Orcutt v. Vice CA2/6

CourtListener 10362759Calctapp24 de mar. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/24/25 Orcutt v. Vice CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

RICHARD V. ORCUTT, 2d Civ. No. B335120
(Super. Ct. No. 21CV-0030)
Plaintiff and Appellant, (San Luis Obispo County)

v.

NATHANIEL VICE,

Defendant and Respondent.

Richard Orcutt sued Nathaniel Vice for intentional
infliction of emotional distress, alleging he was responsible for
sending threatening cards to implicate Orcutt in a crime. Orcutt
appeals from the trial court’s grant of summary judgment against
him. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Anonymous cards were mailed to four real estate agents,
complaining about racial minorities living on Cavalier Lane in
San Luis Obispo. The return address was given as “Cavalier
Neighbors.” The cards warned the agents against renting homes
to racial minorities, and threatened to shoot the renters or the
agents if that occurred. Orcutt was arrested and prosecuted for
sending the cards but the charges were ultimately dismissed.
Vice and four other college student roommates lived in a
house on Cavalier near Orcutt. Several months before the cards
were sent to the real estate agents, Orcutt sent anonymous
letters to the roommates’ landlord to complain about a dog owned
by one of the roommates, Alex S. The letters claimed to be sent
by the “Cavalier Lane Homeowners Association,” which does not
actually exist. As a result, the dog was removed from the
residence.
Vice and Alex S. went to Orcutt’s house to talk about the
dog. In a declaration filed with the trial court, Vice stated that
was the only time he interacted with Orcutt. In his deposition,
Vice was asked if he wanted to keep the dog. He responded,
“Alex wanted to keep the dog.” Vice was asked if he also wanted
the dog to stay and responded, “It would have been nice to have
kept the dog there.” Vice said his goal in going to Orcutt’s home
was to “eliminate the confusion” with Orcutt about the dog and
avoid any neighbors being upset.
In his declaration filed with the trial court, Orcutt stated
that on another occasion he spoke to an unidentified tenant of
Vice’s residence about current and former residents of Cavalier
Lane, and that some of that information, which Orcutt does not
describe, appeared in the four cards sent to the real estate
agents.
Orcutt sued Vice for intentional infliction of emotional
distress, making criminal threats (Pen. Code, § 422, subd. (a)),
and preparing false evidence (Pen. Code, § 134). The complaint
alleged that Vice was “a person legally responsible for the
issuance of the four correspondences,” and the letters were

2
created to implicate and harm Orcutt. The complaint alleged
that Orcutt’s arrest, prosecution, and other adverse consequences
caused him severe emotional distress. The operative pleading for
the motion for summary judgment was the first amended
complaint, which added allegations that Vice conspired with, and
aided and abetted, one or more of his roommates in “the
issuance” of the correspondence to the real estate agents.
In his deposition, Vice testified he did not know who
drafted, wrote, created, or sent the cards. He stated in his
declaration that he did not write the cards. In his supplemental
declaration, he stated, “I had absolutely no involvement in any
way shape or form in causing the existence of any of the four
letters, the four envelopes, or any part thereof. I have absolutely
no knowledge about who is responsible in any way for the
existence of the four letters or the four envelopes. I have
absolutely no knowledge about how the four letters or the four
envelopes came into existence.” He added that he was not
involved in encouraging, drafting, writing, issuing, or sending
any of the letters, or providing any of the materials or ideas for
them, and he did not know who did.
Forensic document examiner Linda L. Mitchell compared
the cards and their envelopes with handwriting samples she
dictated to Vice to write. She “eliminated Nathaniel Vice as the
writer of the four threatening letters and envelopes with the
highest level of certainty (elimination/beyond a reasonable
doubt), level 9 out of 9.” In response, Orcutt submitted the
declaration of forensic scientist Larry F. Stewart, who opined
that Mitchell should have relied on “ ‘non-requested’ ” samples of
Vice’s handwriting, and accordingly, she should have reached
“ ‘no conclusion’ ” or found the analysis “inconclusive, pending the

