In re A.A. CA4/2

CourtListener 10596699Calctapp2 de jun. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 6/2/25 In re A.A. CA4/2

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re A.A., a Person Coming Under the
Juvenile Court Law.

SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, E085561

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super.Ct.No. J298562)

v. OPINION

A.A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of San Bernardino County. Lynn M. Poncin,

Judge. Affirmed.

Rich Pfeiffer, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant A.A.

Tom Bunton, County Counsel, Landon Villavaso, Deputy County Counsels, for

Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
I.

INTRODUCTION

A.A. (Father) appeals from the juvenile court’s order terminating parental rights as

to his seven-month-old son Aa.A. (A.). (Welf. & Inst. Code,1 § 366.26.) Father contends

the juvenile court erred in failing to find the sibling relationship exception applied to the

termination of parental rights and that the court erred in not adequately addressing a

postadoption sibling visitation order.2 We find no error and affirm.

II.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

The family came to the attention of the San Bernardino County Department of

Children and Family Services (CFS) in October 2023 after A. tested positive for fentanyl

and methamphetamine at his birth and was experiencing withdrawal symptoms.

Consequently, A. was placed in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU). A.’s

withdrawal symptoms included being jittery, having a respiratory rate over 80, a heartrate

over 160, and a fever of 100.8 degrees. Mother reported that she began using fentanyl

and methamphetamine about a year ago after witnessing an uncle commit suicide. She

then began smoking fentanyl six to seven times a day, and then tapered off to smoking it

two to three times a day by the end of her pregnancy. Mother also admitted to using

methamphetamine two to three times a week throughout her pregnancy. Mother claimed

1 All future statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

2 K.W. (Mother) is not a party to this appeal.

2
that Father had tried to stop her drug use and that Father did not use drugs himself.

Father, however, admitted to using fentanyl once a day and methamphetamine two to

three times a week during Mother’s pregnancy. Father also admitted that he knew

Mother used fentanyl and methamphetamine while she was pregnant with his son.

Mother noted that she had another child, V.T.N. (V.), who was six years old at the

time with a different father.3 V. lived with his maternal great-grandmother, Mrs. R., at

the time. Mrs. R. did not have legal guardianship over V. or any formal custody

arrangement. Mother did not have an address or phone number to contact the maternal

great-grandmother. V.’s father did not have contact with V. or support the child in any

way. Mother denied having any contact information for V.’s father or his paternal family

to locate his whereabouts. Upon concluding its investigation, the children were taken

into protective custody.

On October 3, 2023, CFS filed a petition on behalf of the children pursuant to

section 300, subdivision (b) (failure to protect). At the detention hearing held on the next

day, the juvenile court formally detained the children from parental custody. Mother

requested placement of A. with the paternal grandmother who was present in court. The

parents were provided with supervised visitation with A. and services pending the

jurisdictional/dispositional hearing.

When CFS interviewed Mother again, she admitted to having a substance abuse

problem but denied her substance use affected her ability to care for the children, and

3 A.’s half-sibling V. is not a subject of this appeal.

3
assured CFS that the children were her priority. Mother reiterated that she began using

drugs two weeks after she lost her uncle to his unexpected suicide and continued to use

until she eventually became addicted to fentanyl and methamphetamine. Mother reported

using marijuana at the age of 18, cocaine at the age of 24, fentanyl in 2020, and

methamphetamine in 2022. By the end of 2020, Mother was smoking fentanyl three

times a day at a minimum and last used in October 2023. Mother had been using

methamphetamine about three times per month since 2022 and last used

methamphetamine in October 2023. Mother admitted to using both methamphetamines

and fentanyl during her pregnancy with A. Mother also reported that she and Father used

substances together. She explained that V. was at school when she and Father used

substances and that V. would be under the care of the maternal grandmother, maternal

aunt, or the maternal great-grandmother when she used drugs. On October 4, 2023,

Mother submitted an on-demand drug test and tested positive for amphetamines, cocaine,

methadone, marijuana, fentanyl, and nor-fentanyl.

When Father was reinterviewed regarding the allegations, Father stated the

allegations regarding his substance abuse and his knowledge of Mother’s substance abuse

were true. He began smoking marijuana at the age of 13 and used it daily around the age

of 18. He last used marijuana on September 30, 2023. Father also reported a history of

alcohol abuse. He admitted to being arrested for driving under the influence

approximately five years ago. Since that time, he continued to drink, but not excessively.

