CourtListener 10378889•In re E.H. CA5
Texto completo
Filed 4/14/25 In re E.H. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re E.H., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.
THE PEOPLE, F087985
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. JJD074329)
v.
OPINION
E.H.,
Defendant and Appellant.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Tulare County. John P. Bianco,
Judge.
Candice L. Christensen, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant
and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant Attorney General,
Kimberley A. Donohue, Assistant Attorney General, Amanda D. Cary and Joseph Penney,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* Before Franson, Acting P. J., Smith, J. and Snauffer, J.
-ooOoo-
Minor E.H. contends on appeal that the juvenile court’s disposition order
committing her to the mid-term program must be reversed and the matter remanded. The
People disagree, and alternatively argue the issue of whether the court erred when it
committed her to the mid-term program may be moot. We dismiss the appeal as moot.
PROCEDURAL SUMMARY
On July 22, 2022, a juvenile wardship petition was filed in Tulare County Superior
Court, pursuant to Welfare & Institutions Code section 602,1 alleging minor committed
battery (Pen. Code, § 242; count 1). A section 300 petition was also filed.
Subsection c-1 of the section 300 petition alleged minor was at substantial risk of serious
emotional damage, due to her adoptive parents’ abusive behavior and neglect.2 The
petition stated minor’s adoptive parents’ derogatory statements about her being sexually
abused prior to adoption caused her to self-harm and abscond from their home.
Subsection g-1 of the section 300 petition alleged the adoptive parents were unwilling or
unable to care for minor and no other relatives were available.
On July 25, 2022, the juvenile court held a detention hearing. Minor denied the
allegation of the section 602 petition. The court ordered a section 241.1 staffing report
and minor was placed in a resource home.
On August 26, 2022, an amended petition was filed further alleging minor
committed vandalism (Pen. Code, § 594, subd. (a); count 2) and two counts of
misdemeanor battery (Pen. Code, § 242; counts 1 & 3).
1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless otherwise
noted.
2 Minor had run away from home. She reported her adoptive parents made
derogatory comments to her. The petition indicated the adoptive parents were unwilling
or unable to care for minor.
2.
On October 12, 2022, after a staffing and suitability report was completed,3 the
juvenile court found minor was suitable for an informal probation disposition alternative
pursuant to section 654.2. The court granted informal probation.
On January 12, April 5, and May 17, 2023, the juvenile court found minor to be in
partial compliance with her informal probation.
On July 18, 2023, the juvenile court indicated it intended to dismiss the informal
probation as successfully completed and seal minor’s record. However, minor’s adoptive
mother disclosed minor had committed a serious new offense and was expelled from
school. The court then continued the case and minor’s informal supervision.4
On July 21, 2023, a second amended petition was filed, further alleging minor
committed felony assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury (Pen.
Code, § 245, subd. (a)(4); count 4).
On August 3, 2023, minor denied the allegations of the second amended petition.
The juvenile court ordered a section 241.1 staffing report and the matter was referred to
probation for a section 654.2 suitability report.
On August 21, 2023, a new section 654.2 suitability report and a section 241.1
staffing report were completed. The juvenile court ordered minor to continue with
informal probation. The court also ordered minor to remain a dependent.
On October 25, 2023, a third amended petition was filed, adding two additional
misdemeanor counts, alleging as follows: misdemeanor battery (Pen. Code, § 242;
3 Two suitability reports for minor were prepared, each dated September 5, 2022.
The reports are substantially similar, but one declares minor to be “not suitable” and the
other declares minor to be “suitable” for informal probation.
4 The minute order from the hearing indicates the juvenile court “recall[ed] and
vacate[d]” minor’s order of informal probation. However, the hearing transcript states
that when the court stated it was “going to order [that the petition be recalled and
vacated],” minor’s adoptive mother disclosed minor’s new offense to the court. When the
court clerk asked the court if it was recalling its order of dismissal, the court confirmed it
was.
