People v. Rodriguez CA1/3

CourtListener 10355533Calctapp12 de mar. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/12/24 P. v. Rodriguez CA1/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A170528
v.
CARLOS NEGRETE RODRIGUEZ, (Solano County
Super. Ct. No. VCR220337)
Defendant and Appellant.

In 2016, Carlos Negrete Rodriguez pled no contest to attempted murder
(Pen. Code, §§ 187, subd. (a), 664) and five other felonies, for which he was
sentenced to a total term of 32 years in prison.1
In 2024, Rodriguez petitioned for resentencing under section 1172.6.2
The trial court found Rodriguez failed to make a prima facie showing that he
was eligible for resentencing and denied the petition. On appeal, Rodriguez
argues the trial court erred in finding he was ineligible for relief as a matter
of law. We affirm the trial court’s order but remand to provide Rodriguez the
opportunity to amend his petition.

1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2 Effective June 30, 2022, the Legislature renumbered section 1170.95

to section 1172.6, with no substantive changes in the statute. (Stats. 2022
(2021–2022 Reg. Sess.) ch. 58, § 10.) We cite to section 1172.6 throughout
this opinion for ease of reference.

1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
General Background
In 2014, Rodriguez was involved in a shooting that occurred at a small
party at a house belonging to Elba Montes. After a night of drinking,
Rodriguez got into an argument with those present, left, came back with a
rifle, and fired the rifle at Montes’s face. Among those also present were
Rodriguez’s infant child, the mother of his child, and Lisa Rodriguez (no
relation to appellant).3
Preliminary Hearing Testimony4
The pertinent uncontroverted testimony at the preliminary hearing
was as follows.
Lisa testified the group was drinking beer one night in Montes’s
bedroom until the morning hours. Around 5:00 a.m., Rodriguez got into an
argument with the mother of his child and left the house. He returned 20
minutes later and stood outside a window looking in on the group. He was
angry and yelling about how he wanted his son. After one of the partygoers
told him to go home, Rodriguez again left.
Rodriguez later returned to the same window, this time carrying a rifle.
While still standing outside the window, he said he was not afraid to shoot
and fired a shot into the air (apparently outside the house). Rodriguez then
aimed the rifle at Lisa and Montes, going back and forth between the two of
them. He then fired the rifle while aiming at Montes, hitting her in the
cheek.

3 For ease of comprehension, and intending no disrespect, we refer to

Lisa Rodriguez by her first name.
4 On November 12, 2024, we granted the Attorney General’s unopposed

motion to augment the record on appeal with the preliminary hearing
transcript.

2
Montes’s testimony was consistent with Lisa’s testimony as to the
series of events leading up to the shooting. Montes stated the last thing she
remembered was the rifle being fired at her and then screaming. She had
extensive injuries to her face, requiring numerous surgeries and significant
rehabilitation.
The cross-examination of Lisa and Montes largely sought to establish
that everyone at the party was drinking and there may have been a sharp
object in the room that could have been used to threaten Rodriguez (though
no evidence of any threat was presented). There was no testimony that
anyone other than Rodriguez was the perpetrator and no evidence of any
accomplices.
Charges and Plea Proceedings
In 2015, Rodriguez was charged by second amended information with
one count of attempted willful, deliberate, premeditated murder (§§ 187, 664);
one count of mayhem (§ 203); three counts of assault with a firearm (§ 245,
subd. (a)(2)); and one count of shooting at an inhabited dwelling (§ 246).
As to the attempted murder count, the information alleged Rodriguez
personally and intentionally discharged a firearm (§ 12022.53, subd. (c)),
personally used a firearm (§§ 12022.5, subd. (a)(1), 12022.53, subd. (b)),
personally and intentionally discharged a firearm, which proximately caused
great bodily injury (§ 12022.53, subd. (d)), and personally inflicted great
bodily injury upon the victim (§ 12022.7, subd. (a)).
In 2016, pursuant to a negotiated plea deal, the prosecution struck
from the information that the attempted murder was willful, deliberate, and
premeditated. Rodriguez pled no contest to all counts in the information so
amended. He also admitted two enhancements to the attempted murder
count: (1) that he personally and intentionally discharged a firearm within

