CourtListener 10377040•People v. Haro CA2/5
Texto completo
Filed 4/11/25 P. v. Haro CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
THE PEOPLE, B334187
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. KA088341)
MARTIN HARO,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, H. Clay Jacke II, Judge. Affirmed.
Dwyer + Kim and John P. Dwyer, under appointment by
the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Senior
Assistant Attorney General, Idan Ivri and Theresa A. Patterson,
Deputy Attorneys General for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________
Martin Haro appeals the trial court’s order denying his
petition for vacatur of his conviction and resentencing for the
murder of Marquise Le Blanc. The trial court denied Haro’s
petition following an evidentiary hearing held pursuant to Penal
Code1 section 1172.6, subdivision (d)(3). On appeal, Haro argues
that the evidence was insufficient to support his conviction for
directly aiding and abetting the murder with implied malice. We
affirm the trial court’s order.2
FACTS
A. The Murder
On April 17, 2009, eighteen-year-old Le Blanc went to a
large party in Pomona with friends, including Taylor H.3 The
boys were not familiar with Pomona. They learned about another
party in Pomona through a text. They were not able to find the
party, but as they were driving they saw a bunch of kids walking
1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 Haro also contends that if this court reverses the trial
court’s order the matter should be transferred to juvenile court
for disposition pursuant to Proposition 57. Because we affirm the
trial court’s order, it is not necessary to address the contention.
3 The party was attended by teenagers mostly between the
ages of 13 and 19 years old, so we refer to the party-goers using
terms that describe minors. Haro was 15 years old at the time.
No disrespect is intended.
2
around. The boys asked if there was a party and were told there
was, so they decided to go.
The party was held at Leslie C.’s house. Leslie C. asked
her adult cousin, Deborah M., to help her set up the party.
Leslie C. hired Deborah M.’s boyfriend, Joshua R., as security for
the party because she wanted to exclude “anybody that looked
like a gangster.” Leslie C. told Joshua R. she did not want Edgar
Cisneros4 or Adam Delgado at the party. The party took place in
Leslie C.’s back yard. The kids entered through the front gate
where security was stationed. About 100 people attended the
party. The majority of the party-goers were Hispanic. Cisneros
and his girlfriend tried to get into the party but they were refused
entrance. Leslie C. checked to make sure they did not get in
through a different entrance, but could not find them.
Deborah M. was at the front gate talking to Joshua R.
when Le Blanc arrived. Le Blanc seemed cheerful and excited to
go to the party. Le Blanc was one of the few Black people there.
Taylor H. and Le Blanc tried to dance with a few girls but the
girls turned them down. At one point, Taylor H. saw Le Blanc
talking to a Hispanic male wearing a jacket with “Pomona”
written on it. The Hispanic male pointed to a tattoo on his neck
and asked Le Blanc if he saw the tattoo. Le Blanc responded that
he did not want any problems. Le Blanc also said “I don’t care
about that.” After that Le Blanc and Taylor H. split up.
About 10 minutes later, Taylor H. heard a commotion and
heard that someone had a gun. Taylor H. heard someone yell
“Fuck that [derogatory racial epithet]” and “Get that [derogatory
racial epithet]”. Taylor H. looked around for Le Blanc because he
4 Cisnero and Haro were jointly tried for the murder.
3
knew Le Blanc was one of the only Black people at the party. As
he was looking for Le Blanc he heard a gunshot. He went out
front and saw people in the street running toward the house.
Taylor H. ran in the direction that people were coming from and
saw Le Blanc lying still on the ground. There was blood around
him. Paramedics arrived soon thereafter.
Vivian P. also attended the party. When she arrived she
went over to an area where a dance floor was set up. There were
about 50 to 60 people at the party by that time. Most of the
people were Hispanic. She saw one Black male. After Vivian P.
had been at the party for a while, a commotion started near the
D.J. At that point, the crowd in the back yard had increased.