3.
count 1), felony vandalism (Pen. Code, § 594, subd. (a); count 2), misdemeanor battery
(Pen. Code, § 242; count 3), felony assault (Pen. Code, § 245, subd. (a)(4); count 4),
misdemeanor battery on a school employee (Pen. Code, § 243.6; count 5), and
misdemeanor vandalism (Pen. Code, § 594, subd. (a); count 6).5
On December 19, 2023, after minor ran away from her placement, the juvenile
court issued a bench warrant. A follow-up section 241.1 staffing report recommended
minor be adjudicated and placed on formal probation.
On December 27, 2023, following minor being taken into custody on the warrant,
minor waived her rights and admitted the allegations of the third amended petition. The
juvenile court terminated dependency jurisdiction over minor and terminated minor’s
section 654.3 informal probation.
On January 11, 2024, the juvenile court declared minor a ward of the court and
placed minor on formal probation. Minor was committed to 180 days in juvenile hall,
less 66 days’ credit for time served and was committed to the Tulare County short-term
program at the county juvenile ranch camp or forestry camp for a period of 180 days.
The court set minor’s maximum confinement time at four years six months.6
On February 27, 2024, a notice of violation of minor’s probation was filed
pursuant to section 777, subdivision (a), alleging minor failed to abide by the rules and
regulations of juvenile hall, to obey all laws, and to abstain from disruptive and assaultive
behavior.
5 The third amended petition alleged count 1 occurred on or about July 20, 2022;
count 2 occurred on or about June 27, 2022; count 3 occurred on or about June 27, 2022;
count 4 occurred on or about May 11, 2023; count 5 occurred on or about October 23,
2023; and count 6 occurred on or about October 23, 2023.
6 The record does not show minor appealed from this declaration of wardship and
placement.
4.
On March 1, 2024, a new wardship petition was filed pursuant to section 602,
alleging minor committed felony resisting an executive officer by means of force or
violence (Pen. Code, § 69; count 1).
On March 7, 2024, minor waived her rights and admitted the probation violation
and the allegation of the March 1, 2024 petition.
On April 30, 2024, the juvenile court held a disposition hearing. The court
ordered minor to continue probation. Minor was ordered to serve 365 days of juvenile
detention in the mid-term program and was granted 136 days’ credit for time served.
Other conditions of probation were imposed. The court set minor’s maximum possible
term at five years, two months.
On May 2, 2024, minor filed a notice of appeal.
FACTUAL SUMMARY
Minor was born on June 26, 2009.
Facts Underlying the July 22, 2022 Petition
On July 20, 2022, when minor’s adoptive father instructed her to go to her room,
she pushed, slapped and struck him once with her fist.
July 22, 2022 Detention Report and Probation Report
The July 22, 2022 probation report contained an assessment of minor from
July 21, 2022. It stated,
“[Minor’s adoptive] parents report they fear for the safety of all
members of the family if … minor is in the home. They advise she does
not follow the rules of the home and is constantly running away from the
home. They report … minor is currently receiving [W]raparound
[S]ervices, and is currently taking medication for her diagnosis of PTSD,
ODD, and has been diagnosed with [h]istrionic [p]ersonality [d]isorder.
The parents informed … minor meets with therapist [seven times] per
week, and is currently working with multiple therapists. They claim …
minor tells them she will hurt them and can do ‘a[ ]lot worse.’ They
disclose[d] … minor was previously in a residential treatment facility for
alleged sexual assault against her younger sibling. They disclose … minor
has a history of watching child pornography and has been suspended from
5.
school for such conduct. They report … minor has [begun] to act out
because she wants to ‘be like her biological mother.’ They believe …
minor may be associating with [Sureño] gang members.”
Facts Underlying the August 24, 2022 First Amended Petition
On June 27, 2022, minor damaged surveillance cameras inside her adoptive
parents’ home. The damage was in the amount of $400 or more. The same day, she also
headbutted, hit and pushed her adoptive mother.
