People v. Rodriguez CA4/2

CourtListener 10599897Calctapp6 de jun. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 6/6/25 P. v. Rodriguez CA4/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

THE PEOPLE,

Plaintiff and Respondent, E081589

v. (Super. Ct. No. RIF2200825)

JUAN RODRIGUEZ, OPINION

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of Riverside County. Matthew C. Perantoni,

Judge. Affirmed.

Robert E. Boyce, under the appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant

and Appellant.

Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant Attorney General,

Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Eric A. Swenson, and Tyler L. Krentz,

Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
I.

INTRODUCTION

A jury convicted defendant and appellant Juan Rodriguez of sexual penetration of

a child 10 years or younger by a person 18 years or older (Pen. Code, § 288.7, subd. (b)),

and the trial court sentenced him to 15 years to life in prison. Defendant contends the

trial court prejudicially erred by failing to instruct the jury on battery as a lesser included

offense. We affirm.

II.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Jane Doe, then five years old, went to stay with her grandparents when her parents

contracted COVID-19. Defendant rented a room in the house.

One morning, defendant had the day off work, so he began drinking around noon

and continued drinking into the afternoon. In the late afternoon, Jane Doe and her

siblings were playing in the front yard while their grandparents were supervising and

defendant was sitting at a table in the yard drinking. By that point, he was “really drunk,

super drunk.” At some point, Jane Doe’s siblings went inside, her grandmother went to

shower, and her grandfather went to put a trash can away, leaving Jane Doe alone with

defendant.

Jane Doe testified about what happened next as follows. Defendant told her to sit

on his lap, which she did. Jane Doe quickly told him to let her go so she could get off his

lap because she “felt like he was doing something” to her, but defendant refused.

2
Defendant began “touching [her]” and “put[ting] his hand in [her] private part,” which

made her feel like “there was a fire.” He did so by placing one of his arms around her

and using his other hand to penetrate her. When she later went to urinate, it hurt where

defendant had touched her.

At another point in her testimony, however, Jane Doe said that defendant touched

her “on top of [her] clothes” and did not touch her underneath her clothes. Jane Doe

explained that as she sat on defendant’s lap, he had “one of his arms around [her], and

then he touched [her].” She then got off his lap while “his arms were around [her],” and

she went to use the bathroom.

Jane Doe’s grandmother testified that Jane Doe knocked on the bathroom door

while she was showering, knocked “really hard” on the door, and said, “‘Grandma, I need

to pee.’” Right after she was let in, Jane Doe said, “‘Aye, Grandma, it hurts, it hurts.’”

Jane Doe’s grandmother asked what was wrong, and Jane Doe said repeatedly, “My

cheese hurts” while crying and seeming “desperate” and moving around in pain. (Later

testimony confirmed that Jane Doe referred to her vagina as her “cheese.”)

Jane Doe’s grandmother did not understand what Jane Doe meant by “cheese,” so

she got Jane Doe’s brother, N., to try to translate. Jane Doe then told her grandmother

and N. that defendant used his fingers to penetrate her and that “it hurt.” She told them

both that defendant “‘put his finger in’” and touched her “inside her shorts” and that he

“wouldn’t stop” even though she “told him to stop.” Jane Doe’s grandmother told N. to

call their mother because Jane Doe was in danger.

3
Jane Doe’s mother arrived shortly after the call and immediately took her to the

emergency room. While driving there, Jane Doe told her mother that defendant “had

touched her, that he had put his fingers in her vagina,” and that he would not let go of her

even though she told him to.

Law enforcement scheduled a child abuse examination, which Nurse M.

performed at 3:00 a.m. in the morning after the incident. Nurse M. noted increased

redness and tenderness on Jane Doe’s genital area, outside her vagina, and on the clitoral

hood, periurethral tissue, and hymen area. There was an abrasion near the opening of the

vaginal area. Nurse M. took photographs and swabbed Jane Doe’s genital area.

Doctor G. reviewed Nurse M.’s photographs and documentation. In her opinion,

there was “evidence of penetrating vaginal trauma.” Specifically, the photographs

showed a tear in Jane Doe’s perineovaginal tissue, the area around the vagina. According

to Doctor G., this was consistent with sexual abuse because it can be caused by a

fingernail and would have caused the burning sensation Jane Doe experienced when she

tried to urinate.

During a follow-up exam 10 days later, Doctor G. no longer saw a tear in Jane

Doe’s paravaginal area. Jane Doe also did not complain of pain when urinating. In

Doctor G.’s view, the exam results further supported a finding of sexual abuse because

they were consistent with a prior injury that typically “heals very rapidly.” Doctor G.

thus believed “sexual abuse is highly suspected.” The only more “definite evidence” that

4
would have changed her opinion from “highly suspected” sexual abuse to “confirmed”

sexual abuse would have been the presence of semen or sperm.

DNA retrieved from swabs on Jane Doe’s vulva and perianal levels revealed a

“low level amount of DNA” from two males. No DNA was detected on the vestibule

swab, which was more internal than the other swabs.

Jane Doe and N. were later forensically interviewed. During her interview, Jane

Doe said that a man at her grandparents’ house was sitting on a chair outside and told her

to hug him, and then he “just went through [her] pants, [her] undies,” “and then he

grabbed . . . this right here,” which she referred to as her “cheese.” The man touched her

“inside . . . really hard.” She told him it hurt but he would not let go. After she got away,

she went to urinate and it hurt.