3
the meaning of section 12022.53, subdivision (c); and (2) that he personally
inflicted great bodily injury upon the victim within the meaning of
section 12022.7, subdivision (a). The remaining enhancement allegations
were dismissed.
Rodriguez stipulated that the preliminary hearing transcript provided
the factual basis for his plea. The transcript provided the sole factual basis
for the plea.
In April 2016, consistent with the negotiated plea deal, the trial court
sentenced Rodriguez to a total term of 32 years in prison.
Section 1172.6 Proceedings
In January 2024, Rodriguez petitioned in propria persona for
resentencing under section 1172.6. Rodriguez used the Judicial Council
section 1172.6 petition for resentencing form and checked the following boxes:
(1) an information was filed against him that allowed the prosecution to
proceed under a theory of attempted murder under the natural and probable
consequences doctrine; (2) he accepted a plea offer in lieu of a trial at which
he could have been convicted of attempted murder; and (3) he could not
presently be convicted of attempted murder because of changes made to
sections 188 and 189, effective January 1, 2019.
The prosecution filed a response asserting Rodriguez failed to make a
prima facie showing that he was eligible for resentencing under section
1172.6 because he “was convicted as the actual attempted killer who
personally discharged a firearm and personally inflicted great bodily injury
on the victim.” The answer recounted the plea and admissions described
above and noted the evidence at the preliminary hearing established the
factual basis for the plea. Finally, the answer averred the petition should be
denied as “the record of conviction (Information, plea form, and preliminary

4
hearing transcript) conclusively establishes that petitioner was the actual
attempted killer of the victim.”
The trial court appointed counsel to represent Rodriguez. Appointed
counsel did not file any supplement to Rodriguez’s previously filed
resentencing petition or any reply to the answer.
At an April 2024 hearing, the parties stated they were prepared to
submit the matter on the petition and answer without further argument.
The court denied the petition, stating: “At this time the Court has read and
considered the Petition and the Response, and the Court at this time will
deny the Petition outright, and so the Petition is denied. Sentence will
remain as pronounced by the Court, and that will be the order.” The parties
agree the preliminary hearing transcript was not provided to or considered by
the trial court.
Rodriguez appealed.
DISCUSSION
Rodriguez avers the trial court erred by denying his section 1172.6
petition at the prima facie stage as the record of conviction does not
conclusively establish he is ineligible for relief. We review this issue de novo.
(People v. Williams (2022) 86 Cal.App.5th 1244, 1251.)
I. Legal Framework
We begin with an overview of the legal principles applicable to our
analysis.
A. Changes to Homicide Law
Effective January 1, 2019, the Legislature passed Senate Bill No. 1437,
making ameliorative changes to California’s homicide law. (People v. Patton
(Mar. 3, 2025, S279670) __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *2] (Patton).)
“As part of these ameliorative changes, malice . . . may no longer be imputed

5
to a defendant solely because the defendant participated in another crime.”
(Ibid.) As a result, “a defendant is no longer guilty of murder as an aider and
abettor solely because the ‘natural and probable consequences’ of that other
crime included a confederate’s commission of murder.” (Ibid.)
Senate Bill No. 1437 also created a procedure for those convicted of
murder under the former law to seek retroactive relief by filing a petition for
resentencing under section 1172.6. (People v. Strong (2022) 13 Cal.5th 698,
708; § 1172.6.) The Legislature subsequently extended that procedure to
those who were convicted of attempted murder under the natural and
probable consequences doctrine. (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL
666005, at p. *2]; § 1172.6, subd. (a).)
Such persons may seek relief under section 1172.6 when three
conditions apply. (§ 1172.6, subd. (a).) “As relevant here, given the nature of
[Rodriguez’s] prosecution, those enumerated conditions are: First, the
charging document allowed the prosecution to ‘proceed under a theory of . . .
attempted murder under a natural and probable consequences doctrine.’ (Id.,
subd. (a)(1).) Second, petitioner . . . accepted a plea offer in lieu of trial on [an
attempted murder] charge. (Id., subd. (a)(2).) And third, ‘petitioner could not
be presently convicted’ of the charge, given the changes to homicide law
effective in 2019. (Id., subd. (a)(3).)” (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL
666005, at p. *2.])
The statute sets forth a three-step process by which such petitions are
adjudicated. (§ 1172.6, subds. (b)–(d).) First, a petitioner must file a facially
sufficient petition by indicating, among other criteria, that he meets the three
requirements in subdivision (a). (Id., subd. (b).) Second, if a facially
sufficient petition is filed, the parties have an opportunity to submit briefing
before the court holds a hearing to determine if the petitioner has made a