August 18, 2022 Section 241.1 Staffing Report
The August 18, 2022 staffing report stated minor entered foster care in 2014 and
was adopted in 2017. She suffered past trauma and sexual abuse with her biological
family and her biological mother was a prostitute. On September 5, 2020, minor’s
adoptive parents saw her looking at child pornography, rape, and lesbian sex on her
computer. On October 7, 2022, her adoptive parents were concerned because she kissed
her 11-month-old sibling on the face and lip area while playing with him. The adoptive
parents reported they were afraid minor would turn into a “sexual predator” because she
had been abused as a young child. The adoptive parents sent her to a group home in Utah
for 17 months. She returned to her adoptive parents’ home in April 2022.
The report stated the adoptive parents reported minor did not display any abnormal
or sexualized behavior since returning to their home, but that she cut her legs, punched
walls, and made herself bleed. The report stated minor stated she acted out only because
her adoptive parents said derogatory things to her every day, reminding her that she was
sexually abused as a child. She stated they tell her she is going to get pregnant at the age
of 14, “ ‘just like’ ” her birth mother.
The report stated the adoptive parents stated they did not know about minor’s
sexual abuse history prior to adoption and no longer wanted her as their adoptive child.
The adoptive parents contacted the adoption agency about relinquishing her. The
adoptive parents reported they wanted to become teachers and were concerned that a
relinquishment might affect their career plans.
6.
The report stated minor shared that the adoptive parents’ words and behavior made
her feel unloved and unwanted. She stated they isolated her to her room. She reported
feeling very sad and that she might be better off somewhere else.
The report recommended informal probation.
October 10, 2022 Probation Report
The October 10, 2022 probation report recommended section 654.2 informal
probation for minor. At the time, minor was living in a foster home and getting straight
A’s in eighth grade.
October 12, 2022 Detention Hearing
On October 12, 2022, the juvenile court ordered minor to remain a dependent. It
assigned her 40 hours of community service and referred her to “Wraparound”
counseling services. Minor’s foster mother reported minor was working on community
service hours and attending counseling. She stated minor had been well behaved at her
foster home and minor had no negative law enforcement contacts. Minor was found to be
in partial compliance with the terms and conditions of section 654.2 informal probation,
as she had completed 20 hours of her 40 assigned community service hours.
July 18, 2023 Disposition Hearing
The juvenile court found minor to be in partial compliance with her informal
probation on January 12, April 5, and May 17, 2023.
On July 18, 2023, the juvenile court found minor in compliance with her informal
probation. The court stated it was “going to order [that the petition be recalled and
vacated],” and dismiss her section 654.2 informal probation as satisfactorily completed.
However, minor’s adoptive mother interrupted the court and disclosed minor’s new
offense. When the court clerk asked the court if it was recalling its order of dismissal, the
court confirmed it was.
7.
Facts Underlying the July 21, 2023 Second Amended Petition
On May 11, 2023, minor blocked another student at her school from going to the
restroom. Minor then punched the other student and pushed her, got on top of her and
continued to physically attack her for “no apparent reason.” The other student suffered
visible injuries and had to go to the hospital after the attack.
August 3, 2023 Pretrial Hearing
After minor denied the allegations of the second amended petition, the juvenile
court ordered a section 241.1 staffing report and referred the matter to probation for a
section 654.2 suitability report. The foster family agency social worker indicated minor
was doing very well in her resource home.
August 21, 2023 Section 654.2 Suitability Report
The August 21, 2023 section 654.2 suitability report recommended informal
probation. Minor’s resource foster mother stated minor’s behavior was “ ‘good’ ” with a
lot of improvement. Minor was benefitting from “Wraparound” counseling services and
was controlling her emotions. It stated minor agreed her relationship with the resource
foster parents was good. The report recommended informal probation.