The Black male was arguing with a Hispanic male who she did
not know. She could not hear what they were arguing about
because the music was loud. Someone stepped between them and
tried to intervene. The Black male pulled out a gun and waved it
at the people around him, including Vivian P. The Black male
yelled “Who wants to mess with me now?” He started backing
out of the yard, towards the gate, and then began running. Some
people ran away from him and tried to climb over a fence to get
out of the yard, but about 15 people followed the Black male.
Leslie C. testified that Cisneros and Delgado were right behind
the Black male as he ran. Vivian P. saw the Hispanic male who
had been arguing with the Black male run back into the yard to a
wood pile, grab a piece of construction wood, and run back
towards the front of the house, yelling “Fuck that [derogatory
racial epithet]”. Vivian P. stayed in the back yard. She lost sight
of the Black male as he ran to the front. After about three to four
minutes she heard two gunshots, followed by tires screeching
about 10 seconds later.
4
Deborah M. was inside the house looking out the window
when she saw people running and screaming, “He has a gun.
Run, run. He has a gun.” Le Blanc was waving a gun around at
the party-goers. Deborah M. was afraid for her young son who
was also inside the house; she ran to the side door to lock it.
When Deborah M. got to the door, the gate was closed and Le
Blanc was hunched over on the stairs that lead up to the door.
“[A] swarm of guys [were] hitting [Le Blanc] really hard.
Everybody was just wailing on him.” Le Blanc was being
attacked by more than 13 Hispanic males. More people were
behind them, rushing forward to join the attack. Le Blanc was on
his knees with his hands up by his head. Deborah M. could
clearly see that his hands were empty. Deborah M. testified that
“Everybody was just punching, kicking, but to the point where
like you could actually hear him—like when you hear someone
getting hit, like you could hear the thud sounds of when they
were hitting him.” The males were saying “ ‘Get that [derogatory
racial epithet]. Kick his ass. That’s what he gets.’ ” and “ ‘Let me
at him, Let me at him.’ Everybody was just trying to hit him.”
Deborah M. screamed for the mob to stop, but the beating
continued. Le Blanc was not fighting back. Deborah M. had
“never seen violence like that. . . . [She had] never seen [any]body
get beat up like that in [her] life. . . . It was just relentless. It
was non-stop. [She] could just hear the punches and kicks on his
body.” People in the crowd were throwing bottles, and one hit
Deborah M. Leslie C.’s mother came outside and tried to help
Deborah M. One of the males swung his fist at Deborah M. She
ducked out of the way and the blow hit her aunt’s thigh, leaving a
big welt. Deborah M. was able to pull Le Blanc up and push the
gate open for him to escape. The crowd pushed Deborah M. back.
5
Le Blanc ran down the street with a group of males chasing after
him. Deborah M. later identified Haro as one of the people who
was hitting Le Blanc. Haro struck Le Blanc with a closed fist.
After Le Blanc fled, someone called Deborah M. a
“[derogatory racial epithet] lover” and told Deborah M. that she
was “lucky that [she] didn’t end up like him and that [she] should
have got [her] ass beat just like he did.” Deborah M. walked over
to pick up a fallen chair and tripped over a “fake” gun. Joshua R.
picked up the gun and took it away. Deborah M. saw a male
running back from the direction the mob had gone. He retrieved
what looked like a gun from a car parked across the street and
ran back toward the mob. Deborah M. could not see Le Blanc
down the street, but she heard a gunshot. She also heard
someone yell, “Pomona, Pomona.” The crowd ran back toward
Leslie C.’s house. She saw the person who had retrieved
something from the car get into the vehicle and drive away.
Sandra A. and her husband, Pablo A., lived down the street
from Leslie C. She was inside when she heard a commotion and
looked out the window to see what was happening. Sandra A.
saw a group of 25 to 30 kids running in the street toward her
house. They gathered in one area and a fight broke out.
Everyone in the group was kicking and hitting a boy. Pablo A.
estimated that there was a group of 20 to 25 people in the street.
