CourtListener 10330371•Abrams v. True Bullion CA2/1
Texto completo
Filed 2/10/25 Abrams v. True Bullion CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
CYNTHIA ABRAMS, B335814
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21VECV01020)
v.
TRUE BULLION LLC, et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Valerie Salkin, Judge. Affirmed.
Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith, Corinne C. Bertsche,
Lann G. McIntyre and Rita R. Kanno for Defendants and
Appellants.
Vardapour Law Group and Patrick Vardapour for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
____________________________
This is an appeal from an order denying a motion to compel
arbitration filed by defendants and appellants True Bullion LLC,
Subculture Services LLC, Anthony Allen Anderson, and Agnes
Viacrucis.1 The trial court found that plaintiff and respondent
Cynthia Abrams’s employment-related claims against appellants
do not fall within the scope of her arbitration agreement with
True Bullion. As an alternative ground for denial of the motion,
the court also found appellants waived their right to compel
arbitration.
Appellants fail to show the trial court erred in concluding
that the parties did not agree to arbitrate the instant
controversy. The arbitration clause in question provides: “The
Parties agree that unless specifically provided to the contrary in
this Agreement, any Grievance shall be resolved exclusively by
binding Arbitration.” The contract that contains this clause is a
confidentiality agreement between Abrams and True Bullion that
was executed months after Abrams began working for True
Bullion. The agreement does not purport to govern all aspects of
Abrams’s relationship with appellants, and none of Abrams’s
claims in this case involves her obligations under that contract.
Accordingly, the trial court correctly found that the parties did
not intend to submit all employment-related claims to binding
arbitration. We thus affirm the order denying appellants’ motion
without addressing the alternative ground for the trial court’s
ruling.
1 We refer to True Bullion LLC as “True Bullion,”
Subculture Services LLC as “Subculture,” and all four appellants
collectively as “appellants.”
2
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2
We summarize only those facts pertinent to our resolution
of this appeal.
In August 2021, Abrams filed a complaint against
appellants, alleging: (1) failure to provide employee/personnel
records; (2) breach of written contract; (3) breach of oral contract;
(4) breach of implied-in-fact contract; (5) common count (services
rendered); (6) illegal deductions from wages; (7) fraud;
(8) violation of Penal Code section 496; (9) failure to pay wages
for missed rest periods; (10) failure to provide accurate, itemized
wage statements; (11) waiting time penalties; (12) violation of the
unfair practices/competition law; and (13) failure to pay
minimum wages.
In her complaint, Abrams asserts True Bullion and
Subculture are “in the business of selling precious metals such as
gold and silver coins and bullion directly to consumers”; Anderson
is True Bullion’s and Subculture’s “manager, principal, and/or
self-declared ‘Senior Partner’ ”; and Viacrucis is True Bullion’s
and Subculture’s “Chief Accounting Officer and/or Director of
Human Resources . . . .”3 Appellants employed Abrams as an in-
house salesperson from May 2019 to March 2021. Appellants
willfully misclassified Abrams as an independent contractor and
2 We derive our Procedural Background in part from
admissions made by the parties in their appellate briefing and
undisputed aspects of the trial court’s order. (Association for
Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs v. County of Los Angeles (2023)
94 Cal.App.5th 764, 772, fn. 2 [utilizing this approach]
(Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs).)
3 The remainder of this paragraph summarizes certain
allegations from Abrams’s complaint.
3
perpetrated several Labor Code violations against her. After
appellants terminated Abrams, they promised to promote her if
she returned to work and released them from all liability for
misconduct.
In August 2023, appellants moved to compel arbitration
and stay the action. Abrams opposed the motion, and appellants
filed a reply.
On December 20, 2023, the trial court denied appellants’
motion. The court identified two grounds in support of its ruling:
(1) “Abrams’s claims against [appellants] do not fall within the
scope of the parties’ agreement to arbitrate,” and (2) appellants
“waived their ability to arbitrate this matter” by (a) moving to
compel arbitration two years after Abrams filed her complaint
and (b) previously representing to the court through counsel that
“Abrams did not have an arbitration agreement.” The arbitration
agreement in question is a clause of a “NON-
DISCLOSURE/NON-CIRCUMVENTION/NON-COMPETITION
AGREEMENT” (NDA) between Abrams and True Bullion. In
rendering its decision, the trial court found it did not need to
“reach a determination as to the parties’ other arguments
regarding whether the NDA is legally enforceable” (e.g., whether
appellants properly authenticated the contract).4
On January 10, 2024, appellants timely appealed the trial
court’s order denying their motion.5
4 We describe pertinent aspects of the NDA and the trial
court’s order, respectively, in greater detail in Discussion,
parts A–B, post.