August 23, 2023 Section 241.1 Staffing Report
The August 23, 2023 section 241.1 staffing report stated minor’s prior resource
foster parents placed a 14-day notice due to minor’s defiant behavior. She continued to
participate in mental health services through “Wraparound” counseling and was working
to identify triggers and use positive communication skills. The report also noted minor
was expelled from school on May 16, 2023, for battery, and was attending a community
day school. Minor reported she liked her current resource home, as the foster parents
treated all the children equally. The report recommended informal probation.
August 24, 2023 Disposition Hearing
On August 24, 2023, the juvenile court ordered minor to be placed on
section 654.3 informal probation and to remain a dependent.
8.
Facts Underlying the October 25, 2023 Third Amended Petition
On October 23, 2023, minor’s school principal attempted to stop her from fleeing
the school campus. Minor hit him with a closed fist and kicked him several times. That
same day, she had damaged or destroyed approximately $50 of various classroom items
and school supplies.
October 26, 2023 Pretrial Hearing
On October 26, 2023, the juvenile court ordered minor to be placed in a new
resource home. She was admonished by the court regarding her runaway history, and the
court stated she would be detained if she ran away again from her placement.
In response to the juvenile court’s concerns about minor’s runaway behavior,
minor asked the court to put her on an electronic GPS ankle monitor. The court agreed
an electronic monitor might be useful and ordered minor to be fitted with one. The court
warned minor not to cut the monitor off or throw it away.
November 9, 2023 Pretrial Hearing
On November 9, 2023, minor asked the juvenile court to have the ankle monitor
removed, despite having further behavioral issues since it was put on. The court
declined, stating:
“I think [the monitor is] the only thing keeping [minor] from getting
into more trouble. So[,] no. She’ll remain on the monitor. On the 21st [of
November], when we come back [to court], we can reassess. If she’s doing
well at home and at school and so forth, I will seriously consider taking her
off. If there’s no need for it, there’s no reason to have her on the monitor.
She needs to demonstrate that she’s doing okay.”
November 21, 2023, Pretrial Hearing
On November 21, 2023, the juvenile court held a pretrial hearing. Minor’s
adoptive mother told the juvenile court she had seen a video of minor with a
“much older” man. The video was recorded in a car. In the video, minor and the
9.
man cut off the electronic monitoring device and threw it out the car window. The
court issued a warrant for minor’s arrest.
December 19, 2023 Detention Hearing
On December 19, 2023, the juvenile court held a detention hearing. Minor was in
custody after being apprehended on the warrant. She had been a runaway for
approximately five weeks. While on the run, minor lived in a “ ‘trap house,’ ” where she
had daily access to cocaine and marijuana.7
The court ordered a section 241.1 staffing report. Minor asked the court to release
her from custody. She stated to the court she would not run away from her placement
again. The court stated,
“I don’t believe it. I’ve tried very, very hard for a long, long time to
get [minor] to [not run away]. It doesn’t work. I’m more concerned about
her out there in the street running around and doing God knows what. I
think right now it’s in her best interest that she be detained. I am absolutely
concerned that something terrible is going to happen to her. She’ll remain
detained.”
December 22, 2023 Section 241.1 Staffing Report
The December 22, 2023 section 241.1 staffing report discussed several incidents
involving minor running away from her resource home. While on runaway status, minor
was living in a “trap house” where she had access to drugs and was on the run for
approximately five weeks. Minor also had burn marks on her arms and several tattoos.
The section 241.1 staffing report recommended minor be made a ward of the juvenile
court and that services through delinquency proceedings and probation should move to
7 “Trap house” is slang for a place where drugs are bought, sold, or used. (See
<https://www.dictionary.com/browse/trap-house>, [as of March 4, 2024].)
(<https://www.dictionary.com/browse/cutover>, [as of Nov. 7, 2019].)
10.
the forefront, due to her history of absconding from resource placements, substance abuse
and inconsistent school attendance.