Father snorted fentanyl in 2021, and admitted to becoming addicted to it and started

4
smoking it a minimum of three times per day. He last used fentanyl around

September 29, 2023. Father further stated that he used methamphetamine in 2021, but

did not use it again until 2023 and used it two times a week. He last used

methamphetamine around September 20, 2023. Father claimed that he had tried to stop

Mother from using drugs while she was pregnant, but admitted to feeling like a hypocrite

asking Mother to stop while he was actively using substances. Father also admitted that

he used substances while V. was in their care, outside playing, or playing a game on his

phone in another room.

Both Mother and Father failed to attend an on-demand drug test on October 17,

2023. CFS recommended suspending in-person visits for the parents until they tested

negative for fentanyl three times and requested video-call visits for the parents.

A. was placed in the relative home of the paternal grandmother, Ms. G., after his

discharge from the NICU at two weeks old. Ms. G. had been A.’s only placement since

being removed from his parents’ care. The placement was appropriate, and the caregiver

was meeting all the child’s needs. A. appeared to be doing well. Ms. G. reported she

was able to be a concurrent home for the child if the parents failed to reunify. V. was

placed in the relative home of the maternal great-grandmother, Mrs. R. Mrs. R. had been

V.’s only placement since he was removed from his parents. V. appeared to be doing

well in the placement and in his school. V. did not report any concerns with the

placement, and Mrs. R was meeting all the child’s needs. Mrs. R. reported she was

willing to be a concurrent home placement for V., but was unsure if she would pursue

5
legal guardianship or adoption because she lived in a senior community. Mrs. R was also

assessed to be a placement resource for A. However, due to V.’s hyperactivity, Mrs. R.

felt she would not be able to dedicate enough attention to both children if they were

placed in her home together. Nevertheless, Mrs. R. had good communication with Ms.

G., and she displayed an understanding of the need for sibling visitation to allow the

children to bond with one another.

The jurisdictional/dispositional hearing was held on November 6, 2023. Mother

was present for the hearing, but Father was not present. After reading and considering

the reports filed by CFS, the juvenile court found true the allegations in the petition,

declared the children dependents of the court, and provided the parents with reunification

services and supervised visits once a week for two hours with in-person visits to resume

once parents tested negative for fentanyl. The court also ordered supervised sibling visits

for the children.

By the six month review hearing in May 2024, the parents’ progress in their case

plan was minimal and CFS recommended terminating their reunification services.

Mother was ordered to complete individual counseling, parenting education, random

substance abuse testing, and outpatient substance abuse treatment. Mother did not submit

to drug testing on October 16 and 26, 2023, November 9 and 21, 2023, December 7 and

19, 2023, January 10, 2024, February 21, 2024, March 11 and 19, 2024, and April 10,

2024. Mother tested positive for illicit substances on October 4, 2023, January 25, 2024,

and February 6, 2024. On October 19, 2023, Mother was referred to individual

6
counseling and parenting education. She attended a few sessions of individual

counseling, but stopped participating because transportation and homelessness were

issues for her. Mother also attended a few parenting classes, but stopped attending after a

few sessions. On December 6, 2023, Mother was referred to Inland Behavioral Health

Services Perinatal (IBHS) for outpatient substance abuse treatment. Mother completed

the intake on January 10, 2024, and began outpatient substance abuse treatment on

January 11, 2024. Mother stopped attending services thereafter due to a

miscommunication with the service provider. She reported the coordinator would not let

her attend the program if Mother continued to be late, so Mother never returned for

classes. Mother later made an appointment with CFS and her substance abuse

coordinator to discuss re-enrollment in an outpatient program. Mother was then referred

to IBHS and had an intake appointment scheduled for April 22, 2024. CFS made

attempts to support Mother by providing her with monthly bus passes, housing resources,

and referrals for a parent partner to receive additional support.

Father was ordered to complete individual counseling, parenting education,

random substance abuse testing, and an outpatient substance abuse treatment program.

