CourtListener 10516852•In re J.L. CA6
Texto completo
Filed 5/2/25 In re J.L. CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re J.L., a Person Coming Under the H052018
Juvenile Court Law. (San Benito County
Super. Ct. No. JV-21-00027)
SAN BENITO COUNTY HEALTH AND
HUMAN SERVICES AGENCY,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.L.,
Defendant and Appellant.
On November 16, 2021, the San Benito County Health and Human Services
Agency (Agency), filed a juvenile dependency petition alleging the failure of the mother,
D.L. (Mother) and the father, A.L. (Father) to protect and provide support for their minor
child, J.L., under Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b)(1).1 The
Agency alleged that Father, who had sole physical and legal custody of J.L., was unable
to supervise or protect J.L. adequately because of Father’s alcohol abuse. The Agency
also alleged that Mother, whose reunification services with J.L. had previously been
terminated in a prior dependency matter, continued to struggle with alcohol and
1
Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
substance abuse. On November 22, 2021, the juvenile court ordered that J.L. be detained
and placed in protective custody.
The juvenile court later ordered that J.L. be removed from Mother and Father’s
(the parents) care, while granting them reunification services. Following a contested
twelve-month hearing, the court terminated the parents’ reunification services and
scheduled a selection and implementation hearing pursuant to section 366.26 (section
366.26 hearing). The Agency ultimately recommended a parental plan of adoption and
termination of Mother’s and Father’s parental rights, which the court adopted.
On appeal, Father contends that a crucial page of the Agency’s report for the
section 366.26 hearing, namely, the page informing the court of Father’s relationship and
visitation with J.L., was missing. He therefore argues that because the information on
this page was not before the court, he was denied constitutional due process and a
meaningful opportunity to be heard on whether his parental rights should be terminated.
He further argues that the trial court erred in failing to find that an exception to adoption
had been proven. In the alternative, he argues that he received ineffective assistance of
counsel based on counsel’s failure to object to the missing page or the introduction of
testimonial evidence regarding his visitation with J.L.
For the reasons stated below, we find no merit to Father’s claims and affirm.2
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Petition and Detention (November 2021)
1. Petition and Allegations
On November 16, 2021, the Agency filed a juvenile dependency petition alleging
that six-year-old J.L. came within the juvenile court's jurisdiction because he had
suffered, or was at substantial risk of suffering, serious physical harm “as a result of the
failure or inability of his or her parent or legal guardian to supervise or protect the child
2
By separate order, the habeas corpus matter filed by Father in Case No. H052878
related to the same underlying juvenile case was summarily denied on May 2, 2025.
2
adequately.” (See § 300, subd. (b)(1).) The Agency alleged that on October 9, 2021,
Father was reported to be heavily intoxicated at a local bar, while J.L. was sitting
unsupervised in Father’s car parked outside the bar. Mother later arrived and observed
J.L. alone in the car, then saw Father outside the bar. Mother reported that Father was
intoxicated and arguing with Mother’s sister and her friend. Father then grabbed J.L. by
the wrist and tried to pull him away from Mother. Father was subsequently arrested.
The Agency additionally alleged that at the time of this incident, Mother
confirmed she was continuing to use methamphetamine and drink alcohol. The Agency
then spoke to J.L., who stated that Father was “drunk because he drinks too
much. He is sick, he wants to drive too fast.” Father later admitted that he had consumed
nine beers outside the bar while J.L. sat alone in Father’s vehicle.
In an amended petition filed on November 17, 2021, the Agency indicated that
Mother had an 18-year history of criminal convictions involving drugs, including
methamphetamine, and had been ordered to rehabilitative services on multiple occasions.
The Agency further noted that due to both parents’ chronic history of substance and
alcohol abuse, J.L. was placed in protective custody in 2019, and court-ordered services
were provided from then until February 2021. The case was closed in March 2021 with
successful reunification to Father, who was granted full physical and legal custody, and
termination of reunification services to Mother. However, Father admitted that he
resumed drinking in June 2021, approximately three months after he had completed
services.
The Agency additionally reported that Father had three prior convictions for
driving under the influence of alcohol in 2017, 2018, and 2019, and was unlicensed.
Further, as a result of the October 9, 2021 incident, Father had been arrested on charges
of child abuse and battery on a former partner or spouse.