6
prima facie case for relief. (Id., subd. (c).) Third, if the court determines a
prima facie showing has been made, it issues an order to show cause and
holds an evidentiary hearing on “the ultimate question of resentencing at
which the People will bear the burden of defending a conviction under the
amended law.” (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *1];
§ 1172.6, subds. (c), (d).)
B. Prima Facie Inquiry After Patton
At the prima facie stage, a court may look at the record of conviction to
“distinguish petitions with potential merit from those that are clearly
meritless.” (People v. Lewis (2021) 11 Cal.5th 952, 971.) In making this
“limited” inquiry, the court should not engage in factfinding; rather, “ ‘ “the
court takes petitioner’s factual allegations as true and makes a preliminary
assessment regarding whether the petitioner would be entitled to relief if his
or her factual allegations were proved. If so, the court must issue an order to
show cause.” ’ ” (Id. at pp. 971–972.)
In Patton, the California Supreme Court recently provided clarification
on the prima facie inquiry under section 1172.6. (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__
[2025 WL 666005, at pp. *5–*10].) Like Rodriguez, Patton pled no contest to
attempted murder and admitted that he personally and intentionally
discharged a firearm within the meaning of section 12022.53, subdivision (c).
(Id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *2].) Also like Rodriguez, Patton filed a
form section 1172.6 petition and offered no specific facts in support.5 (Id. at
p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *3].) The trial court deemed the petition facially
sufficient and appointed counsel, and the prosecution filed a response

5 Rodriguez included additional pages of argument to his form petition

in support of his challenge to sentencing enhancements; those pages did not
raise any specific facts explaining how he was eligible for relief under section
1172.6.

7
asserting Patton could not make a prima facie case for relief because, based
on facts in the preliminary hearing transcript, he was the sole participant in
the shooting. (Id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *3].) Patton filed no reply
and declined to present any argument at the prima facie hearing. (Id. at
p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at pp. *3–*4].) The trial court denied the petition and
the court of appeal affirmed. (Id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *4].)
Both the trial and appellate courts in Patton relied on uncontroverted
facts in the preliminary hearing transcript showing Patton was convicted as
the sole shooter, acting alone, in determining he was convicted under a
theory of attempted murder that survived changes made to the homicide law,
thereby rendering him ineligible for resentencing. (Patton, supra,
__Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at pp. *4, *6] (citing People v. Delgadillo
(2022) 14 Cal.5th 216, 233 (Delgadillo) [petitioner could not have made a
prima facie showing of relief because he was the “only participant in the
killing” and therefore not convicted under an invalid theory]).)
Noting a divergence of opinions as to whether reliance on a preliminary
hearing transcript at the prima facie stage was proper, the California
Supreme Court ruled: “[A] court, in determining at the prima facie stage
whether a petitioner was convicted under a now-invalid theory, [may] rely on
unchallenged, relief-foreclosing facts within a preliminary hearing transcript
to refute conclusory, checkbox allegations.” (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025
WL 666005, at pp. *4, *6].)
The Court reasoned that “[c]onclusory allegations, such as the checkbox
ones offered here, are particularly subject to refutation by the record of
conviction.” (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *6].)
Requiring nonconclusory allegations merely reflects that a petitioner must
make a prima facie showing to “frame a disputed issue that entitles that

8
petitioner to an evidentiary hearing”; therefore, “a section 1172.6 petitioner
who, despite having access to counsel upon submission of a facially sufficient
petition, offers only conclusory allegations of entitlement to relief, in response
to a record of conviction that demonstrates the petitioner’s conviction was
under a still-valid theory, has not, thereby, made a prima facie showing.” (Id.
at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at pp. *7–*8].)
The Court concluded “there is no dispute that the record of conviction
the parties may consult at the prima facie stage includes a preliminary
hearing transcript preceding a guilty plea.” (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025
WL 666005, at p. *9].) It disapproved of “condition[ing] the use of
preliminary hearing transcripts on whether a petitioner previously admitted
the truth of testimony contained therein or stipulated to the transcript as the
factual basis of a plea.” (Id. at p. __ & fn. 12 [2025 WL 666005, at p. *10 &
fn. 12].)
With this legal framework in mind, we turn to the issue presented in
this case: whether Rodriguez failed to make a prima facie case for relief. For
the reasons discussed below, and based on our independent review of the
record, we conclude he has not made a prima facie showing.
II. Conclusory Allegations in the Petition Fail to Make a Prima Facie
Case for Relief in Response to the Record of Conviction
Rodriguez asserts that the record of conviction does not establish he is
ineligible for resentencing as a matter of law. Specifically, he contends the
charging and plea documents do not show he was the sole perpetrator. He
further asserts the preliminary hearing transcript does not preclude relief as,
even if the transcript may be considered at the prima facie stage—which he
disputes—he did not admit the truth of any testimony therein. Briefing
concluded prior to the issuance of Patton, which forecloses his arguments on