December 27, 2023 Section 241.1 Staffing Hearing
On December 27, 2023, minor waived her rights and admitted the allegations of
the third amended petition. The juvenile court terminated dependency jurisdiction and
section 654.3 informal probation. The court ordered minor to be seen regularly by mental
health services.
January 11, 2024 Disposition Hearing
On January 11, 2024, the juvenile court committed minor to the short-term
program for six months. The maximum term of confinement was set at four years
six months. Minor was given 66 days of credit for time served. The court ordered minor
to attend school regularly, to not use or possess drugs or alcohol, to participate in
individual, substance and anger management counseling, and to perform 20 hours of
community service. The court also imposed gang terms.
Facts Underlying the February 27, 2024 Probation Violation and
Fourth Wardship Petition
On February 5, 2024, an officer at the juvenile facility where minor was
committed encountered minor with a fresh cut on her arm and holding a toothbrush with
a sharpened edge. Minor refused to hand the toothbrush to the officer. When the officer
grabbed minor’s arm to prevent her from harming herself, minor struck the officer several
times with a closed fist.
March 7, 2024 Jurisdiction Hearing
On March 7, 2024, the juvenile court told minor she could be placed in a foster
home as well as other options. Minor waived her rights and admitted the petition and
probation violation.
March 21, 2024 Probation Report
The March 21, 2024 probation report stated:
11.
“Fourteen year old [minor] is making a formal appearance before the
Tulare County Superior Court, Juvenile Division regarding disposition for a
[f]elony, violation of [Penal Code] section 69 … [o]bstruct/[r]esist
[e]xecutive officer and a [v]iolation of [p]robation, violation of
section 777[, subdivision](a) …. [¶] … [¶]
“In addition, … minor was found in violation as she failed to comply
with her terms and conditions of the [s]hort-[t]erm [p]rogram by failing to
abide by the rules and regulations of the [j]uvenile [d]etention [f]acility
further obtaining a new offense.
“[M]inor exhibits a repeated pattern of criminogenic behavior and
with that, [p]robation believes … minor requires a greater period of time in
a structured facility which can be offered through the [m]id-[t]erm
[p]rogram. [M]inor has failed to play an active role in her rehabilitation
and had failed to address her criminogenic needs although has been offered
tools to do so.
“Therefore, it is respectfully recommended … minor be re-adjudged
a ward of the [j]uvenile [c]ourt and be committed to the Tulare County
[m]id[-][t]erm [p]rogram, for [365] days. It is further recommended …
minor be ordered to abide by the standard terms and conditions of
probation, not in conflict, as well [as] those specific to h[er] needs,
including she abide by all of the rules and regulations of the [m]id[-][t]erm
[p]rogram and participate in all services as provided by the program; as
well as those pertaining to the [a]ftercare [p]rogram, which include she
attend school as scheduled, not use or possess alcohol, marijuana, or
controlled substances, abide by an 8:00 [p.m.] curfew, enroll and participate
in anger management and individual counseling, not knowingly have
contact with any known gang member and be subject to search and test
clauses. Further, all prior terms and condition[s] of probation not in
conflict remain in full force and effect.”
April 2, 2024 Probation Memorandum
An April 2, 2024 probation memorandum stated minor’s adoptive parents were
unwilling to take her back if she were released. The memorandum noted her runaway
and behavior issues in five placement homes and recommended she be placed in the
mid-term program.
12.
April 30, 2024 Disposition Hearing
On April 30, 2024, minor’s counsel requested she be placed in a foster home. The
juvenile court denied the request, stating minor was not eligible for foster placement, and
believed custody and the camp program recommended by probation were appropriate.
The court explained:
“What my intention is, and the recommendation of probation is,
mid[-]term program, which is not going to be until [minor is] 18. She’s not
going to be in custody until she’s 18, and they are going to have to look at
placement.