3
availability of additional comparison standards.” Stewart did not
express his own opinion as to whether Vice was the author of the
cards.
The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of
Vice.1
DISCUSSION
Tort elements
At issue is whether Vice committed any conduct associated
with sending the cards to the real estate agents or conspired to do
so. “The elements of the tort of intentional infliction of emotional
distress are: ‘ “(1) extreme and outrageous conduct by the
defendant with the intention of causing, or reckless disregard of
the probability of causing, emotional distress; (2) the plaintiff’s
suffering severe or extreme emotional distress; and (3) actual and
proximate causation of the emotional distress by the defendant’s
outrageous conduct.” ’ ” (Christensen v. Superior Court (1991) 54
Cal.3d 868, 903.)
Civil conspiracy requires proof “that each member of the
conspiracy acted in concert and came to a mutual understanding
to accomplish a common and unlawful plan, and that one or more
of them committed an overt act to further it. . . . [¶] ‘Bare’
allegations and ‘rank’ conjecture do not suffice for a civil
conspiracy.” (Choate v. County of Orange (2000) 86 Cal.App.4th
312, 333.) Aiding and abetting a tort requires “ ‘ “intentional
participation with knowledge of the object to be attained.” ’ ”
(Upasani v. State Farm General Ins. Co. (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th

1 The appeal challenges only the ruling regarding
intentional infliction of emotional distress and does not challenge
the summary judgment against Orcutt for the Penal Code causes
of action.

4
509, 519, italics omitted.)
Summary judgment
“[A] motion for summary judgment shall be granted if all
the papers submitted show that there is no triable issue as to any
material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a judgment
as a matter of law.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd. (c).) A
defendant meets their burden by showing “that one or more of
the elements of the cause of action . . . cannot be established.”
(Id., subd. (p)(2).) The burden then shifts to the plaintiff “to show
that a triable issue of one or more material facts exists as to the
cause of action . . . . The plaintiff . . . shall not rely upon the
allegations or denials of its pleadings to show that a triable issue
of material fact exists but, instead, shall set forth the specific
facts showing that a triable issue of material fact exists as to the
cause of action or a defense thereto.” (Ibid.)
A defendant moving for summary judgment is not required
“to conclusively negate an element of the plaintiff’s cause of
action. . . . All that the defendant need do is to ‘show[] that one or
more elements of the cause of action . . . cannot be established’ by
the plaintiff.” (Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2001) 25 Cal.4th
826, 853, fn. omitted.) “There is a genuine issue of material fact
if, and only if, the evidence would allow a reasonable trier of fact
to find the underlying fact in favor of the party opposing the
motion in accordance with the applicable standard of proof.” (Id.
at p. 845.)
On appeal of a grant of summary judgment, we review the
record de novo. (Coral Construction, Inc. v. City and County of
San Francisco (2010) 50 Cal.4th 315, 336.) We liberally construe
the evidence in support of the party opposing summary judgment
and resolve doubts concerning the evidence in their favor. (Lyle

5
v. Warner Brothers Television Productions (2006) 38 Cal.4th 264,
274.)
Triable issue of fact
We conclude the facts upon which Orcutt relies do not
establish that Vice had any involvement in writing or sending the
cards, participated in doing so, acted in concert, or even had
knowledge of the conduct.
Vice testified at his deposition that he did not know who
wrote or sent the cards. His declarations stated he was not
involved in sending the cards or “causing [their] existence.” His
“declarations may well be self-serving, ‘but where (as here) [they
are] uncontradicted, case law establishes that such a showing can
provide the basis for summary judgment.’ ” (Trujillo v. First
American Registry, Inc. (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 628, 636.)
Orcutt contends the trial court erred in considering Vice’s
supplemental declaration, which was filed with his reply to
Orcutt’s opposition to summary judgment. The declaration
responded to the theories raised for the first time in Orcutt’s
opposition to summary judgment that Vice could have provided
materials for the letters, contributed ideas or encouragement, or
mailed them. Orcutt has forfeited this issue because he did not
object to Vice’s supplemental declaration in the trial court. (Evid.
Code, § 353, subd. (a); Guastello v. AIG Specialty Ins. Co. (2021)
61 Cal.App.5th 97, 105.)2
Forfeiture aside, the trial court did not abuse its discretion
by considering the supplemental declaration. “[T]he trial court’s