The boy was on the ground. It looked like all the people had been
surrounding the boy and were dispersing. After the beating
stopped and people were walking away, one person pulled out a
gun and shot the boy. The person got into an SUV and drove
away.
City of Pomona Officer Melvon Bird was on patrol that
night and received a call that there was a man in his twenties
6
with a gun. On the way en route dispatch advised that someone
had been shot. When he arrived at the scene, Officer Bird saw 30
to 40 kids running away. Le Blanc was lying on the ground.
Le Blanc did not appear to be breathing and did not respond to
the officer. Officer Bird felt for a pulse and found none. He saw
that there was blood in Le Blanc’s ears and a puddle of blood
under his head. There was a bullet casing near Le Blanc’s head.
The officer called for paramedics.
B. Cause of Death and Injuries
Deputy Medical Examiner Dr. Lisa Scheinin of the Los
Angeles County Coroner’s Office determined that the cause of
Le Blanc’s death was a combination of stabbing and gunshot
wounds. He was stabbed three times, including a stab to the
heart. After the stabbing, Le Blanc was shot once through the
back of the head. In addition to the stabbing and gunshot
wounds, Le Blanc suffered multiple head injuries, including
abrasions, contusions, and shallow lacerations. His nasal bridge
and ear cartilage were fractured. Dr. Scheinin opined that
Le Blanc likely suffered the injuries as a result of being kicked in
the head and stomped on the face. The abrasions were consistent
with tread marks and “pushing the left side of the head into the
ground and . . . grinding it into the ground.” Dr. Scheinin did not
observe any offensive wounds that would indicate Le Blanc had
been fighting back.
7
C. Gang Evidence
City of Pomona Officer Greg Freeman testified that the
12th Street gang (12th Street) is the largest Hispanic gang in
Pomona. The area where Leslie C.’s house is located is claimed
by 12th Street. 12th Street is notorious for its hatred of Black
people. The officer explained that members of a gang are people
who live for the gang. They have no other job and are focused on
bettering the gang at all times. Associates are people who have a
life outside the gang that may include a job or school but “will
drop what they got and go assist the gang at a moment’s notice.”
Tagging crews are bonded groups of younger people who operate
within a gang’s territory and are a source of future recruits for
the gang. Tagging crews commit crimes that benefit the gang.
The Tinto Killers or TK is a tagging crew that operates within
12th Street’s territory. “Tinto Killers” means Black Killers. The
Tinto Killers are primarily Hispanic. 12th Street engages in a
wide variety of criminal offenses; one of their major activities is
murder. 12th Street is also known as “The Pomona 12th Street
Gang” and “The Shark Gang.” Their symbols include sharks, the
letter “P”, and the number “12.”
Given hypothetical facts that mirror this case Officer
Freeman opined that the crime would have been committed for
the benefit of a criminal street gang. The murder would benefit
the gang because it would demonstrate to rival gangs that there
are serious consequences of coming into the gang’s territory and
disrespecting it. The crime would be more violent because the
victim was Black. Numerous people at the party on the night of
the killing were members of 12th Street, including Cisneros,
Adrian Zuniga, Victor Guillen, and Francisco Martinez. Delgado
8
was a member of the Most Budded Kings, another tagging crew
that operates under 12th Street. At the time of trial, Delgado
belonged to 12th Street. Ralph Alfaro and Richard Vasquez were
at least associates of 12th Street.
There was no evidence presented at trial that Haro was
affiliated with 12th Street or either of the tagging crews.
However, at Haro’s parole suitability hearing on February 10,
2021, Haro admitted, “Before I came to prison, I was a criminal
in every sense of the word. I was a gang member. I was a racist.”
D. Haro’s Text Messages to Friends
The day after the murder, Haro texted Jessica V., one of
the hosts of the party, regarding the incident. Jessica V. was in
the back yard when Le Blanc pulled out a gun. Someone told her
to get down because there was a guy with a gun. She remained
in the garage until the police arrived. Jessica V.’s text
conversation with Haro was as follows:
[Haro]: “Did the [derogatory racial epithet] that we fucked
up die?”
