CourtListener 10601165•People v. Gebauer CA2/3
Texto completo
Filed 6/9/25 P. v. Gebauer CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE, B331503
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. YA105929
v.
CRAIG DAVID GEBAUER,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Hector M. Guzman, Judge. Affirmed
in part, reversed in part, and remanded with directions.
Natalie Cohen and Andrew F. Alire, under appointments
by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters,
Chief Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey,
Assistant Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and David F.
Glassman, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
_________________________
Craig David Gebauer appeals from his conviction for
assault with a firearm, carrying a loaded firearm in a vehicle,
and carrying a concealed firearm in a vehicle under the
defendant’s control or direction. We affirm Gebauer’s conviction
for assault with a firearm, concluding the trial court did not
abuse its discretion in striking the testimony of a witness who
asserted her Fifth Amendment rights and refused to answer
questions. As to all three counts, we conclude the court erred
in permitting the prosecution to impeach Gebauer with a prior
conviction for simple possession of a controlled substance, but
that error was not prejudicial. Finally, we reverse Gebauer’s
conviction for carrying a concealed firearm in a vehicle, finding
the evidence was insufficient to prove he had control or direction
of the vehicle in which the firearm was found.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
1. Gebauer points a revolver at Carly Martinez
On May 25, 2022, around 9:00 p.m., Carly Martinez
parked her car on the street outside her residence. She got out
to see if she’d left enough space around the car. Martinez heard
someone shouting. She “kind of looked around and there was
another person a few cars behind [her], so [she] assumed that the
person who was yelling was yelling at that person.” The person
who was shouting—later identified as Gebauer—said, “ ‘Get your
ass over here.’ ” He seemed angry.
Martinez got back in her car to turn it off and gather
her belongings. She looked up and realized the person across
the street, who had been yelling, was holding a gun at waist
level and pointing it at her. She could see the barrel of the gun
pointed toward her. The gun looked like a revolver, but its barrel
was not as long as those in the old cowboy movies. Martinez
2
“saw a glint,” so she thought the gun was silver or gray in color,
“something that would catch the light.” That light came from
a streetlight; Gebauer was standing in front of a black BMW
stopped under the streetlight. The BMW was in a red zone
and seemed to be “idling, waiting.”
After Gebauer told the person a few cars away from
Martinez to “[g]et your ass over here,” he said, “Oh, I see you
brought your friends here,” apparently referring to Martinez.
The female Gebauer was yelling at then walked slowly back to
the BMW. Gebauer put the gun down, then he got into the front
passenger seat, the female got into the back seat, “and they left.”
Martinez couldn’t see the BMW’s driver.
Martinez ran to her house and called 911. She gave the
police descriptions of the car, including the license plate number,
the person who’d pointed the gun at her, and the gun.
Between 9:00 and 9:30 that night, Deputy Sheriff Angel
Ochoa went to Martinez’s home after receiving a call. Martinez
gave Ochoa “a partial plate on a vehicle and the description of
the suspect.” Redondo Beach police and “assisting units” from
the sheriff’s department then stopped the BMW. Ochoa took
Martinez to do a field show-up.
Ochoa searched the BMW. As he walked up to the
passenger side he saw a black holster on the sidewalk. Ochoa
found a revolver with live rounds of ammunition in it under the
passenger front seat. The footage from Ochoa’s body camera was
played for the jury at trial. The revolver was not registered to
Gebauer.
2. The charges, trial, and verdicts
The People charged Gebauer with assault with a firearm
on Martinez in violation of Penal Code section 245, subdivision
3
(a)(2)1 (count 1); carrying a loaded handgun, not registered to
him, on his person or in a vehicle in violation of section 25850,
subdivision (a) (count 2); and having a concealed firearm,
not registered to him, in a vehicle that was under his control or
direction in violation of section 25400, subdivision (a)(1) (count 3).
