CourtListener 10324867•In re I.P. CA3
Texto completo
Filed 1/31/25 In re I.P. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----
In re I.P. et al., Persons Coming Under the Juvenile C100371
Court Law.
SACRAMENTO COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF (Super. Ct. Nos. JD240129,
CHILD, ADULT AND FAMILY SERVICES, JD242557)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
E.L.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appellant E.L., mother of minors I.P. and W.P., appeals from the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional and dispositional orders finding that minors come within the provisions of
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (b) and adjudging them
1
dependents of the court. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 300, 361, 395.)1 Mother contends that
the evidence was insufficient to support jurisdiction, the application of the detrimental
condition presumption in section 355.1 was improper, and the juvenile court applied an
incorrect legal standard in considering expert opinion testimony. The Sacramento County
Department of Child, Family and Adult Services (Department) concedes that there was
insufficient evidence to support jurisdiction and does not oppose reversal. Given the
record before us, we accept the Department’s concession and reverse.
BACKGROUND
In September 2019, the Department filed a non-detaining section 300 petition on
behalf of I.P. Both I.P. and mother tested positive for amphetamine and
methamphetamine at the time of his birth. Mother denied any illicit drug use and
suggested that the positive test results may have resulted from her prescription
medications. Although this explanation was ruled out by lab results, mother continued to
insist that her prescription medications caused the positive toxicology results. Mother
had several subsequent positive tests in the month following I.P.’s birth (and was
reportedly breastfeeding at the time), but later tests were negative for all substances and
mother reported she was taking different medication. The Department determined that
there were sufficient safeguards in place, including father’s presence in the home and
ample family support, and the juvenile court dismissed the section 300 petition at the
November 2019 jurisdiction hearing.
On March 16, 2023, the Department received a referral reporting that mother
tested positive for amphetamine and methamphetamine at the delivery of newborn W.P.
Mother denied using any illicit drugs and asserted that she tested positive due to her
prescription medications. Mother was reportedly taking between seven and 13 different
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
medications or supplements, including oxycodone, labetalol, and nifedipine. W.P. had no
withdrawal symptoms, but his meconium was sent for testing. Mother said that she was
not going to breastfeed W.P. due to the allegations and that she would feed him formula.
Father reported no concerns about mother testing positive for methamphetamine
and denied having any knowledge of mother using illicit drugs. Mother’s physician, who
prescribed her medications, did not believe mother was using methamphetamine; the
physician had no concerns about mother as a parent and believed she was a “great mom.”
Minors’ maternal grandmother, whom mother listed as her support person, agreed to stay
at the home and not allow W.P. to be left with mother without supervision. I.P. told the
social worker that his parents took good care of him; he did not know what drugs or
alcohol were. He said he was happy living with his parents, although father would eat all
the food. Father was sometimes mean to mother, but I.P. had never seen them fight with
their hands.
On March 21, 2023, W.P.’s meconium lab results came back positive for
methamphetamine and amphetamine. Mother tested positive for amphetamine,
methamphetamine, and oxycodone on March 21 and 23, 2023.
Minors’ maternal grandmother did not observe mother using any drugs during the
time she (maternal grandmother) stayed with the family. She reported that mother was
just fine with minors and said she did not understand why mother “ ‘needs a babysitter.’ ”
Minors’ maternal great-uncle and maternal great-aunt likewise reported no suspicions of
drug use by mother, and they expressed no concerns for the children. Another great-
uncle and great-aunt, as well as minors’ paternal grandmother, were also unaware of any
drug use by mother. A family friend, B.L., who had known parents for eight years and
also provided support to mother, said mother was an “amazing mother” and she (B.L.)
had no suspicions of any drug use by either parent.
On April 3, 2023, the social worker met with mother and father to explain the
March lab results. Father was holding and feeding W.P. Mother appeared attentive and
3
responded to W.P.’s cues. She denied using any illicit drugs, claiming her prescription
medication caused false positive tests.