9
appeal. (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at pp. *9–*10]
[preliminary hearing transcripts may be considered at the prima facie stage
even where petitioner does not admit the truth of the testimony therein].)
Although the preliminary hearing transcript was not provided to the
trial court, we exercise our discretion to conduct an independent review of the
record, including the transcript. (Delgadillo, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 233,
fn. 6.)
Undisputed facts in the preliminary hearing transcript show Rodriguez
was the sole perpetrator, acting without any accomplice. No testimony at the
hearing, including on cross-examination, even suggested that anyone other
than Rodriguez was the direct perpetrator of the attempted murder of
Montes. It therefore refutes the conclusory allegations in the resentencing
petition that he was convicted on a now-invalid theory of attempted murder.
(See Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *10] [petitioner fails
to make a prima facie showing based on conclusory allegations in response to
a record of conviction showing he was the sole shooter, acting alone, thereby
foreclosing claim that attempted murder conviction was under a now-invalid
homicide theory]; Delgadillo, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 233 [no prima facie
showing of relief where petitioner was the “only participant in the killing”
and not convicted under an invalid theory].)
Rodriguez had “multiple opportunities to proffer specific facts,”
including in the petition itself, in a substitute or supplemental petition for
resentencing after appointment of counsel, in a reply to the response, and in
arguments at the April 2024 prima facie hearing. (Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__
[2025 WL 666005, at p. *9].) Yet he failed to avail himself of any opportunity
to point to specific facts identifying someone else as the direct perpetrator of
the attempted murder or otherwise creating a dispute as to the basis of his

10
conviction. (See id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at p. *8] [“[A]bsent specific
facts, no . . . dispute [as to the basis of the conviction] arises . . . from mere
latent, speculative possibilities; that is, a hypothetical alternate direct
perpetrator cannot be conjured from thin air or a legal conclusion.”].) Even in
his appellate briefing—including after the preliminary hearing transcript
was made part of the record on appeal—Rodriguez points to no fact refuting
the undisputed testimony in the preliminary hearing transcript showing he
was the direct perpetrator. (See id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at pp. *4, *10]
[appellate court correctly affirmed denial of resentencing petition where
petitioner never suggested facts in trial court or on appeal to demonstrate
someone else shot victim].)
In sum, just like in Patton, as “statements within [Rodriguez’s]
preliminary hearing transcript contributed specific factual assertions about
his conviction—namely, that it was premised on him being the sole
shooter”—his “conclusory checkbox allegations alone could not create a
factual dispute about whether he played a meaningfully different role in the
attempted murder.” (See Patton, supra, __Cal.5th__ [2025 WL 666005, at
p. *9].) Accordingly, on this record, Rodriguez has not made a prima facie
case for relief under section 1172.6. (See id. at p. __ [2025 WL 666005, at
p. *10].)
In light of counsel’s failure to present the trial court with the
preliminary hearing transcript, and in an abundance of caution, we will
remand this matter with directions for the superior court to consider an
amended petition should Rodriguez seek to file one within 30 days of remand.
We express no opinion on the viability of any additional facts Rodriguez may
allege.

11
DISPOSITION
We remand this matter to the trial court with directions to consider an
amended petition should Rodriguez, within 30 days of remand, seek to file
one. We otherwise affirm the order denying Rodriguez’s section 1172.6
resentencing petition.

_________________________
Petrou, J.

WE CONCUR:

_________________________
Tucher, P. J.

_________________________
Fujisaki, J.

A170528/People v. Rodriguez

12

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.