The People also alleged, under section 25400, subdivision (c)(6),
that the firearm was loaded and “unexpended ammunition
[was] in the immediate possession of, and readily available to,”
Gebauer.
Gebauer testified on his own behalf at trial. Gebauer
said he and his girlfriend Marissa McPheeters went to pick up
McPheeters’s daughter Alyssa. Gebauer got out of the car,
saw Alyssa, and called to her to “get [her] ass in the car.”
Alyssa came over, she followed Gebauer to the car, he got in
the front seat, Alyssa got in the back, “and we drove away.”
Gebauer denied having “pulled a gun” on Martinez,
having had a gun in his possession while he was standing
outside the car, or having held a gun at his waist while waiting
for Alyssa. He said he’d never seen Martinez before she came
to court. Gebauer admitted he had been in the car “where
that weapon was found.” When asked on cross-examination,
“So essentially you’re calling Ms. Martinez a liar; is that what
you’re saying?” Gebauer replied, “Yes.”
Gebauer testified he’d had the holster between the seat
and the door and, when he got out of the car, the holster fell
out onto the ground. Gebauer admitted the holster was for the
1 References to statutes are to the Penal Code unless
otherwise stated.
4
revolver and he’d put the revolver under the passenger seat
that day.
Alyssa McPheeters testified she didn’t see Martinez on
the street that night and Gebauer never had a gun in his hands.
Alyssa told the jury Gebauer was “a father figure” to her: “I see
him as my dad.”
The jury convicted Gebauer on all three counts. The court
denied Gebauer’s motion for a new trial and sentenced him to the
low term of two years in the state prison on count 1. The court
imposed the midterm of two years on count 2, to be served
concurrently with count 1. The court also imposed the midterm
of two years on count 3 and then stayed that sentence under
section 654.
DISCUSSION
1. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in striking
Marissa McPheeters’s testimony after she asserted
her right against self-incrimination and refused to
answer any questions about the gun
a. McPheeters’s testimony and invocation of her
Fifth Amendment rights
The prosecution called McPheeters as a witness in its case-
in-chief. McPheeters testified she was driving her black BMW
on May 25, 2022, around 9:00 p.m. McPheeters was going to pick
up her daughter Alyssa and Gebauer was with her. McPheeters
was “calling [Alyssa] frantically on the phone because [she]
could not find her.” Gebauer got out of the car and “was yelling
at [Alyssa] to get in the vehicle.”
McPheeters was looking down at her phone; Gebauer’s
back was to her. She “did not see him” because she was “looking
towards the left.” McPheeters testified she never saw Gebauer
5
point a firearm at anyone. She didn’t see anybody on the street
or anyone in a car on the street. McPheeters said she didn’t see
Gebauer with a firearm when he came back to the car, she was
not aware he had a firearm, and he never told her he did.
McPheeters testified she “recognize[d]” the holster but she
didn’t see it in the car nor did she see it fall “off of [Gebauer’s]
person” when he got out of the car at the traffic stop. McPheeters
testified the gun was her father’s and she kept it in Gebauer’s
safe, “a safe that we both used.”
Defense counsel began her cross-examination of
McPheeters and, after a few questions, the court recessed
for the day. After the jurors left, the prosecutor told the court
that it “may want to appoint Fifth Amendment counsel for
Ms. McPheeters.” The prosecutor said he hadn’t been aware
Gebauer and McPheeters were living together, and McPheeters’s
testimony that they shared the safe where the gun was kept
“gives rise to some criminal liability on her part” because
McPheeters must have known Gebauer, with a felony drug
conviction from Colorado, was not permitted to have a firearm.