That same day, mother tested positive for oxycodone and alcohol. She tested
positive for amphetamines and alcohol on April 5, 2023, positive for alcohol on April 13,
2023, and positive for methamphetamine on April 17, 2023.
On May 18, 2023, parents agreed that father would be the primary caregiver for
minors and that mother would be supervised when she was with them. Parents agreed to
informal supervision services. Mother’s support person, B.B., also agreed to not allow
mother to be unsupervised with minors.
Parents did not drug test for two weeks in June 2023. The Department was
concerned that minors were at risk as a result of parents’ failure to comply with consistent
drug testing and assessments, mother’s continued denial of substance abuse despite
positive tests for amphetamines and methamphetamines, parents’ failure to acknowledge
mother’s substance abuse, and parents’ failure to engage in services.
On June 26, 2023, the Department filed petitions on behalf of I.P. (then three years
old) and W.P. (then three months old), alleging that minors came within the provisions of
section 300, subdivision (b)(1). The petitions alleged that mother had a substance abuse
problem from which she failed and/or refused to rehabilitate and that her substance abuse
issues impaired her judgment and ability to adequately care for and supervise minors.
The petitions asserted that mother tested positive for amphetamine and methamphetamine
at the time of W.P.’s delivery and that W.P.’s meconium tested positive for amphetamine
and methamphetamine. Mother also had a positive prenatal exposure test for
amphetamine and methamphetamine on October 6, 2022, and her post-delivery urinalysis
toxicology screenings on March 21, March 23, and April 17, 2023 were positive for
amphetamine and methamphetamine. The petitions alleged that mother’s ongoing
substance abuse problem placed minors at substantial risk of physical harm, abuse, and/or
4
neglect.2 Mother insisted that she had never used amphetamine or methamphetamine and
that the positive test results were due to prescribed medications she was taking. At the
July 2023 initial hearing, the juvenile court ordered minors to remain in parents’ custody
under the Department’s supervision.
Minors’ maternal grandmother reported that mother had never had a drug problem
and that mother was very attentive to her children. Maternal grandmother said that father
“is always there and provides both children with what they need.” She was aware that
mother had a previous, similar case and stated that mother “went through a lot of trouble
to prove that it was her prescribed medications not illicit substances.” Maternal
grandmother cleaned the entire home while parents were in the hospital with W.P., and
she never saw anything suggestive of illicit substance abuse. She said the children were
doing well and W.P. was thriving. She had never seen mother appear under the influence
of any illicit drugs.
On August 2, 2023, the social worker met with the family in their home. Minors
showed no signs of abuse or neglect. Father was minors’ primary caregiver and was
always home with them. Mother worked from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday.
Parents confirmed that W.P. was born premature, but he was not in the NICU and did not
have any withdrawals. Mother reported that W.P. was sleeping well and was drinking six
ounces of baby formula every three to four hours. I.P. was doing well with no behavioral
issues, although he needed constant supervision to prevent him from trying to scratch his
eczema.
Parents shared pick-up and drop-off duties for I.P.’s daycare. On August 17, 2023,
the social worker met with daycare staff, who reported that I.P. had been attending their
2 The petitions also initially alleged that father failed to provide adequate care and
supervision because he knew or should have known of mother’s substance abuse
problem, but that allegation was later dismissed by the juvenile court.
5
daycare since he was two years old and that they never had concerns about parents’ care
for I.P. or witnessed parents under the influence.
The social worker went to the family home on several more occasions, including
an unannounced visit in November 2023. The home was clean, safe, and appropriate.
The social worker did not have any safety concerns about the home or the adequacy of
food and supplies. Minors were dressed appropriately, appeared happy and healthy, and
showed no signs of abuse or neglect. Both minors appeared developmentally on track.
The social worker observed parents to be attentive to their needs, and minors appeared
comfortable going to parents to have their needs met. There had been no reports of
concerns about the adequacy of parents’ care or of any abuse or neglect.