Finally, the Agency noted that Father had not been abiding by the safety plan
initiated on October 9, 2021. Pursuant to this plan, J.L. was placed in the care of his
3
maternal grandmother, who agreed to contact law enforcement if Father attempted to pick
up J.L. On November 8, 2021, the Agency learned that the terms of the safety plan were
not being followed, thus placing J.L. in substantial risk of harm.
Neither the initial nor amended petitions recommended that J.L. be detained or
removed from Father’s custody.
2. Detention Hearing
An initial detention hearing was held on November 22, 2021. In anticipation of
the hearing, the Agency prepared another report and changed its recommendation to now
support detention. The Agency indicated that its recommendation was based on Father
continuing to display unsafe decision making and lack of insight into his substance abuse
problem, even after receiving 18 months of services. The Agency noted that Father
continued to allow Mother to be around J.L., despite knowing Mother’s history with
drugs and her own admission to currently use. In addition, after the safety plan was put
into place on October 9, Father disregarded the plan by repeatedly asking to pick J.L. up
from his maternal grandmother, including within less than 24 hours of the safety plan
being implemented, and had violated the plan by taking custody of J.L. from October 29
through November 4. Father also questioned the Agency’s integrity and goals, and
displayed a lack of insight into how his actions were placing J.L. at serious risk of harm.
The Agency therefore recommended that J.L. be detained and an out of home placement
be made.
At the hearing, the court found that a prima facie showing had been made with
respect to the allegations in the petition and ordered that J.L. be detained and temporarily
placed under the Agency’s care, custody, and control.
B. Jurisdictional/Dispositional Orders (December 2021 and January 2022)
1. Jurisdictional Hearing
A contested jurisdictional hearing was scheduled for December 20, 2021. In
anticipation of the hearing, the Agency’s report recommended that the court continue
4
J.L.’s out of home placement until disposition. In addition to the allegations in the initial
petition and detention report, the Agency indicated that on November 30, 2021, Father
admitted he had not abided by the safety plan at all, and J.L. had been in his custody the
entire time that the plan was meant to be in effect. The Agency noted that both parents
continued to struggle with substance abuse, and Father admitted that he continued to
consume alcohol, including immediately following his October 9 arrest, and had
previously consumed alcohol on days when J.L. was in his care. At the December 20
hearing, the court adopted the recommended findings and order from the report, found
the allegations of the amended petition true, and ordered that J.L. remain in his out of
home placement pending disposition.
2. Dispositional Hearing
On December 29, 2021, the Agency filed a report in anticipation of the disposition
hearing. In its report, the Agency recommended that that the court sustain the petition,
adjudge J.L. as a dependent of the court, have J.L. remain in out of home care, and offer
reunification services to Mother and Father. J.L. had been placed in a nonrelative
resource family approved (RFA) home in San Benito County.
According to the Agency, Mother admitted to currently using alcohol and
methamphetamine, but was aware that she needed to work towards sobriety and obtain
counseling to help her address past trauma from being in abusive relationships. In
contrast, Father felt he primarily needed to work on his parenting skills, and did not
believe he required substance abuse or similar services because such courses only taught
how to “fear” drinking, as opposed to assisting in stopping drinking entirely.
The Agency concluded that J.L. would be at substantial risk of harm if he were
returned to either parent. In addition to Father resuming alcohol consumption only 18
months after successfully reunifying with J.L., Father had not demonstrated his
willingness or ability to protect J.L. from Mother, who continued to engage in substance
abuse. Father also did not believe he had a substance abuse problem or that he needed
5
treatment. With respect to Mother, she admitted to currently using methamphetamine,
and had not reunified with J.L. in 2021 after receiving services to address past drug and
substance abuse concerns. Mother also indicated that she would be losing her housing
soon, thus reflecting that she did not have a safe environment for J.L. to live in if she
were to be awarded custody. Further, the Agency expressed concern that Mother had not
demonstrated a willingness or ability to protect J.L. from Father’s substance use, as
Mother did not take any steps to ensure J.L. was safe in Father’s care despite being aware
that Father had begun consuming alcohol again.
At the uncontested dispositional hearing on January 3, 2022, the court declared
J.L. as a dependent of the court, and ordered family reunification services to the parents
along with visitation in accordance with their case plans. A six-month review hearing
was set for June 27, 2022.
C. Six-Month Review
On June 22, 2022, the Agency filed a report in anticipation of the six-month
review hearing. The Agency reported that apart from attending one Child and Family
Team Meeting in February, Mother had not complied with her court-ordered case plan.