When trial resumed, the prosecutor told the court he’d
spoken with McPheeters in the hallway and told her he’d “ask the
court to appoint her counsel, and it would need to be a criminal
defense attorney, because of the testimony.” The prosecutor cited
several provisions of the Penal Code that he said prohibited
“transferring a firearm to a prohibited person.”2
2 The prosecutor cited sections 26500, 27500, and 27545.
On appeal Gebauer concedes that at least section 27500 “could
expose Ms. McPheeters to criminal liability.” That statute
provides no person shall knowingly supply, deliver, or give
6
A short time later, attorney Paul Peters from the bar panel
appeared in the courtroom and the court appointed him to advise
McPheeters. After conferring with Peters, McPheeters took
the stand without the jury in the courtroom. In response to the
court’s questions, McPheeters testified she was asserting her
privilege against self-incrimination “pertaining to the firearm.”
The prosecutor then asked McPheeters, “[D]id you possess the
revolver that was discussed . . . [;] was that stored in your home?”
McPheeters replied, “I’m exercising my right to remain silent
about the firearm.” In response to the prosecutor’s next seven
questions, McPheeters stated, “Exercise the fifth.” At that point,
the court halted the questioning.
After McPheeters left the courtroom, the court stated,
“So now the witness has asserted her privilege against self-
incrimination. The issue now becomes whether her entire
testimony should be stricken.” The prosecutor asked the court
to strike all of McPheeters’s testimony and to instruct the jury
to disregard it. Defense counsel said she “believe[d] that her
testimony should stand as it is.”
The court stated,
“I don’t see how any of her testimony could be
left in without further inquiry into these issues
that are still outstanding, and primarily the
issue of the gun, where it was, who owned it,
all of those things . . . . I don’t see how I can
just leave that in there without complete direct
and cross-examination.”
possession of a firearm to any person who is prohibited by law
from possessing a firearm. (§ 27500.)
7
After a further colloquy with counsel, the court stated
McPheeters’s “assertion of her Fifth Amendment right” was
“properly asserted” and “well-taken.” The court said it was
“not going to force her to testify.” The court continued, “I cannot
allow her to testify partially on some issues but not have to deal
with what could be impeaching information. It doesn’t work
that way.” The court then brought the jury back in and told
them McPheeters’s testimony had been “stricken in its entirety”
and the jurors must disregard it and “must not consider that
testimony for any purpose.” The court denied Gebauer’s motion
for a mistrial.
b. McPheeters’s credibility was not a collateral matter
and the prosecutor’s questions—which she refused
to answer—were not peripheral to the case
“Generally speaking, a defendant is ‘not entitled to place
[his witness’s] testimony before the [trier of fact] free from any
threat of impeachment’ by the prosecution, even if the witness
has a valid Fifth Amendment privilege.” (People v. Seminoff
(2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 518, 527 (Seminoff).) There are, however,
“instances where the cross-examiner’s questions are so peripheral
to the case that the witness’s refusal to answer them does not
justify the sanction of striking [the witness’s testimony].” (Ibid.)
In deciding whether to strike a defense witness’s testimony based
on her refusal to answer one or more questions, the trial court
should examine the motive of the witness and the materiality
of the answer. (People v. Reynolds (1984) 152 Cal.App.3d 42, 47
(Reynolds).) The court should also consider if less severe
remedies are available before employing the “drastic solution”
of striking the witness’s entire testimony. (Id. at pp. 47–48.)
“Striking the testimony is the appropriate remedy in most cases;
8
a mistrial will not be granted unless incurable prejudice is
shown.” (3 Witkin, Cal. Evidence (6th ed. 2024) Presentation
at Trial, § 250.)