[Jessica V.]: “O.M.G. W.T.F.”
[Haro]: “A lot of people text me telling me that he died.”
[Jessica V.]: “What did you guys do?”
[Haro]: “Well, we stomped the shit out of his face.”
[Jessica V.]: “You know what, I really don’t find that
funny, but yes he died and someone shot him. What the fuck
were you guys thinking[?]”
[Haro]: “Nah we didn’t shoot him and I didn’t find that shit
funny either. I just wasn’t sure what happened.”
9
Jessica C. was also at the party. There was a disturbance
and she saw a tall Black male waving a gun. Afterwards,
Jessica C. thought that the Black male had been killed by the
police officers. Jessica C. had known Haro since elementary
school and had dated him in the past. The day after the party,
Jessica C. and Victor F. texted with Haro on Victor F.’s phone.
[Jessica C.]: “Hey so are you okay. It’s me Shorti.[5]”
[Haro]: “Yeah I’m koo. We killed them though.”
[Jessica C.]: “What the fuck. I thought the cops did it.”
[Haro]: “Nah they told me he was already dead.”
[Jessica C.]: “W.T.F.F[?]. I know I seen him on the ground
dead. I couldn’t sleep I was so scared.”
[Haro]: “I know. Imagine how I feel right now. Me and
[Alfaro] were the first ones to fuck him up.”
[Jessica C.]: “By the way, how did you guys fuck him up.
He had a gun.”
[Haro]: “I know but when he was running down the street,
we ran behind him. Then [Alfaro] and me starting socking him
til he fell. Then I started kicking his face. And then I noticed he
was unconscious. That’s when more and more people came. And
at the end I starting yelling to everyone to leave and I looked at
him and he wasn’t moving.”
[Jessica C.]: “What, then you know who killed him huh?”
[Haro]: “And that’s when I knew he was dead already.”
[Jessica C.]: “Oh, shit, it wasn’t your fault though huh
because he was probably on drugs and you guys knocked him out
huh.”
[Haro]: “Yeah, I hope so, but I can’t stop thinking about it.”
5 Jessica C.’s nickname was “Shorti.”
10
[Jessica C.]: “Don’t trip sweetie. I know it wasn’t your
fault.”
[Haro]: “Yeah, I guess.”
[Jessica C.]: “Are you okay babe?”
[Haro]: “Yeah, I’m cool. He fuckin’ looked for it so he can
rest in fuckin piss now.”
[Jessica C.]: “Laughing my ass off. It’s peace.”
[Haro]: “I meant to write piss stupid.”
[Jessica C.]: “You liar. For real?”
[Haro]: “Yeah, laugh out loud.”
[Jessica C.]: “So you’re livin’ to the fullest or what.”
[Haro]: “Nah, I living to the money G.”
Haro also exchanged text messages with an unidentified
person the day after the murder:
[Unknown]: “So what did you do yesterday?”
[Haro]: “I went to a party. And you?”
[Unknown]: “Oh. Cool. How was it? I did nothin’.”
[Haro]: “Me and the homies nearly killed a [derogatory
racial epithet].” [followed by frowny face emoji].
[Unknown]: “O.M.G. Was this on Virginia Street?”
[Haro]: “Yeah.”
[Unknown]: “O.M.G. O.M.G. O.M.G. What happened?”
[Haro]: “Why you asking like that?”
[Unknown]: “Like what? Tell me what happened. So what
happened?”
[Haro]: “We beat his ass.”
[Unknown]: “Why?”
[Haro]: “Because he pulled a strap out on the homies.”
11
[Unknown]: “Oh, damn, that sucks.” “Oh, damn, how
scary.”
[Haro]: “I know, but now I’m a little scared because people
say he died.”