N. told the forensic interviewer that his grandmother called for him because Jane

Doe was in pain. Jane Doe was crying and said it burned when she tried to urinate. She

told N. and their grandmother that she could not urinate because defendant had touched

her “cheese” while sitting on his lap.

When law enforcement interviewed defendant the day after the incident, his story

changed repeatedly. He claimed he had difficulty recalling what had happened. He first

said that “maybe I had [Jane Doe] sitting on my lap.” He then denied she had sat on his

lap, claiming that he did not “really remember that.” Then, he stated that “maybe” she

had sat on his lap, but repeated that he could not “really remember very well.” Not long

after saying that, he said that she did sit on his lap, but only briefly. Later, he again

5
claimed he could not remember. Eventually, he again admitted that Jane Doe sat on his

lap when her grandfather was not around.

At trial, however, defendant twice testified that Jane Doe never sat on his lap. He

could not recall with certainty whether he had ever touched her, but did not think he had.

But he specifically denied ever trying to touch her genitals, sticking his hands down her

pants, or touching her inappropriately.

III.

DISCUSSION

The trial court instructed the jury on sexual penetration of a child 10 years of age

or younger (CALCRIM No. 1128) and attempted sexual penetration of a child 10 years of

age or younger (CALCRIM No. 460), but did not instruct the jury on battery. Defendant

contends the trial court erred by failing to do so because (1) battery is a lesser included

offense of sexual penetration of a child 10 years of age or younger, and (2) there was

substantial evidence that he committed only a battery of Jane Doe.

We assume without deciding that defendant is correct on both points. We

conclude, however, that any error was harmless.

The parties agree, as do we, that we review this kind of instructional error under

the Watson standard, which asks whether it is reasonably probable defendant would have

achieved a more favorable result had the error not occurred. (People v. Gonzalez (2018)

5 Cal.5th 186, 195-196; People v. Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, 836.) “[T]he Watson test

for harmless error ‘focuses not on what a reasonable jury could do, but what such a jury

6
is likely to have done in the absence of the error under consideration. In making that

evaluation, an appellate court may consider, among other things, whether the evidence

supporting the existing judgment is so relatively strong, and the evidence supporting a

different outcome is so comparatively weak, that there is no reasonable probability the

error of which the defendant complains affected the result.’” (People v. Beltran (2013)

56 Cal.4th 935, 956.)

Here, we must determine whether it is reasonably probable that the jury would

have convicted defendant of battery had the trial court instructed the jury on that offense.

We conclude that it is not reasonably probable.

To begin with, defendant unequivocally testified that he never touched Jane Doe

inappropriately. In other words, defendant’s defense theory was that no crime occurred.

If the jury believed defendant, then it would have acquitted him. The fact that it did not

do so suggests that any instructional error was harmless. (People v. Chenelle (2018) 4

Cal.App.5th 1255, 1265 [failure to instruct on battery in child sex abuse case harmless

because defendant was not guilty of any offense if jury believed he did not

inappropriately touch victim].)

Although at one point during her testimony Jane Doe stated defendant only

touched her above her pants, she repeatedly stated before and after that statement that

defendant penetrated her. In her forensic interview, Jane Doe unambiguously stated that

defendant penetrated her. And immediately after the incident, Jane Doe told her

grandmother and N. that defendant penetrated her. Then, at trial, she stated multiple

7
times that defendant penetrated her. If the jury believed Jane Doe’s testimony that

defendant did not penetrate her and only touched her above her clothes, then they would

not have found that he committed a sexual penetration of Jane Doe. (People v. Lewis

(2001) 25 Cal.4th 610, 646 [“Error in failing to instruct the jury on a lesser included

offense is harmless when the jury necessarily decides the factual questions posed by the

omitted instructions adversely to defendant under other properly given instructions.”].)

What’s more, Jane Doe’s multiple statements that defendant penetrated her were

corroborated by her medical exam done shortly after the incident, which revealed that she

had suffered a tissue tear in her vaginal area and presented with tenderness and redness in

the area. Because of this evidence and the fact that the tear had resolved by the time of

her follow-up exam about 10 days later, Doctor G. opined that sexual abuse was “highly

suspected.” This was strong evidence that defendant committed a sexual penetration of

Jane Doe, not just a battery.

By contrast, the defense evidence defendant relies on in arguing for reversal was

comparatively weak. Defendant first argues that Jane Doe’s testimony “was clear that

[he] only touched her over and not under the clothing.” As explained, Jane Doe

consistently testified before and after that statement that defendant digitally penetrated

her. Again, the jury’s verdict shows that it found this testimony true.

Defendant next emphasizes that Jane Doe’s DNA was not found on his fingernail

clippings or on his “hand swabs.” As to the fingernail clippings, there is no evidence that

the clippings, though collected, were tested for DNA. And there is no evidence his hands

8
were swabbed for DNA. The only swabs noted in the record were buccal (inner cheek)

swabs.

Given the jury’s finding that defendant sexually penetrated Jane Doe and the

strong evidence supporting that finding, we conclude it is not reasonably probable that

the jury would have found defendant guilty of a battery only had it been instructed on that

offense. The trial court’s error, if any, in failing to give a battery instruction was therefore

harmless.

IV.

DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

CODRINGTON
J.

We concur:

McKINSTER
Acting P. J.

FIELDS
J.

9

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.