In re Dy.B. CA2/2

CourtListener 10358150Calctapp19 de mar. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/19/25 In re Dy.B. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re DY.B. et al., Persons B334841
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP00133A-B)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

M.B.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County. Julie Fox Blackshaw, Judge. Affirmed.
Law Offices of Arthur J. LaCilento and Arthur J.
LaCilento, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jessica S. Mitchell, Senior Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.

__________________________________________

In this juvenile dependency appeal, M.B. (father)
challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings and
disposition order removing his, at the time, ten-year-old twin
sons, Dy.B. and Da.B. (collectively, the twins), from his custody
and care. Father argues substantial evidence does not support
the jurisdictional findings (of physical abuse, sexual abuse, and
serious emotional abuse) or the removal order. He also argues
the juvenile court violated his due process rights by not allowing
the twins to testify at the adjudication hearing. We find no error
and affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The Family
Father and the twins’ mother, S.B. (mother), married in
2012. After three years of marriage, mother left father because of
alleged verbal and physical abuse. Their divorce was finalized in
2017. Mother and father’s divorce was far from amicable. For
years, they have engaged in a highly contentious and
acrimonious divorce and custody battle. In a May 2018
statement of decision, when the twins were approximately five
years old, the family law court stated, “the parties have had a
contentious relationship with little cooperation. Each blames the
other and each has invoked law enforcement and/or the

2
Department of Children and Family Services on thin pretexts or
based on unwarranted assumptions. The parties should know
that involving law enforcement to cure the parents’ abysmal
communication risks unintended consequences. The parties’
longstanding failure of communication is harming the boys.”
When the underlying proceedings began, the twins were
nine years old. At that time, a family court order granted mother
and father joint legal and joint physical custody of the twins. The
twins stayed with father every second and fourth week of the
month from Thursday to Tuesday. The twins are mother and
father’s only children together. However, mother and father each
have older children. Mother has two adult children, a son E.K.
and a daughter M.L. Father has one older child, a teenaged
daughter named H.B.
Prior to this case and beginning in 2016, there were several
referrals regarding the family to the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (Department). The
referrals include allegations of general neglect, physical abuse,
emotional abuse, and sexual abuse, all related to father. The
allegations were closed as either “unfounded” or “inconclusive.”
Mother also had a previous referral to the Department regarding
alleged physical abuse of her daughter in 2010. That referral was
closed as “unfounded.”
2. Petition
In November 2022, a referral was made to the Department
alleging father sexually abused the twins. That month, mother
filed an incident report with the sheriff’s department stating that
in April 2022, she witnessed Dy.B. “continuously inserting his
finger into his anus” while lying on his bed. When she asked him
why he was doing that, Dy.B. told her “[father] always does that

3
to him.” Da.B. told mother he saw father put his fingers in
Dy.B.’s anus and father tried to do the same to him. Mother told
the officer she took Dy.B. to be examined by their pediatrician the
following day. The doctor did not see signs of trauma to Dy.B.’s
anus. The twins made similar statements to the officer. Da.B.
also said father physically abused him on occasion.1
As stated in its January 2023 detention report, after
investigating the claims of sexual abuse, the Department
reported “the risk level was Moderate and the recommended
decision was not to promote however the referral was promoted
due to the children’s disclosure of sexual abuse.”
In January 2023, the Department filed a multicount
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300 petition on behalf of
the twins (petition).2 The petition stated counts under
subdivisions (a), (b), (d), and (j) of section 300. The petition
alleged father had physically and sexually abused the twins.
Mother was not named in the petition. At the initial hearings on
the petition, the juvenile court detained the twins from father.
The twins remained in mother’s custody and care, and father was
granted monitored visits.
In its March 2023 jurisdiction and disposition report, the
Department reported the twins were “thriving in the home of
mother.” The Department assessed the family “as being at ‘very
high’ risk for future abuse.” In a May 2023 report, the
Department summarized its findings as to the pending

1 It appears no criminal charges have been filed against
father.
2 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

4
allegations. The allegations of general neglect by father were
“substantiated.” The allegations of sexual abuse and physical
abuse by father were both “inconclusive.” The allegations of
general neglect by mother were “inconclusive.”
3. Dy.B.
a. Interviews with Department Social Workers
In November 2022, Dy.B. told a Department social worker
he had already spoken with the courts and the police. Dy.B. said
he was “very suspicious of his father,” who he believed “trie[d] to
act ‘big nice’ so that the [twins would] forget all the negative
things that he has done and report good things for him in court.”
Dy.B. did not trust father because, according to Dy.B., father was
“very sneaky,” “very creepy,” “very manipulative and he is a
mastermind at trying to get things together to fit his way.”
Dy.B. also said father was “gross because he has been
putting two fingers” (his index and middle fingers) in Dy.B.’s
anus. Dy.B. explained father made Dy.B. remove his underwear
and pants and lie down on the bed. Then father “inserts his two
fingers in his butt and will tell [Dy.B.] that he was trying to get
his poop out.” Dy.B. reported father had been doing this for
several years, with the last time being a few months earlier.
Dy.B. said when he told father to stop, father would “make an
excuse or tell [Dy.B.] to be quiet.” Dy.B. believed father did the
same thing to Da.B.
Dy.B. also revealed father used belts and his hands to whip
him “on his butt and other areas of his body.” Dy.B. said father
hit his arm, leaving marks or bruises. Dy.B. also said father
“spies on him” through an open door while Dy.B. is showering
and changing clothes. Dy.B. told the social worker he was not
afraid of father, but was not comfortable with him at times.

5
Dy.B. was more comfortable with mother and did not want to
visit with father.
In February 2023, Dy.B. spoke again with a Department
social worker. Dy.B. told the social worker he was comfortable in
mother’s home. He denied being coached by anyone. Dy.B.
reiterated that father had hit and punched him. He showed the
social worker a scar on his arm that he said happened because
father hit him. Dy.B. told the social worker he was scared of
father and did not want to live with him. The social worker
reported Dy.B. spontaneously and without any cues stated, “ ‘I
don’t understand why people don’t believe what we are saying. I
don’t want to see my dad because he raped me!’ ” and then
lowered his head. Dy.B. also said father hit Da.B. During her
February 2023 interview with Dy.B., the social worker declined
to ask him about father’s alleged sexual abuse.
In June 2023, Dy.B. spoke again with a Department social
worker. He said he did not want to visit father “ ‘because he
raped me.’ ” He was scared father would hurt him and said he
had difficulty falling asleep after visits with father. Dy.B. stated
he was “open” with his therapist, who was helping him cope.
b. Forensic Interview
In early December 2022, soon after the referral to the
Department, Dy.B. sat for a forensic interview, which was video
recorded. Toward the start of the interview, when the
interviewer first asked Dy.B. to tell her “everything about your
parents,” Dy.B. responded with a sigh, leaned his head back, and
asked for a break. He told the interviewer, “I always hate telling
that part” and “It sounds like weird telling other people.” Later
during the interview, Dy.B. made a “grimacing face” and felt
“disgusted” talking about what father did to him. Dy.B. said,

6
“When it comes to talking like family stuff, I never show my
emotions.” He said “talking to somebody about it. It’s just so
weird.” About mid-way through his forensic interview, Dy.B.
asked if he could take a break.
Dy.B. told the interviewer he thought his dad was “gay”
“because he’s always putting his hand in my butt hole for no
apparent reason.” Dy.B. said father touched his anus “at least 46
times,” “maybe more,” “like 48 times.” Dy.B. could only
remember three specific times father did this to him. Dy.B.
recounted that he “kept count” of the times father did this to him
by drawing a small “random picture” on the wall and floor in a
corner of father’s office where father would not expect to find
Dy.B. Dy.B. explained, however, father repainted that wall and
put in a new floor so Dy.B.’s drawings were no longer there.
Dy.B. said the first time father did this to him, he told
Da.B. to go upstairs. Father then told Dy.B. to take off his shirt,
shoes, pants and underwear. Dy.B. asked why, and father
responded, “ ‘Just do it’ ” or “ ‘You have to’ ” so Dy.B. did. Father
had his clothes on. Father told Dy.B. to lay on the couch facing
down and father “put his finger in [Dy.B.’s] butt hole” and said he
had to “ ‘dig deep’ ” to get “Booboo out [of his] butt.” (Dy.B.
explained “booboo” meant “poop.”) Dy.B. specified father used
two fingers, his index and middle fingers. Dy.B. said Da.B. was
upstairs the first time this happened, but he snuck downstairs
the second time. Dy.B. was reluctant to describe how it felt when
father did this, but he noted it was “[v]ery weird” and “just as
bad” as when your arm is hit with a belt. Dy.B. said his “butt
hole” felt “[m]ushy” or “nasty, like weird” after father did this to
him.

