Park v. Lee CA2/5

CourtListener 10582088Calctapp12 de mai. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 5/12/25 Park v. Lee CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

YUN SOOK PARK, B335212

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BC701416)
v.

JIMMY LEE,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Timothy P. Dillon, Judge. Affirmed.

Jimmy Lee, in pro. per., for Defendant and Appellant.

Biggins Law Group and Chad Biggins for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
******
A person found liable for defaming a fellow member of his
local Korean community through statements re-published in a
Korean-language newspaper article appeals the judgment against
him, arguing that no reliable translation of the article was
admitted at trial and that he cannot be held jointly liable with
the newspaper and its publisher. We reject these arguments and
affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Facts1
Yun Sook Park (plaintiff) has enjoyed a long career on
radio, television, and newspaper programming serving Los
Angeles’s Korean community. He is also a golf instructor.
In 2015, plaintiff became the president of the Los Angeles
Korean Festival Foundation (the Foundation). The Foundation is
“well-known . . . in the Korean community” and “puts on a
widely-attended and popular annual festival” that brings in $1
million in sponsorships each year. Also in 2015, Jimmy Lee was
a chairman of the Foundation. Lee “harbored dislike” of plaintiff
because, years prior, plaintiff had accused Lee of
misappropriating funds from the Foundation.
In the spring of 2017, Lee hatched a plan to impugn
plaintiff by “deliberate[ly] fabricat[ing]” a story that plaintiff had
embezzled funds from the Foundation. Lee filed a false police
report accusing plaintiff of embezzlement and then “sought out”
Simon Yang, who also “strongly disliked” plaintiff and ran a

1 Pursuant to the standard for reviewing a judgment based
upon a statement of decision following a bench trial, we state the
facts in the light most favorable to the prevailing party.
(Thompson v. Asimos (2016) 6 Cal.App.5th 970, 981 (Thompson).)

2
Korean publication called SISA (Current Affairs) Journal (SISA),
to publish an article in SISA repeating Lee’s accusations. Lee
knew the truth—namely, that the funds he reported as
embezzled had been placed in plaintiff’s personal bank account
with the approval of the Foundation’s board in order to pay down
the debt the Foundation owed plaintiff.
On June 5, 2017, Yang and SISA published, in print and
online, an article headlined “Yun-Sook Park criminally charged.
Will he end up in handcuffs?” Alongside the article were
photographs of plaintiff, a pair of handcuffs, and stacks of money.
The article stated, in pertinent part, that an audit performed by
the Foundation “prompted” it to “initiate a criminal action”
because the audit “prove[d]” “its funds have been recklessly used
as [plaintiff’s] pocket money.” The information in the article
came “‘primarily’” from Lee, and Yang did not investigate the
facts or verify the content of the article before publishing it.
SISA has approximately 20,000 readers.
II. Procedural Background
In April 2018, plaintiff filed a defamation action against
Lee, Yang, and SISA US Midea Holdings, Inc., which owns
SISA.2
The matter proceeded to a bench trial over the course of
several days in December 2021, February 2022, April 2022, May

2 Plaintiff named a fourth defendant in his defamation
claim—Jean Kim, also known as Gene Hyoung Kim—but that
party was dismissed.
Plaintiff also sued the Foundation for breach of contract,
and the Foundation filed a cross-complaint against plaintiff and
other parties, but they reached a settlement and dismissed those
various claims.

3
2022, and June 2022.3 The parties stipulated to the authenticity
and admission at trial of the SISA article and to an English
translation of the article. Following post-trial briefing, the trial
court issued a statement of intended decision on November 17,
2022.
After the parties filed objections, the trial court issued its
final statement of decision on December 20, 2022. The court
found that there was no truth to the statements in the SISA
article; that Lee’s report to Yang and Yang’s republication of that
report, each of which accuses plaintiff of a crime, constituted
slander and libel per se and thus entitled plaintiff to “assumed”
damages; that plaintiff is a “public figure”; and that Lee, Yang,
and SISA acted with actual malice. The court also rejected as
“not credible” Lee’s testimony denying his knowledge of the
article. Because plaintiff failed to prove actual damages to his
golf business or other sources of income, the court awarded him
“assumed” damages of $25,000 “against . . . Lee and also against .
. . Yang/SISA.” At oral argument, plaintiff conceded this award
referred to a total award of $25,000 (rather than an award of
$25,000 against Lee and $25,000 against Yang/SISA). Following
a bifurcated proceeding in July 2023 on punitive damages, the
court issued a further ruling on September 29, 2023, awarding
plaintiff $25,000 in punitive damages “against Lee and against
Yang/SISA.”
Following the entry of judgment, Lee filed this timely
appeal.

3 Lee failed to designate the entirety of the trial proceedings
for the record on appeal. (See Cal. Rules of Court, rules 8.120(b),
8.130.)