Mother had been referred to mental health therapy, but did not attend her scheduled
intake appointments and had yet to schedule a new one. Mother had also not complied
with substance abuse counseling requirements and frequently missed appointments and
group sessions, resulting in her being discharged from substance abuse services in May
2022. Although Mother indicated she had been sober since April 2022, she stated that
she was still using “on occasion,” and failed to submit to regular drug testing or enroll in
Alcoholics Anonymous Meetings as required under her case plan.
Mother consistently attended her supervised visitation during the review period,
which consisted of visitation once a week for one hour. The Agency reported that apart
from one visit where J.L. threw a tantrum, Mother’s visitation was going well, as she
6
engaged and interacted well with J.L., brought appropriate snacks and activities, and
promptly addressed any behavior concerns promptly.
With respect to Father, the Agency reported that he had complied with a number
of requirements of his court-ordered case plan, including: (1) attending a Child and
Family Team Meeting; (2) attending a mental health intake appointment; and (3)
successfully completing parent education programs. Father had also partially complied
with substance abuse counseling and testing requirements, but had missed a number of
group sessions and seemed more focused on what he felt the Agency was not doing to
support reunification.
Father also consistently attended his supervised visitation during the review
period, which consisted of visitation once a week for one hour. While the Agency
reported that visits were going well overall, Father would often use time during the visits
to address his concerns with his case and social worker, and raised his voice to the social
worker on one occasion, causing J.L. to ask Father why he was fighting. On one
occasion, J.L. had a tantrum because he wanted a toy, and Father ultimately gave in and
bought him one instead of talking to him about why he could not have one.
The Agency also expressed concern that Father had refused to make himself
available or meet with staff from the Agency during the review period, and had expressly
indicated he would only meet Agency staff in court. As a result, the Agency had not
been able to meet with Father to assess his progress, review his case plan, or discuss
anything regarding J.L.
It was concluded by the Agency that Mother: (1) had not engaged in services; (2)
had not made progress; and (3) had not been able to maintain her sobriety. The Agency
also concluded that while Father had engaged in services, made minimal progress, and
appeared to be maintaining sobriety, his failure to maintain contact and make himself
available to the Agency made it difficult to fully assess his current circumstances and
progress. In addition, Father continued to minimize both parents’ substance abuse issues
7
and had not demonstrated his ability to protect J.L. from these behaviors. The Agency
therefore recommended that reunification services be continued for both Mother and
Father.
At the hearing on June 27, 2022, the court adopted the recommendations of the
Agency and continued reunification services for Mother and Father. A twelve-month
review hearing was set for December 8, 2022.
D. Twelve-Month Review
On December 7, 2022, the Agency filed a report in anticipation of the twelve-
month hearing. The Agency indicated that on August 24, 2022, Father had been arrested
on charges of felony driving under the influence of alcohol, driving without a license, and
making threats to a police officer. Father’s bail was set at $100,000, and he remained
incarcerated for most of the review period. On December 2, 2022, Father pled no contest
to all three charges and was awaiting sentencing at the time of the Agency’s report.
The Agency indicated that at the time of his arrest, Father’s blood alcohol level
was 0.194%. Father later reported that he had purchased three bottles of tequila on
August 22 and secretly began drinking at work the next day, which resulted in him
consuming the majority of the bottles. He then began driving home, but felt unwell and
pulled over on the road to sleep. After Father awoke, he began driving to a local
restaurant but was pulled over by law enforcement and subsequently arrested for driving
under the influence. Father claimed that he “did not think it was anything criminal”
because he had just consumed alcohol and had not assaulted or robbed anyone.
The Agency noted that due to Father’s incarceration, he had not been able to
comply with certain portions of his case plan, including additional parental education
courses. While Father had partially complied with substance abuse counseling through
July 2022, he stopped attending sessions in August 2022 shortly before his arrest.
However, in September 2022, Father began regularly attending substance abuse
counseling in jail and was reportedly engaging well in his sessions. In addition, prior to
8
his arrest, Father had submitted to drug tests, which were all negative, and had been
attending Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous sessions in jail.
Prior to his arrest, Father had consistent weekly visitation with J.L. However,
when he missed his visit on August 25, 2022, J.L. had a difficult time and became very
upset. J.L. had been experiencing more behavioral difficulties since the visits stopped.
He later told his social worker to communicate to the parents that “it was not ok to not
attend a visit,” he missed visiting Father, and he wanted Father “to behave and be good.”
