Hogan v. DeAngelis Construction CA1/2

CourtListener 10385228Calctapp25 de abr. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 4/25/25 Hogan v. DeAngelis Construction CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

RONALD HOGAN, et al.,
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
A166172
v.
DEANGELIS CONSTRUCTION, (Sonoma County
INC., et al., Super. Ct. No. SCV-230846)
Defendants and Respondents.

MEMORANDUM OPINION
Plaintiffs Ronald and Victoria Hogan (the Hogans) appeal from an
order denying their motion for an award of legal fees and costs against
defendants DeAngelis Construction, Inc., DeAngelis-Pope Homes, Marvin
DeAngelis, and Gary Pope (collectively the Developers or defendants), which
was filed 12 years after the judgment was entered and more than three years
after the judgment was deemed satisfied. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
A Brief History of this Litigation
The parties are familiar with the history of this case, which we briefly
described in 2019 as follows. In 2002, the Hogans sued the Developers,
“asserting claims related to the Hogans’ purchase of a home in 2000. . . . [T]he
Hogans alleged the home was defective in various ways and defendants failed

1
to disclose material facts about the home. [This lawsuit] resulted in a trial
court order rescinding the purchase agreement for the home, a jury trial on
consequential damages, a judgment (sometimes referred to as the ‘modified
amended judgment’), many appeals, and six appellate decisions by this
court.1 Most recently, in 2018, we ordered the trial court to deem the
judgment satisfied as to the Developers.” (Hogan v. Deangelis Construction,
Inc. (A152771, Aug. 30, 2019) [nonpub. opn.] 2019 WL 4127270.)2
Later, in 2022, we wrote, “We do not repeat the history of this case,
which the parties are familiar with and which is set out in our prior
decisions. In brief, the parties’ litigation over the rescission of a contract to
purchase a home (the Gardenview property) resulted in a modified amended
judgment filed by the trial court in April 2010, and conflict over executing
this judgment has led to years of litigation.” (Hogan v. Deangelis
Construction, Inc. (A157615, Jan. 28, 2022) [nonpub. opn.] 2022 WL 263290.)
In short, the Hogans filed this lawsuit in 2002; following a jury trial
and multiple appeals by the Hogans, the final judgment was filed in 2010;
and the judgment was satisfied as to the Developers in 2018.
In 2007, the trial court determined there was no “ ‘ “prevailing party”
under any definition.’ ” In Hogan I, we affirmed this determination, noting,

1 “(See Hogan v. DeAngelis Construction, Inc. (A117321, A118257,

A120840, May 20, 2009) [nonpub. opn.] . . . (Hogan I) [describing the trial
court order of rescission and jury trial on damages]; Hogan v. DeAngelis
Construction, Inc. (A146057, A146582, A147273, May 17, 2018) [nonpub.
opn.] . . . (Hogan V) [referring to the operative judgment filed on April 20,
2010, ‘as the modified amended judgment or the judgment’]; Hogan v.
[Engstrom] (A149571, May 17, 2018) [nonpub. opn.] . . . (Hogan VI) [‘This is
our sixth opinion in this action’].) . . . .”
2 We cite our prior opinions “to explain the factual background of the

case.” (K.G. v. Meredith (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 164, 172, fn. 9.)

2
“Although the Hogans initiated an action seeking relief based on rescission,
they thoroughly resisted accepting rescission in accordance with their
election. Furthermore, their efforts at trial to increase their monetary
recovery by expanding the concept of consequential damages, though
extremely time consuming, were largely unsuccessful. Indeed, on this record,
the trial court could reasonably have concluded that the Hogans’ primary
goal at trial was to obtain legal damages to which they were not entitled.”
In July 2010, the trial court denied the Hogans’ request to include their
fees and costs in the judgment; the trial court stated, “ ‘The court has already
ruled on these in its prior orders regarding the parties’ motions seeking to
recover, tax, or strike costs and fees on appeal and the order at issue does not
change these.’ ” (Hogan v. DeAngelis Construction, Inc. (A128451, Apr. 18,
2012) [nonpub opn.] 2012 WL 1340809 (Hogan II).) In October 2010, the
Hogans argued they had a judgment for $602,000 in costs, which the trial
court rejected. The trial court explained, “ ‘[T]o my knowledge there has
never been an award to you [addressing Victoria Hogan] of attorneys’ fees in
this case, period, for any theory, that I’m—so right now, my belief from
looking at the file is you have never been given an award of attorneys’ fees.’ ”
The Hogans’ Motion
On April 13, 2022, the Hogans filed a document titled “motion for
award of legal fees and costs incurred per agreement between the parties and
law of the case; and right of setoff.” (Capitalization omitted.) The Hogans
asserted they “have consistently taken the position that the deemed offer of
rescission, accepted by developers, included all costs and fees.” They noted
that Ronald Hogan filed a declaration in the trial court on September 10,
2012, stating they incurred costs and attorney’s fees “as a result of the
purchase and rescission of the [Gardenview Property] . . . in the amount of