We review a trial court’s decision to strike a witness’s
testimony for abuse of discretion. (People v. Brooks (2017) 3
Cal.5th 1, 26, 30–32 (Brooks); Seminoff, supra, 159 Cal.App.4th
at pp. 525, 528; Reynolds, supra, 152 Cal.App.3d at p. 47.)3
3 Citing People v. Cromer (2001) 24 Cal.4th 889 and People
v. Sanders (2010) 189 Cal.App.4th 543, Gebauer contends our
review should be de novo. Cromer was a confrontation clause
case. Our high court held the standard of review for evaluating
a trial court’s determination of whether the prosecution had
exercised due diligence in trying to locate a witness, before
that witness’s prior testimony could be presented at trial, was
independent, de novo review rather than the more deferential
abuse of discretion test. (Cromer, at pp. 892–893.) Sanders
involved a challenge to a trial court’s order striking only part of
a witness’s testimony—rather than all of it—after the witness
refused on recross-examination to identify who told him another
suspect in a shooting was a gang member. The witness already
had testified at length on direct and cross-examination about
the shooting, his identification of the two shooters, and his
preliminary hearing testimony. (Sanders, at pp. 546, 550, 552–
553, 557.) The Sanders court concluded the trial court had
not erred in declining to strike the witness’s testimony after
he refused to answer one question on the collateral matter of
the source of the rumor. (Id. at p. 558.) While noting a trial
court “ ‘ought to have a measure of discretion in ruling on
[whether to strike testimony]’ ” when a witness refuses to answer
questions, the Sanders court stated in a footnote that its review
was independent rather than for abuse of discretion because the
appeal presented an issue of “federal constitutional error.” (Id.
at p. 554 & fn. 2.) The court did not discuss or distinguish cases
such as Reynolds that applied an abuse of discretion standard.
9
Gebauer contends McPheeters asserted her Fifth
Amendment right “solely as to where Mr. Gebauer stored his
firearm,” and that issue wasn’t “relevant or material.” Gebauer
reads the record too narrowly. The gun was a key issue in the
case. It was the weapon the victim testified had been pointed
at her, and it was the subject of two felony charges for the
possession of the firearm in McPheeters’s car. McPheeters
asserted her constitutional right and refused to answer the
prosecutor’s questions about whether she possessed the revolver,
when she received it from her father, how long the safe had been
in her home, whether the revolver had been stored in that safe,
whether Gebauer had access to the safe, where the ammunition
for the revolver was, and whether any ammunition was stored
in her home. Based on her refusal to answer all of those
questions, as well as her counsel’s confirmation to the court
that McPheeters was “going to be asserting her Fifth Amendment
privilege not to testify,” the court reasonably concluded she
wasn’t going to answer any questions about the gun.
Gebauer contends the questions the prosecutor planned
to ask McPheeters on recross4 were “ ‘peripheral to the case’ ”
Gebauer acknowledges the California Supreme Court
applied the abuse of discretion standard of appellate review
as recently as 2017 in Brooks, supra, 3 Cal.5th 1. As this is not
a confrontation clause case as in Cromer, we continue to follow
the guidance of our high court as well as the many courts
of appeal that have applied an abuse of discretion standard
in cases like this.
4 The facts here are a bit different from the usual case in
which the defendant himself testifies or calls a defense witness,
whom the prosecutor then cross-examines. Although the People
10
and they related only to the “ ‘collateral matter’ ” of McPheeters’s
credibility as a third-party witness. Yet he also contends
McPheeters was “a key eyewitness who maintained that she
never saw [Gebauer] hold the firearm” or tell Alyssa “ ‘I see
you’ve called your friends here.’ ” Gebauer cannot have it
both ways. The prosecutor sought to challenge McPheeters’s
testimony that she never saw Gebauer with the gun that night,
and she didn’t even know it was in the car, by asking her about
Gebauer’s access to the gun, whether she’d let him use it, and
so forth. These questions had a “clear and logical bearing on
her connection” to the gun and her answers would have “directly
touched upon her interest in the case.” They therefore were
“crucial to assessing her credibility.” (See Seminoff, supra,
159 Cal.App.4th at p. 526.)
2. Any error in permitting the prosecutor to impeach
Gebauer with his conviction for simple possession
of a controlled substance was not prejudicial
During a hearing on motions in limine, the prosecutor told
the court he intended to impeach Gebauer—if he testified—with
prior drug convictions from Colorado. Several days later, counsel
again discussed the issue with the court. Defense counsel told
the court Gebauer had “several Colorado convictions for drug-
related offenses,” but most of them were more than 10 years old.