On October 17, 2023, Father was referred to random substance abuse testing, but did not

submit to testing on October 16, 20, and 24, 2023, November 7 and 15, 2023,

December 13, 2023, January 18, 2024, February 1 and 13, 2024, March 7 and 15, 2024,

and April 8, 2024. When questioned about his missed tests, Father admitted he thought it

would be better to not test than test positive. On October 19, 2023, Father was referred to

7
an individual counseling and parenting education provider. Father initially struggled with

consistently attending individual therapy and chose to stop participating. Father also

stopped participating in parenting classes, but asked to be reenrolled in parenting

education and subsequently received a new referral on April 19, 2024. On December 6,

2023, Father was referred to an outpatient substance abuse program. Father completed

the intake appointment on January 11, 2024, and started outpatient substance abuse

treatment on January 17, 2024. Father later stopped participating in outpatient services,

explaining that Mother paid for him to stay in a hotel so that he could get off the streets

and focus on his sobriety. However, Father was unable to maintain his sobriety which

resulted in him asking for a referral to either an inpatient program or outpatient services

again. On April 10, 2024, Father met with CFS and his substance abuse counselor to

discuss being enrolled in an outpatient treatment program. Father was referred to Rialto

Behavioral Addiction Treatment Services and had an intake appointment scheduled for

April 30, 2024. Father was homeless during the reporting period which was a barrier to

completing the court ordered case plan and engaging in visitation. CFS made attempts to

support Father by providing him with monthly bus passes and referred him to a parent

partner to assist with navigating the child welfare system.

The parents had supervised visits with A. at a CFS office on Tuesdays between

3:00 p.m. and 5:00 p.m. The caregivers, Mrs. R. and Ms. G., supervised the visits and

initially reported the parents would take turns caring for A. Mother excelled at parenting

A. because she had a child from a previous relationship and supported Father with

8
learning how to hold, feed, and change A. However, the parents appeared to be under the

influence during a supervised visit on February 20, 2024. When questioned, the parents

admitted to actively using fentanyl. The parents were then informed that visitation with

A. would be discontinued until they were able to provide three consecutive negative test

results. As of May 6, 2024, the parents did not provide negative tests to CFS.

A. had weekly visits with his half-sibling brother V. at the home of a relative

caretaker. In addition, the relative caretaker provided daycare twice a week for A. while

Ms. G. was working. Ms. G. understood the importance of familial connections and

expressed a willingness to continue such relationships if it was appropriate and in the best

interest of the child. Due to the caregiver engaging with the child and providing him with

therapy, A. appeared to be meeting his developmental milestones. A.’s relative caregiver

Ms. G. was bonded to A. and she was meeting the child’s needs. A. was placed in Ms.

G.’s home when he was two weeks old and they had formed a healthy mutual attachment

and bond. Ms. G. was willing to provide stability and security to A. and desired to

provide him with permanency. A. looked to Ms. G. for love, comfort, and soothing.

The six-month review hearing was held on May 28, 2024. Mother was present for

the hearing; Father was not. CFS recommended the juvenile court terminate reunification

services for Mother and Father. Mother objected to the setting of a section 366.26

selection and implementation hearing. Father objected to the termination of reunification

services and setting of a selection and implementation hearing. Counsel for the child

submitted on CFS’s recommendation. After reading and considering CFS’s reports, the

9
juvenile court terminated reunification services for Mother and Father and set a

section 366.26 hearing.

On January 7, 2025, the juvenile court held a section 366.26 selection and

implementation hearing. Mother was present; Father was present in custody. Mother

requested a continuance to complete reunification services. The juvenile court denied

Mother’s request. CFS recommended the juvenile court terminate reunification services

and select a permanent plan of adoption for A. Father objected to CFS’s

recommendation without any affirmative evidence and asked the court to consider a

lesser plan of legal guardianship and find it’s in the child’s best interest. Mother also

objected to the termination of her parental rights and requested a less restrictive

permanent plan of legal guardianship. The child’s counsel asked the juvenile court to

follow CFS’s recommendation. After considering CFS’s admitted reports, the juvenile

court found that the beneficial parental relationship exception to adoption did not apply,

terminated the parents’ parental rights, found A. to be both generally and specifically

adoptable by clear and convincing evidence, and advised the parents of their appellate

rights. Father timely appealed.

III.

DISCUSSION

A. Sibling Relationship Exception

Father argues the juvenile court erred in failing to find the sibling relationship

exception to adoption applied to the children. CFS responds that because Father did not

10
request the court to consider the sibling relationship exception, he cannot argue on appeal

that the court erred by not finding the exception applies in A.’s case. Alternatively, CFS

asserts the sibling relationship exception to the termination of parental rights is not

applicable in this case.

A parent must raise an exception to the termination of parental rights at the

selection and implementation hearing; otherwise, the issue is forfeited on appeal. (In re

Erik P. (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th 395, 403 (Erik. P.).) “If a parent fails to raise one of the

exceptions at the hearing, not only does this deprive the juvenile court of the ability to

evaluate the critical facts and make the necessary findings, but it also deprives this court

of a sufficient factual record from which to conclude whether the trial court’s

determination is supported by substantial evidence.” (Ibid.)

