CourtListener 10407781•In re R.C. CA2/2
Texto completo
Filed 4/29/25 In re R.C. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re R.C., a Person Coming B339416
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
Super. Ct.
No. 20CCJP02562C)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
S.T.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Brett Bianco, Judge. Affirmed.
Megan Turkat Schirn, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Sally Son, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________________
Defendant and appellant S.T. (mother) challenges the
juvenile custody order (exit order) issued by the juvenile court
upon termination of dependency jurisdiction over her daughter,
R.C. (minor, born Aug. 2019). (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 362.4.)1 The
exit order granted mother and minor’s father, Raj C. (father),2
joint legal custody of minor; father sole physical custody; and
monitored visits for mother. Mother contends that the court
abused its discretion by ordering her visitation with minor be
monitored.
We affirm.
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.
2 Father is not a party to this appeal. We refer to mother
and father, collectively, as the parents.
2
BACKGROUND3
I. Prior Dependency History
In August 2020, the juvenile court sustained a section 300
petition filed on behalf of minor based on the parents’ history of
domestic violence; mother’s mental and emotional problems;
mother creating a detrimental and endangering situation for
minor while under the influence of alcohol, including mother
feeding minor flower petals and threatening to throw minor’s
great-grandmother off a balcony; and the parents’ substance
abuse issues, including mother’s alcohol abuse. A year later, in
August 2021, the court terminated its jurisdiction and released
minor to mother.
In September 2022, the juvenile court sustained another
section 300 petition based on the parents’ domestic violence and
father’s substance abuse. In March 2023, the court terminated
its jurisdiction over minor, released minor to mother, and granted
father monitored visits.
II. September 2023 Exercise of Dependency Jurisdiction
On July 17, 2023, DCFS filed a third dependency petition
seeking the juvenile court’s exercise of jurisdiction over minor
pursuant to section 300, subdivision (b)(1) (failure to protect).
The petition alleged that mother had “a history of substance
abuse including marijuana and [was] a current abuser of alcohol,”
rendering her incapable of providing regular care for minor. On
3 Respondent Los Angeles County Department of Children
and Family Services (DCFS) filed a motion requesting that we
incorporate or, in the alternative, take judicial notice of the
appellate record in mother’s prior appeal in this dependency
matter, appeal No. B334592, which was dismissed as abandoned.
We hereby grant the request for judicial notice. (Evid. Code,
§§ 452, subd. (d), 459.)
3
several occasions, mother was under the influence of alcohol
while minor was in her care. Mother’s substance abuse
endangered minor’s physical safety and placed her at risk of
serious physical harm.
At the adjudication hearing held on September 12, 2023,
the juvenile court sustained the dependency petition as pled. The
court once again declared minor a dependent of the court but
ordered that she remain placed with mother under DCFS
supervision. The court conditioned minor’s release to mother on
mother “stay[ing] in her program, shelter, or in DCFS approved
housing, participat[ing] in testing, abstain[ing] from all alcohol
products, and complet[ing] the other conditions of her case plan.”
III. Detention; Supplemental and Subsequent Petitions
On October 19, 2023, DCFS received a report that mother
had been found intoxicated at a park. Later that day, a DCFS
social worker met with mother, who appeared to still be under
the influence of alcohol and exhibited slurred speech. Mother
stated that she had accepted a drink from a friend without
knowing what it was. She declined to submit to a drug/alcohol
test that day, admitting she was currently under the influence of
alcohol. When she was informed minor would be detained,
mother threatened to cut herself, which led to law enforcement
being called. After minor was removed from mother’s arms,
mother assaulted a social worker.
On October 23, 2023, DCFS filed a supplemental petition
under section 387 seeking to detain minor based on mother being
under the influence of alcohol to such a degree that she was
unconscious, in violation of the juvenile court’s order to abstain
from all alcohol products.
4
On October 24, 2023, the juvenile court ordered minor
detained from mother and that their visits be monitored. Minor
was placed in shelter care under DCFS supervision. Shortly
thereafter, minor was placed in the home of her paternal aunt in
San Jose.
In a November 2023 interview, a paternal cousin reported
that mother had arrived intoxicated to a visit with minor in
San Jose. She returned the next day sober and was able to have
a visit. The relatives then purchased a bus ticket for mother to
return to Los Angeles. The paternal cousin called to check on
mother and, eventually, called law enforcement after mother
provided responses that prompted concerns about her mental
health. Law enforcement found mother at a fast food restaurant
in Bakersfield; according to restaurant staff, mother had been
there for seven hours.
Mother was later transported to a psychiatric hospital.
Mother’s discharge summary stated that she was placed on a
hold as a danger to herself and was diagnosed with “major
depressive disorder, recurrent episode, severe with psychosis,
principal, [a]lcohol use disorder, severe, and dependence[.]”