With respect to Mother, the Agency reported that Mother continued to not engage
in services, including mental health counseling, substance abuse counseling, and
substance abuse testing. While Mother generally was consistent with her weekly
visitation with J.L., the Agency indicated that she was frequently late, resulting in the
visits lasting less than an hour. Mother also missed a number of visits, and often did not
communicate that she would not be attending the visit until contacted to ask where she
was.
The Agency further noted that J.L. had been experiencing behavioral issues at
school, including aggressive and disruptive behaviors that resulted in him either being
sent to the principal’s office, or the principal or vice-principal being called to his
classroom almost daily. Academic personnel also confirmed that J.L.’s behavior began
to worsen after Father was arrested. J.L. had been provided with mental health services
to assist him with processing his emotions in a healthy manner, and an Individualized
Education Plan (IEP) to assist him with educational difficulties. However, the Agency
noted that J.L.’s placement had changed during the review period after his prior
caretakers had to repeatedly leave work early to pick up J.L. from school due to his
behavioral issues, and they could no longer maintain the placement as a result. While
J.L. was familiar with the new placement, as he had previously been placed there briefly
during the prior dependency case, he expressed that he was sad to be leaving his previous
caregivers, and was “bored” because his new caregivers were not as active.
9
The Agency concluded that like the previous dependency case, Mother did not
take advantage of the services offered as she did not engage in services, did not make
progress, remained homeless, and had not been able to maintain sobriety. The Agency
also concluded that Father’s choice to resume drinking only a few months after
successfully reunifying with J.L., and his actions that led to the October 2021 arrest,
reflected he was making unsafe decisions and lacked insight into his alcohol issues even
after receiving 18 months of services. Father also made another unsafe decision by
choosing to drive after drinking a substantial amount of tequila, which led to his August
2022 arrest. The Agency determined that based on Father’s actions, he had not fully
resolved his substance abuse issues and was not taking accountability for his actions or
their effect on J.L.’s mental and physical health. The Agency therefore believed that
further services would not be beneficial to for the family, and recommended that
reunification services be terminated for both Mother and Father.
The December 8, 2022 hearing was continued at Father’s request, who indicated
he wished to set the matter for a contested hearing. On February 16, 2023, Father
indicated he no longer wished to move forward with a contested hearing, and instead
requested that the court consider J.L.’s maternal aunt for guardianship. The court
adopted the recommendations of the Agency and terminated reunification services for
Mother and Father. At the Agency’s request, a selection and implementation hearing was
scheduled for June 15, 2023.
E. Selection and Implementation Proceedings
1. August 2023 Proceedings
a. Adoption Assessment and Agency Report
An adoption assessment was performed by the California Department of
Social Services (CDSS) on June 1, 2023. The assessment concluded that J.L. was likely
to be adopted, and recommended that the court order a plan of adoption without
terminating the parental rights of Mother and Father. The assessment noted that J.L. had
10
been in five placements since the inception of his case, and had been in his current
placement with his maternal relatives in Bakersfield since March 2023. The maternal
relatives were interested in adopting J.L. once he had reached an adequate level of
behavioral and emotional stability in their home. The assessment indicated that J.L.
continued to have difficulty regulating and appropriately expressing his emotions, and
had already engaged in disruptive behavior at his new school, which he began attending
shortly after moving to Bakersfield. However, the assessment found that J.L. enjoyed his
current placement and felt safe with his caregivers, and was happy to be living with
family.
The assessment additionally noted that beginning in March 2023, Father had been
able to engage in video visits with J.L., and Mother was also engaging in visits once a
month with J.L. However, in reviewing whether J.L. would benefit from continued
contact with his parents, the assessment concluded that the parents had not mitigated the
issues that resulted in J.L.’s dependency, and were not able to provide him with a safe
and stable home. Although the assessment did not recommend that parental rights be
terminated, it concluded that the exception to termination as set forth in section 366.26,
subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i)3, did not apply, and termination would not be “significantly
unfavorable” to J.L.
The Agency subsequently prepared a report on June 6, 2023, recommending a
permanent plan of adoption without terminating Mother’s and Father’s parental rights. In
addition to the information provided in the adoption assessment, the Agency indicated
that since the February 2023 court hearing, both Mother and Father were consistently
3
This section provides, in relevant part, that if a court determines by clear and
convincing evidence that a child will be adopted, it shall order adoption and terminate
parental rights unless it “finds a compelling reason for determining that termination
would be detrimental to the child due to one or more of the following circumstances: [¶]
(i) The parents have maintained regular visitation and contact with the child and the child
would benefit from continuing the relationship.”