[Unknown]: “Well, Yesenia’s brother was there and he said
he got shot.”
[Haro]: “Who got shot?”
[Unknown]: “A Black guy. . . .”
Later that day, Haro and the unidentified person had a
second exchange of texts:
[Haro]: “Oh, babe I need to tell you something.”
[Unknown]: “What?”
[Haro]: “That [derogatory racial epithet] we fucked up
died.”
[Unknown]: “Fuck babe that fuckin sucks and scary.”
[Haro]: “I know.”
[Unknown]: “You think it was your guys fault?”
[Haro]: “Yeah.”
[Unknown]: “Oh, damn.”
[Haro]: “Yeah, I know.”
[Unknown]: “I don’t think it was you guys.”
[Haro]: “I hope not.”
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The People tried Haro for murder on two theories—(1)
direct aiding and abetting and (2) aiding and abetting under the
natural and probable consequences doctrine. The People did not
allege that Haro stabbed or shot Le Blanc. He was prosecuted
based on his role in the mass beating.
12
The jury found Haro guilty of second degree murder. The
jury further found that the murder was committed for the benefit
of a criminal street gang (§ 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(C)), and that a
principal personally and intentionally discharged a firearm
proximately causing the victim’s death (§ 12022.53, subds. (d),
(e)(1)). After the jury returned its verdict, the People moved to
dismiss the gang and firearm allegations in exchange for Haro’s
agreement to withdraw his motion for new trial and to waive his
right to appeal. The trial court sentenced Haro to 15 years to life
in state prison.
In 2019, Haro petitioned to be resentenced under former
section 1170.95, now section 1172.6. The trial court summarily
denied Haro’s petition without appointing counsel because the
court concluded that (1) section 1170.95 was unconstitutional,
and (2) even if the statute was constitutional, Haro aided and
abetted the murder with intent to kill Le Blanc.
On appeal, this court concluded that section 1170.95 was
not unconstitutional, and that the trial court had improperly
decided the petition without appointing counsel. We reversed the
trial court’s order and remanded the matter for further
proceedings.
On remand, the trial court appointed counsel, and the
parties briefed the matter. The trial court issued an order to
show cause and held an evidentiary hearing pursuant to section
1172.6, subdivision (d)(3).
At the hearing, the court considered the transcripts of trial,
the transcripts of Haro’s February 10, 2021 parole board hearing,
and the testimony of Dr. Katy Dorit Gaines regarding Haro’s
youth at the time of the crimes and its negative impact on his
ability to make decisions and to appreciate the consequences of
13
his actions. Following the hearing, the trial court again denied
Haro’s petition. The court found that the People had met their
burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that Haro was
guilty of directly aiding and abetting implied malice murder.
Haro timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
A. Legal Principles
1. Section 1172.6
“Effective January 1, 2019, the Legislature passed Senate
Bill 1437 ‘to amend the felony murder rule and the natural and
probable consequences doctrine, as it relates to murder, to ensure
that murder liability is not imposed on a person who is not the
actual killer, did not act with the intent to kill, or was not a
major participant in the underlying felony who acted with
reckless indifference to human life.’ (Stats. 2018, ch. 1015, § 1,
subd. (f).)” People v. Lewis (2021) 11 Cal.5th 952, 959.) As
relevant here, the bill eliminated second degree murder liability
predicated on the natural and probable consequences doctrine.
(§ 188, subd. (a)(3), as amended by Stats. 2018, ch. 1015, § 2;
People v. Strong (2022) 13 Cal.5th 698, 707, fn. 1.)
“ ‘[N]otwithstanding Senate Bill 1437’s elimination of
natural and probable consequences liability for second degree
murder, an aider and abettor who does not expressly intend to
aid a killing can still be convicted of second degree murder if the
person knows that his or her conduct endangers the life of
another and acts with conscious disregard for life.’ [Citation.]”
14
(People v. Reyes (2023) 14 Cal.5th 981, 990 (Reyes).) “[A]
defendant may directly aid and abet an implied malice murder.
