CourtListener 10336625•Schrader v. Watts CA2/6
Texto completo
Filed 2/20/25 Schrader v. Watts CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
ERIC SCHRADER, 2d Civ. No. B330648
(Super. Ct. No. 17FL-0248)
Petitioner and Respondent, (San Luis Obispo County)
v.
STEPHANIE WATTS,
Respondent and Appellant.
Stephanie Watts (Mother) appeals an order requiring her to
pay child support to Eric Schrader (Father). She contends the
family court should not have considered cash payments she
received from her parents during the proceedings as “income” for
the purposes of calculating support under Family Code section
4058.1 She also contends the court violated her due process
1 Further unspecified statutory references are to the Family
Code.
rights when it ordered her to pay retroactive support. We will
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Mother and Father began divorce proceedings in San Luis
Obispo County in 2017. Their only child, daughter S.S., was born
in 2015. The family court entered a status-only judgment of
dissolution in 2020.
S.S. initially lived with Mother after the couple separated
but started living full time with Father in August of 2019. A
protracted custody dispute followed, driven by Mother’s
allegations that Father and paternal grandmother had abused
S.S. The family court held a trial on custody and visitation over
17 days from February to June of 2022. It eventually awarded
Father sole legal and physical custody and imposed restrictions
on Mother’s visitation.
Father requested an order modifying his child support
payment shortly after S.S. moved in with him in August of 2019.
The family court did not hold a hearing on his request until
November of 2022—several months after the custody trial
finished, and more than three years after he filed the request. It
ordered Mother to pay temporary support to Father of $450.00 a
month “without prejudice to either party’s claims at the time of
further hearing.”
Trial on permanent support took place over two days in
May of 2023. The parties testified to earning modest incomes:
Father as a union bricklayer, and Mother as a former prison
employee on disability retirement. They described how their
respective families paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in
attorney’s fees to fund their custody litigation. Each described
the payments as loans. Several family members testified that
they expected Mother and Father to repay the loans when they
2
were able. None had written agreements to this effect. The
family court took the matter under submission at the close of
evidence.
The family court issued a tentative statement of decision.
After considering the parties’ objections and it issued a final
statement of decision in July of 2023. The court found the money
given to Father by his family to be loans rather than income for
the purposes of calculating support. It found the opposite true of
the money given to Mother by her family. This resulted in her
income far exceeding Father’s. It set guideline support of
$1,414.00 per month for the period of September 2019 to
December 2019, $924.00 per month in 2020, $1,587.00 per month
for 2021, and $1,400.00 per month for 2022 and 2023. The court
adjusted these figures downward in the interest of fairness under
section 4056 and 4057. It calculated Mother’s net arrears as
$43,680.99 and ordered her to begin repaying Father at $200.00
per month. It set her support payments to Father at $1,000.00
per month going forward.
DISCUSSION
Appealability
Mother appeals the final statement of decision filed in July
of 2023. “The general rule is that a statement or memorandum of
decision is not appealable. [Citations.] The rule’s practical
justification is that courts typically embody their final rulings not
in statements of decision but in orders or judgments. Reviewing
courts have discretion to treat statements of decision as
appealable when they must, as when a statement of decision is
signed and filed and does, in fact, constitute the court’s final
decision on the merits.” (Alan v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.
(2007) 40 Cal.4th 894, 901.)
3
We exercise our discretion to entertain the merits of
Mother’s appeal. The family court incorporated the final
statement of decision into its “Findings and Order after Hearing”
filed on October 23, 2023.2 We construe the appeal as taken from
this order, which resolved the custody and support issues
reserved in the judgment of dissolution entered in August of
2020. (See Champlin/GEI Wind Holdings, LLC v. Avery (2023)
92 Cal.App.5th 218, 223 [appellate court may consider premature
appeal when “judgment [is] actually entered and respondent has
not been misled to its prejudice”].)
Considering Family Loans as Income
For Calculating Child Support
Mother contends the family court erred when it found
payments from her family to be income but considered similar
payments from Father’s family as loans for the purpose of
calculating child support. She highlights the persuasiveness of
her evidence and describes the family court’s decision as flowing
from its “bloodlust against [Mother] for her tenacious attempts to
save the child from further abuse by Father.” “Our review is
limited to determining whether the court’s factual
determinations are supported by substantial evidence and
whether the court acted reasonably in exercising its discretion.”
(In re Marriage of De Guigne (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 1353, 1360.)