The prosecutor sought to introduce a 2018 conviction for
called McPheeters as a witness, she was essentially a defense
witness.
11
possession of a controlled substance.5 Defense counsel objected
and asked the court “to exclude it as not being relevant to this
trial and under [Evidence Code section] 352.” The court stated
the prosecution “will be allowed to use that prior” “[f]or
impeachment purposes,” finding it “relevant on the issue of
credibility.” The court said it had “gone through all the . . .
352 factors and [did] not find that it is wholly prejudicial.”
When Gebauer testified, defense counsel asked him if
he’d been convicted of a drug possession charge and Gebauer
answered, “Yes.” On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked
Gebauer if that conviction was for a felony and Gebauer replied,
“Yes.”
As Gebauer notes on appeal, simple possession of a
controlled substance is not a crime of moral turpitude and
therefore may not be used to impeach a witness’s testimony.
(People v. Castro (1985) 38 Cal.3d 301, 317.) Accordingly, it was
error for the trial court to permit the prosecutor to ask Gebauer
about his 2018 conviction. (Ibid. [defendant should not have been
impeached with his conviction for possession of heroin at all].)
The Attorney General contends Gebauer’s trial counsel
“did not claim the prior conviction did not involve moral
turpitude” and, therefore, he has forfeited the claim. While
counsel did not make that precise argument about moral
turpitude, she did object to the proposed impeachment on
relevance and Evidence Code section 352 grounds. This objection
was sufficient to preserve the issue. (See People v. Clark (2011)
5 We grant Gebauer’s unopposed (1) Motion to Augment the
Record on Appeal with a certified record of his 2018 conviction for
possession of a controlled substance in 2015, and (2) Motion for
Judicial Notice of the Colorado statute to which Gebauer pled.
12
52 Cal.4th 856, 931 [“ ‘the admissibility of any past misconduct
for impeachment is limited at the outset by the relevance
requirement of moral turpitude’ ”].) In any event, we exercise
our discretion to consider the issue on the merits.
While we agree the court erred, Gebauer has not
demonstrated that the error was prejudicial. Simple possession
of a controlled substance is not a crime of violence nor does it
involve a weapon. The jurors listened to Martinez’s testimony
and then Gebauer’s (as well as Alyssa’s), and decided whom
they believed. On this record, it is not reasonably probable that
a result more favorable to Gebauer would have occurred in the
absence of the error. (See Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13.)
3. Gebauer’s conviction on count three must be reversed
a. The jury’s questions and the court’s responses
Section 25400, subdivision (a)(1) provides, “(a) A person
is guilty of carrying a concealed firearm when the person does
any of the following: (1) Carries concealed within any vehicle
that is under the person’s control or direction any pistol, revolver,
or other firearm capable of being concealed upon the person.”
(§ 25400, subd. (a)(1).) The fourth element of the offense that
the People must prove is “[t]he vehicle was under the defendant’s
control or direction.” (See CALCRIM No. 2521.)
The testimony at trial established McPheeters and Gebauer
drove to the location to look for Alyssa. McPheeters drove and
Gebauer was the passenger.6 Gebauer got out of the car;
McPheeters stayed in the driver’s seat with the motor running.
6 As we noted, in testimony that later was stricken,
McPheeters testified the BMW was her vehicle and she was
driving.
13
After Gebauer told Alyssa to get “her ass” in the car, she did.
McPheeters then drove the car away with Gebauer in the front
passenger seat.
Addressing count 3 in his closing argument, the
prosecutor told the jury, “[T]he law doesn’t say exclusive control.”
He continued,
“It merely says it’s under the defendant’s
control or direction. What does that mean?
We have testimony that the vehicle actually
stayed at the location until the defendant got
back into it with Alyssa. At the point he got in,
it left. That shows some control over direction
[sic]. It also showed that they arrived
together.”