3
$681,841.42,” and they sought an award for that amount, plus “costs and fees
incurred since that time,” in the current motion.
The Trial Court’s Ruling
The trial court denied the motion. In its tentative ruling, which was
adopted when no party appeared for the hearing, the court explained: “As
stated by this Court in its February 26, 2010 order, Plaintiffs ‘provide no
basis for finding that the rescission included an obligation to pay all legal fees
and costs.’ This statement remains true.
“Both this Court and the Court of Appeal have explained to the Hogans
on multiple occasions that an award for legal fees and costs is not required in
this action. As the Court of Appeal explains ‘the rescission statutes expressly
confer broad discretion on the trial court to balance the equities between
these parties. . . . [W]hile the Hogans resisted the consequences of their own
election for several years, thereby generating significant costs to the parties
and the court, the Developers’ early acknowledgement and acceptance of the
rescission could have led to a speedy resolution of this entire dispute if not for
the Hogans’ resistance to that outcome.’ (Hogan [I] . . . [2009] WL 1398646,
p. 35.)
“When this issue was subsequently brought by the Hogans the Court of
Appeal stated ‘the 2007 order denying the Hogans costs and attorneys fees
was affirmed on appeal.’ (Hogan [II] . . . [2012] WL 1340809, p. 12 [see also
p. 5, which addresses the Hogans[’] other filings related to requests for costs
and fees].)
“Therefore, based on the prior rulings of this Court and the Court of
Appeal this Court DENIES the Hogans’ motion as this issue has already been
addressed by both courts on multiple occasions.” (Fn. omitted.)

4
DISCUSSION
“[A] trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the
burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record
presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that
justifies reversal of the judgment. [Citations.] ‘This is not only a general
principle of appellate practice but an ingredient of the constitutional doctrine
of reversible error.’ [Citations.] ‘In the absence of a contrary showing in the
record, all presumptions in favor of the trial court’s action will be made by
the appellate court.’ ” (Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608–609.)
The Hogans fail to show error. They argue the trial court “erred by
disregarding the agreement between the parties for a remedy.”
(Capitalization omitted.) But the trial court considered their argument about
the existence of an agreement and rejected it because the same argument has
been rejected by the trial court and the Court of Appeal in the past. The
Hogans themselves point out that on January 6, 2010, they argued to the
trial court, “there is an agreement for fees and costs,” and, “Fees and costs
are available [to the Hogans] regardless of prevailing party status at the trial
level since they are an essential part of the rescission.”3 Thus, the Hogans
have been claiming there is an “agreement” requiring defendants to pay their
fees and costs since at least January 2010, and this claim has failed
repeatedly.
The Hogans argue their claim is not barred by res judicata or law of the
case. But, after a trial court rejects an argument, litigants cannot just make
the same argument over and over again in the same litigation. Their current
motion is, in effect, a motion for reconsideration of prior court orders that

3 The Hogans made this argument in their opposition to defendants’

motion to strike their costs bill.

5
rejected (explicitly or implicitly) their claim that an “agreement” exists that
requires defendants to pay their fees and costs. Motions for reconsideration
can be made only within time limits and “based upon new or different facts,
circumstances, or law.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 1008, subd. (a).) The Hogans’
motion is untimely and is not based on new facts, circumstances, or law.4
DISPOSITION
The order denying the Hogans’ motion for an award of fees and costs is
affirmed.

_________________________
Miller, J.

WE CONCUR:

_________________________
Stewart, P. J.

_________________________
Desautels, J.

A166172, Hogan, et al. v. DeAngeles Construction, Inc., et al.

4 The motion is also untimely under California Rules of Court, rule

3.1702(b).

6

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.