7
Dy.B. described the most recent time father touched him.
Dy.B. said he was eight years old at the time and was laying on
his bed praying. Father was sitting next to him.3 Dy.B. knew
father was going to try to touch his anus again because of the
way father held his two fingers. Both he and father had clothes
on, but father’s fingers still touched Dy.B.’s “butt hole,” hurting
him. Dy.B. said, “[I]f you have clothes [the fingers] go in and out.
If you don’t have clothing go in and then out.” Dy.B. mentioned
another incident when he was dressing after a bath and father
watched him and “smiled super creepy.” Dy.B. told the
interviewer that, other than his fingers, father did not use any
other part of his body to touch Dy.B., and father never asked
Dy.B. to do anything to father’s body. Dy.B. said father was
“nifty, shady, and sketchy,” which meant “you can’t trust him.”
Dy.B. told the interviewer father touched Da.B. in the same
way, but only one time, and Da.B. had his clothes on. Dy.B. said
father tried to do it a second time to Da.B. but Da.B. jumped off
the bed and looked at father “like he was crazy.” That was the
last time father tried to do it to Da.B. According to Dy.B., Da.B.
said father had gone to anger management. Dy.B. said he tells
Da.B. everything and he told him what father did to him.
Dy.B. said that, prior to the forensic interview, mother told
him to “ ‘tell the truth,’ ” “ ‘[d]on’t lie, don’t be scared. Just tell

3 The video recordings of the twins’ forensic interviews
have been lost and are not included in the record on appeal.
Thus, we are unable to view the video recording to understand
some of Dy.B.’s descriptions of, for example, how he and father
were positioned during the incidents discussed during the
interview. The juvenile court, however, was able to and did view
the recordings.

8
the truth.’ ” Dy.B. also told the interviewer that mother said
father is “a very mean man,” “selfish man,” and “a weird bad
man.” Dy.B. told mother what father did to him because “I felt
like I could trust her more than my dad.” After he told mother,
he said mother texted “the court or something” and she made a
face like “Eww” and “Nasty.” He felt relieved after telling mother
because he “didn’t have to like keep the truth anymore.” When
asked what father says about mother, Dy.B. said father “pretends
to be nice all the time.”
c. Forensic Medical Exam
In December 2022, Dy.B. also underwent a forensic medical
exam. During his exam, Dy.B. disclosed father “ ‘put 2 fingers in
my butthole’ ” and “ ‘whoops me with a shoe, hand or belt.’ ” The
results for the exam were “within normal limits. A
normal/nonspecific examination does not rule out the possibility
of child sexual abuse.”
4. Da.B.
a. Interviews with Department Social Workers.
In November 2022, Da.B. spoke with a Department social
worker. Da.B. told the social worker “ ‘father is straight up
mean.’ ” He said, “on occasion” father “whipped him with his
hands and with different objects such as his belt.” Da.B. said
father had hit or punched his butt, his back, and his eye,
resulting in a black eye. The last time father “ ‘beat [him] up
bad’ ” was four or five years earlier.
Da.B. also told the social worker that “for years,” father has
stuck “his two fingers in his brother Dy.B.’s anus and tells him
that he’s getting the poop out.” Da.B. explained that when father
was going to do this to Dy.B., father told Da.B. to go downstairs
but Da.B. “ends up spying on him to see what he is doing.” Da.B.

9
said father tried to do the same thing to him one time. When
that happened, Da.B. jumped away quickly and father “tried to
joke it off.” Da.B. also said father watched “them play in the
bedroom and just will stand by the door and look oddly at them,”
making Da.B. “very uncomfortable.”
Da.B. told the social worker father used to be an alcoholic.
Da.B. explained he knew this “because he is very smart, he
remembers things.” The social worker noted both Da.B. and
Dy.B. “spoke in a matter of fact tone and provided information
and details freely.”
In February 2023, Da.B. again spoke with a Department
social worker. Da.B. told the social worker he was comfortable in
mother’s home. He denied being coached by anyone. Da.B.
reiterated that father had hit and punched him. He said he used
to cry about it, “ ‘but now I feel pissed off. I actually got used to
him hitting me.’ ” He said father also hit and punched Dy.B. but
he did not remember how many times it happened. He said
mother reported the allegations of physical abuse, “ ‘but nothing
happened.’ ” Da.B. told the social worker he did not want to visit
or see father. He believed father was “ ‘weird because of the
things he used to do to us.’ ” During her February 2023 interview
with Da.B., the social worker declined to ask him about father’s
alleged sexual abuse.
In June 2023, Da.B. spoke again with a Department social
worker. He said he did not miss father and was scared when he
saw father. He felt people did not believe him because “ ‘we are
still being asked to visit’ ” father. Da.B. said he could not sleep
after he saw father’s face.

10
b. Forensic Interview
Like Dy.B., Da.B. sat for a videorecorded forensic interview
in early December 2022.4 Da.B. told the interviewer father
“stuck his fingers up my butt hole.” Da.B. described one time
father did this, it “felt like a mosquito bit my butt.” Da.B.
explained father “pinched” him on his bottom under his clothes.
Another time, when he was six years old, Da.B. believed father
tried to stick his fingers in Da.B.’s anus, but Da.B. questioned
him and moved. Da.B. denied father touched him with any other
body parts or asked Da.B. to touch father’s body.
Da.B. also described seeing father do the same to Dy.B.
Da.B. explained, “Four times Dad told me to go upstairs. The
first two times I went upstairs. The third time I stayed
downstairs. I watched him tell Dy.B. to lay down. He pulled
down his pants, pulled down his underwear and stuck his fingers
up his butt hole.” Dy.B. heard father tell Da.B. he was “ ‘just
getting booboo out of your butt.’ ” Although Da.B. was not sure
how many times he saw father do this to Dy.B., Da.B. said he saw
father do it two or three times. He recalled one time it happened
on the couch, another time it was father’s bed, and he seemed to
remember another time when it happened in Dy.B.’s bed. He
described how father held his fingers and how Dy.B. and father
were positioned. At one point, Da.B. stated father was using his
fingers “like a knife stabbing somebody like this, except it went in
the butt hole” and “he did it like slow, like super slowly.”

4 As noted in footnote 3 above, we are unable to view the
video recording of Da.B.’s forensic interview and, therefore, it is
difficult to understand some of Da.B.’s descriptions.

11
Da.B. wondered whether father raped Dy.B. Da.B.
explained he understood rape to mean when “you inappropriately
touch someone besides their will and they don’t like it.” Da.B.
told the interviewer he knew “some things that I should not
know,” saying, “I know some people” and “TV.” Later he said he
learned what rape was through television shows and “some
people talking about it.”
Da.B. stated he was five, seven, eight and nine years old
when he saw these things happen to Dy.B. Da.B. did not see
father touch anyone else in these ways. Da.B. told the
interviewer he did not say anything about what father had done
to him “at first” because he “didn’t want to think it was that.”
After he saw father do it to Dy.B., however, Da.B. believed father
“must have did that to me. Oh, crap.” He said he told mother
about it because he was afraid and did not want to go back to his
father’s home. He said he and Dy.B. “cried multiple times” “when
we had to go back over there.” A few times Da.B. mentioned
being scared of father. He also said father spied on them, but it
was not clear exactly what he meant by that.
After Da.B. told mother what father had done, mother said
father was “ ‘weird’ ” and “ ‘super whacked.’ ” According to Da.B.,
mother said when she and father were married, father “ ‘was
always mean to me’ ” and he never bought them food. Da.B. also
explained mother said when she “ ‘tried to leave [father] he
fractured [mother’s] leg’ ” then father lied about it, saying mother
“ ‘fell down the stairs.’ ” Da.B. said mother told him father “went
to anger management for 12 years.” Da.B. explained that mother
told him to be honest for the forensic interview. She said, “ ‘I
need you to be honest again. I’m so proud of you for being honest.
I need you to be honest again.’ ”

