People v. Avery CA4/3

CourtListener 10350692Calctapp5 de mar. de 2025

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 3/5/25 P. v. Avery CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

THE PEOPLE,

Plaintiff and Respondent, G063293

v. (Super. Ct. No. 19CF1922)

DARIOS STEAVEN AVERY, OPINION

Defendant and Appellant.

Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Terry K. Flynn-Peister, Judge. Affirmed.
James R. Bostwick, Jr., under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Eric A.
Swenson, Christine Y. Friedman, and Monique Meyers, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* * *
Darios Steaven Avery appeals from a three-year sentence
following his convictions for pandering and attempted pimping of a minor.
Avery contends the trial court erred in denying his request for an entrapment
instruction. We conclude there was insufficient evidence to support the giving
of an entrapment instruction. Avery also argues there was insufficient
evidence to support his convictions. As discussed below, we conclude
substantial evidence supports the jury’s verdict. Accordingly, we affirm.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On July 16, 2021, the Orange County District Attorney filed an
information against Avery, charging him with (1) human trafficking of a
minor, (2) pandering, and (3) attempted pimping of a minor. A jury found
Avery guilty of pandering and attempted pimping. The trial court sentenced
him to the low term of three years on count 2 (pandering), and imposed and
stayed an 18-month low term on count 3 (attempted pimping of a minor).
Avery appealed.
STATEMENT OF THE FACTS
I.
PROSECUTION CASE-IN-CHIEF
Orange County Police Sergeant Christina Strunk testified that,
in 2019, she was an undercover investigator with the Orange County Human
Trafficking Task Force. As part of her investigative work, Strunk created a
profile on a social network site under the fictitious name of “Jessica Peters.”
The profile included nine photographs of her wearing lingerie and dresses

2
and three photographs of cash. It also stated how much she charged for sex
acts.
On May 23, 2019, Avery, using a profile on the same social
network site, sent “Jessica” a message, saying, “How are you? Can you come
1
home to Daddy?” Jessica responded, “What do you have to offer?” Avery
replied, “‘A place, great guidance, and you know you will be straight. If you
stay down for the crown, you won't need for nothing. Just know you will be
straight 104 percent.’” In response to Avery’s request, Jessica gave him her
cell phone number, and the two began texting. Avery asked Jessica whether
she had a pimp, and she replied by stating she had a pimp and complaining
about her pimp’s rules. Avery subsequently suggested that Jessica begin
working for him.
Strunk testified that Avery’s profile, which had photographs of
himself and a stack of cash, was similar to profiles of other pimps, and his
messages contained pimping vernacular. Sex workers would refer to their
pimps as “Daddy,” and pay for their “guidance.” Pimps will typically refer to
themselves as a king, so “‘stay down for the crown’” meant to be loyal to the
pimp. Finally, his promise of a “place” would be attractive to many sex
workers who tended to live “very transitory” lives.
Jessica eventually asked Avery about his “choose-up fee” or a fee
a sex worker would pay a pimp to start working under him. Avery replied it
was $300. Because Strunk wanted to find out if there were other victims, she
asked Avery if he had any other sex worker working for him. After Avery
responded that a sex worker had been working for him for five years, she

1
For clarity, we refer to Sergeant Strunk as “Jessica” when she
interacts with Avery in that role.

3
ended the conversation by saying she did not think it was going to “work
between me and you.”
A few hours later, a female sent a text message to Jessica on the
social network site, stating her pimp had told her about Jessica and she
wanted Jessica to work with them. The female asked Jessica to give Avery “a
chance,” promising he was not violent. Jessica responded she was interested,
but did not “want to do [Avery] dirty” because she was not 18 years old. The
female replied Jessica “‘should have just told’” Avery her age and reiterated
that Jessica should give him a chance.
Subsequently, Avery sent Jessica a text about her being under 18
years old, telling her she should have been open and honest about her age.
The two then talked on the phone for 13 minutes. During the phone call,
Avery stated he had “a young girl before,” that he had a house, and “since
you’re not 18 years old, we want to stay under the radar.”
Avery asked Jessica exactly how old she was, and she answered
she was turning 17 years old in two months. Avery then asked if anyone had
reported her missing, and she responded, “Nah no one care about me.” Avery
replied, she might “find your family” with him. When Jessica asked for more
details about his rules, Avery explained that the plan was, at night, they
would “go out, get money, [and] in the morning come home, have breakfast,
and kind of hang out as a family.” He reiterated he was not violent. After
Jessica confirmed the $300 choose-up fee, she stated she would begin to save
that amount. Avery told her to stay safe and to let him know if she wanted to
work for him.
The next day, Avery texted Jessica twice. Each time, she
responded she had started saving money for the choose-up fee.