(See People v. Glukhoy (2022) 77 Cal.App.5th 576, 588–591;
People v. Superior Court (Valenzuela) (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 485,
499; People v. Powell (2021) 63 Cal.App.5th 689, 710–714,
(Powell); see also People v. Langi (2022) 73 Cal.App.5th 972, 979–
983.)” (Ibid.)
Senate Bill No. 1437 also added former section 1170.95,
now section 1172.6, to provide a procedure for those convicted of
murder to seek resentencing. (§ 1172.6, subds. (a)–(c).) If the
sentencing court determines the petitioner has made a prima
facie showing, the court must issue an order to show cause and
hold a hearing to determine whether to vacate the murder
conviction. (§ 1172.6, subds. (c), (d)(1).) At the evidentiary
hearing, “the burden of proof shall be on the prosecution to prove,
beyond a reasonable doubt, that the petitioner is guilty of murder
. . . under California law as amended by the changes to [s]ection
188 or 189 made effective January 1, 2019.” (§ 1172.6, subd.
(d)(3).)
“[A] trial court’s denial of a section 1172.6 petition is
reviewed for substantial evidence. [Citation.] Under this
standard, we review the record ‘ “ ‘in the light most favorable to
the judgment below to determine whether it discloses substantial
evidence—that is, evidence which is reasonable, credible, and of
solid value—such that a reasonable trier of fact could find the
defendant guilty [of murder under a still-valid theory] beyond a
reasonable doubt.’ ” ’ ” (Reyes, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 988.)
We will not reverse unless there is no hypothesis upon
which sufficient substantial evidence exists to support the trial
court’s decision. (People v. Bolin (1998) 18 Cal.4th 297, 331.) We
15
must “presume in support of the judgment the existence of every
fact the trier could reasonably deduce from the evidence.” (People
v. Jones (1990) 51 Cal.3d 294, 314.) “The same standard applies
when the conviction rests primarily on circumstantial evidence.”
(People v. Kraft (2000) 23 Cal.4th 978, 1053.) “An appellate court
must accept logical inferences that the [trier of fact] might have
drawn from the circumstantial evidence.” (People v. Maury
(2003) 30 Cal.4th 342, 396.)
2. Implied Malice Murder
“Murder is committed with implied malice when ‘the killing
is proximately caused by “ ‘an act, the natural consequences of
which are dangerous to life, which act was deliberately performed
by a person who knows that his conduct endangers the life of
another and who acts with conscious disregard for life.’ ” ’ (People
v. Knoller (2007) 41 Cal.4th 139, 143 (Knoller).) ” (Reyes, supra,
14 Cal.5th at p. 988.) “[T]he defendant’s act must not merely be
dangerous to life in some vague or speculative sense; it
must ‘ “involve[ ] a high degree of probability that it will result in
death.” ’ (Knoller, supra, 41 Cal.4th at p. 152; see ibid. [under
the objective component of implied malice, ‘ “ ‘dangerous to life’ ” ’
means the same thing as a ‘ “high degree of probability that” ’ the
act in question ‘ “will result in death” ’]; People v. Cravens (2012)
53 Cal.4th 500, 513 (conc. opn. of Liu, J.) [‘Although an act that
will certainly lead to death is not required, the probability of
death from the act must be more than remote or merely
possible[]’].)” (Reyes, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 989.)
16
3. Direct Aiding and Abetting Implied Malice
Murder
“ ‘[D]irect aiding and abetting is based on the combined
actus reus of the participants and the aider and abettor’s own
mens rea. ([People v. McCoy (2001) 25 Cal.4th 1111, 1122.]) In
the context of implied malice, the actus reus required of the
perpetrator is the commission of a life-endangering act. For the
direct aider and abettor, the actus reus includes whatever acts
constitute aiding the commission of the life-endangering act.