We agree with CFS that Father did not raise the sibling relationship exception at

the selection and implementation hearing. At the hearing, Father’s counsel argued: “On

behalf of Father, we would object to the recommendation to terminate parental rights

today, without affirmative evidence. I would ask the Court order a lesser plan of legal

guardianship and find that it’s in the minor’s best interest. Submit it.” However, Father’s

counsel never requested the court to find the sibling relationship exception applied to A.’s

case. Father’s counsel never addressed any of the factors specified in section 366.26,

subdivision (c)(1)(B)(v), to argue that termination of his parental rights would cause

substantial interference with A.’s sibling relationship, and he did not present, or direct the

court’s attention to, any evidence that supported applying the exception to A.’s case.

11
(See Erik P., supra, 104 Cal.App.4th at p. 403.) Thus, Father forfeited this issue on

appeal.

Even if Father did not forfeit the issue, he has failed to demonstrate the sibling

relationship exception applies in A.’s case. (See In re S.B. (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1287, 1293

[appellate courts may exercise discretion and excuse forfeiture], superseded by statute on

other grounds as stated by In re S.J. (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 953, 962.) Section 366.26,

subdivision (c)(1)(B)(v), provides an exception to adoption where “the juvenile court

determines that there is a ‘compelling reason’ for concluding that the termination of

parental rights would be ‘detrimental’ to the child due to ‘substantial interference’ with a

sibling relationship.” (In re Daniel H. (2002) 99 Cal.App.4th 804, 813 (Daniel H.).) The

statute places a heavy burden on the party advocating the exception to overcome the

statutory preference for adoption. (In re Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 61.) The

language of the statute “focuses exclusively on the benefits and burdens to the adoptive

child, not the other siblings.” (Daniel H., supra, 99 Cal.App.4th at p. 813.) “[T]he

application of this exception will be rare, particularly when the proceedings concern

young children whose needs for a competent, caring and stable parent are paramount.”

(In re Valorie A. (2007) 152 Cal.App.4th 987, 1014.)

“Many siblings have a relationship with each other, but would not suffer detriment

if that relationship ended. If the relationship is not sufficiently significant to cause

detriment on termination, there is no substantial interference with that relationship.” (In

re L.Y.L. (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 942, 952 (L.Y.L.).) In determining whether the

12
exception applies, the juvenile court should consider the nature and extent of the sibling

relationship, including a child’s long-term emotional interest, as compared to the benefit

of legal permanence through adoption. (In re Michael G. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 580,

593.) Section 366.26, subdivision (c)(1)(B)(v), expressly requires the court to consider

“whether the child was raised with a sibling in the same home, whether the child shared

significant common experiences or has existing close and strong bonds with a sibling,

and whether ongoing contact is in the child’s best interest, including the child’s long-term

emotional interest.” If the court determines terminating parental rights would

substantially interfere with the sibling relationship, “[t]he court must balance the

beneficial interest of the child in maintaining the sibling relationship, which might leave

the child in a tenuous guardianship or foster home placement, against the sense of

security and belonging adoption and a new home would confer. [Citation.]” (L.Y.L.,

supra, 101 Cal.App.4th at p. 951.)

A parent who raises the sibling exception to adoption bears the evidentiary burden

of establishing the exception. (In re D.M. (2012) 205 Cal.App.4th 283, 290.) We review

the ruling of the juvenile court for substantial evidence. (Id. at p. 291.)

We reject Father’s contention that the sibling relationship exception applies in this

case. Sufficient evidence supports the juvenile court’s determination of adoptability and

termination of parental rights. The evidence presented by CFS indicates that A. and V.

had little connection or interaction during visits. A. was detained at birth and placed with

his paternal grandmother Ms. G. at two weeks old. His half-brother V., who was six

13
years old at the time A. was born, lived with the maternal great grandmother Mrs. R.

Mrs. R. could not accept placement of A. so he remained in the care of Ms. G. Hence, A.

was not raised with V. in the same home and there is no indication in the record that they

shared significant common experiences or had existing close and strong bonds with each

other. CFS had no obligation to create a sibling bond where little or no bond existed.

Even though A. and V. had regular and consistent visits, the record does not reflect A., a

newborn, had any shared or significant experiences with V. between the date of his birth

and the date of the selection and implementation hearing when he was 10 months old.

Given the very young age of A. and the six-year age gap between he and V., there is

insufficient evidence to show there would be any harm to A. if he lost all contact with V.

