Parker v. Ainsworth CA5

CourtListener 10382835Calctapp23 de abr. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 4/23/25 Parker v. Ainsworth CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

TIFFANY ANN PARKER,
F086823
Appellant,
(Super. Ct. No. BFL-18-003913)
v.

ROBERT HOWARD AINSWORTH, OPINION
Respondent;

KERN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CHILD
SUPPORT SERVICES,

Intervener and Respondent.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Kern County. Cynthia L. Loo,
Temporary Judge. (Pursuant to Cal. Const., art. VI, § 21.)
Tiffany A. Parker, in pro. per., for Appellant.
Robert H. Ainsworth, in pro. per., for Respondent.
No appearance for Intervener and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
Tiffany Ann Parker (Mother) and Robert Howard Ainsworth (Father) have
litigated disputes over child support in three states—Hawaii, California, and Florida. In
this appeal, Mother challenges the denial of her request for an order directing Father to
disclose information about the disability benefit he receives from the Department of
Veteran Affairs (VA). The family court denied Mother’s request as untimely and
concluded it was an attempt to relitigate a motion to modify child support heard on
November 8, 2021.
Before this court can reach the merits of the appeal, we must determine whether
we have jurisdiction, which requires an appealable order. As explained below, the
challenged order is not appealable. Therefore, we dismiss this appeal for lack of
jurisdiction.
FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS
Mother and Father are self-represented litigants familiar with the factual and
procedural history of their dispute over child support. Some of that history is set forth in
our opinion in case No. F086739. As a result, we do not repeat details contained in that
opinion, but begin by describing the request for order that is the basis for this appeal.
On July 19, 2023,1 Mother filed (1) a peremptory challenge to Commissioner
Cynthia Loo; (2) a request for order directing Father to disclose information about his VA
disability benefit; and (3) a declaration supporting the request. A superior court judge
denied the peremptory challenge to the commissioner on the day it was filed.2 On

1 On July 20, 2023, a commissioner of the family court held a hearing on Mother’s
request for order and her motion that are addressed in case No. F086739, and orally
denied them. The oral ruling was formalized on July 31, 2023, when the commissioner
signed and filed the order after hearing (Judicial Council form FL-687) prepared by
counsel for Kern County Department of Child Support Services.
2 In case No. F086844, we dismissed Mother’s appeal from the order denying her
peremptory challenge because it “is not an appealable order.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 170.3,
subd. (d).) Instead, such order may be reviewed only by a writ of mandate filed with the
appropriate court of appeal within 10 days after service of the order. (Ibid.; see People v.

2.
August 22, 2023, Mother filed another declaration in support of her request for an order
directing Father to disclose information about his VA disability benefit.
On August 25, 2023, the family court held a hearing on Mother’s request. An
attorney appeared for the Kern County Department of Child Support Services (Kern
DCSS) and Mother and Father appeared remotely. The minute order states Mother and
Father were duly sworn and testified, the court found the request was an attempt to
relitigate the matter heard on November 8, 2021 (i.e., Kern DCSS’s request to modify
child support), and the court denied the request as untimely. The last three sentences of
the minute order state: “[Mother] continues to argue with, speak over and interrupt the
court after the court issues its ruling. [¶] [Mother] reports she is recording the
proceeding, which is in violation of California Rule of Court 1.150. The court directs the
termination of the proceeding.”
The record does not include an order after hearing on Judicial Council form FL-
687. Also, it does not include a reporter’s transcript of the August 25, 2023 hearing.
Mother filed a notice of appeal in September 2023.
To address the absence of a reporter’s transcript, Mother submitted an initial
proposed settled statement in December 2023. After Mother submitted two amended
proposed settled statements, the family court, using Judicial Council form APP-022,
issued a May 22, 2024 order on appellant’s proposed settled statement that stated Mother
failed to follow the court’s earlier orders and, as a result, the record of oral proceedings
would be Kern DCSS’s proposed settled statements filed on January 18, 2024 and March
12, 2024.

Webb (1993) 6 Cal.4th 494, 522 [expedited writ procedure is the exclusive means for
reviewing an unsuccessful peremptory challenge].)