Defense counsel didn’t address either of the gun counts in her
closing argument.
During deliberations, the jury sent out a note that referred
to instruction 2521 and asked, “Question: Can you please
clarify 4, where it says ‘The vehicle was under the defendant’s
control or direction’? [¶] Can you further explain ‘control or
direction’?”
The court conferred with counsel. The court noted the
citation, in “RELATED ISSUES” under CALCRIM No. 2521, of
People v. Davis (1958) 157 Cal.App.2d 33, 36 (Davis).7 The court
7 Davis was convicted of violating former section 12025, the
predecessor of section 25400, subdivision (a)(1). (Davis, supra,
157 Cal.App.2d at p. 34.) In that case, police stopped Davis,
who was driving a car with three passengers in it. Police found
a loaded revolver under the driver’s seat. One of the passengers
testified she saw a fellow passenger—and not Davis—put the gun
14
told counsel, “So I propose to simply tell them in regard to their
specific question, the statute does not require that the defendant
have exclusive possession and control of the firearm [sic].”
Defense counsel said, “Submit it.”
Counsel later appeared again before the court. (The
chronology is not clear from the record.) The court stated
CALCRIM No. 2304 includes “additional language” “regarding
possession.” (CALCRIM No. 2304 concerns possession of a
controlled substance.) The prosecutor asked the court to give
that language as well as language that “A person does not have
to actually hold or touch something[ ] to possess it. It is enough
if the person has control over it or the right to control it, either
personally or through another person.” (CALCRIM No. 2304.)
Defense counsel objected.
The prosecutor then mentioned CALCRIM No. 2511, the
instruction for possession of a firearm “by [a] person prohibited
due to conviction.” That instruction states, “Two or more people
may possess something at the same time.” The court said, “But
here’s the issue, . . . because they’re not asking about the firearm.
They’re asking about the car.” Defense counsel noted CALCRIM
No. 2521 “doesn’t address this specific issue.” Counsel objected
under the seat. (Id. at p. 35.) The court held the law did not
require Davis himself to have put the gun under the seat in order
to be guilty of the crime. The court stated, “The statute does not
require that the defendant have the exclusive possession and
control of the firearm.” (Id. at p. 36.) Davis, the court continued,
owned the car, had control or direction of the vehicle, and knew
the gun was concealed in the car. (Ibid.) The Davis court did not
suggest—much less hold—that two or more people could have
control or direction of a vehicle.
15
to “tak[ing] language from another completely different set
of crimes,” adding, “We’re talking about the car itself, did
Mr. Gebauer have direction and control of the vehicle.” Counsel
stated the notion that “two people can have control and direction
of the same vehicle” was not accurate, and that’s not what the
Legislature intended. The court replied, “I would tend to agree
with that.”
After further discussion, the court stated, “[F]or now, I’m
going to simply direct them back to that CALCRIM instruction
and then finish by saying if you have any additional questions,
please let us know.” The court apparently did that. Written
at the bottom of the question form is, “Please look at all
instructions, specifically 2521 again. [¶] If you continue to
have any questions, please let us know.”
The jury then sent the form back again with another
question: “Is there a definition of (#4) of 25400: ‘under the
control or direction?’ Additionally, if there is no definition,
does the court agree with the prosecutor’s definition of control
and direction in his closing statement?”
The court eventually gave—over defense counsel’s
objection—the jury the language the prosecutor requested
about “possession” of an object.8
8 In deciding to give that additional language, the court cited
People v. Padilla (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 127. Padilla, however,
involved a different statutory provision. There, the defendant
was convicted of violating former section 12025, subdivision
(a)(3), “carrying a concealed firearm in a vehicle while an
occupant of the vehicle.” (Padilla, at p. 131, italics added.)