5 (See also Code Civ. Proc., § 1294, subd. (a) [“An aggrieved
party may appeal from: [¶] . . . An order dismissing or denying a
petition to compel arbitration.”].)
4
APPLICABLE LAW AND STANDARDS OF REVIEW
“On a petition to compel arbitration, the trial court must
first determine whether an ‘agreement to arbitrate the
controversy exists.’ [Citation.] ‘Because the existence of the
agreement is a statutory prerequisite to granting the petition, the
petitioner bears the burden of proving its existence by a
preponderance of the evidence.’ [Citation.]” (Bannister v.
Marinidence Opco, LLC (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 541, 543.)
“ ‘ “Under California law, ordinary rules of contract
interpretation apply to arbitration agreements. . . . ‘ “The
fundamental goal of contractual interpretation is to give effect to
the mutual intention of the parties. . . .” ’ ” ’ [Citation.]” (Western
Bagel Co., Inc. v. Superior Court (2021) 66 Cal.App.5th 649, 662
(Western Bagel Co., Inc.).)6 “As a general rule, arbitration should
be upheld ‘ “ ‘unless it can be said with assurance that an
arbitration clause is not susceptible to an interpretation covering
the asserted dispute.’ ” ’ [Citations.] ‘Nonetheless, this policy
does not override ordinary principles of contract interpretation.
“[T]he contractual terms themselves must be carefully examined
before the parties to the contract can be ordered to
6 During the trial court proceedings, appellants argued
that the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA, 9 U.S.C., § 1 et seq.)
applies to the NDA. The trial court did not address whether the
FAA governs, and appellants do not clarify whether they are
reasserting that position on appeal. Appellants’ lack of clarity on
this point has no impact on our conclusion that the trial court
did not err in its interpretation of the NDA. (See Western Bagel
Co., Inc., supra, 66 Cal.App.5th at p. 662 [“ ‘ “[E]ven when the
[FAA] applies, interpretation of the arbitration agreement is
governed by state law principles. . . .” ’ ”].)
5
arbitration . . . . [Citation.]” ’ ‘ “[T]he terms of the specific
arbitration clause under consideration must reasonably cover the
dispute as to which arbitration is requested.” ’ [Citation.]”
(Ahern v. Asset Management Consultants, Inc. (2022) 74
Cal.App.5th 675, 687–688 (Ahern).)
“ ‘ “Whether an arbitration agreement applies to a
controversy is a question of law to which the appellate court
applies its independent judgment where no conflicting extrinsic
evidence in aid of the interpretation was introduced in the trial
court.” ’ [Citations.]” (Ahern, supra, 74 Cal.App.5th at p. 687.)
“ ‘Even when our review on appeal “is de novo, it is limited
to issues which have been adequately raised and supported in
[the appellant’s opening] brief. [Citations.] . . . .” ’
[Citation.] . . . ‘ “[T]he most fundamental rule of appellate review
is that an appealed judgment or order is presumed to be correct.
[Citation.] It is the appellant who bears the burden of
overcoming that presumption.’ [Citation.]” (Golden Door
Properties, LLC v. County of San Diego (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th
467, 554–555.) “Thus, ‘ “ ‘it is the appellant’s responsibility to
affirmatively demonstrate error’ ” ’ by ‘ “ ‘supply[ing] the
reviewing court with some cogent argument supported by legal
analysis and citation to the record.’ ” [Citation.]’ [Citations.]”
(Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra,
94 Cal.App.5th at p. 777.)
DISCUSSION
Appellants argue, “The trial court erred in finding the
arbitration clause [from the NDA] did not apply to [Abrams’s]
claims.” For the reasons set forth below, we conclude appellants
have failed to establish the trial court erred in determining that
Abrams’s claims fall outside the scope of the NDA’s arbitration
6
provision. Our resolution of this question moots appellants’ claim
the trial court erred in finding they waived their right to compel
arbitration. (See Mondragon v. Sunrun Inc. (2024)
101 Cal.App.5th 592, 601 (Mondragon) [observing that “ ‘whether
the parties’ dispute falls within the scope of [an arbitration]
agreement’ ” is “a ‘threshold question[ ] presented by every
motion or petition to compel arbitration’ ”].)
Before addressing appellants’ challenge to the trial court’s
ruling, we describe certain relevant provisions of the NDA.