12
c. Forensic Medical Exam
In December 2022, Da.B. also underwent a forensic medical
exam. During his exam, Da.B. disclosed father’s “ ‘fingers went
to my buttcrack’ ” and father “ ‘pops me and hits me with a shoe,
hand, or belt.’ ” The results for the exam were “within normal
limits today. A normal/nonspecific exam does not exclude the
possibility of child sexual abuse or negate the child’s disclosure.”
5. Mother
In November 2022, mother reported the twins told her
father had “been physical with them, they have had marks and
bruises and [father] has been fingering them in their anus over
the past few months.” Mother said she had been raising these
issues for years in family court. Mother believed the family court
was “on father’s side.” According to mother, the family court
believed she was “making up the stories to get full custody” and
“told her on multiple occasions that no one should bring up false
information again or the other parent will be granted full
custody.” Mother denied coaching the twins, telling them to lie,
or trying to keep them away from father. She said that, because
of “the ongoing issues over the past few years,” Dy.B. “has been
acting out, emulating negative behavior and got suspended from
school.” Mother said she took the twins to their pediatrician for
an exam, which “revealed that there was no evidence.”
Mother told the Department social worker there had been
“severe domestic violence” between her and father in the past.
She said father was a “recovering alcoholic” and had been
hospitalized twice for “psychiatric reasons.”
In February 2023, mother spoke again with a Department
social worker. Mother denied coaching the twins. She said they
“are also telling the truth and are upset that they are not

13
believed.” Mother reiterated what the twins said about father’s
physical and sexual abuse. She said there had been years of
abuse, she repeatedly reported it to law enforcement and the
family law court, but nothing was done. Mother stated she found
Dy.B. putting his finger in his anus at her home one year earlier.
When she asked him what he was doing, he said father did that
to him while saying he was getting “the boo boo out.” She said
Da.B. was “very aggressive and wants to fight when he gets
mad.” She said Dy.B. was “more aggressive now” and cried
because he did not think anyone believed him.
In a June 2023 email to a Department social worker,
mother said father had mental health issues and was a
pedophile. She said she was being “victimized” and no one was
holding father accountable. She said Dy.B. recently woke her up
in the middle of the night, said he was scared, and got into her
bed. She also said Da.B. recently had “peed in the bed” and “on
himself AGAIN today and had a meltdown.” She reported the
twins were “struggling” and “scared.”
Later that same month, mother spoke with a Department
social worker. She denied coaching or emotionally abusing the
twins. She stated “they are triggered” when they speak with
father. She said, “No parent wants their children to go through
anything like this. I am not perfect. I have asked the children
about their visits but that is not coaching. . . . I am just trying to
protect my kids.”
In June 2023, mother completed a “high conflict
divorcing/separating families” on-line course. Mother also was
participating in individual therapy.
Department social workers also spoke with maternal family
members and one of mother’s friends. The twins’ half brother

14
E.K. said the twins never told him father abused them. However,
he stated father “gave him ‘weird vibes.’ ” A maternal great aunt
said the twins “ ‘are very articulate and smart.’ ” She did not
believe mother coached them and said mother “ ‘always tells her
children to tell the truth.’ ” She believed Dy.B. was aggressive at
times “ ‘because of what happened to him.’ ” She said father was
not nice to and did not help mother when they were married.
Maternal great aunt believed there was “ ‘something wrong
with’ ” father. Mother’s friend L.C., who had known mother since
they were 13 years old, said mother was not coaching the twins.
Ms. C. had never seen marks or bruises on the twins.
6. Father
In November 2022, a Department social worker spoke with
father. Father denied physically or sexually abusing the twins.
Father believed mother was coaching the twins in order to get
more custodial time. He also denied any history of domestic
violence, substance abuse, or mental health issues. In a follow up
email, father again denied harming the twins. He wrote, “My
kids have done nothing wrong. They said these things because
they were forced to. I would bet my life that with every fiber of
my being.” A few weeks later, father spoke again with the social
worker. He believed mother was using and coercing the twins in
a plot to defraud “him out of thousands of dollars.” In February
2023, on advice of his counsel, father declined to be further
interviewed by the Department.
By the end of February 2023, father had completed a
parenting program focused on, among other things, conflict
resolution and anger management. He was also participating in
individual therapy. As of November 2023, however, father had
not participated in “counseling for perpetrators.” Father

15
explained he had not been charged with anything and, therefore,
was “ ‘putting that off for as long as I can.’ ” Previously, in late
2021, father completed an anger and high-conflict behavioral skill
training program.
Department social workers also spoke with two of father’s
friends. K.W., a retired police officer and current private
investigator, said she had seen father interact with the twins
many times and she had no concerns. She did not believe father
would hurt his children. She believed mother manipulated the
twins, and the allegations against father were lies. She said
there was “ ‘[a]bsolutely zero chance’ ” father abused the twins
and “ ‘a lot of lives are being destroyed.’ ” She told the social
worker father disciplined the twins by talking to them, giving
them a time out, or a book to read. She said father “ ‘is a man
who would do anything for his children.’ ”
Dr. D.W. said father “ ‘adores his children,’ ” “ ‘would not do
anything to hurt his children,’ ” and did not believe in corporal
punishment. She believed mother “ ‘made up’ ” the allegations
against father not only “ ‘to get funds and to get full custody’ ” of
the twins but also “ ‘to destroy’ ” father. According to Dr. W.,
father was “ ‘devastated’ ” when he read the allegations against
him. She said the twins “ ‘adore their father,’ ” were “ ‘not scared
of their father,’ ” and did not “ ‘look sad.’ ” She questioned
mother’s mental health and believed mother needed therapy.
Father’s mother declined to speak with a Department social
worker, but she wrote an email stating, “ ‘My son is innocent and
I am declining to make any statement and I am requesting not to
have any further contact from your agency.’ ”

16
7. Karen Nakamatsu
Karen Nakamatsu is a family court services specialist. In
that role, she performs child custody evaluations and mediations
for the Los Angeles County Family Court. In November 2022, in
connection with mother and father’s family court proceedings,
Ms. Nakamatsu was assigned to conduct a child custody
evaluation, or a parenting plan assessment, during which the
twins disclosed father put his fingers in Dy.B.’s anus and tried to
do the same to Da.B. As a mandated reporter, Ms. Nakamatsu
made a referral to the Department.
In connection with the parenting plan assessment, Ms.
Nakamatsu testified in family court, as is customary. She
testified mother and father were unable to cooperate with each
other, making things, including school and after school activities,
difficult for the twins. She noted mother and father had “ever-
present problems” “that have historically and continue to
negatively impact these boys.”
She spoke with the twins, individually and jointly. She
explained to them that nothing they told her would be
confidential. Despite that, the twins “answered every question
without hesitation, and did not mind.” She said the twins were
“not at all shy about sharing their feelings and their thoughts.”
The twins told her father used “two of his fingers to penetrate the
anus of Dy.B.” in order to get something out. Da.B. acted out an
incident for Ms. Nakamatsu where father tried to do the same to
him. Da.B. also told her he secretly watched when father did this
to Dy.B. According to Ms. Nakamatsu, it was unclear when
father last did this. She understood the twins to say it had not
happened “for at least the last several months to a year.”

17
Although the twins repeatedly told Ms. Nakamatsu they
loved father, they also said they were afraid of him, believed he
watched them dress and undress, and described him as
“ ‘creepy.’ ” They became angry when talking about father and
said he lied to them. Ms. Nakamatsu stated the twins told her
they can be “ ‘sneaky,’ ” meaning they “spy on their parents
sometimes” and listen to what mother and father say to other
people. Ms. Nakamatsu believed the twins heard mother and
father speak to others about their various legal proceedings. The
twins told Ms. Nakamatsu they “can always tell when their
parents are about to go to court again” because father is “ ‘fake
nice’ to them.” She also explained the twins were very curious
and told her they asked mother questions. For example, they
said they asked mother about her relationship with father, and,
according to the twins, mother responded, “ ‘When you’re older,
we’ll talk about it.’ ”
Ms. Nakamatsu did not know whether the twins had been
coached. However, she indicated they were consistent in what
they told her, stating, “All I can say to you is that these boys
repeatedly stated it in different ways individually, together, and
this is what they believe.” She recommended a forensic interview
and full Evidence Code section 730 evaluation.
In November 2022, a Department social worker spoke with
Ms. Nakamatsu. Ms. Nakamatsu recounted the allegations the
twins had made against father, stating the twins “are adamant
about the allegations.” She told the social worker there was not
sufficient evidence to take away father’s visits permanently. She
noted father was seeking sole physical and legal custody of the
twins.