3.
DISCUSSION
I. APPEALABILITY
“The existence of an appealable order or judgment is a jurisdictional prerequisite
to an appeal. [Citation.] Accordingly, if the order or judgment is not appealable, the
appeal must be dismissed.” (Canandaigua Wine Co., Inc. v. County of Madera (2009)
177 Cal.App.4th 298, 302.) To assist appellate courts in complying with this
requirement, an appellant’s opening brief must “[s]tate that the judgment appealed from
is final, or explain why the order appealed from is appealable.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.204(a)(2)(B).)
A. Mother’s Contentions Regarding Appealability
Under heading IV.D. of Mother’s opening brief, “Final Judgment,” she set forth
the following sentence: “This appeal is from a final judgment that disposes of all parties’
claims.” This is not an accurate statement because the order denying Mother’s request is
not a judgment. It is an order.
Under the next heading of Mother’s opening brief, “Appealability,” she stated:

“Appellant filed an Amended Motion to Find Appealable with this Court of
Appeal on January 24th, 2024 referencing case law. This Court is in
possession of an order dated March 1st, 2024 from Polk County, Florida’s
10th District Court rejecting the transfer of Kern County Superior Court’s
family case BFL-18-003913 to them. This Court of Appeal retains
jurisdiction to review error in law and de novo on the allowable time to
vacate/set aside the California district court’s modification of the original
stipulated Hawaiian child support order calculated based on fraud, perjury,
duress, imputed wages on the disabled Mother, and failure to disclose
actual income by the Father and collection agency employees. No other
state district court or collection agency is enforcing the California modified
child support order.”
This statement also is inaccurate. No “Amended Motion to Find Appealable” or
other document was filed in this appeal on January 24, 2024. Mother did file a letter
brief with this court on November 21, 2023, that argued the family court’s transfer of the

4.
case to Florida’s Polk County did not render the appeal moot. On December 20, 2023,
this court filed an order stating the appeal would be allowed to proceed and also stating
the order should not be construed as a ruling on the issue of appealability.
Consequently, neither Mother’s briefing nor the other documents submitted in this
appeal have demonstrated the appealability of the family court’s order denying her
request for an order directing Father to disclose information about his VA disability
benefit.
B. Independent Analysis of Appealability
Our next step is to conduct an independent review of the record and the law to
determine whether the challenged order is appealable. The general rules of law regarding
appealability are well established.
“In California, the right to appeal is governed solely by statute and, except as
provided by the Legislature, the appellate courts have no jurisdiction to entertain
appeals.” (Art Movers, Inc. v. Ni West, Inc. (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th 640, 645.) In other
words, “[i]n the absence of a statute authorizing an appeal, we lack jurisdiction to review
a case[.]” (Smith v. Smith (2012) 208 Cal.App.4th 1074, 1083; Griset v. Fair Political
Practices Com. (2001) 25 Cal.4th 688, 696 [“A trial court’s order is appealable when it is
made so by statute.”].)
Code of Civil Procedure section 904.1 is the “primary statute” addressing the
appealability of judgments and orders in civil actions. (Smith v. Smith, supra, 208
Cal.App.4th at p. 1083.) Subdivision (a)(2) through (14) lists various type of orders that
are appealable. Orders denying a motion for disclosure of information or, more
generally, discovery orders are not among the appealable orders listed. However, the
statute refers to “an order made appealable by the Probate Code or the Family Code.”
(Code Civ. Proc., § 904.1, subd. (a)(10).) We have not located a provision in the Family
Code that makes the order denying Mother’s request for an order directing Father to

5.
disclose information appealable. (See generally, State ex rel. Dept. of Pesticide
Regulation v. Pet Food Express (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 841, 852 [noting that “discovery
orders in civil litigation ... are not considered final, appealable orders”].)
Based on the minute order’s characterization of Mother’s request as an attempt to
relitigate Kern DCSS’s motion to modify child support that was heard on November 8,
2021, Mother’s request could be construed as a motion to reconsider. Such a
construction, however, does not make the order appealable. (See Association for Los
Angeles Deputy Sheriffs v. County of Los Angeles (2008) 166 Cal.App.4th 1625, 1633
[denial of motion for reconsideration not appealable]; In re Marriage of Burgard (1999)
72 Cal.App.4th 74, 81 [if motions to reconsider were appealable, it would give a party
two appeals from the same decision].)
Consequently, we conclude the order is not appealable and, under established
principles of appellate procedure, this appeal must be dismissed.
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed. The parties shall bear their own costs on appeal.

FRANSON, J.
WE CONCUR:

LEVY, Acting P. J.

SNAUFFER, J.

6.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.