4
On May 26, 29, 30 and 31, Avery texted Jessica to check up on
her. She responded only to the May 30th text, stating she had a “shitty
weekend” and could not converse with Avery at the moment. On July 2,
Avery texted Jessica, asking if she still wanted to work for him. He kept
messaging Jessica, until on July 9, Jessica texted, “I’m coming back to OC.
What do I need to prove to you I’m for real and wanna choose you?” He
responded to let him know and he would pick her up.
On July 10, Jessica called Avery. She asked Avery if he still
wanted her to work for him, and he replied in the affirmative. They decided
Avery would pick up Jessica when she was with a sex buyer, away from her
pimp.
Later that day, Jessica texted Avery that the sex buyer promised
he would pay an additional $300, which would bring the total money she
could give Avery to $650. Later, Jessica texted Avery the name and address
of a motel. After Avery texted Jessica he was “here,” police pulled his vehicle
over and arrested him.
Strunk advised Avery of his Miranda2 rights, and he voluntarily
agreed to speak with her. Avery admitted that he knew Jessica was a minor
and a sex worker, and that he was there to collect money from her.
II.
DEFENSE CASE
A. Kenyetta W’s Testimony
Kenyetta W., the mother of two of Avery’s children, testified she
has known Avery for more than 20 years. She testified he was a good person
and a family man. To her knowledge, Avery was not a pimp.

2
Miranda v. Arizona (1966) 384 U.S. 436.

5
B. Shafora H.’s Testimony
Shafora H. testified that at the time of the incident, she was
living with Avery and had been dating him for six years. During the six-year
period, she periodically worked as a sex worker. Avery was not her pimp or
anyone else’s pimp.
Shafora testified she used Avery’s phone to create his profile on
the social network site. She is bisexual, and was trying to attract girls. She
authored and sent all of the messages to Jessica. When Jessica called,
Shafora would hand the phone to Avery and give him directions. She testified
she was present for all of the calls and never heard anything pimping-related.
As to the meetup at the motel, Shafora testified she did not tell Avery they
were going to pick up Jessica.
Shafora acknowledged she pled guilty to pandering. As part of
her plea, she admitted she committed the crime “with and at the direction of
Co-Defendant Avery.” Shafora testified this phrase was added by her
attorney after she had signed the change of plea form, but acknowledged she
subsequently initialed the plea document.
C. Avery’s Testimony
Avery testified in his own defense. He stated he allowed Shafora
to use his phone, and it was Shafora who created the profile on the social
network site. Avery denied sending any messages to Jessica. He denied being
a pimp, but acknowledged growing up in an area where the sex trade was
prevalent. Avery was aware Jessica said she was 17 years old, but he kept
conversing with her because “she sounded like she was going through
something, and she’s a kid and [he] felt sorry for her.” He also thought she
might be lying about her age because people lie “online all the time.”

6
III.
REBUTTAL
Sergeant Strunk was presented with a hypothetical that
mirrored the facts in this case. She opined that even if the male did not
participate in creating the profile or messaging the minor, the male was
guilty of pimping and pandering because at a minimum, he assisted the
female associate by speaking with the minor on the phone and driving the
female associate to pick up the minor.
DISCUSSION
I.
ENTRAPMENT
During the jury instruction conference, defense counsel requested
an entrapment instruction. The court denied the request, finding no
“evidence of badgering, persuasion, coaxing, [or] any of that from the
undercover operation.” Avery contends the trial court erred because
substantial evidence supported the instruction.
An entrapment instruction was required “if, but only if,
substantial evidence supported the defense.” (People v. Watson (2000) 22
Cal.4th 220, 222 (Watson).) “In California, the test for entrapment focuses on
the police conduct and is objective. Entrapment is established if the law
enforcement conduct is likely to induce a normally law-abiding person to
commit the offense. [Citation.] ‘[S]uch a person would normally resist the
temptation to commit a crime presented by the simple opportunity to act
unlawfully. Official conduct that does no more than offer that opportunity to
the suspect—for example, a decoy program—is therefore permissible; but it is
impermissible for the police or their agents to pressure the suspect by
overbearing conduct such as badgering, cajoling, importuning, or other

