counsel claimed he began to doubt Norman’s cognitive ability in late
December, about two months earlier. Counsel noted he was “awaiting receipt of an
opinion from a medical professional” regarding Norman’s “mental capacity.” He also
cited an inability for Norman “to testify due to the pending criminal case which will force

1 The criminal matter is ongoing and largely immaterial to this case.

2 The timeframe is measured from the last amended complaint to jury
empanelment.
3 Prior counsel’s motion to withdraw was granted on June 15, 2023.

4 The ruling is contained in a one page minute order. The matter was “argued and
submitted” but not reported.

2.
him to invoke his Fifth Amendment privilege[.]” In sum, he suggested that “[i]f [Norman
was] unable to assist … counsel … then he [would] be denied his rights to a fair hearing.”
The survivors opposed a continuance, noting Norman’s mental competence was
already resolved in criminal court where “[h]e was deemed fit to stand trial.”5 The
contested request proceeded to hearing.
Norman’s counsel asserted, in addition to the competence and privilege points,
“judicial economy” favored trying the case “in criminal court.” He lamented prior
counsel did little to represent Norman “for a good part of a year and a half[.]” Jerry’s
survivors feared further delay would jeopardize any ability to collect on a potential
judgment; although financial investigation revealed a prospect of recovery, that prospect
dwindled by the day.
The trial court noted prior counsel’s failure to “do anything [was]n’t unique to this
case,” citing “30 years” of apparent personal knowledge and labeling him as a
“continuance champion[.]” The court believed it heard “a lot of excuses but not a lot of
good cause.” It subsequently denied the request and confirmed the March 4 trial date.
Undeterred, Norman’s counsel again moved to continue the trial. This time the
request was based on an inability to serve subpoenas on allegedly material witnesses.
Counsel described issuing subpoenas one week prior to the trial date. All told, six
witnesses—all law enforcement—were not available. Counsel stated the witnesses’
involvement in the case. For example, one witness “was present during many key …
interviews[.]”6 Another “was … involved in interviewing” Norman,7 and another

5 Technically, the criminal court found “insufficient evidence” to doubt Norman’s
competence due to willful refusal to meet with a doctor.
6 This witness appeared at the trial.

7 This witness appeared at the trial.

3.
“accumulated much of the evidence.” The survivors again opposed, citing a lack of
“good cause” and a failure to “properly disclose[]” the witnesses prior to trial.
The trial court denied the motion “for five reasons.” One, counsel was dilatory in
requesting the continuance. Two, counsel was not diligent “in preparing the matter for
trial[.]” Three, counsel did “not demonstrate[] the materiality of any of the suggested six
witnesses.” Four, counsel failed to ever subpoena the witnesses “despite two trial dates
having come and gone and the current trial date having been known for about seven
months.” Five, the witnesses were not disclosed “in trial readiness disclosures,” making
it “unlikely they would be allowed to testify even if they were subpoenaed.”
As noted, the matter proceeded to trial as scheduled. The jury found in the
survivors’ favor, awarding them a combined nearly $2,800,000, plus costs and interest.
DISCUSSION
At issue are the two denied motions to continue the trial. Norman argues “the
judgment should be reversed and remanded due to [him] being denied his requests to
continue the trial[.]” Jerry’s survivors contend Norman “failed to establish that the trial
court abused its discretion[.]”
We need not address whether the trial court abused its discretion.8 We affirm
because Norman has failed to allege, let alone demonstrate, any prejudice.
“[U]nder article VI, section 13 of the California Constitution, ‘[a] judgment may
not be reversed on appeal ... unless “after an examination of the entire cause, including
the evidence,” it appears the error caused a “miscarriage of justice.” ’ [Citation.] The

8 We will note the trial court’s potential reliance on facts outside the record, i.e.,
its personal observations of prior counsel throughout the years, might constitute an abuse
of discretion if it truly relied on those facts rather than ruling solely on the record before
the court. It is unclear, however, how influential, if at all, the court’s personal
observations outside the record were to its ruling, and Norman’s counsel certainly sought
no clarity. We cannot conclude, based on this record, that there was shown any abuse of
discretion by the trial court.

4.
constitutional constraint, which applies in civil as well as criminal cases, ‘generally
“prohibits a reviewing court from setting aside a judgment due to trial court error unless
it finds the error prejudicial.” ’ [Citation.] This means that a litigant that might have
been able to establish error on interlocutory writ review, and thus secure a writ
compelling the trial court to conduct proceedings differently, typically will not be able to
secure relief on direct review of the court’s judgment without demonstrating both error in
the conduct of proceedings and ‘prejudice occasioned by the error.’ ” (TriCoast
Builders, Inc. v. Fonnegra (2024) 15 Cal.5th 766, 786; Freeman v. Sullivant (2011)
192 Cal.App.4th 523, 527-528 [“any error in failing to grant a request for a
continuance—whether mandatory or discretionary—is reversible only if it is tantamount
to the denial of a fair hearing.”].)9
At best, Norman raises the specter of his “mental capacity” and “the impact it had
on his … ability to assist … in the case.” No evidence supports an inference, let alone
proves, an impact on the case’s outcome. There exists no offer of proof anywhere in the
record.10 For example, counsel asserted a continuance was necessary because he was
“awaiting receipt of an opinion from a medical professional” regarding Norman’s mental
capacity. No such report is in the record.11
The only other salient claim raised is “the impact of [the] criminal case on
[Norman’s] ability to testify at the civil trial[.]” But “the fact that a man [or woman] is
indicted cannot give him [or her] a blank check to block all civil litigation on the same or
related underlying subject matter. Justice is meted out in both civil and criminal

9 Norman has not alleged any facts suggesting a constitutionally defective trial,
and we discern none on our own review.
10 We note Norman, in the same timeframe he is claiming mental incapacity,
executed at least one declaration and a personal waiver of his attendance at the trial.
11 The notice of appeal was filed more than two months after the final continuance
request was denied. There was no posttrial litigation.

5.
litigation.” (Avant! Corp. v. Superior Court (2000) 79 Cal.App.4th 876, 882.) More
importantly, again, no prejudice is demonstrated.
Finally, as to the unavailable witnesses, Norman never clearly states why those
witnesses were necessary or material. Rather, he, both in the trial court and on appeal,
simply incants their materiality because they were involved in the case. His incantations
do not demonstrate prejudice.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Appellate costs are awarded to Respondents.

SNAUFFER, J.
WE CONCUR:

PEÑA, Acting P. J.

DE SANTOS, J.

6.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.