11
attending supervised visits with J.L. once a month, which had been going well, and the
Agency recommended that these visits continue.
b. Section 388 Petition
Prior to the hearing, Father filed a petition pursuant to section 3884 requesting that
reunification services be reinstated for an additional six months. In his petition, Father
indicated that he had completed a number of classes and programs while in jail, and also
attended three virtual visits with J.L. Father noted that J.L. was “bonded” to him, had
been struggling in foster care, and would benefit from further visitation and services in
order to obtain more stability. Father also indicated that he would be released shortly
from jail, thus allowing him to resume visits and provide J.L. with a stable and loving
home.
c. Hearing
On August 10, 2023, the court held a joint hearing on Father’s section 388 petition
and the section 366.26 proceedings. At the hearing, Father’s counsel argued that he had
made “tremendous progress” on his sobriety even while incarcerated, acknowledged his
failings and shortfalls, and had made substantial changes that would justify him receiving
more time to engage in services. In opposition, the Agency argued that Father’s track
record of short periods of sobriety, followed by relapses, provided a “forecast” of what
Father was capable of doing, and therefore did not constitute changed circumstances.
The Agency further argued that the maximum time for offering future services, which
was 18 months, had already passed. Minor’s counsel agreed with the Agency that Father
had not demonstrated changed circumstances warranting further reunification services,
4
This section provides, in pertinent part, that a parent may, “upon grounds of
change of circumstance or new evidence, petition the court in the same action in which
the child was found to be a dependent child of the juvenile court … for a hearing to
change, modify, or set aside any order of court previously made or to terminate the
jurisdiction of the court.”
12
and indicated that the focus of the proceedings should shift to achieving permanency for
J.L.
The court denied Father’s petition and found that while Father was making “some
effort,” that did not constitute a substantial change in circumstances given his past history
and lack of understanding of the steps needed to maintain sobriety. The court
subsequently adopted the recommendations in the Agency’s report for a permanent plan
of adoption without terminating Mother’s and Father’s parental rights. A further
selection and implementation hearing was set for February 8, 2024.
2. February 2024 Proceedings
a. Further Adoption Assessment and Agency Report
An updated CDSS adoption assessment was performed on January 12, 2024. The
assessment again concluded that J.L. was likely to be adopted and recommended the
court order a plan of adoption; however, the updated assessment recommended that
parental rights be terminated. The assessment noted that: (1) J.L.’s grades had improved
in all subjects; (2) his mental and emotional stability had also improved; and (3) he had
adjusted well to his new home and school. J.L. also expressed that he wanted to be
adopted by his maternal relatives and felt safe in their home, though he did wish to
continue seeing Father. Although the specialist performing the assessment had not
observed any visitation with the parents, the visitation supervisor at the Agency had
reported that J.L. continued to have visits once a month for an hour with Mother and
Father, and that he enjoyed these visits. However, prior to visits with Father, J.L.
regularly told his caregivers he would “be back” in an hour, and only asked about
subsequent visits with Father, but not with Mother. The assessment again concluded that
terminating parental rights due to J.L.’s relationship with Mother and/or Father would not
be detrimental to him, particularly given both parents’ inability to meet J.L.’s needs and
provide him with a safe and stable home.
13
The Agency also prepared an updated report on January 25, 2024, in anticipation
of the continued selection and implementation hearing. The Agency similarly
recommended a permanent plan of adoption with termination of Mother’s and Father’s
parental rights. The report did not contain information regarding visitation between J.L.
and Father since the last hearing. However, the Agency noted that J.L. had displayed the
most progress to date during the past 11 months spent in his current placement, and his
maternal relatives had demonstrated their attentiveness to J.L.’s needs and desire to raise
him in a healthy and loving home.
b. Section 388 Petition and Opposition
On February 20, 2024, Father filed a new section 388 petition requesting
additional reunification services, increased visitation, and maintaining the current
guardianship with a goal of allowing Father to co-parent J.L. In support of his request,
Father provided documentation that he had completed a number of classes related to
parental accountability and was “well engaged” in treatment for substance abuse,
including negative test results for alcohol and drugs
In opposition, the Agency argued that Father had not demonstrated a substantial
change in circumstances, particularly given his history of relapsing after maintaining
sobriety for short periods of time. The Agency also noted that the instant case was the
second one involving J.L., and was opened only eight months after Father had reunified
with J.L. after J.L was removed under similar circumstances involving general neglect
and substance abuse. The Agency further argued that changing the permanent plan from
adoption to guardianship would not be in J.L.’s best interests, particularly given the
improvements in J.L.’s behavior after being in the same placement for a sustained period
of time, as well as his desire to be adopted by his relatives and be safe.