7
affirmative acts likely to induce a normally law-abiding person to commit the
crime.’” (Id. at p. 223.) Thus, there are “two guiding principles.” (Ibid.) “‘First,
if the actions of the law enforcement agent would generate in a normally law-
abiding person a motive for the crime other than ordinary criminal intent,
entrapment will be established.’” (Ibid.) “‘Second, affirmative police conduct
that would make commission of the crime unusually attractive to a normally
law-abiding person will likewise constitute entrapment. Such conduct would
include, for example, a guarantee that the act is not illegal or the offense will
go undetected, an offer of exorbitant consideration, or any similar
enticement.’” (Ibid.)
Here, whoever used Avery’s profile to contact Jessica initiated the
conversation by asking her to “come home to Daddy.” When Jessica asked
what the person could offer, the person responded, “‘A place, great guidance,
and you know you will be straight. If you stay down for the crown, you won’t
need for nothing. Just know you will be straight 104 percent.’” Later, after
Jessica texted she was only 17 years old, the person responded Jessica should
have been honest about her age. Avery then spoke with Jessica on the phone
to persuade her to work for him as a sex worker. On this record, there is no
evidence Jessica’s actions “would generate in a normally law-abiding person a
motive for the crime other than ordinary criminal intent.” (Watson, supra, 22
Cal.4th at p. 223.)
Nor is there any evidence of “affirmative police conduct that
would make commission of the crime unusually attractive to a normally law-
abiding person.” (Watson, supra, 22 Cal.4th at p. 223.) Avery notes it was
Strunk who raised the issue of the choose-up fee and who called Avery on
July 10 asking if he was still interested in being her pimp. These acts,
however, occurred after Avery tried to persuade Jessica to work for him as a

8
sex worker. More important, a $300 or $650 choose-up fee would not be so
unusually attractive to a normally law-abiding person that it would cause
him to persuade a minor to work as a sex worker for him.
Finally, it is irrelevant whether Shafora did all of the messaging
and directed Avery’s conduct. Under that version of events, the police conduct
was directed at Shafora, not Avery. Thus, Avery would not have grounds for
asserting the defense of entrapment. In sum, the trial court properly denied
the request for an entrapment instruction.
II.
SUFFICIENCY OF THE EVIDENCE
Avery next contends his convictions for pandering and attempted
pimping of a minor are not supported by substantial evidence. In considering
a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence, our role is limited. “[W]e review
the entire record in the light most favorable to the judgment to determine
whether it contains substantial evidence—that is, evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value—from which a reasonable trier of fact
could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v.
Albillar (2010) 51 Cal.4th 47, 60 (Albillar).) “We presume every fact in
support of the judgment the trier of fact could have reasonably deduced from
the evidence. [Citation.] If the circumstances reasonably justify the trier of
fact’s findings, reversal of the judgment is not warranted simply because the
circumstances might also reasonably be reconciled with a contrary finding.”
(Ibid.) “It is not our function to reweigh the evidence, reappraise the
credibility of witnesses, or resolve factual conflicts, as these are functions
reserved for the trier of fact.” (People v. Tripp (2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 951,
955.) And “[w]e need not be convinced of the defendant’s guilt beyond a
reasonable doubt; we merely ask whether ‘“any rational trier of fact could