Mother had previously declined psychotropic medication and had
been hospitalized in 2015, 2017, 2020, and 2023.
On November 1, 2023, mother’s therapist reported that
mother did not think she was “being negligent” so long as she was
not drinking in minor’s presence. Mother would ask, “‘I’m an
adult. Why can’t I drink?’”
On November 13, 2023, when asked about the incident in
the park, mother stated, “‘Things happened, and they took my
daughter.’” Mother did not believe that she needed to participate
5
in an inpatient program because she had been “‘prescribed . . .
medication that took away [her] cravings.’”
On December 1, 2023, DCFS filed a subsequent petition
under section 342 alleging that mother’s mental and emotional
problems and her failure to participate consistently in mental
health services endangered minor.
IV. Adjudication of Supplemental and Subsequent Petitions
On January 16, 2024, the juvenile court sustained the
supplemental and subsequent petitions as pled. The court
removed minor from mother and ordered minor released to father
under the condition that they remain in the paternal aunt’s
home. Mother was given monitored visitation with minor. The
court explained, “The basis for the removal from mother is that
we just have a long way to go it seems to get her both mentally
stable and free from the substances—specifically alcohol.”
Mother’s court-ordered case plan included a full
drug/alcohol treatment program with aftercare, a 12-step
program, weekly drug testing, a parenting course, a domestic
violence support group for victims, individual counseling, and
mental health counseling. The juvenile court ordered mother to
“abstain from any alcoholic beverages.” The court advised
mother to “strongly consider and follow through on [her] plans to
get into an [in]patient treatment program because the court”
would not release minor to mother or liberalize mother’s
visitation to unmonitored unless she was in such a program.
V. July 2024 Status Review Report
Minor remained in her paternal aunt’s home with father.
DCFS reported no safety concerns and reported that minor
appeared to be happy and bonding well with father.
6
Mother continued to meet with the DCFS social worker on
a monthly basis. During these visits, the social worker did not
observe mother displaying any behaviors indicative of substance
abuse. Mother claimed to be sober. She had not, however,
enrolled in an inpatient treatment program. Mother reported
that she was addressing her addiction through an outpatient
program. She acknowledged the seriousness of her addiction and
the consequences of losing custody of minor. Overall, mother had
complied with the juvenile court’s weekly drug/alcohol testing
order, was participating in a 12-step program and individual
counseling, and had enrolled in a domestic violence support
group. No safety concerns were reported during mother’s visits
with minor.
DCFS recommended that dependency jurisdiction be
terminated with father having sole physical custody of minor and
the parents sharing joint legal custody.
VI. Judicial Review Hearing (July 16, 2024)
During the section 364 judicial review hearing on July 16,
2024, minor’s counsel joined DCFS’s recommendations, including
that mother’s visits remain monitored. Mother’s counsel objected
to notice for the hearing, as the notices indicated that DCFS was
recommending unmonitored visits for mother. Mother’s counsel
argued that mother had taken accountability for her past actions,
was consistently participating in services, and did not present
any safety concerns.
After entertaining oral argument, the juvenile court found
that the conditions that would justify the initial assumption of
jurisdiction under section 300 no longer existed and were not
likely to exist if supervision was withdrawn. Because continued
supervision was no longer necessary, the court terminated its
7
jurisdiction. The court stayed the termination of jurisdiction
pending receipt of an exit order providing sole physical custody to
father, joint legal custody to the parents, and monitored visits for
mother.
The juvenile court addressed mother as follows: “[T]he
court is very impressed with the hard work you’ve put in to
remain sober. The social worker does indicate how you are
consistently and actively participating in your programs and
really doing the hard work to remain sober and become an
appropriate parent for [minor].
“However, I do find minor’s counsel’s arguments very
persuasive regarding your extensive history as well as the fact
that while your recent sobriety is very commendable given the
long history, we are still at the early stages. So visits will remain
monitored at this time. You can talk to your attorney about how
to get that changed in family court should that be appropriate.”
VII. Termination of Jurisdiction
On July 17, 2024, the juvenile court received, signed, and
filed the exit order and lifted the stay on the order terminating
jurisdiction. The exit order provided mother with a minimum of
three monitored visits with minor each week for three hours.
VIII. Appeal
Mother timely filed a notice of appeal from the orders made
on July 16 and July 17, 2024.
DISCUSSION
Mother’s sole contention on appeal is that the juvenile court
abused its discretion by issuing an exit order that required her
visits with minor be monitored.
8
I. Standard of Review
We review an exit order for an abuse of discretion and may
not disturb the order “‘“‘unless the . . . court has exceeded the
limits of legal discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or
patently absurd determination.’”’ [Citation.]” (In re J.M. (2023)
89 Cal.App.5th 95, 113.)
II. Applicable Law
Section 362.4 “empowers the juvenile court, if it terminates
its jurisdiction over a dependent minor, to issue ‘an order
determining the custody of, or visitation with, the child.’ (§ 362.4,
subd. (a).)” (In re C.W. (2019) 33 Cal.App.5th 835, 862–863.)