c. Hearing
On February 22, 2024, the court held a joint hearing on Father’s new section 388
petition and the continued section 366.26 proceedings. At the hearing, Father ‘s counsel
14
argued that Father had done “a lot of work” to rehabilitate himself and address his
substance abuse problems. Counsel acknowledged that Father recognized the necessity
for J.L. to have permanency, but still wanted an opportunity to “redeem” himself and
remain a part of J.L.’s life and upbringing. Counsel therefore asked that the court “assist
in [Father] not having his parental rights terminated. Or at least, if they are terminated, to
allow some sort of visitation or contact with his son.”
In response, the Agency argued that Father was attempting to shift the focus from
what was best for J.L. to what Father wanted, without showing changed circumstances
that would justify a modification of the permanent plan of adoption. The Agency also
noted that J.L. had been in out of home placements for more than half of his life as a
result of the two dependency matters, and was finally doing well and achieving stability
in his current home with his relatives/prospective adoptive parents. Minor’s counsel
joined in the Agency’s argument and similarly contended that Father failed to
demonstrate his request was in J.L.’s best interest or furthered the goal of permanency.
Prior to making its ruling, the court asked the Agency to summarize J.L.’s contact
with Father, to which the Agency responded: “Up to this point he’s had monthly
visits, one per month. And the adoptive parents are given the option to enter into a post
adoption contact agreement. And I believe they have declined to do that. [¶] And once
parental rights are terminated, it’s up to the adoptive parents whether or not they’re going
to, as the parents of the child, allow any future contact with the birth parents.” The
Agency also confirmed that J.L. wished to be adopted.
The court ultimately concluded that Father had been given “ample opportunity to
remedy this situation he finds himself in, and to do everything he could for his child, and
ensure that relationship and possible reunification.” The court therefore found no
changed circumstances and denied Father’s motion. The court adopted the recommended
findings and orders in the Agency’s report for a permanent plan of adoption and
termination of parental rights to both parents.
15
Father timely appealed.
II. DISCUSSION
A. Due Process Violation
Father argues that a page was missing from the Agency’s January 25, 2024 report,
namely, the page that should have contained information regarding the history of his
contacts with J.L. and which included information regarding Father and J.L.’s visitation
prior to the February 2024 hearing. Father further argues that the court improperly
accepted the Agency’s statement on the record of this information as true, without
requiring sworn testimony or allowing Father the opportunity to conduct cross-
examination. Father claims that because such information was “exculpatory evidence”
relevant to the issue of terminating his parental rights, the omission of such information
constituted a violation of his constitutional due process rights and deprived him of a fair
opportunity to be heard. In response, the Agency argues that because Father did not
object to the missing page in the juvenile court, he has forfeited this claim on appeal.
Based on the information before us, we agree that Father forfeited this issue based
on his failure to object to the missing page and purported missing information regarding
visitation.
1. Applicable Law
The purpose of a section 366.26 report is to provide the juvenile court with the
information necessary to determine the permanent plan for the children. (See In re
B.D. (2019) 35 Cal.App.5th 803, 821.) To that end, the agency supervising the child and
the adoption agency are both required to prepare an assessment that must include, among
other things, the following: “A review of the amount of and nature of any contact
between the child and their parents or legal guardians and other members of their
extended family since the time of placement.” (§ 366.21, subd. (i)(1)(B).)
Where “no objection to the sufficiency of the assessment reports was made at
time of trial, [we] refer to the familiar principle that failure to object to the admission of
16
improper or inadequate evidence [forfeits] the right to raise the issue on appeal.