9
have found the essential elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.”’”
(Ibid.) “Because we must draw all inferences in support of the judgment, [a]
defendant ‘bears an enormous burden’ when challenging the sufficiency of the
evidence.” (People v. Vasco (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 137, 161.)
A. Pandering
Penal Code section 266i, subdivision (a), provides in relevant
part: “[A] person who does any of the following is guilty of pandering . . . : [¶]
. . . [¶] (2) By promises, threats, violence, or by any device or scheme, causes,
induces, persuades, or encourages another person to become a [sex worker].”
(§ 266i, subd. (a)(2).)3 “[P]andering is a specific intent crime[;] [i]ts
commission requires that a defendant intend[s] to persuade or otherwise
influence the target ‘to become a [sex worker.]’” (People v. Zambia (2011) 51
Cal.4th 965, 980 (Zambia).)
Avery contends “[t]he totality of [Strunk’s] communications with
Avery shows she needed no persuasion or inducement to continue to engage
in prostitution.” Stated differently, Avery argues that because Strunk was
posing as a sex worker, he said or did nothing that would have encouraged
her to “become a [sex worker].” However, encouraging someone to “become a
[sex worker]” under the pandering statute is not limited to causing someone
to become a sex worker for the first time. It also “includes encouragement of
someone who is already an active [sex worker], or undercover police officer.”
(Zambia, supra, 51 Cal.4th at p. 981.) Here, Avery encouraged Jessica to
continue to be a sex worker by offering a “place,” “great guidance” and a
“family.” The evidence was sufficient to support the pandering conviction.
(See, e.g., Zambia at p. 981 [evidence sufficient to support pandering

3
All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.

10
conviction where “defendant offered his services as a pimp by telling her he
would provide her with protection, housing, and clothing if she turned her
earnings over to him”].)
B. Attempted Pimping of a Minor
Avery was convicted of attempted pimping of a minor. “Pimping
of a minor under section 266h, subdivision (b) includes three elements: (1) the
defendant knew the person was a [sex worker]; (2) the defendant derived
support in whole or in part from the money or proceeds the person earned as
a [sex worker]; and (3) the person was under 18 years old. [Citation.] All that
is needed to be convicted of attempted pimping of a minor is ‘a specific intent
to commit the crime, and a direct but ineffectual act done toward its
commission.’ (§ 21a.) ‘The act must go beyond mere preparation, and it must
show that the perpetrator is putting his or her plan into action, but the act
need not be the last proximate or ultimate step toward commission of the
substantive crime.’ [Citation.] “‘[A]cts which indicate a certain, unambiguous
intent to commit that specific crime, and, in themselves, are an immediate
step in the present execution of the criminal design will be sufficient.’””
(People v. Clark (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 270, 287, fn. omitted (Clark).)
Avery argues he could not be convicted of attempted pimping of a
minor because the evidence was insufficient to show (1) he “had the requisite
knowledge and intent” or (2) “his conduct went beyond mere preparation.” We
disagree. Avery’s actions went beyond mere preparation because, besides
repeatedly encouraging Jessica to work for him as sex worker and informing
her about his rules, he drove to the motel to pick up Jessica and the choose-
up fee. (See, e.g., Clark, supra, 43 Cal.App.5th at p. 287 [defendant’s conduct
went beyond “mere preparation” where he “repeatedly told Jessica to come to
Los Angeles to work for him as a [sex worker]”; “negotiated a choose up fee,

11
[and] gave Jessica specific instructions on how to send the money to him”;
“told her she could make $500 per night”; informed her about his plan for her
sex work; and “arranged to meet her and told her how to take a bus to Los
Angeles where he would pick her up”].) Additionally, substantial evidence
supported the jury’s finding that Avery had the specific intent to commit the
crime of pimping a minor. After being advised of his Miranda rights, Avery
admitted he knew Jessica was a minor and a sex worker, and that he drove to
the motel to collect the choose-up fee. Moreover, a reasonable jury could
conclude not only that Avery sent the text messages, but that Avery’s written
and oral communications indicated he wanted Jessica to work for him as a
sex worker and that he was driving to the motel to pick up Jessica so she
could start working for him. Substantial evidence supported the conviction
for attempted pimping of a minor.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

DELANEY, J.

WE CONCUR:

MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.

GOODING, J.

12

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.