Such orders—“commonly referred to as ‘exit orders’” (In re
Anna T. (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 870, 871–872)—“become part of
any family court proceeding concerning the same child and will
remain in effect until they are terminated or modified by the
family court. [Citation.]” (In re T.H. (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th
1119, 1123.)
In crafting exit orders, “it is the best interests of the child,
in the context of the peculiar facts of the case before the court,
which are paramount.” (In re John W. (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 961,
965.) “Because juvenile dependency proceedings arise when
children are subject to or at risk of abuse or neglect, ‘[t]he
presumption of parental fitness that underlies custody law in the
family court just does not apply. . . . Rather the juvenile court,
which has been intimately involved in the protection of the child,
is best situated to make custody determinations based on the best
interests of the child without any preferences or presumptions.’
[Citations.]” (In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p. 112.)
9
III. Analysis
We find no abuse of the juvenile court’s “‘broad discretion’”
(In re J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p. 112) in issuing an exit
order that required mother’s visits with minor be monitored.
Mother had a long history of alcohol abuse and mental
health problems, which had placed minor at direct risk of serious
harm on numerous occasions. When jurisdiction was terminated
in the most recent of three dependency cases involving the
family, mother had, at most, maintained sobriety for less than
nine months. While commendable, this was a relatively short
period of time compared to her years of abuse. (See In re
Cliffton B. (2000) 81 Cal.App.4th 415, 423–424 [200 days of
sobriety insufficient to reassure the juvenile court that a relapse
would not occur]; In re Kimberly F. (1997) 56 Cal.App.4th 519,
531, fn. 9 [“It is the nature of addiction that one must be ‘clean’
for a much longer period than 120 days to show real reform”].)
And, although no concerns arose when mother visited minor in a
monitored setting, mother’s conduct during an unmonitored visit
was untested. The court could reasonably remain concerned
about minor’s safety and well-being if she were to be alone with
mother. Under the totality of these circumstances, ordering
mother’s visits with minor remain monitored was not “‘“‘an
arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd determination.’”’” (In re
J.M., supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at p. 113.)
Urging reversal, mother makes several arguments that
lack merit.
First, mother contends that the family’s previous
dependency cases were not initiated because of mother’s
substance abuse. This is inaccurate. In exercising jurisdiction
over minor in 2020, the juvenile court sustained allegations that
10
mother had “a history of substance abuse including alcohol and
marijuana abuse” and that, while mother “was under the
influence of alcohol, she fed . . . [minor] numerous flower petals
causing the child to choke. Further, . . . mother threatened to
throw the child’s great grandmother off the 10th story balcony.”
These previously sustained allegations demonstrate a nexus
between mother’s history of alcohol abuse and risks of serious
physical harm to minor.
Second, mother argues that minor was almost five years old
when jurisdiction was terminated and her “age . . . did not
require monitored visitation.” We disagree with any suggestion
that, at only four years old, minor was old enough to
independently withstand inadequate supervision during an
unmonitored visit with mother.
Third, mother points to evidence that one of minor’s
teachers did not express concerns about mother, mother and
minor appeared to be bonded, and mother was participating in
parenting classes. While this evidence supports the juvenile
court’s implied finding that visitation with mother was in minor’s
best interest, it does not demonstrate that the court abused its
discretion by putting a reasonable monitoring restriction on that
visitation.
Fourth, mother contends that the circumstances present
when minor was detained in October 2023 were not the same as
when jurisdiction was terminated in July 2024, because she was
attending a 12-step program with a sponsor, was enrolled in
outpatient services, and was drug testing negative. Mother
identifies no authority—nor are we aware of any—dictating that
upon substantial compliance with a case plan a parent must be
granted unmonitored visitation. To the contrary, “[w]hen the
11
juvenile court makes custody or visitation orders as it terminates
dependency jurisdiction, it does so as a court with ‘a special
responsibility to the child as parens patriae and [it] must look to
the totality of a child’s circumstances when making decisions
regarding the child.’ [Citation.]” (In re J.T. (2014)
228 Cal.App.4th 953, 963.)
Finally, mother argues that it was improper to order
monitored visitation based on mere speculation that mother
might relapse. However, given mother’s long history of alcohol
abuse and her relatively short period of recent sobriety, the court
was justified in concluding that mother was “still at the early
stages” of her recovery. Thus, it was reasonable for the court to
continue to be concerned about mother’s ability to maintain her
sobriety and, thus, to place a monitoring restriction on mother’s
visitation.
DISPOSITION
The orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS.
_____________________, Acting P. J.
ASHMANN-GERST
We concur:
________________________, J.
CHAVEZ
________________________, J.
RICHARDSON
12
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.