18
8. Therapists
a. Valai Smith (individual therapist for the twins)
In January 2023, the twins began seeing Valai Smith for
individual therapy. Ms. Smith was not a licensed therapist. She
was working as a clinical therapist and was supervised by a
licensed therapist. She had a master’s degree in social work.5
Ms. Smith reported, “As a result of their initial
assessments, the boys have been diagnosed with Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder, and Dy.B. with the additional diagnosis of
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.” She treated each twin
separately “in their own 50-minute sessions” followed by a
conjoint 5-10 minute session with mother “solely to instruct her
on how she can best assist and support [the twins] with their
learned techniques.”
In June 2023, Ms. Smith reported, “concerns remain that
these youth have been traumatized.” During individual sessions
at the mention of father’s name, the twins had “anger outbursts,”
shut down in silence, and cried. She said the twins have “pleaded
to be exempted from” visits with father because they feared
“reoccurring events.” She noted the twins acted out at home and
at school, including “fighting, vulgar language, intense and
noticeable mood swings, and bedwetting, all indicative of abuse.”

5 At a July 2023, hearing, father’s counsel raised the issue
that Ms. Smith was not a licensed therapist and it was unknown
how she was selected or whether she was working with the twins
toward reunifying with father. The court was “not too troubled”
by the fact Ms. Smith was not licensed as long as she was
supervised by a licensed therapist. The court ordered the
Department to ensure Ms. Smith “has all of the reports from this
case, including the forensic interviews,” and “all the information
that is relevant.”

19
Ms. Smith did not believe the twins were coached. She said,
“[W]hat is being reported by them presents genuine,” consistent,
and “without coaching.” The twins had made clear to her that
they wanted “to be believed by the adults involved with their
cases.”
Ms. Smith also reported the twins had “made considerable
progress except for their lack of desire to engage with” father.
According to Ms. Smith, “[c]ontinuing any form of visit with their
father would be detrimental to the mental health of the boys due
to prolonged exposure to the alleged perpetrator.” She believed
the twins should continue with individual therapy but cautioned
conjoint sessions with father could retraumatize them and cause
regression in their improved behaviors. Ms. Smith opined the
twins had “been exposed to traumatic events.” She noted the
twins “respond with high regard for their mother as their source
of love, attention, security, and safety.”
A couple of months later, in August 2023, Ms. Smith
reported Dy.B. had made “moderate progress” toward his
treatment goals and “exhibited noticeable improvement,” while
Da.B. had made “average progress” toward his treatment goals
and “exhibited moderate improvement.” In a December 2023
report, Ms. Smith stated the twins were doing well in therapy.
Dy.B. exhibited “some improvement” and Da.B. had made
“noticeable improvement.”
b. Scott Barella (conjoint therapist for the twins
and father)
Between August and December 2023, the twins and father
attended 10 remote conjoint therapy sessions with therapist Scott
Barella. Mr. Barella reported the twins did not want to speak
with father, called father disparaging names, often disconnected

20
from the conjoint sessions, and rejected items father sent to them
and offers to attend events with him. Mr. Barella stated the
twins “resented [father] for his abuse and lack of honesty about
it, and did not want to be on these sessions with him.” In one
session, Dy.B. cried because “he was worried he was ‘in trouble’
for speaking to [father].” In another session, the twins stated
father “ ‘raped’ them with his fingers in their anus area multiple
times. Dy.B. said it occurred ‘over 30 times’ and Da.B. said ‘2–5
times.’ The boys were assertive and did not cry when recalling
these details.” Mr. Barella noted the twins’ “demeanor became
aggressive, defiant, and irritated” when father joined the conjoint
sessions. Mr. Barella reported father had maintained his
innocence and expressed frustration with the twins’ “lack of
respect for the process and [for] him.”
The Department provided all case reports as well as the
transcripts and video recordings of the twins’ forensic interviews
to Mr. Barella, which he reviewed.
c. Chevonna Gaylor (individual therapist for
father)
Father began individual therapy sessions with Chevonna
Gaylor in July 2023. As of December 2023, father had met with
Ms. Gaylor eight times. She stated father’s treatment remained
“in the preliminary stage” and “highly recommended that [he]
continue individual therapy services to support his ongoing
processing of underlying emotions associated with current life
stressors, enhance skill building and build emotional intelligence/
resilience.”
9. Pediatrician Dr. David Berman
Dr. David Berman had been the twins’ pediatrician since
they were infants. In a November 2022 letter, he stated he

21
reviewed the twins’ files from 2021 and found no documentation
of sexual abuse. He said he did “not recall any allegation of
sexual abuse.”
10. Father’s Experts
a. Dr. Hy Malinek
Dr. Hy Malinek is a clinical and forensic psychologist with
more than 35 years of clinical experience. He holds a doctoral
degree in Clinical Psychology. Dr. Malinek presented a
psychosexual evaluation and risk assessment of father. In
particular, Dr. Malinek assessed father’s “mental state, proclivity
to engage in sexually inappropriate behavior,” “sexual
dangerousness,” “whether he suffers from sexual deviation and
whether he poses a danger to [the twins].” Dr. Malinek
interviewed and tested father for five hours at his office and
reviewed relevant documents from the underlying proceedings,
including the video recordings of the twins’ forensic interviews.
In his final report, Dr. Malinek stated, “[o]verall,” the
results of father’s psychological testing “did not reveal any
evidence of significant psychopathology.” Dr. Malinek did “not
believe that [father] can be diagnosed with pedophilic disorder.”
Dr. Malinek opined “that the risk [father] currently poses to his
sons is low.” According to Dr. Malinek, father did “not impress
me and does not test as inherently antisocial, psychopathic or
criminally oriented.” Dr. Malinek noted, although father “tends
to be defensive and lacks insight,” he “did not reveal any evidence
of noteworthy psychopathy.” Father’s measurements of “sexual
dangerousness” were “uniformly low” and did “not designate him
as sexually dangerous.” In his report, Dr. Malinek noted the
“allegations in this case have emerged in the context of a highly

22
contentious divorce” and there were “prior concerns about the
reliability of the mother’s [previous] reports.”
b. Dr. Bradley D. McAuliff
Dr. Bradley D. McAuliff is a Professor of Psychology at
California State University, Northridge, with a doctorate in
psychology and a law degree. He has “studied children’s memory
and suggestibility for more than 25 years.” He prepared a report
addressing, among other things, “the presence of factors in this
case known to increase suggestibility.” In his report, Dr.
McAuliff expressed “serious concerns about the accuracy of [the
twins’] allegations of inappropriate touching against their
father.” Based on his expertise and after reviewing relevant
documentation in the underlying proceedings, he stated he found
several “factors known to increase suggestibility,” which “likely
decreased the accuracy of Dy.B. and Da.B.’s reports.” He noted it
is more common to see parents coaching or influencing children
to falsely accuse an innocent person in cases such as this that
involve “child custody or access disputes.”
11. Visits
Early in the underlying proceedings, father was restricted
to monitored visits with the twins. From December 2022 through
mid-March 2023, a professional visitation monitor, Michael
Valdovinos, monitored visits between the twins and father. Mr.
Valdovinos stated they had five successful visits, during which he
said the twins “appeared to have fun and enjoy being with their
father.” In January 2023, however, he noted the twins refused to
visit with father twice. Mr. Valdovinos noted mother accused
him of not doing his job and had been “a little aggressive” in
emails she sent to him. For example, in December 2022, mother
did not agree with, and questioned the twins about, a portion of

23
his visitation report. Mother had many complaints about Mr.
Valdovinos and said he lied.
Throughout the underlying proceedings, there were reports
of the twins either resisting or refusing to attend visits with
father. Sometimes father disputed that the twins did not want to
visit him, stating either there were no visits scheduled at certain
times, mother was alienating the twins from him and not
encouraging them to visit, and the Department was disregarding
the court’s visitation orders.
In mid-March 2023, father had a medical procedure and
could not visit with the twins for some time. In early April 2023,
mother reported father had monitored visits over Zoom with the
twins three times a week. One virtual visit began with Dy.B.
stating, “ ‘Why should I face time with someone who raped me?’ ”
and then crying. That visit lasted six minutes. During another
virtual visit, the twins again “brought up the trauma,” and father
ended the visit after ten minutes. After those visits, the
Department recommended father’s visits be in a therapeutic
setting.
April through December 2023, father had one visit with the
twins. Despite the Department’s consistent efforts and mother
making the twins available, the twins continued to refuse to visit
with father. A Department social worker reported the twins
became angry and often cried when it was time to visit father.
On one occasion, the twins “experienced an emotional
breakdown” after declining to attend a visit. The Department
listed close to 30 attempted but unsuccessful visits. The twins
attended one in-person visit in mid-June 2023 (father’s day), but
only because their half sister H.B. was there and they wanted to
see her. By all accounts, that visit went well. This was the