“Unfortunately, there are more limited placements when you do stuff
that makes you a ward of the [c]ourt than there are when you’re just a
dependent. I can’t control the way the availabilities are. Not a lot of people
are willing to take in a teenager who has a delinquent background.
Probation does its best, but they have limited options. The next option is a
short-term residential program.
“My hope is I’ll place you in the midterm, you’ll get enough services
while you’re at the detention facility so that you can address your anger
management issues and get some counseling so that when you’re placed in
the aftercare, they can find good placement for you, and you won’t be
returning back to the detention facility.
“I tried as best I could when you first appeared in front of me to keep
you as a dependent, but I’m limited in my actions to place you in foster care
because you’re no longer a dependent of the [c]ourt. It really is incumbent
upon you, [minor], to behave appropriately so you don’t have any further
conduct.
“What you did while you were detained is inappropriate. If you
continue to act out while you’re detained, you will remain detained. If you
choose to make a choice, and you want to get out of the detention facility,
let us help you so you can get released. Make sense?”
Minor was continued on probation. The juvenile court placed minor in the
mid-term program for 365 days with 136 days of credit for time served. The court found
the maximum amount of time minor could be detained on the petition to be eight months
and set the maximum term of confinement for all petitions at five years two months.
13.
Minor was ordered to attend school, participate in all programs offered in the mid-term
program, perform 80 hours of community service, and write a letter of apology to the
victim. Gang terms and a restitution fine of $100 were imposed.
DISCUSSION
Minor contends the juvenile court abused its discretion when it placed minor in the
mid-term program. The People disagree and argue as a threshold issue that whether the
court erred by committing her to the mid-term program may be moot. We agree with the
People.
Mootness
The People argue as a threshold issue that whether the juvenile court erred when it
committed minor to the mid-term program is moot because her release from detention in
the mid-term program would have occurred on December 15, 2024.8 We agree.
“ ‘A case becomes moot when a court ruling can have no practical impact or
cannot provide the parties with effective relief.’ ” (In re Stephon L. (2010) 181
Cal.App.4th 1227, 1231.) “Generally, courts decide only ‘actual controversies’ which
will result in a judgment that offers relief to the parties.’ [Citations.] Thus, appellate
courts as a rule will not render opinions on moot questions: ‘[W]hen, pending an appeal
from the judgment of a lower court, and without fault of the [respondent], an event occurs
which renders it impossible for [the reviewing court] if it should decide the case in favor
of [appellant], to grant [appellant] any effectual relief whatever, the court will not
proceed to a formal judgment, but will dismiss the appeal.’ ” (Ebensteiner Co., Inc. v.
Chadmar Group (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 1174, 1178.)
Minor’s period of confinement of 365 days, less 136 days credit, in the mid-term
program ended December 15, 2024, pursuant to the juvenile court’s April 30, 2024
8 Minor did not file a response addressing the People’s argument that the issue of
whether the juvenile court erred when it committed minor to the mid-term program may
be moot.
14.
order.9 Although a maximum possible term was placed on the record as required by law,
nothing in the record reflects any additional detention time beyond what is noted above.
Because we cannot provide minor with any effective relief, as her time for release from
detention in the mid-term program has already occurred, we find the issue of whether the
court erred when it committed minor to the mid-term program for 365 days to be moot.
(See In re Sodersten (2007) 146 Cal.App.4th 1163, 1217.)
Commitment to the Mid-Term Program
However, regardless of whether the issue is moot, we conclude the juvenile court
did not err when it committed minor to the mid-term program on April 20, 2024.
“After finding that a minor is a [ward of the court], the court shall hear evidence
on the question of the proper disposition to be made of the minor. The court shall receive
in evidence the social study of the minor made by the probation officer and any other
relevant and material evidence that may be offered, including any written or oral
statement offered by the victim[.] … In any judgment and order of disposition, the court
shall state that the social study made by the probation officer has been read and that the
social study and any statement has been considered by the court.” (§ 706.)