A. The NDA’s Purpose Is To Protect True Bullion’s
Confidential Information
The prefatory paragraph of the NDA provides that the
contract is “entered into by and between [True Bullion] . . . and
the undersigned (‘Confidant’), as of the date signed below by
[True Bullion], and on behalf of any and all affiliated companies,
or approved agents and official representatives of the above
parties.” Abrams is the party identified as “Confidant” in the
NDA. The NDA provides that it “remain[s] in full force and effect
for a period of five years from the date signed and executed by all
parties . . . .” The signature page indicates that Abrams and
Anderson (on behalf of True Bullion) signed the NDA on
October 4, 2019.7
As the trial court observed in its ruling, paragraph 1 of the
NDA provides: “ ‘PURPOSE OF AGREEMENT [¶] The parties to
this Agreement desire to engage in discussions regarding present
7 Abrams asserts that appellants failed to authenticate
properly the NDA. We assume solely for the purposes of this
appeal that appellants authenticated the NDA and that Abrams
signed it on October 4, 2019.
7
and/or potential future business relationships. This Agreement
combines a non-disclosure, a non-circumvention, and a non-
competition agreement. The parties intend to engage in
substantive discussions and sharing of confidential information
regarding certain new and useful business opportunities, trade
secrets, business entity formation and structuring, and tax
planning. [. . .] Accordingly, the commitments of confidentiality
in this Agreement are a condition to the Confidant’s willingness
to engage in the contemplated business discussions and
planning.[8] The Confidant agrees that it shall not use any
advantages derivable from such information in its own business
or affairs, unless the same is done pursuant to a new agreement
with all other signatories to this document . . .’ ” (With the
exception of the fn., all alterations made by the trial court.)
Paragraph 2, which is titled “CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION,” provides: “During and at all times following
this Agreement, Confidant shall keep secret and retain in the
strictest confidence all confidential matters and information
relating to [True Bullion] and/or any of their respective
customers, including, without limitation, trade secrets,
proprietary information, ‘know-how,’ ‘show-how,’ customer
identities, information or lists, [and] pricing policies . . . learned
by it prior to and during its relationship with [True Bullion]
([‘]Confidential Information’). Confidant shall not disclose such
Confidential Information to anyone other than authorized
8 This sentence from paragraph 1 of the NDA appears to
contain a typographical error, given that True Bullion would
likely be reluctant to engage in contemplated business
discussions and planning with Abrams unless she committed to
safeguarding True Bullion’s confidential information.
8
personnel of [True Bullion], or use such Confidential Information
for its own benefit or for the benefit of any other person or entity
other than [True Bullion] . . . .” (Underscoring omitted from
heading.)
Paragraph 3 contains a provision titled “NON-
CIRCUMVENTION,” which states: “The Confidant hereby
agrees for itself . . . that it will not, directly or indirectly, contact,
deal with or otherwise become involved with any entity or any
other entities or parties introduced, directly or indirectly, by or
through the other party, its officers, directors, agents or
associates, for the purpose of avoiding the payment to [True
Bullion] of profits, fees or otherwise, without the specific written
approval of [True Bullion].” (Underscoring omitted from
heading.)
Paragraph 4 provides: “NON-COMPETITION [¶] The
Confidant hereby agrees for itself . . . that the non-competition
provision of this Agreement is an essential and material part of
the total agreement, by which the Confidant agrees it shall not
use any advantages derivable from such Confidential Information
in its own business or affairs, unless the same is done pursuant
to a new agreement executed by all signatories to this
Agreement.” (Underscoring omitted from heading.)
Appellants argue that paragraph 5 obligates Abrams to
arbitrate her claims against them. Paragraph 5 provides in full:
“ARBITRATION OF GRIEVANCES [¶] The Parties agree that
unless specifically provided to the contrary in this Agreement,
any Grievance shall be resolved exclusively by binding
Arbitration.” (Underscoring omitted from heading.) The trial
court correctly noted, “Nowhere is the term ‘Grievance’
specifically defined in the NDA.”
9
B. The Trial Court Found That Abrams’s Employment-
Related Claims Fall Outside the Scope of the
Arbitration Clause
The trial court determined the NDA “is limited to covering
Abrams’s non-disclosure, non-circumvention, and non-
competition obligations to [True Bullion].” The court reasoned,
“The stated purpose of the NDA is to facilitate ‘discussions and
sharing of confidential information regarding certain new and
useful business opportunities, trade secrets, business entity
formation and structuring, and tax planning.’ [Citation.] Thus,
read in context, the NDA’s arbitration provision applies to ‘any
Grievance’ arising from a matter covered by the NDA, e.g., a
breach of Abrams’s non-disclosure obligations.” According to the
trial court, “[T]he parties’ agreement to arbitrate ‘any Grievance’
arising under the NDA cannot be reasonably understood as
applying to all interactions between the parties, including those
outside the parameters of the NDA.”