24
twins’ last in-person visit with father. At a mid-July 2023
hearing, the juvenile court was disappointed the twins had not
been visiting father and conjoint counseling had not begun.
12. Amended Petition
In June 2023, the Department filed and the juvenile court
accepted an amended petition, which, in addition to the original
counts, alleged two counts under subdivision (c) of section 300
(amended petition). The two new counts alleged the twins
suffered serious emotional and behavioral issues because of
mother and father’s highly acrimonious relationship and
contentious divorce and custody dispute.
13. Order Declaring Twins Unavailable to Testify
On June 21, 2023, the juvenile court addressed the twins’
motion asking the court to declare the twins unavailable and
excluding them from testifying or being subject to examination by
counsel. Counsel for the twins argued the twins’ testimony would
not have a material effect on the jurisdictional issues before the
court and requiring them to testify would cause psychological
trauma. Counsel recognized “the [twins’] statements are relevant
and go[ ] to the heart of this case,” but nonetheless stated “the
court has ample material from which it can assess the [twins’]
credibility” and “[f]orcing the [twins] to testify would be
traumatic.” Counsel noted “there is a marked difference between
being interviewed in a closed setting by an expert who’s trained
to interview minors versus being interviewed by an adverse
party.”
In the alternative, if the juvenile court required the twins’
testimony, counsel requested the twins be allowed to testify in
chambers. In support of the motion, counsel included the twins’
therapist Ms. Smith’s opinion on the twins’ ability to testify. Ms.

25
Smith noted the twins were “emotionally anchored to their
parents, which could potentially pose as a challenge in
testifying.” In her opinion, the twins could be “negatively
impacted emotionally and psychologically should they be required
to testify against their father.”
Counsel for father opposed the motion. Counsel stated
there were no signs of trauma and there was no expert testimony
that the twins would suffer substantial trauma if required to
testify. Father’s attorney noted the video recordings of the twins’
forensic interviews show the twins “laughing,” “smiling,”
“giggling,” and “freely volunteering information.” In any event,
counsel argued safeguards, such as having the twins testify in
chambers, were available. Moreover, counsel argued, it was
father’s due process right to cross-examine the twins, who had
provided the only evidence that father had sexually abused them.
Counsel emphasized the twins had been coached, their claims
were false, and “the only way we can elicit it” is through their
cross-examination.
Counsel for the Department submitted the matter to the
court, but noted “Originally,” she “was planning on calling the
children so that the court can assess the[ir] veracity.”
The juvenile court granted the motion. The court
acknowledged father’s concerns, but ultimately found “on
balance, the children will be traumatized by this confrontation by
the father” and that it would not “materially affect the court’s
ability to decide this case.” The court noted it not only had the
twins’ statements from interviews and but also had “looked at the
videotaped forensic interview.” Pointing to letters from the twins’
therapist Ms. Smith, the forensic interview videotapes, and the
twins’ consistent refusal to visit with father, the court stated, “[I]t

26
is uncontroverted that these children are suffering trauma
already, even before they are being asked to testify.” The court
concluded the twins’ in-court testimony was not “necessary for
the court to decide their credibility in this case.”
14. Court-appointed Expert, Dr. Nancy Kaser-Boyd
On July 17, 2023, the juvenile court appointed clinical and
forensic psychologist Dr. Nancy Kaser-Boyd to conduct an
Evidence Code section 730 psychological evaluation of mother,
father, Dy.B., and Da.B. (730 evaluation). The court ordered Dr.
Kaser-Boyd “to determine” the “Mental health” of mother, father,
and the twins, and to provide her assessment of the “likelihood
that Father will successfully reunify with the [twins]” and what
“programs or services would be beneficial for Father to reunify
with the [twins].”
Importantly, the juvenile court restricted the use of the 730
evaluation. Preceding the court’s order appointing Dr. Kaser-
Boyd, the court and counsel had several discussions on and off
the record regarding the scope and purpose of the 730 evaluation.
At one hearing, the juvenile court held “an extensive off-the-
record conference on the 730 evaluation,” after which the court
stated for the record, “As I said earlier, the court will not be
reading the 730 evaluation until after the adjudication hearing
but will use it for disposition.” At a January 2024 hearing, long
after Dr. Kaser-Boyd had submitted her 730 evaluation but
before disposition, the court reminded the parties that neither
counsel for mother nor for father wanted the court to consider the
730 evaluation for purposes of adjudication. The court reiterated
it would consider the 730 evaluation for purposes of disposition
only.

27
Dr. Kaser-Boyd submitted her final report in October 2023.
The adjudication hearing had begun two months earlier (as
discussed below). Dr. Kaser-Boyd explained she individually
interviewed mother, father, Dy.B., and Da.B. She viewed the
videotapes of twins’ forensic interviews, read father’s experts’
reports, and spoke with conjoint therapist Mr. Barella as well as
with the twins’ adult half sister M.L. She did not interview the
twins “about the various allegations” because she believed they
had been interviewed “too much” and she “was able to read the
things they said in the past.”
Dr. Kaser-Boyd tested Dy.B. and Da.B. to determine
whether either of the twins had symptoms that normally result
from sexual and physical abuse. She reported neither Da.B. nor
Dy.B. tested “elevated on” Posttraumatic Stress Disorder,
Anxiety Disorder, or Sexual Concerns. Dr. Kaser-Boyd found it
significant that the medical examination results for the twins
“were negative for anal penetration” and that neither of the twins
tested “positive for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder or Anxiety
Disorder.” She stated, “This is completely inconsistent with the
level of abuse that they are reporting” and “boys who are anally
assaulted often have very significant psychological disturbances.”
Dr. Kaser-Boyd concluded the twins had learned from
others about family events they could not have otherwise known
about. She believed the twins “likely acquired [this information]
from their mother or their older siblings.” Dr. Kaser-Boyd noted
she could not “ ‘say that Mother purposefully has biased the
minors against their father’ ” but it was “clear that the twins
have been privy to, overheard, or heard many things about their
father, perhaps also from their older siblings, that contribute to
their current negative feelings.” She did not believe mother

28
understood “the negative impact this creates for her children.”
She suggested that the juvenile court “explain to Mother that she
has a role in helping her twins modulate their emotions, that she
cannot discuss any of this in front of them, and that they have
been harmed by their exposure to the history she has allowed
them to hear.”
Dr. Kaser-Boyd was particularly concerned not only with
the twins’ belief that father might kidnap or kill them but also
their clearly stated hatred for father. She believed the twins
“need to be in therapy with a more trained person, such as a
person with a Ph.D. who has experience with children who have
become completely alienated from the other parent.” She
“strongly recommend[ed]” that the Department find a therapist
for the twins who is “clearly qualified to deal with alienated
children.”
15. Adjudication and Disposition
In June and July 2023 reports, the Department noted the
twins “have continued to be consistent with their disclosures of
physical and sexual abuse by father.” In another report, the
Department listed multiple examples, reaching back to early in
the parents’ divorce proceedings, of mother and father’s inability
to cooperate and failure to abide by court rulings not to discuss
the other parent or court proceedings with the twins. The
Department believed the twins “have continued to be exposed to
the parental conflict and have been made aware of court issues,
which is detrimental to the children’s emotional wellbeing.”
a. Testimony
The adjudication hearing began on August 29, 2023, and
continued for several days over the course of many months,
concluding in January 2024. On the first day, father’s expert Dr.

29
McAuliff and the twins’ therapist Ms. Smith both testified. Dr.
McAuliff explained his areas of expertise were “children’s
suggestibility and forensic interviewing” and the court found him
qualified as an expert in those areas. Dr. McAuliff stated he was
asked to “talk about the scientific literature on children’s memory
and suggestibility.” He reiterated what he previously had
presented in his expert report. He said he was “not here to tell
the judge this child was or was not abused. But what I can say is
that there are several factors that we know increased
suggestibility and decreased accuracy.” Dr. McAuliff believed the
forensic interviews of the twins were “[f]or the most part” “done
well.” He was not concerned with the forensic interview but was
focused on “the issues that happened before that good forensic
interview.”
When asked if it was his opinion that mother influenced
the twins, either intentionally or unintentionally, to make false
sexual abuse allegations against father, Dr. McAuliff responded,
“It is.” He testified, “[T]here was either coaching or suggestibility
[by mother] in the sense that it is possible that mom was
concerned about what she saw” when she found Dy.B. on her bed
at home touching his anus. He believed mother “influenced the
reporting of Dy.B. And Dy.B. influenced the reporting of his
brother as well.”
Ms. Smith testified she had been seeing the twins for
individual therapy since January 2023. She reiterated what she
had written in her reports for the court. She explained she had
diagnosed the twins with posttraumatic stress disorder and Dy.B.
with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, although she did
“run it by” her supervising therapist.