Thus, to be liable for an implied malice murder, the direct aider
and abettor must, by words or conduct, aid the commission of the
life-endangering act, not the result of that act. The mens rea,
which must be personally harbored by the direct aider and
abettor, is knowledge that the perpetrator intended to commit the
act, intent to aid the perpetrator in the commission of the act,
knowledge that the act is dangerous to human life, and acting in
conscious disregard for human life.’ [Citations.]” (Reyes, supra,
14 Cal.5th at pp. 990–991.)
In contrast, “ ‘the natural and probable consequences
doctrine did not require that the aider and abettor intend to aid
the perpetrator in committing a life-endangering act . . . . What
was natural and probable was judged by an objective standard
and it was enough that murder was a reasonably foreseeable
consequence of the crime aided and abetted.’ (Powell, supra, 63
Cal.App.5th at p. 711, fn. 26.)” (Reyes, supra, 14 Cal.5th at
p. 991.)
17
B. Analysis
Haro argues that the evidence is not sufficient to support
the additional elements required to convict him of directly aiding
and abetting implied malice murder. He asserts there is not
substantial evidence that (1) he knew that the perpetrators
would stab and shoot Le Blanc; (2) he intended to aid and abet
the shooting and the stabbing; or that (3) in light of his youth, he
understood that his assaultive conduct could enable greater acts
of violence.
We reject Haro’s third argument at the outset. Haro does
not assert that the trial court failed to consider his youth at the
time of the murder, nor could he, as Dr. Gaines testified
extensively regarding the impact of Haro’s youth at the
evidentiary hearing. Haro’s argument goes to the weight that
should be afforded to this type of evidence. On appeal, we do not
consider whether there is some evidence that could cause the
trier of fact to reach a different conclusion, and we do not re-
weigh the evidence. (People v. Lindberg (2008) 45 Cal.4th 1, 27.)
Haro’s remaining arguments assume that the life-
threatening acts in this case were the fatal stabbing and the
shooting, and not the mass beating. Implied malice murder, as
our Supreme Court explained in Reyes, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pages
988 through 989, is not so limited. “ ‘[A]n act that will certainly
lead to death is not required[.]’ ” (Id. at p. 989.) Rather, the act
“ ‘ “must have been a substantial factor contributing to the result,
rather than insignificant or merely theoretical.” ’ [Citation.]” (Id.
at p. 988.) The question is not whether Le Blanc would have
survived the attack if not for the stabbing and shooting—rather,
we ask whether there was a high probability that the mass
18
beating would lead to Le Blanc’s death, and whether it did in fact
contribute substantially to his death. We answer both those
questions in the affirmative.
This case bears striking similarities to People v. Schell
(2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 437 (Schell). There, the defendant
appealed following the trial court’s denial of his section 1172.6
petition. (Id. at p. 440.) After an evidentiary hearing, the trial
court found beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant aided
and abetted implied malice murder. (Ibid.) The defendant was
one of at least eight attackers who participated in a mass beating
of a lone victim. (Ibid.) While some of the other attackers used a
bat and a shovel to strike the victim, the defendant did not
supply or wield a weapon, but used his hands and feet in the
“vicious assault.”6 (Id. at pp. 440, 443.) The killing was
committed in retaliation for perceived “disrespect” of the
attackers, who were gang members. (Id. at p. 440.) The
appellate court concluded that the defendant’s presence at the
scene, his companionship with the other attackers, his
participation, his motivation, and his conduct before and after the
fatal attack constituted substantial evidence to support the
conclusion that the defendant aided and abetted an implied
malice murder. (Id. at p. 443.) In reaching this conclusion, the
appellate court stated: “The trial court could reasonably infer
that appellant knew [the victim] was repeatedly being hit in the
head with a shovel and bat and that he intended to aid those acts
by participating in the assault. The blows to [the victim’s] head
were loud enough to be heard by several neighbors, some of
6 Evidence was presented that the victim was stabbed, but
the trial court expressly stated that its ruling “ ‘[did] not depend
on the knife.’ ” (Schell, supra, 84 Cal.App.5th at p. 441.)