[Citation.] If the complaint on appeal be deemed not the admissibility … of inadequate
assessment reports, but substantive insufficien[c]y to establish requisite findings, this
complaint, too, [is] [forfeited] by failure to raise it at the trial level. [Citation.]” (In re
Crystal J. (1993) 12 Cal.App.4th 407, 411–412, fn. omitted (Crystal J.); see also In re
Mary C. (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th 793, 801 [by failing to object in the juvenile court to
specific defects in the reports, parents forfeit any challenge to them on appeal].) “ ‘The
purpose of this rule is to encourage parties to bring errors to the attention of the trial
court, so that they may be corrected. [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (In re Daniel B. (2014)
231 Cal.App.4th 663, 672.)
2. Forfeiture
In reviewing the record, we agree with Father that the Agency’s report dated
January 25, 2024, appears to be missing a page, as the page numbers go directly from
page 8 to 10, and the report does not contain information regarding Father’s visitation
with J.L., which appeared in all of the Agency’s prior reports. With that said, it is
undisputed that Father failed to raise any objections below regarding the admission of the
report, including any specific objections regarding the missing page and the information
it purportedly contained regarding his visitation with J.L. However, Father claims that
because the missing page contained “exculpatory evidence,” its omission constituted a
violation of his due process rights, a constitutional issue which he may raise for the first
time on appeal.
We find no merit to this claim. “ ‘Where [ ] the assessment report is prepared, is
available to the parties in advance of the noticed hearing, and does address the principal
questions at issue in the particular proceeding, errors or omissions in the report cannot be
characterized in terms of denial of due process.’ [Citations.] Deficiencies in an
assessment report surely go to the weight of the evidence, and if sufficiently egregious
may impair the basis of a court's decision to terminate parental rights. Such deficiencies,
17
however, will ordinarily not amount to a deprivation of procedural due process.”
(Crystal J., supra, 12 Cal.App.4th at p. 413.)
In the instant case, the Agency’s report was prepared almost a month in advance
of the selection and implementation hearing, and addressed the principal question at
issue, namely, J.L.’s likelihood of adoption. In addition, while the Agency’s report did
not contain information regarding Father’s visitation with J.L., the record reflects that the
missing page was not the sole evidence available regarding this information. The
updated adoption assessment prepared prior to the February 2024 hearing indicated that
the visitation supervisor had reported Father and J.L. continued to have monthly
visitation.5 Further, Father was aware that visitation would be at issue at the section
366.26 hearing, and therefore had every incentive to ensure the court had an adequate
record before it on this issue; indeed, Father himself provided a letter from the executive
director of his parenting education program, which documented the number of video and
in-person visits he had with J.L. as of February 2024.
Accordingly, we conclude that no due process violation occurred due to the
omission of the page in question, and Father’s failure to object on this basis constituted
forfeiture.
B. Applicability of Beneficial Parent-Child Relationship Exception
Father argues that he met his burden in establishing that there was a beneficial
parent-child relationship between him and J.L., which serves as an exception to adoption
or termination of parental rights. He therefore claims that the trial court erred in not
applying the exception and terminating his parental rights.
5
Although Father claims such evidence was unreliable because the assessment
specialist did not personally supervise or observe these visits, we note that no such
requirement is contained in section 366.21 regarding the required information for the
assessment.
18
1. Applicable Law
“At a permanency plan hearing, the court may order one of three alternatives:
adoption, guardianship or long-term foster care. [Citation.] If the dependent child is
adoptable, there is a strong preference for adoption over the alternative permanency
plans. [Citations.] [¶] Once the court determines the child is likely to be adopted, the
burden shifts to the parent to show that termination of parental rights would be
detrimental to the child under one of the exceptions listed in section 366.26, subdivision
(c)(1). [Citations.] Section 366.26, subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i), provides an exception to
termination of parental rights when ‘[t]he parents have maintained regular visitation and
contact with the child and the child would benefit from continuing the relationship.’ ”
(In re S.B. (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 289, 296–297.)
“The party claiming an exception to adoption has the burden of proof to establish
by a preponderance of evidence that the exception applies. [Citation.]” (In re Rachel M.
(2003) 113 Cal.App.4th 1289, 1295 [finding that failure to raise an exception to adoption
at the hearing below results in waiver of the issue on appeal]; see also In re Melvin
A. (2000) 82 Cal.App.4th 1243, 1252.) The juvenile court does not have a sua sponte
duty to determine whether an exception to adoption applies. (Id. at p. 1252; see also In re
Erik P. (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th 395, 402–403.)
2. Forfeiture
As a threshold matter, the Agency argues that because Father failed to raise the
exception at the trial level, he has forfeited it on appeal, and the juvenile court was under
no obligation to raise the exception sua sponte. On reply, Father appears to concede that
the Agency’s argument is “legally correct.”