30
Ms. Smith explained how the twins described and talked
about father’s alleged abuse. She testified when Da.B. spoke of
father’s abuse, he balled his fists, his body was a little stiff, and
sometimes he sat in the corner of the couch and cried. He asked
“does he have to repeat this.” She also testified Dy.B. reacted
similarly when describing what happened to him. Dy.B. “balled
his fists,” “cried,” and once abruptly “walked out” of the session.
Their descriptions of the alleged abuse were similar to the
descriptions they had given to others. Ms. Smith believed the
twins “were forthcoming” with her.
On the second day of the adjudication hearing, held in
September 2023, family court services specialist Ms. Nakamatsu
and professional visitation monitor Mr. Valdovinos testified. Ms.
Nakamatsu reiterated what she previously had testified to in
family court and reported to the Department. She indicated the
twins were “not comfortable with” father and said he was “mean.”
The twins had told her father was “creepy” when he looked at
them and they did not feel like they had privacy at father’s home.
She testified that when the twins told her what father had done
to them, “they were a little angry,” “clearly upset about it,” and
“[o]ther times relieved.” She noted the twins “wanted to know if I
was going to listen to them” and “believe them when they spoke
about their concerns regarding their dad.” When she said she
would, “they began individually and also conjointly [telling] the
same story about [w]hat they had been experiencing.” Based on
her discussions with the twins, she did not believe they had been
coached. She testified that Dy.B. had been kicked out of an
elementary school because he got into a physical altercation with
another student. Da.B. told her Dy.B. sometimes got very angry
and acted out when frustrated.

31
Ms. Nakamatsu testified to the “constant acrimony
between” mother and father. She said they had “no ability, at
least at this point, to co-parent these children.”
Mr. Valdovinos reiterated what he previously had reported
to the court. He testified the visits he monitored between the
twins and father went well and the twins appeared comfortable
with father. The last visit he monitored was in March 2023.
The third and fourth days of the adjudication hearing were
held in November 2023. On these days, the twins’ pediatrician
Dr. Berman, father’s friends Dr. W. and L.S., Department social
workers Hiliana Lopez and Beverly Tomlinson-German, and
conjoint counselor Mr. Barella all testified. The court also
received stipulated testimony from the twins’ half sister H.B.
The twins’ pediatrician Dr. Berman reiterated what he had
reported to the Department previously. Dr. Berman further
testified that, in 2016 when the twins were almost three years
old, mother reported “she found [Dy.B.] putting his finger in his
butt.” As a result, Dr. Berman testified he examined Dy.B.
carefully, noting Dy.B. had a history of constipation. Dr. Berman
testified the exam was normal. Dr. Berman stated mother did
not say on that occasion father was inserting his finger in Dy.B.’s
anus.
Dr. Berman explained that, at the twins’ annual exam in
December 2022, mother mentioned allegations of sexual abuse by
father had been made and reported to law enforcement and the
Department. As a result, Dr. Berman performed external anal
exams for both Dy.B. and Da.B. Dr. Berman testified the exams
were normal and he saw no signs of abuse. Dr. Berman stated he
was a mandated reporter but he did not make reports in
December 2022 because mother had said reports already were

32
made. Dr. Berman testified he had never “examined or seen
abuse regarding anal penetration on a minor child.”
Dr. W. testified she attempted to monitor two visits
between father and the twins. Those visits did not take place
because the twins did not want to attend. She testified father
was a loving, focused, and patient parent. She denied having
safety concerns regarding father parenting his children.
L.S. testified she had been friends with father for
approximately 40 years. She believed father was a “great father.”
She denied any safety concerns regarding father parenting his
children. Ms. S. monitored one visit and attempted to monitor 12
visits between father and the twins. She said the successful visit
took place on father’s day 2023 and “went great.” Ms. S. said half
sister H.B. was present for the pick up at the sheriff’s station
that day and the twins “were extremely happy to see her.” Ms. S.
testified she asked the twins if they wanted to leave the station to
spend time with father and H.B. Initially, the twins said no.
Ms. S. testified the twins ultimately had lunch with father and
H.B., then bought anime cards. Since that father’s day visit,
however, Ms. S. explained the twins adamantly refused to visit
with father.
Hiliana Lopez is a Department investigator and social
worker. She testified she was assigned to this case in early 2023
and authored some of the Department reports filed with the
juvenile court. She testified she did not discuss the sexual abuse
allegations with the twins during a February 2023 interview
because they “were already interviewed by a forensic interviewer
about that.” She denied that she or the Department had any
concerns about mother coaching the twins.

33
Counsel for father asked Ms. Lopez about the Department’s
findings that the current referrals for both sexual abuse and
physical abuse were “inconclusive.” Ms. Lopez stated, “I
consulted with the E.R. staff that completed those investigations
and those were their findings, and I reported their findings.” She
testified the “I.D.C. staff” informed her “that they don’t typically
file any counts against a parent when the finding in E.R. is
inconclusive.” She did not know if that was a Department
“policy.” Although she testified it was not her expertise, she
explained her understanding of the difference between
“inconclusive” and “unfounded” allegations. She stated an
“inconclusive allegation is when you don’t have enough evidence
to go either way” and an “unfounded [allegation] is when there’s
no evidence for anything.”
Beverly Tomlinson-German is a Department social worker.
She testified she had been assigned to this case for approximately
six months. She explained how she encouraged the twins to visit
with father: “By attempting to transport them every Friday to
the visit. Taking them aside and talking to them by myself,
inquiring why they don’t want to visit. Encouraging the mother
to make sure she has the children ready for the weekend visits.
Also, conducting facetime visits with them.” She also monitored
some facetime visits with the twins and father. She testified the
twins did not want to talk and sometimes would hang up or walk
away. She testified further that she tried every Friday to pick
the twins up from their school for visits with father, but they
always refused to go with her. She explained she would sit with
them in the school office and try to encourage them to attend the
visits. She said sometimes the twins cried, asked “when this was
going to be over,” called father names, or were angry with her for

34
being there. They asked her “several times, ‘Why should I visit
someone who has raped me.’ ” Ms. Tomlinson-German cried
while testifying about her attempts to encourage the twins to
visit and their responses to her efforts. She believed a pause in
their visitation schedule with father would be in their best
interest.
Mr. Barella reiterated what he had already reported. In
addition, he testified the twins spoke of father’s physical and
sexual abuse many times during their conjoint counseling
sessions. He said Da.B. spoke “matter-of-factly, as if he was
reporting a regular story. He was not overly emotional. He was
describing it as if it was bothersome but not traumatic.” Mr.
Barella noted Dy.B., however, “had much more emotion. He was
more intense with his description and had more emotional
reaction to the questions.” Mr. Barella described the twins as
“almost angry” and “condescending” when discussing the sexual
abuse claims. He testified Dy.B. had “some kind of anxiety
associated with his relationship with his father.” Dy.B. was
“nervous,” “emotional,” and “angry.” Da.B. on the other hand,
Mr. Barella testified, was “very angry. He’s not anxious. He’s
just angry.”
When asked whether there were signs mother coached the
twins to say certain things about father, Mr. Barella responded,
“The boys are very clear about their perspective about their
father. They speak freely and consistently, and they don’t
reference their mother.” He testified, “In general, [the twins] feel
[father is] a rapist, and he’s an angry man that has not treated
them well in the past, and that they’re fearful of him.” He said

35
the twins described the inappropriate touching as “insertion of
finger in” “their anus area.”6
In a filed declaration, half sister H.B. said that, until
recently, she had a close bond with the twins. She described
times, as recently as June 2023, when she, twins, and father were
together and everyone enjoyed themselves and appeared
comfortable with one another. Beginning in July 2023, however,
half sister explained twins did not “want to say hi to me or even
hug me,” which shocked and hurt her. She said “[t]hey were not
themselves” and had changed. Half sister also stated she had
never seen father hit, curse at, or inappropriately touch twins;
and they never told her father had done any of those things to
them. She said father had never beaten or inappropriately
touched her.
The fifth day of the adjudication hearing was held January
11, 2024. Mother testified. Mother recounted the claims the
twins had made about father abusing them. She stated she did
not coach the twins or tell them to make up stories. She said she
did not talk about father or the case in her home “[b]ecause the
boys get really frazzled when they hear [father’s name], they get
upset.” She said she first heard about father’s alleged sexual
abuse of the twins one or two years earlier. She had no

6 At the end of the November 2023 hearing dates, after
hearing Ms. Tomlinson-German’s and Mr. Barella’s testimony
and discussing visitation with counsel, the juvenile court ordered
a “cooling off” period during which the twins would not be
required to have weekly visits with father. Instead, they would
visit with father and his family during the holidays and before
the next adjudication hearing date. However, conjoint counseling
would continue.