On the other hand, A. had formed a healthy mutual attachment and bond with Ms. G. A.

looked to Ms. G. for love, comfort and support. On balance, the benefits of adoption

outweighed the benefit of continuing his relationship with half-sibling V.

“If the relationship is not sufficiently significant to cause detriment on termination,

there is no substantial interference with that relationship.” (L.Y.L., supra, 101

Cal.App.4th 942, 952.) Under the circumstances of this case, there was insufficient

evidence to establish the sibling relationship exception to the termination of parental

rights.

B. Postadoption Contract for Visitation Between the Siblings

Father also contends that the juvenile court erred in not adequately addressing

postadoption sibling visitation. Father relies primarily on sections 16002, which provides

14
that if parental rights are terminated and the child is to be placed for adoption, CFS

“shall” take certain steps “to facilitate ongoing sibling contact.” (Id., subd. (e).) Father

also relies on section 366.29, which similarly promotes the continuation of sibling

relationships by recognizing that prospective adoptive parents can agree to voluntary

contracts to “facilitate postadoptive sibling contact,” which may be enforced provided it

“is in the best interest of the child.” (Id., subds. (a), (c)(2).) Father asks us to remand the

matter for a hearing “to deal with preserving sibling visitation.”

Initially, we note Father does not have standing to challenge the lack of

postadoption sibling visitation. “Generally, parents can appeal judgments or orders in

juvenile dependency matters. [Citation.] However, a parent must also establish [he or]

she is a ‘party aggrieved’ to obtain a review of a ruling on the merits. [Citation.]

Therefore, a parent cannot raise issues on appeal from a dependency matter that do not

affect [his or] her own rights. [Citation.] Standing to appeal is jurisdictional.” (In re

Frank L. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 700, 703 (Frank L.).)

Postadoption sibling visits are a concern of the children, not of a parent whose

rights have been terminated. Accordingly, although a child’s siblings have standing to

enforce section 16002 (In re Clifton B. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 415, 427 (Clifton B.)), a

parent whose rights have been terminated does not. (Frank L., supra, 81 Cal.App.4th at

p. 703; Clifton B., at p. 427; In re Nachelle S. (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 1557, 1561-1562.)

Once parental rights are terminated, the parent has no more legally cognizable interest in

the proceeding or in the children’s visitation plans than would a stranger. Standing

15
depends on the nature of the party’s interests. Sibling visitation simply does not affect

the parent’s interests once parental rights are terminated. (Daniel H., supra, 99

Cal.App.4th at p. 810; see Frank L., at p. 703.) Father therefore lacks standing to assert

the postadoption sibling visitation claims.

Even if Father did have standing, we would reject his contentions.

Section 16002 reflects the legislative policy in favor of maintaining the continuity

of the family unit and strengthening family ties by ensuring that siblings be placed

together when removed from their homes. (§ 16002, subd. (a).) Thus, the agency is

required to “make a diligent effort” in all out-of-home placements to maintain sibling

relationships. (§ 16002, subd. (b).) In this regard, if siblings are not placed together in

the same home, the social worker is required to “explain why the siblings are not placed

together and what efforts” he or she is making to place the siblings together or why those

efforts are not appropriate. (§ 16002, subd. (b).) Further, when placement of siblings

together in the same home is not possible, diligent effort is required to provide for

ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings. (Ibid.)

The statute expresses a legislative goal but does not create a mandatory duty.

(County of Los Angeles v. Superior Court (2002) 102 Cal.App.4th 627, 641-642.) It

simply requires “diligent efforts.” Such efforts were made in this case. CFS had

attempted to place A. with V.’s relative caretaker, Mrs. R. However, the hyperactivity of

V. was a concern for Mrs. R. As such, Mrs. R. declined placement of A., who was only

two weeks old when he was released from the NICU and ten months old at the time of the

16
section 366.26 hearing. Mrs. R. believed she would not be able to dedicate enough

attention to both children if they were placed in her home together. CFS spoke to both

Ms. G., the caregiver for A., and Mrs. R., to confirm the caretakers had good

communication and displayed a mutual understanding of the need for sibling visitation to

allow the children to bond with one another. As a result, A. had weekly visits with his

half-brother V. at the home of a relative caretaker. In addition, the relative caretaker

provided daycare twice a week for A. while Ms. G. worked, and Ms. G. understood the

importance of familial connections and expressed a willingness to continue such

relationships if it was appropriate and in the best interest of the child. CFS had explored

the option of placing A. in the same home as his half-brother; however, the half-sibling’s

prospective adoptive parent was unable to take A. Contrary to Father’s contention,

appropriate steps were taken to attempt to place the children together and to facilitate

visitation.