19
whom heard someone yell, ‘Stop it’ and ‘[y]ou’re killing him.’ ”
(Ibid.)
Here, evidence was presented that the attackers were
predominantly gang members who despised Black people. The
mob that attacked Le Blanc was filled with people who belonged
to 12th Street—a gang that was notorious for its hatred of Black
people—and the tagging crews that operated under it. One of the
tagging crew’s names translated to Black Killers. One of 12th
Street’s primary activities was murder. The males chasing Le
Blanc to the gate were saying “ ‘Get that [derogatory racial
epithet]. Kick his ass. That’s what he gets.’ ” “ ‘Let me at him,
Let me at him.’ ” At his parole board hearing, Haro admitted he
was a gang member and a racist at the time of the murder. In
his text to Jessica C., Haro admitted he was with Alfaro, who was
a 12th Street member, and that the two of them “were the first
ones to fuck [Le Blanc] up.”
Like the defendant in Schell, Haro attacked Le Blanc as
one of a very large number of gang members and taggers working
together. Le Blanc was even more severely outnumbered than
the victim in Schell—Le Blanc was attacked by more than 13
Hispanic males who were hitting him very hard, just “wailing on
him.” Deborah M. identified Haro as one of the attackers at the
front gate. She saw him hit Le Blanc with a closed fist. More
people were behind them, rushing forward to join the attack. Le
Blanc was on his knees with his hands up by his head and was
not fighting back. Deborah M. could clearly see that Le Blanc’s
hands were empty. Deborah M. had “never seen violence like
that. . . . [She had] never seen [any]body get beat up like that in
[her] life. . . . It was just relentless. It was non-stop. [She] could
hear the punches and kicks on his body.” As in Schell, the
20
beating was so violent that “you could actually hear him—like
when you hear someone getting hit, like you could hear the thud
sounds of when they were hitting him.”
If Deborah M. had not managed to open the gate, there is a
high probability that Le Blanc would have been beaten to death
in the back yard. There was no indication that the mob intended
to cease beating Le Blanc, who was visibly unarmed by the time
he reached the stairs. Like the people in Schell who witnessed
the beating, Deborah M. yelled for the mob to stop, but they
persisted. They physically attacked Deborah M. They also
injured Deborah M.’s aunt, whose only involvement was
attempting to facilitate Le Blanc’s escape. There was no pause in
the mob’s pursuit of Le Blanc. Numerous members of the crowd
immediately chased Le Blanc through the gate. By his own
admission, Haro led that group. He and Alfaro knocked Le Blanc
to the ground and resumed beating him relentlessly until Haro
first believed Le Blanc to be unconscious, and then thought he
was “dead already.”
Although the beating may not have been the cause of
death, it was unquestionably a life-threatening act. Absent
intervention, there was a very high probability that the beating
would lead to Le Blanc’s death, in one manner or another—
something that Haro well understood. In a text to Jessica C.,
Haro stated that he believed Le Blanc was dead. When he made
the statement, Haro was not aware that Le Blanc was later
stabbed and shot. The evidence demonstrates that the attack
was vicious and unrelenting from inception. The goal, as several
of the participants loudly proclaimed, was to kill Le Blanc.
Once the mass beating is properly identified as a life-
endangering act, Haro’s other arguments fall to the wayside. He
21
cannot and does not contend that his actions did not contribute to
the mass beating, that he did not know the perpetrators intended
to beat Le Blanc so severely that his life would be endangered; or
that he did not intend to aid and abet the mass beating. Even
after he knew that Le Blanc had died, he made callous jokes
about the killing in texts with his friends and said that Le Blanc
deserved it. There is substantial evidence that Haro aided and
abetted the murder with implied malice.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the trial court’s order denying Haro’s petition for
resentencing pursuant to section 1172.6.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:
BAKER, Acting, P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
22
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.