When determining the appropriate disposition in a delinquency proceeding, the
juvenile courts are required to consider “(1) the age of the minor, (2) the circumstances
and gravity of the offense committed by the minor, and (3) the minor’s previous
delinquent history.” (§ 725.5.) The court is required to “consider ‘the broadest range of
information’ in determining how best to rehabilitate a minor and afford him adequate
care.” (In re Robert H. (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 1317, 1329.)
The standard of review in juvenile commitment decisions is abuse of discretion.
(In re Joey G. (2012) 206 Cal.App.4th 343, 346.) “ ‘A [juvenile] court abuses its
9 Minor was to be detained in the mid-term program for a total of 229 days
(365 days–136=229). Two hundred and twenty-nine days after the April 30, 2024 hearing
is December 15, 2024.
15.
discretion when the factual findings critical to its decision find no support in the
evidence.’ ” (In re Khalid B. (2015) 233 Cal.App.4th 1285, 1288.) Courts of Appeal
reviewing juvenile court dispositions “must indulge all reasonable inferences to support
the decision of the juvenile court and will not disturb its findings when there is
substantial evidence to support them.” (In re Lorenza M. (1989) 212 Cal.App.3d 49, 53.)
“ ‘Substantial evidence’ is evidence of ponderable legal significance, evidence that is
reasonable, credible and of solid value.’ ” (Roddenberry v. Roddenberry (1996) 44
Cal.App.4th 634, 651.)
“ ‘ “In determining whether there was substantial evidence to support the
commitment, we must examine the record presented at the disposition hearing in light of
the purposes of the Juvenile Court Law.” ’ ” (In re Oscar A. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th
750, 756.) In reviewing a commitment determination, we remember that “ ‘the primary
goal behind maintaining separate courts and procedures for adults and minors is to ensure
that juvenile offenders who have not yet become hardened criminals receive treatment
and rehabilitation.’ ” (In re Carlos E. (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 1529, 1542.) That goal is
reflected in the mandate that juvenile courts consider “the protection of the public as well
as the rehabilitation of the minor” in reaching a disposition. (Ibid.) Accordingly, “when
we assess the record in light of the purposes of the Juvenile Court Law [citation], we
evaluate the exercise of discretion with punishment and public safety and protection in
mind.” (In re Lorenza M., supra, 212 Cal.App.3d at p. 58.)
Here, the juvenile court stated, in pertinent part:
“What my intention is, and the recommendation of probation is,
midterm program, which is not going to be until [minor is] 18. She’s not
going to be in custody until she’s 18, and they are going to have to look at
placement.
“Unfortunately, there are more limited placements when you do stuff
that makes you a ward of the [c]ourt than there are when you’re just a
dependent. I can’t control the way the availabilities are. Not a lot of people
are willing to take in a teenager who has a delinquent background.
16.
Probation does its best, but they have limited options. The next option is a
short-term residential program.
“My hope is I’ll place you in the midterm, you’ll get enough services
while you’re at the detention facility so that you can address your anger
management issues and get some counseling so that when you’re placed in
the aftercare, they can find good placement for you, and you won’t be
returning back to the detention facility.
“I tried as best I could when you first appeared in front of me to keep
you as a dependent, but I’m limited in my actions to place you in foster care
because you’re no longer a dependent of the [c]ourt.”
The juvenile court’s statement shows it read and considered the probation
department’s report, as required by section 706, and considered minor’s age, previous
delinquent history, and the circumstances and gravity of her offenses when it committed
her to the mid-term program, as required by section 725.5. Pursuant to sections 706 and
725.5, and in light of the dual purposes of juvenile law to protect the public and
rehabilitate the minor, there is sufficient evidence to support its commitment of minor to
the mid-term program for 365 days, less 136 days of credit. Accordingly, regardless of
whether the issue is moot, we conclude that the court did not err when it committed
minor to the mid-term program.
DISPOSITION
The appeal is dismissed as moot.
17.
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.