The record before us demonstrates CFS made “diligent efforts” to keep the

children together and to maintain sibling visitation. The fact there were difficulties was

not the fault of CFS. In any event, at no time prior to the section 366.26 hearing did

either Father or Mother object to the placements or the lack of consistent sibling

visitation. Thus, any error was waived. (In re Anthony P. (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 635,

641-642.) In Anthony P., the court held that “[a]ppellant has waived her right to assert

error as to sibling visitation on appeal by not properly raising the issue below. No

objection was interposed in superior court premised upon: the alleged failure to

17
‘maintain[] sibling togetherness and contact’ (§ 16002, subd. (b)); the purported failure to

‘provide for ongoing and frequent interaction among siblings until family reunification is

achieved’ (§ 16002, subd. (b)); or the supposed failure to state reasons for the suspension

of sibling interaction. (§ 16002, subd. (c).) Hence, any objection to the absence of an

order providing for sibling visitation has been waived.” (Anthony P., at p. 641.)

Father also claims that the juvenile court failed to make an order for sibling

visitation following the termination of parental rights, citing Cliffton B., supra, 81

Cal.App.4th 415. In Cliffton B., the court referred to the statutory provisions dealing with

sibling contact after parental rights are terminated. (§ 16002, subd. (e).) That section

only requires DPSS to take steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact and to educate

adoptive parents on the importance of such ongoing contact. (§ 16002, subd. (e).)4

Nothing in the statute imposes a mandatory duty on the court to order sibling visits,

notwithstanding the legislative policy.

4 Section 16002, subdivision (e), provides that, “[i]f parental rights are terminated
and the court orders a dependent child or ward to be placed for adoption, the county
adoption agency or the State Department of Social Services shall take all of the following
steps to facilitate ongoing sibling contact . . . : [¶] (1) Include in training provided to
prospective adoptive parents information about the importance of sibling
relationships . . . and counseling on methods for maintaining sibling relationships. [¶]
(2) Provide prospective adoptive parents with information about siblings of the child. . . .
[¶] (3) Encourage prospective adoptive parents to make a plan for facilitating
postadoptive contact between the child . . . and any siblings. . . .”
Section 366.29, subdivision (a), provides: “When a court . . . orders that a
dependent child be placed for adoption, nothing in the adoption laws of this state shall be
construed to prevent the prospective adoptive parent or parents of the child from
expressing a willingness to facilitate postadoptive sibling contact. With the consent of
the adoptive parent or parents, the court may include in the final adoption order
provisions for the adoptive parent or parents to facilitate postadoptive sibling
contact. . . .”

18
Decisional law holds that the sibling relationship is unaffected by a termination of

the parent/child relationship. (See In re Miguel A. (2007) 156 Cal.App.4th 389, 394.)

Thus, so long as the dependency case remains open (until the adoption is finalized), the

child’s counsel can seek orders for sibling visitation. Neither the provisions of

section 16002, subdivision (e), nor section 366.29 imposes any obligation upon the

juvenile court to enter orders for sibling visitation. In Cliffton B., supra, 81 Cal.App.4th

415 is inapposite. The case does not hold that the failure to order post-termination sibling

visitation is error; rather, it states that the juvenile court has discretion to make interim

visitation orders but does not make it mandatory to do so or reversibly erroneous to

decline.

To the extent that Father focuses on the court’s failure to affirmatively order

sibling visitation in the interim between the termination of parental rights and the

adoption, he has failed to demonstrate any error. As noted, sections 16002,

subdivision (e), and 366.29 address postadoptive sibling contact. The court was not

obligated to make provisions for such contact. A. and his prospective adoptive parent

was amenable to consensual sibling contact with V. Nothing in the court’s orders

interfered with any such arrangement. In any case, no one requested interim, as opposed

to postadoptive, visitation. First, he waived the visitation issue by failing to raise it with

the juvenile court before his parental rights were terminated. Father never objected to the

court’s failure to take the steps articulated in section 16002, subdivision (e). Hence, any

objection to the absence of an order providing for sibling visitation has been waived.

19
(Anthony P., supra, 39 Cal.App.4th at p. 641.) The court can hardly be faulted for failing

to order what was never requested.

IV.

DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s order terminating parental rights is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
CODRINGTON
J.
We concur:

McKINSTER
Acting P. J.

RAPHAEL
J.

20

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.