To the extent Father concedes that the issue was forfeited, such a concession is
well-founded. The record reflects Father’s counsel did not raise or discuss the beneficial
parent-child relationship exception at the February 2024 selection and implementation
hearing, and only focused on Father’s progress in addressing his substance and alcohol
19
abuse. Indeed, the only reference to the exception appears in the adoption assessment,
which concluded that the exception did not apply based on both parents’ inability to meet
J.L.’s needs and provide him with a safe and stable home. Accordingly, because Father
bore the burden of proof to establish that the exception applied, counsel’s failure to raise
the exception below constituted forfeiture of the issue on appeal, and the court was under
no obligation to independently determine whether the exception applied.
C. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
Father alternatively claims that if we find forfeiture of the above issues, he
received ineffective assistance based on counsel’s failure to object to the missing page in
the Agency’s report, which would have provided sufficient evidence to support the
beneficial parent-child relationship exception. He further claims he received ineffective
assistance based on counsel’s failure to object to the court taking the Agency’s counsel’s
statement regarding visitation into evidence.
In a dependency proceeding, a parent seeking to establish ineffective assistance of
counsel must show both that counsel failed to act in a manner to be expected of a
reasonably competent attorney practicing in the field of juvenile dependency law, and it
is “ ‘reasonably probable that a result more favorable to the appealing party would have
been reached in the absence of the error.’ ” (In re Kristin H. (1996) 46 Cal.App.4th 1635,
1668; see also In re A.R. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 234, 247 [affirming holding of Kristen H. and
similar decisions “[a]s a general rule, a parent who has not received competent
representation in juvenile dependency proceedings is entitled to seek relief based on
denial of the statutory right”].) When a parent seeks to assert ineffective assistance of
counsel on direct appeal, appellate courts further limit their review to consider only those
claims “ ‘where “there simply could be no satisfactory explanation” for trial counsel’s
action or inaction.’ ” (In re Darlice C. (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 459, 463, quoting In re
Dennis H. (2001) 88 Cal.App.4th 94, 98, fn. 1.)
20
Turning to Father’s claims, the record does not reflect that counsel’s failure to
object fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, or that it is reasonably probable
Father would have achieved a more favorable result in the absence of such error. With
respect to deficient performance, counsel filed a section 388 petition specifically to object
to the termination of parental rights, which had not originally been recommended at the
first selection and implementation hearing. In the petition, counsel briefly described the
strength of the relationship between Father and J.L., and also provided documentation in
the petition with specific details regarding Father’s visitation and contact with J.L.—the
very details that were apparently missing from the Agency’s report. Additionally, as
described above, information regarding Father’s visitation with J.L. had been
documented in the January 2024 adoption assessment. Moreover, the representation
made by the Agency’s counsel regarding Father’s visitation with J.L.—namely, that visits
took place once a month—was the same information provided in both the adoption
assessment and Father’s section 388 petition. Accordingly, counsel could have
reasonably concluded that it was unnecessary to raise any objections regarding the
missing page from the report when the same information was already before the court.
Further, as indicated above, the adoption assessment specifically reported that it did not
find the beneficial parent-child relationship exception applicable, based on the parents’
continued substance abuse issues and inability to provide a safe and stable home for J.L.
Therefore, counsel could have rationally concluded that raising this exception to adoption
would have been futile or meritless. (See, e.g., People v. Bradley (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th
64, 90 [“[f]ailure to raise a meritless objection is not ineffective assistance of counsel”].)
With respect to prejudice, namely, the reasonable probability of a different
outcome, we again find that there was nothing in the record to demonstrate Father’s
parental rights would not have been terminated if counsel had raised the objections noted
above. In denying Father’s section 388 petition, the court specifically noted that Father
“was given ample opportunity” to remedy the situation he was in and “ensure that
21
relationship and possible reunification,” yet did not do so. Based on such statements, we
cannot conclude that the court’s decision to terminate parental rights rested entirely on
the information—or purported lack thereof—regarding Father’s visitation with J.L.
Consequently, Father has not demonstrated he was prejudiced because he has not met his
burden to show a reasonable probability that he would have obtained a more favorable
result absent counsel’s failure to object.
III. DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order terminating Father’s parental rights is affirmed.
22
___________________________________
Wilson, J.
WE CONCUR:
__________________________________________
Greenwood, P. J.
__________________________________________
Grover, J.
In re J.L.; San Benito County HHS v. A.L.
H052018
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.