2 Orcutt objected to a separate declaration of Vice’s
attorney. The trial court declined to rule on the objections
because that evidence “was immaterial to the Court’s disposition
of this motion. (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd. (q).)”

6
consideration of additional reply ‘evidence is not an abuse of
discretion so long as the party opposing the motion for summary
judgment has notice and an opportunity to respond to the new
material.’ ” (Jacobs v. Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage Co.
(2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 438, 449.) Orcutt did not ask the court to
continue the hearing to respond to the supplemental declaration.
Moreover, in light of Vice’s deposition testimony that he did not
know who drafted, wrote, created, or sent the cards, his
supplemental declaration did not provide “entirely new evidence,”
but “only filled gaps in the evidence” created by Orcutt’s
opposition. (Jay v. Mahaffey (2013) 218 Cal.App.4th 1522, 1537-
1538 [anti-SLAPP motion].)
Mitchell’s expert opinion eliminated Vice as the author.
“When the moving party produces a competent expert declaration
showing there is no triable issue of fact on an essential element of
the opposing party’s claims, the opposing party’s burden is to
produce a competent expert declaration to the contrary.” (Bozzi
v. Nordstrom, Inc. (2010) 186 Cal.App.4th 755, 761-762.)
Notably, Stewart’s declaration did not conclude that Vice was the
author. His criticism of Mitchell’s method, and his disagreement
with the certainty of her conclusion, are not evidence of the
contrary proposition, i.e., that Vice was the author.
Orcutt argues that the author of the cards was familiar
with the neighborhood, Vice had a motive because he was upset
that Orcutt complained about his roommate’s dog, and the return
address on the cards (“Cavalier Neighbors”) was similar to the
fictitious organization Orcutt used in his complaints about the
dog (“Cavalier Lane Homeowners Association”). In our view,
none of these theories would support a jury verdict that Vice,
rather than one of his roommates or another neighbor, had any

7
involvement in writing or sending the cards.
A party opposing summary judgment “may rely upon
inferences, but ‘those inferences must be reasonably deducible
from the evidence, and not such as are derived from speculation,
conjecture, imagination, or guesswork.’ ” (Santa Clara Valley
Water Dist. v. Century Indemnity Co. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 1016,
1035.) As in Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co., supra, 25 Cal.4th
at page 864, evidence that the defendant “may have possessed
the motive, opportunity, and means to enter into an unlawful
conspiracy . . . is not enough. . . . Speculation . . . is not evidence.”
Orcutt’s speculation that Vice was somehow responsible for
sending the cards is “insufficient to create a dispute of fact.”
(Joseph E. Di Loreto, Inc. v. O’Neill (1991) 1 Cal.App.4th 149,
161.)
Because Orcutt did not present evidence that would allow a
reasonable jury to find that Vice participated in the writing or
“issuance” of the cards, the trial court properly granted summary
judgment. (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd. (p)(2); Aguilar v.
Atlantic Richfield Co., supra, 25 Cal.4th at p. 845.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Vice shall recover costs on
appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

BALTODANO, J.

We concur:

GILBERT, P. J. YEGAN, J.

8
Craig B. van Rooyen, Judge

Superior Court County of San Luis Obispo

______________________________

Decker Law, James D. Decker, Griffin R. Schindler and
Christopher M. Jones for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Hall Hieatt Connely & Bowen, Catherine Hall Devlin and
Jay A. Hieatt for Defendant and Respondent.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.