In turn, the trial court found that Abrams’s claims against
appellants do not arise from a matter covered by the NDA. The
court explained, “Abrams alleges that during her time working
for [appellants], she encountered several Labor Code violations,
including that [appellants] failed to allow Abrams to take her
statutorily entitled rest period, that [appellants] made illegal
deductions from Abrams’s wages, and that [appellants] failed to
furnish Abrams with accurate and complete wage statements.”
The court further noted, “Abrams alleges that she was also
willfully misclassified [as an independent contractor,] and
[that] . . . after she was terminated, [appellants] fraudulently
presented her with a contract that purported to release [them]
from all liability for their misconduct under the guise of an offer
10
of reemployment.” Importantly, the court commented, “Nowhere
does Abrams allege facts in the complaint relating to any party’s
breach of a non-disclosure agreement, nor is there any indication
that the nature of Abrams’s wage and hour dispute involves trade
secrets or other confidential information in any way.”
The trial court also found significant that “the NDA
[does not] even reference the fact that Abrams had an ongoing
employment relationship with [True Bullion] when the NDA was
executed.” The court explained, “Neither party disputes that
Abrams became employed by [True Bullion] in May of 2019,
approximately six (6) months before she signed the NDA on
October [4], 2019.[9] It is unclear from either the NDA’s express
terms or [appellants’] argument how or why a non-disclosure
agreement executed six (6) months after the start of Abrams’s
employment should bar her from proceeding with employment-
related claims in Court.”
The trial court summarized its ruling as follows: “Because
Abrams’s wage and hour and other claims do not arise under the
NDA, the NDA’s arbitration provision does not cover the causes
of action alleged in Abrams’s complaint.”
C. Appellants Fail To Demonstrate the Trial Court
Erred In Finding that Paragraph 5 of the NDA
Does Not Apply to Abrams’s Claims
On appeal, appellants do not contest the trial court’s
finding that none of Abrams’s claims relates to her obligations
9 Although the trial court stated in its order that Abrams
“signed the NDA on October 14, 2019” (italics added), this
appears to be a typographical error because her signature is
dated “10/4/19.”
11
under the NDA. Rather, appellants argue that paragraph 5 of
the NDA is a “broad arbitration provision” under which “the
parties agreed that ‘any Grievance[ ]’ would be resolved
‘exclusively by binding arbitration.’ ” Appellants maintain the
text of this clause expresses the parties’ intention to “arbitrate
disputes regarding their relationship, which necessarily includes
their alleged employment relationship.” Applying the de novo
standard to this legal question, we conclude appellants have not
shown the trial court’s construction of the NDA was erroneous.
As a preliminary matter, we agree with the trial court that
context is of paramount importance in construing paragraph 5.
“ ‘[T]he context in which a [contract] term appears is critical.
“ ‘[L]anguage in a contract must be construed in the context of
that instrument as a whole, and in the circumstances of th[e]
case . . . .’ ” [Citations.] . . . While “reliance on [the] common
understanding of language is bedrock[,] [¶] [e]qually important
are the requirements of reasonableness and context.” [Citation.]’
[Citation.]” (See Mount Vernon Fire Ins. Co. v. Busby (2013)
219 Cal.App.4th 876, 882.)
Indeed, the Legislature has instructed courts to interpret
broad contractual language in light of its context: “However
broad may be the terms of a contract, it extends only to those
things concerning which it appears that the parties intended to
contract.” (Civ. Code, § 1648.) Applying this principle in a prior
arbitration case, we declared: “An arbitration agreement is tied
to the underlying contract containing it, and applies ‘only where
a dispute has its real source in the contract. The object of an
arbitration clause is to implement a contract, not to transcend it.’
[Citation.] No authority permits sending a matter to arbitration
simply because the same parties agreed to arbitrate a different
12
matter.” (Moritz v. Universal City Studios LLC (2020)
54 Cal.App.5th 238, 246.)
Thus, however broad the undefined contractual phrase
“any Grievance” may be in the abstract, we cannot divorce that
language from the context in which it appears, to wit, a “NON-
DISCLOSURE/NON-CIRCUMVENTION/NON-COMPETITION
AGREEMENT.” (Underscoring & boldface omitted.) (See Rice v.