4
DISCUSSION
Lee raises two challenges to the judgment. First, he argues
that the defamatory article should not have been admitted at
trial because it was only “partially translated” into English and
because “that translation was not credible.” Second, he argues
that the court erred in holding him jointly and severally liable
with Yang/SISA for the “assumed” and punitive damages
awarded to plaintiff.4
I. Admission of Defamatory Article
Lee argues that the judgment must be overturned because
the SISA article that forms the basis for the defamation claim
should not have been admitted at trial. More specifically, Lee
asserts that there was no accurate translation of the article from
Korean into English. Although we review evidentiary challenges
for an abuse of discretion (Briley v. City of West Covina (2021) 66
Cal.App.5th 119, 132; People v. Powell (2018) 5 Cal.5th 921, 961),
Lee has forfeited this argument by not including the exhibits
containing the article (Exhibits 1 and 103) in the record on
appeal. What is more, the portions of the record on appeal before
us establish that Lee stipulated to the admission of a certified
translation of the article into evidence. (Accord, Cal. Rules of

4 For the first time in his reply brief, Lee also argues that
there was insufficient evidence to hold him liable for defamation
because “strangers” “totally unbeknownst” to him published the
article. This argument is waived. (People v. Tully (2012) 54
Cal.4th 952, 1075 [“arguments made for the first time in a reply
brief will not be entertained”]; Piedmont Capital Management,
L.L.C. v. McElfish (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 961, 970, fn. 6.) It also
lacks merit because it necessarily rests on second-guessing the
trial court’s finding that Lee was not credible in denying
involvement with the article’s publication.

5
Court, rule 3.1110(g) [an exhibit “written in a foreign language
must be accompanied by an English translation, certified under
oath by a qualified interpreter”].) By so stipulating,5 Lee did not
object to the admission of the translation and thus forfeited his
right to appeal that admission. (Evid. Code, § 353, subd. (a)
[judgment shall not be set aside “by reason of the erroneous
admission of evidence” unless the appealing party objected to
that evidence].)
II. Joint and Several Liability for Damages
Lee also argues that the judgment must be overturned
because he was liable for, at most, one-third of the damages
award because (1) the judgment does not specify that he is jointly
liable with Yang/SISA, and (2) imposing joint liability for the
assumed and punitive damages runs afoul of Civil Code section
1431.2. We review the award of damages for substantial
evidence, and any subsidiary questions of law de novo.
(Thompson, supra, 6 Cal.App.5th at p. 981.)
As a threshold matter, Lee has forfeited any objection to
the imposition of joint liability. A defendant who seeks to avoid
joint liability—and thus to have damages apportioned between
the defendants severally—must request apportionment before the
trial court; the failure to do so precludes such an objection on
appeal. (Del Cerro Mobile Estates v. Proffer (2001) 87
Cal.App.4th 943, 951; Pacific Gas & Elec. Co. v. Scott (1938) 10

5 Although Lee subsequently asserted to the trial court that
a portion of the stipulated translation was inaccurate (because
the term “charges” in Korean could be open to interpretation), the
court rejected this assertion because Lee never offered an
alternative certified translation and thus presented no dispute
for the court to “adjudicat[e].”

6
Cal.2d 581, 586; Heiner v. Kmart Corp. (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th
335, 348-349; Meister v. Mensinger (2014) 230 Cal.App.4th 381,
397.) Lee never requested apportionment before the trial court.
Contrary to his assertion on appeal, this forfeiture was not
excused by Lee’s post-judgment settlement offer to plaintiff for
one-third of the total damages award: That offer was made after
judgment, was not filed with the trial court, and did not ask the
trial court to apportion damages.
Further, the trial court properly imposed joint and several
liability against Lee and Yang/SISA for the assumed and
punitive damages.
Contrary to what Lee asserts, the court’s orders did impose
joint liability against the defendants. In its statement of
decision, the court awarded assumed damages of “$25,000 in
favor of [plaintiff] and against [] Lee and also against []
Yang/SISA”; and in its subsequent order, the court awarded
“punitive damages of $25,000 against Lee and against
Yang/SISA.” (Italics added.) By imposing the assumed and
punitive damages upon Lee and Yang/SISA, the court imposed
joint liability. And even if this language was ambiguous, any
ambiguity should be construed in favor of joint liability, which is
the presumptive type of liability. (Civ. Code, § 1431; Aetna
Health Plans of California, Inc. v. Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint
Unified School Dist. (1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 1175, 1189.)
The trial court’s imposition of joint liability was also
consistent with the law. Although Civil Code section 1431.2
precludes the imposition of joint liability for “non-economic
damages” (Civ. Code, § 1431.2, subd. (a)), and although “assumed
damages” include elements of “non-economic damages” because
both address “injury to reputation” and “mental suffering” (id.,

7
subd. (b)(2); Douglas v. Janis (1974) 43 Cal.App.3d 931, 940-941;
DiGiorgio Fruit Corp. v. AFL-CIO (1963) 215 Cal.App.2d 560,
576-577; CACI Nos. 1700, 1704), the rule against the imposition
of joint liability for non-economic damages does not apply to
intentional tortfeasors who are acting in concert to cause a
plaintiff’s indivisible injury. (B.B. v. County of Los Angeles (2020)
10 Cal.5th 1, 20, 24; see also Kesmodel v. Rand (2004) 119
Cal.App.4th 1128, 1145 [statute does not apply to “joint
tortfeasors who act in concert to cause the plaintiff’s harm”].)
Here, the trial court found that Lee and Yang/SISA not only
acted intentionally, but also with malice. Joint liability is
supported by the law.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Plaintiff is entitled to his costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS.

______________________, P.J.
HOFFSTADT

We concur:

_________________________, J.
BAKER

_________________________, J.
KIM (D.)

8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.