36
recollection of either her 2016 declaration filed in family court, in
which she alleged father had sexually abused Dy.B. in the same
way she most recently alleged, or her 2018 declaration also filed
in family court similarly alleging father had sexually abused the
twins. She testified she took the twins one time to Dr. Berman to
be examined for sexual abuse. According to mother, Dr. Berman
“stated with a naked eye, he could not tell if there were any signs
of sexual abuse. There needed to be a different type of exam.”
Mother testified the twins asked a lot of questions, for
example, “why doesn’t anyone believe them,” and “do they have to
go back with [father]?” Mother said she often told the twins to
speak with their therapist or others involved in the case. She
explained that, after their conjoint therapy calls with Mr. Barella
and father, “it’s a nightmare for us in the home, because the boys
are crying. They’re yelling. Sometimes Dy.B. gets in a corner,
and he has meltdowns. He has shaking spells, almost like
seizures.” Mother indicated these episodes sometimes prompted
conversations about father, but normally “they never talk about
him.” She told the twins, “I love them,” “I believe them, and I’m
sorry that happened to them.”
b. Argument
On January 17, 2024, the juvenile court held the final day
of the adjudication hearing and the disposition hearing. Counsel
for father asked the court to dismiss the allegations as to father.
Counsel argued “the only evidence against the father is from the
children, which is fueled by the mother. And the mother has
unfortunately in this case, weaponized these children and has
used them as her ammunition and the prize . . . is to gain sole
custody.” Counsel argued “evidence of coaching is clear and all
over the record,” including instances of the twins saying or

37
knowing things they should not know and repeating the same
things to their therapist, conjoint therapist, social worker, law
enforcement, and forensic interviewer. Counsel also pointed to
Dr. McAuliff’s testimony supporting the presence of coaching, Dr.
Malinek’s opinion “that there is no pedophilia inclination,” the
lack of any medical records supporting physical or sexual abuse,
the lack of criminal charges against father, the Department’s
finding the allegations against father were inconclusive, and the
lack of a clear timeline detailing when the alleged abuse took
place.
Counsel for mother, on the other hand, argued the evidence
supported findings that father physically and sexually abused the
twins. Although counsel acknowledged the twins could have
overheard mother or father disparaging the other since the
parents had “been litigating this for ten years,” counsel insisted
there was “zero” evidence that mother coached or told the twins
what to say. Mother’s counsel also acknowledged “there is a lot of
acrimony” between the parents. However, he did not believe the
Department had shown the required nexus between the acrimony
and the emotional distress suffered by the twins. He encouraged
the court to consider in the interests of justice dismissing one of
the subdivision (c) emotional abuse counts.
Counsel for the twins urged the court to sustain the
amended petition in its entirety. Counsel dismissed father’s
concerns about coaching. She stated not only that the twins were
consistent, detailed, and never recanted, but also that neither
Ms. Nakamatsu nor Ms. Smith were concerned about coaching.
Counsel argued the twins were credible. She noted the animosity
between the parents had “been going on for most of these boys’
lives.”

38
Finally, counsel for the Department also urged the court to
sustain the amended petition in its entirety. Counsel did not
believe the evidence supported father’s theory that mother
coached the twins. He believed the twins were, overall,
consistent with their claims of abuse. He also noted the twins
“are very perceptive” and “have been harmed and are continuing
to be harmed by the acrimony between the mother and father.”
c. Findings and Orders
After hearing argument, the juvenile court sustained the
amended petition as alleged. The court declared the twins
dependents of the court under subdivisions (a), (b), (c), (d), and (j)
of section 300.
As to the physical abuse allegations, the court based its
findings on “the boys’ repeated and credible statements about
father’s physical abuse, their anger against father, and the fact
that they exhibit symptoms of trauma.”
As to the sexual abuse allegations, the court found the
twins’ statements of sexual abuse “credible and persuasive.” The
court had viewed the videotaped forensic interviews and noted,
“[e]ach child described the events in their own words using
different vocabulary, but the events they described were the
same.” The court found this created “an inference of credibility,”
which in turn “underlies the court’s conclusion that the boys were
not likely coached by their mother.” The court found “father’s
coaching accusation to be unfounded.” Although the court found
“a few of Dy.B.’s statements seemed a bit farfetched,” such as his
statement that father anally penetrated him 48 times but he only
remembered three instances well, this was not determinative.
The court also noted the twins had been consistent in their
statements throughout the case, Ms. Smith believed the twins’

39
allegations were true, the twins both exhibited trauma, and they
adamantly refused to visit with father since June 2023. The
court found father’s experts unpersuasive. Dr. McAuliff did not
address the fact that the twins each submitted to a forensic
interview, which did not involve suggestive questioning. Dr.
Malinek did not opine father posed no risk to the twins and he
did not conclude their sexual abuse allegations were untrue.
As to the emotional abuse counts, the juvenile court found
“the parents’ lengthy and continuing acrimony with each other
has detrimentally impacted their sons physically and emotionally
causing severe emotional turmoil, anxiety, acting out, anger,
P.T.S.D., and bedwetting. The children continue to suffer anxiety
and trauma today.” The court found mother failed to protect the
twins from the acrimony between her and father, stating that by
allowing the twins “to overhear conversations with damaging
information about their father is not protective of the children’s
emotional health.” Thus, although the court rejected father’s
coaching theory, the court found mother “exploited the children’s
anger at their father to further alienate them.” Father also had
attempted to alienate the twins from mother.
As to disposition, the juvenile court removed the twins from
father and placed them in mother’s custody and care under
Department supervision. The court ordered father to participate
in parenting and co-parenting classes, sexual abuse counseling,
anger management, and individual counseling. The court
ordered mother to attend parenting and co-parenting classes, sex
abuse awareness counseling, and individual counseling. Father’s
counsel objected to the twins’ continued removal from him.
After discussing the matter with counsel and
acknowledging Dr. Kaser-Boyd’s recommendation that the twins

40
see a therapist with more expertise than Ms. Smith, especially in
the area of children alienated from a parent, the court ordered
the twins to continue their individual counseling with Ms. Smith.
Counsel for father argued for “a more qualified” therapist to
assist the twins. Counsel for the Department, mother, and the
children were all amendable to maintaining the twins’ current
relationship with Ms. Smith, since they had formed a bond with
her and switching therapists would be detrimental to them. The
court did not believe it was prudent to change the twins’
therapist, stating “it does appear that they have a relationship
with Ms. Smith. They are beginning to expose themselves and be
vulnerable with her.” The court, however, ordered the twins’
attorney to consult with Ms. Smith to ensure certain topics were
addressed in therapy. The court also ordered the twins to
continue conjoint counseling with father and continued the
visitation “ ‘cooling off’ period” it previously had ordered, stating
it would address visitation at the next hearing.
16. Appeal and Postappeal Events
Father appealed the juvenile court’s January 17, 2024,
findings and orders.
While the instant appeal was pending, the juvenile court
terminated jurisdiction and issued a custody order granting
mother sole physical and legal custody of the twins.7 Father
appealed those and related orders, which appeal is pending
before this Court (B340713).

7 On February 28, 2025, we granted the Department’s
request for judicial notice of these and related juvenile court
orders.

41
DISCUSSION
1. Dependency Jurisdiction
It is not clear from father’s briefing which jurisdictional
findings he challenges on appeal. At times, he seems to challenge
all jurisdictional findings as to him; other times, he seems to
focus only on the sexual abuse findings against him. We assume
he challenges all of the jurisdictional findings pertaining to him.
Nonetheless, as did the Department in its respondent’s brief, we
address only the sexual abuse allegations. “ ‘When a dependency
petition alleges multiple grounds for its assertion that a minor
comes within the dependency court’s jurisdiction, a reviewing
court can affirm the juvenile court’s finding of jurisdiction over
the minor if any one of the statutory bases for jurisdiction that
are enumerated in the petition is supported by substantial
evidence. In such a case, the reviewing court need not consider
whether any or all of the other alleged statutory grounds for
jurisdiction are supported by the evidence.’ ” (In re I.J. (2013) 56
Cal.4th 766, 773.)8
a. Applicable Law
Under subdivision (d) of section 300, the juvenile court may
assert dependency jurisdiction over a child when “[t]he child has

8 As the Department appears to allude to in a footnote,
dependency jurisdiction would remain regardless of our opinion
here because mother did not appeal the sustained allegations as
to her. Nonetheless, we consider the merits of father’s appeal
because the court’s jurisdictional findings continue to adversely
affect him. If we were to reverse the jurisdictional findings as to
father, the juvenile court’s disposition orders, including its
removal order (also on appeal here), and ultimate custody order
would be called into question. (See In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th
266, 276–277.)