Downs (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 175, 186 [“ ‘ “A court must view
the language in light of the instrument as a whole and not use a
‘disjointed, single-paragraph, strict construction
approach[.]’ ” ’ ”].)
The trial court correctly found that the NDA’s stated
purpose is the protection of True Bullion’s confidential
information, and that the NDA does not purport to regulate any
other aspect of Abrams’s relationship with appellants.
Accordingly, the fact that paragraph 5 appears in the NDA, and
not in some other agreement governing the parties’ relationship,
demonstrates the parties did not intend for any and all disputes
between them to be submitted to binding arbitration.
Appellants contend, “Clearly the circumstances under
which the NDA was made was [sic] in furtherance of [appellants’]
business and alleged employment relationship with Abrams. The
parties would not have entered into an NDA to keep matters
confidential but for information revealed to Abrams by way of her
business relationship or alleged employment with True Bullion.”
It is not apparent to us that this purported causal relationship
between (a) Abrams’s business or employment relationship with
appellants and (b) the NDA has any bearing on whether, in
executing the NDA, the parties intended to arbitrate all
employment-related disputes.
13
Furthermore, as the trial court recognized, the lapse of
time between the commencement of Abrams’s tenure and the
date of the NDA’s execution further undermines appellants’
position. The court observed there is no dispute that Abrams
began working for True Bullion in May 2019, several months
before she signed the NDA in October 2019.10 We cannot assume
that an arbitration clause in a confidentiality agreement
executed months after the commencement of Abrams’s tenure
was intended to apply to all disputes related to her relationship
with appellants.11
10The trial court observed that Abrams alleges in her
complaint “she began working for [appellants] in May of 2019,”
and appellants do not claim that Abrams began working for
Subculture, Anderson, and Viacrucis at some point in time after
Abrams started her tenure at True Bullion.
Additionally, in their opening brief, appellants assert,
without any supporting record citation, that Abrams’s “business
and alleged employment relationship with True Bullion . . .
commenced on October 4, 2019, when [she] signed the NDA.” We
disregard that assertion. (See Alki Partners, LP v. DB Fund
Services, LLC (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 574, 590, fn. 8 [“[C]ourts will
decline to consider any factual assertion unsupported by record
citation at the point where it is asserted.”].) We further note that
appellants seem to abandon this position in their reply by
claiming “the fact that [Abrams] signed the arbitration
agreement after her purported employment began” “does not
bring [her] claims outside of the scope or contemplation of the
arbitration clause set forth in the NDA . . . .”
11 Although appellants maintain True Bullion hired
Abrams “as a Precious Metals Specialist independent contractor
to sell [appellants’] products,” they do not claim to have presented
any such independent contractor agreement to the trial court.
14
Appellants further argue, “The NDA also made clear in
paragraph 14 that the arbitration agreement is a ‘material
inducement[s] [sic] to GSIE’s relationship with Confidant
[Abrams] . . . .’ ”12 By inserting an ellipsis at the end of their
quotation, appellants omit a key word from this portion of
paragraph 14 of the NDA. The full sentence reads: “The parties
to this Agreement acknowledge and agree that the restrictions
contained in Paragraphs 2, 3, 4, and 5 are material inducements
to GSIE’s relationship with Confidant hereunder.” (Italics
added.) The text of paragraph 14 thus belies appellants’
argument that paragraph 5 of the NDA applies to any and all
disputes regarding their relationship with Abrams.
In sum, appellants fail to show the trial court erred in
concluding that, “read in context, the NDA’s arbitration provision
applies to ‘any Grievance’ arising from a matter covered by the
NDA,” and that the clause does not encompass Abrams’s
employment-related claims in this case. Accordingly, we affirm
the trial court’s order denying the motion to compel arbitration.
(See Mondragon, supra, 101 Cal.App.5th at p. 602 [“ ‘[A] trial
court has no power to order parties to arbitrate a dispute that
they did not agree to arbitrate.’ ”].)
Furthermore, our record does not contain a copy of an
independent contractor or employment agreement.
12 (With the exception of the “[sic],” all alterations made by
appellants.) As used in the NDA, “GSIE” is a reference to True
Bullion.
15
DISPOSITION
We affirm the trial court’s December 20, 2023 order
denying appellants’ motion to compel arbitration. Respondent
Cynthia Abrams is awarded her costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BENDIX, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
M. KIM, J.
16
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.