“Trial courts must calculate child support in accordance
with the mathematical formula contained in Family Code section
4055.” (In re Marriage of Williamson (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th
1303, 1312.) Loans are not listed among the income sources the
2 We grant Father’s September 16, 2024 request to
augment the record to include the Findings and Order, as well as
the Notice of Entry thereof.
4
court may consider when determining a parent’s gross annual
income for this calculation. (Ibid.; § 4058, subd. (a).) Recurring
gifts of money, however, may constitute income “so long as the
gifts bear a reasonable relationship to the traditional meaning of
income as a recurrent monetary benefit.” (In re Marriage of Alter
(2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 718, 736-737.) “[T]he question of whether
gifts should be considered income for purposes of the child
support calculation is one that must be left to the discretion of
the trial court.” (Id., at p. 737.)
The statement of decision describes Mother as an
“uncooperative, hostile, evasive, inconsistent, difficult witness”
who “evaded answering even the simplest questions posed by
opposing counsel.” It found Mother’s discovery responses and
income and expense statements inconsistent with her testimony.
“Her behavior and inconsistent testimony on the stand,” the court
concluded, “cast a shadow of doubt over all her testimony and
evidence regarding her income for the entirety of the trial.” (See,
e.g., In re Marriage of Calcaterra & Badakhsh (2005) 132
Cal.App.4th 28, 36 [family court properly inferred higher income
to husband based on variances in his tax returns, loan
applications, and income and expense declaration].)
The statement of decision describes Father and his
witnesses as credible and cooperative. It noted Father testified
honestly about earning “under the table” income between union
jobs even though this reflected negatively on him. The court
determined the payments to Father were loans because they were
“in lump sums, paid directly to his attorneys, not given to him
directly for his personal use, and not commingled with his gross
monthly income from employment.” Mother’s payments, in
contrast, were “periodically and regularly” deposited into an
account she shared with her mother. She used the funds “for her
5
own living expenses, attorney’s fees, expert fees, visitation fees,
including the costs of gas, food, drinks, activities, and monitors’
fees for entry into theme parks as well as hotel and lodging when
necessary for court-ordered custodial time” with S.S.
The family court’s findings were based on its weighing of
each party’s evidence about their finances, particularly the
amount, timing, and nature of the payments they received from
their families. We decline to second guess the family law court’s
factual determinations, particularly where, as here, its findings
were based primarily on witness credibility. (In re Marriage of
Winternitz (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 644, 653.)
Retroactive Support
Mother contends the family court violated her due process
rights by awarding Father retroactive child support after the
May 2023 trial. She argues that the minute order from the
court’s initial support hearing on November 10, 2022 does not
specify that it reserved jurisdiction over the issue of retroactive
support. She insists Father should have filed a second
modification request if he sought arrears in addition to future
support. We disagree.
The November 10 minute order cited by Mother is in fact a
short text entry on the register of actions. The “findings and
order” from that date is a more comprehensive record of the
proceedings. They show the trial court ordered Mother to pay
Father temporary support, then continued the hearing. The
court specified the temporary order was “without prejudice to
either party’s claims at the time of further hearing.” Nothing
suggests the court intended to limit either party’s right to seek
retroactive support at trial. (See § 3653, subd. (a), italics added
[“[a]n order modifying or terminating a support order may be
made retroactive to the date of the filing of the notice of motion or
6
order to show cause to modify or terminate, or to any subsequent
date . . .”].)
Further, Mother’s trial brief responded to the merits of
Father’s request for retroactive support. Her counsel did the
same at trial during opening and closing argument. She did not
raise a due process objection to the tentative statement of
decision or otherwise question the family court’s authority to
award retroactive support. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.1590(g).)
No due process violation occurred, and if one did occur, any
objection is waived. (Code Civ. Proc., § 634; see In re Marriage of
Arceneaux (1990) 51 Cal.3d 1130, 1138 [“It is clearly
unproductive to deprive a trial court of the opportunity to correct
such a purported defect by allowing a litigant to raise the claimed
error for the first time on appeal”].)
DISPOSITION
The trial court’s order modifying child support (entered on
October 23, 2023) is affirmed. Respondent shall recover his costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
CODY, J.
We concur:
GILBERT, P. J.
BALTODANO, J.
7
Hon. Erin Childs, Judge
Superior Court County of San Luis Obispo
______________________________
Stephanie Watts, in pro per, for Appellant.
Kirker Wright Law Group, Vanessa Kirker Wright; Law
Office of Renee M. Fairbanks, Renee M. Fairbanks, for
Respondent.
8
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.