42
been sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child
will be sexually abused, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the
Penal Code, by the child’s parent or guardian or a member of the
child’s household, or the parent or guardian has failed to
adequately protect the child from sexual abuse when the parent
or guardian knew or reasonably should have known that the
child was in danger of sexual abuse.” (§ 300, subd. (d).)
Penal Code section 11165.1 defines sexual abuse to include,
among other things, “[i]ntrusion by one person into the . . . anal
opening of another person” and “[t]he intentional touching of the
genitals or intimate parts, including the breasts, genital area,
groin, inner thighs, and buttocks, or the clothing covering them,
of a child . . . for purposes of sexual arousal or gratification,
except that it does not include acts which may reasonably be
construed to be normal caretaker responsibilities; interactions
with, or demonstrations of affection for, the child; or acts
performed for a valid medical purpose.” (Pen. Code, § 11165.1,
subds. (b)(3)–(4).)
“[S]ection 300 does not require that a child actually be
abused or neglected before the juvenile court can assume
jurisdiction.” (In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) “The
legislatively declared purpose of these provisions ‘is to provide
maximum safety and protection for children who are currently
being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being
neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection,
and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk
of that harm.’ (§ 300.2, italics added.) ‘The court need not wait
until a child is seriously abused or injured to assume jurisdiction
and take the steps necessary to protect the child.’ ” (In re I.J.,
supra, at p. 773.) “ ‘The purpose of dependency proceedings is to

43
prevent risk, not ignore it.’ ” (Jonathan L. v. Superior Court
(2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1074, 1104.)
b. Standard of Review
We review the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings for
substantial evidence. (In re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.)
“ ‘In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting the jurisdictional findings and disposition, we
determine if substantial evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted,
supports them. “In making this determination, we draw all
reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the findings
and orders of the dependency court; we review the record in the
light most favorable to the court’s determinations; and we note
that issues of fact and credibility are the province of the trial
court.” [Citation.] “We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise
independent judgment, but merely determine if there are
sufficient facts to support the findings of the trial court.” ’ ”
(Ibid.) In determining whether substantial evidence exists such
that a reasonable trier of fact could find the order challenged on
appeal is appropriate, we review the entire record in the light
most favorable to the challenged order. (Ibid.)
“Substantial evidence is evidence that is ‘reasonable,
credible, and of solid value’; such that a reasonable trier of fact
could make such findings.” (In re Sheila B. (1993) 19 Cal.App.4th
187, 199.) Substantial evidence “ ‘is not synonymous with any
evidence. [Citations.] A decision supported by a mere scintilla of
evidence need not be affirmed on appeal.’ ” (In re Yolanda L.
(2017) 7 Cal.App.5th 987, 992.)

44
c. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s jurisdictional findings under
subdivision (d).
Father purports to make five points to support his
argument that substantial evidence does not support the juvenile
court’s jurisdictional findings. We boil his arguments down to
two—the twins were not credible and past allegations of similar
conduct were unfounded or inconclusive—neither of which
supports reversal here.
Based on the entire record, including but not limited to
videotaped forensic interviews, interviews with social workers,
and sessions with therapists, the juvenile court found the twins’
statements of sexual abuse “credible and persuasive.” The court
also found the twins “were not likely coached by their mother.”
The court noted the obvious trauma the twins exhibited
throughout the underlying proceedings and, starting in June
2023, their consistent and adamant refusal to visit with father.
The twins repeatedly stated they were scared of father.
Inconsistent and unusual statements were not determinative for
the court. The court had before it the previous allegations and
referrals of physical and sexual abuse by father, which also were
not determinative in evaluating the instant allegations. Finally,
the juvenile court stated it was not persuaded by father’s experts.
It is a long-settled principal of appellate practice that the
reviewing court cannot reweigh the evidence, exercise
independent judgment as to the facts, or substitute its credibility
determinations for those of the trial court. (In re I.J., supra, 56
Cal.4th at p. 773.) Issues of fact and credibility are squarely
within the juvenile court’s province. (Ibid.) Here, although the
record contains evidence supporting father’s position, the record

45
also undeniably contains evidence contrary to father’s position
and supporting the juvenile court’s findings. Thus, despite the
countervailing evidence to which father points, the juvenile
court’s jurisdictional findings of sexual abuse by father are
supported by substantial evidence.
d. Due Process
Father also argues the juvenile court violated his due
process rights because the court did not allow the twins to testify
at the adjudication hearing. Father notes the twins’ credibility
was a central issue below, with his position being mother coached
the twins and their allegations against him were untrue. Father
claims he was prejudiced by not being able to cross-examine the
twins.
“A juvenile court can, consistent with a parent’s due
process rights, refuse to compel the testimony of a child who is
otherwise available when ‘the possible benefit derivable from
[the] testimony would not warrant the [psychological] injury it
would cause.’ (In re Jennifer J. (1992) 8 Cal.App.4th 1080,
[1085–1086] (Jennifer J.).)” (In re Daniela G. (2018) 23
Cal.App.5th 1083, 1086 (Daniela G.).) The juvenile court has
discretion to preclude live testimony from a child witness where
“[(1)] the child’s desires and wishes can be directly presented
without live testimony, [(2)] where the issues to be resolved
would not be materially affected by the child’s testimony, and
[(3)] where it is shown that the child would be psychologically
damaged by being required to testify.” (Jennifer J., supra, 8
Cal.App.4th at p. 1089.) We review a juvenile court’s exclusion of
a child’s testimony for abuse of discretion. (Daniela G., 23
Cal.App.5th at p. 1090.)

46
Here, the juvenile court determined that, “on balance,” the
twins would be traumatized by cross-examination and their
testimony would not “materially affect the court’s ability to
decide this case.” Although, as both the twins’ counsel and the
court recognized, the twins’ statements were central to the case,
the court determined it had sufficient evidence of the twins’
statements that their testimony would not affect its decision on
their credibility. Indeed, the court had ample evidence of the
twins’ statements to consider. For example, the record contained
the video recorded forensic interviews, the twins’ statements
made during interviews with Ms. Nakamatsu and social workers,
as well as statements made to law enforcement and therapists.
As to whether the twins would be traumatized by testifying, the
juvenile court found they would be. The determination regarding
whether testifying would traumatize the twins is a factual
determination that we review for substantial evidence. (Daniela
G., 23 Cal.App.5th at p. 1090.) The twins’ therapist Ms. Smith
opined the twins could be negatively impacted both emotionally
and psychologically if they were required to testify against father.
Additionally, the record reveals numerous times when the twins
became emotional, whether sad or angry, when talking about or
with father. As father points out, the record also includes
evidence showing the twins being unaffected when talking about
him. However, as noted above, we cannot reweigh the evidence
or substitute our judgment for that of the juvenile court. (In re
I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.) We conclude the juvenile court
did not abuse its discretion in refusing to allow the twins to
testify at the adjudication hearing.
In a heading in his briefs on appeal, father states Jennifer
J., supra, 8 Cal.App.4th 1080, and Daniela G., supra, 23

47
Cal.App.5th 1083, are inapplicable here. We disagree. First,
father does not mention, let alone try to distinguish Daniela G. in
the text of his briefs. Second, father’s two-sentence attempt to
distinguish Jennifer J. is unintelligible. In any event, the legal
principles outlined in those two cases are applicable here.
Because we affirm the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
findings as to father under subdivision (d) of section 300, we need
not and do not address the remaining jurisdictional findings. (In
re I.J., supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 773.)
2. Removal
Father also argues the juvenile court erred by removing the
twins from him. To support his position, father simply claims the
juvenile court never should have proceeded to disposition and
again states the twins were not credible. We already rejected
father’s credibility argument and affirmed jurisdictional findings.
Thus, we need not and do not address the removal order.

48
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s January 17, 2024 orders are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

LUI, P. J.
We concur:

ASHMANN-GERST, J.

CHAVEZ, J.

49

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.