Padilla argued he wasn’t guilty because someone else had
brought the gun into the car. The court noted subdivision (a)(3)
was a different offense from the offense described in subdivision
16
b. The evidence was insufficient to establish
McPheeters’s car was under Gebauer’s control
or direction for purposes of section 25400,
subdivision (a)(1)
The Attorney General asserts McPheeters “drove [Gebauer]
to the location where the crime occurred” and “remained in
the stationary car” as Gebauer got out, yelled at Alyssa, and
“pointed a weapon at the victim.” The Attorney General then
says, “Ms. Martinez [sic] returned to the car, still parked with
McPheeters behind the wheel, after she was ordered to do so
by appellant.” (Presumably, the Attorney General means to
refer to Alyssa McPheeters, although the reference to “she” is
ambiguous.) McPheeters then, the Attorney General continues,
drove Gebauer and Alyssa away.
The sole case the Attorney General cites (without
discussion) for its contention that Gebauer had control or
direction over McPheeters’s vehicle is People v. Gant (1968) 264
Cal.App.2d 420 (Gant). In that case, Gant and his codefendant
Reed were convicted of burglary and “carrying a concealed
weapon” (id. at p. 421) in violation of former section 12025.
(The opinion didn’t specify which subsection of section 12025
applied.) Gant also was convicted of grand theft. Police stopped
Gant and Reed in a stolen car, bearing stolen plates. Gant was
driving and Reed was in the front passenger seat. Two other men
were in the back. Police found two stolen firearms (a Mauser
pistol and a Colt .45) in the car, one under the dash to the right
(a)(1), carrying “a gun ‘concealed within any vehicle which is
under his or her control.’ ” (Id. at p. 133.) The court concluded
subdivision (a)(3) “does not require the accused to have brought
the gun into the car.” (Ibid.)
17
of the glove box and one under the floormat of the front passenger
seat. The victim had reported the guns missing after the
burglary. (Gant, at pp. 421–423.)
On appeal, Gant and Reed argued they didn’t know the
guns were in the car. Rejecting this argument, the court stated
the “close proximity and availability” to Reed of the Mauser pistol
“indicate[d] knowledge on his part that the Mauser was there.”
(Gant, supra, 264 Cal.App.2d at p. 424.) As to Gant, the court
continued, “[T]he entire vehicle was under his control inasmuch
as he was the driver.” (Id. at p. 425.) Therefore, “[i]t was
reasonable for the trial judge to infer . . . the vehicle was in
the joint possession of Gant and Reed with Gant having actual
control and direction.” (Ibid.)
Gant supports Gebauer’s position, not the Attorney
General’s. Both in the trial court and here on appeal, the
prosecution seems to equate “possession” with “control or
direction.” At least on the facts here, they are not the same
thing. Even if Gebauer and McPheeters could be said to have
joint “possession” of McPheeters’s car—a dubious proposition
as they were not in a stolen car with a burglary victim’s property
as were Gant and Reed—McPheeters as the owner of the car
and its driver was the person with control or direction of the car.
That Gebauer went along with his girlfriend, in her car with
her driving, to collect her daughter does not constitute his
“control or direction” of the car. Neither Gebauer nor anyone
else ever testified Gebauer instructed or directed McPheeters to
remain in the car, to keep it running, to wait for him to return,
or to drive away once Alyssa had come to the car.
In short, neither the cases the trial court relied on nor the
sole authority the Attorney General has cited on appeal stands
18
for the proposition that a passenger who’s merely accompanying
another person on an errand has “control or direction” of that
other person’s car. Nor have we found any case that so holds.
DISPOSITION
We reverse Craig David Gebauer’s conviction on count 3
for having a concealed firearm, not registered to him, in a vehicle
that was under his control or direction, in violation of section
25400, subdivision (a)(1). We dismiss that count. We otherwise
affirm the conviction. The trial court is to prepare an amended
abstract of judgment and forward it to the Department of
Corrections and Rehabilitation.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
EGERTON, J.
We concur:
EDMON, P. J.
ADAMS, J.
19
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.