W.P.’s medical records reflected that W.P. spent three days in the hospital after his
birth. His delivery had been complicated by a “3 tight nuchal cord.” Mother’s medical
history included chronic hypertension and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, and she
was noted to have taken “PNV,” labetalol, nifedipine, and aspirin during pregnancy. The
notes also indicated that labetalol can have a false positive for methamphetamine on a
urine toxicology screen but stated that it was highly unlikely to cause a false positive with
confirmatory positive results.
When parents brought W.P. to his one-week newborn exam, he weighed four
pounds, 14.3 ounces. The questionnaire for the visit indicated that W.P. ate some breast
milk and some formula. The comments from the exam noted that W.P. was not in acute
distress and was “well-developed and well-nourished.” His pupil, cardiovascular, and
pulmonary assessments were normal. It was recommended that his diet be supplemented
with pumped breast milk.
Eleven days later, W.P. was seen for breastfeeding difficulty. He weighed five
pounds, 13.6 ounces and was noted to be breastfeeding at most feedings and bottle
feeding four to five times a day. The following day, W.P. weighed six pounds, 3.2 ounces
and was eating both breast milk and formula. His respiratory exam did not raise any
6
concerns. Mother’s history of positive methamphetamine and amphetamine tests was
noted, along with her claim of false positives due to her medication. At his one-month
visit, W.P.’s doctor noted that his weight “look[ed] good” at seven pounds, three ounces.
He was still eating both breast milk and formula.
At his two-month exam, W.P. was reported to be eating only formula. The notes
indicated that W.P. would be starting daycare in one to two months “as mom goes back to
work.” W.P. was not in acute distress and was well-developed and well-nourished. His
pupil, cardiovascular, and pulmonary assessments were normal. He weighed 10 pounds,
five ounces. W.P. had similar medical summaries after his four-month and six-month
exams. He continued to gain weight, was reportedly eating only formula, and had no
pupil, cardiovascular, or pulmonary issues.
Mother tested positive for alcohol use on six occasions, tested negative for
substances on seven occasions, and failed to test on 10 occasions. After she was
discharged from the testing program in August 2023 for failing to test, she began testing
with the Just Say No program. Those tests were not random and were not sent to a
laboratory for confirmation. Mother tested three times (twice in August 2023 and once in
September 2023) with Just Say No, and those test results were negative. Mother was
unresponsive to efforts at mobile testing thereafter.
The Department gathered information regarding the accuracy of mother’s test
results and whether the positive results could be due to her prescribed medications.
Among other information gathered, a forensic toxicologist explained that mother’s
March 21, 2023 urine specimen had been analyzed using scientifically accepted methods
“such as liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry.” The toxicologist opined
that “the results are consistent with exposure to methamphetamine.” She also reported
that mother’s medication was not known to contain or metabolize to amphetamine or
methamphetamine. Although “[t]he literature does report false positive screen results
7
following the ingestion of labetalol,” confirmatory testing “rules out false positives
through specific identification of a particular drug or drug metabolite.” (Italics added.)
At a January 2024 combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing, the juvenile
court noted that this was the second time a section 300 petition had been filed as a result
of mother and her newborn testing positive for methamphetamine at the time of delivery,
and, on both occasions, mother denied using methamphetamine. The court considered
the test results and the toxicologist’s opinion regarding the possibility that the results
were false positives. The court stated: “[A]s I believe the evidence requires me to find,
that on those occasions, Mom has tested positive for methamphetamine and those results
are not the result of a prescribed medication.”
The juvenile court further found that the presumption of a detrimental condition
set forth in section 355.1 applied and that mother had failed to rebut the presumption.
The court reasoned: “Given that Mom does not admit methamphetamine use, that she
has tested positive on multiple occasions, that she used while pregnant with her sons, and
that her use while pregnant with [W.P.] came on the heels of a prior dependency case, and
that she has not submitted to laboratory confirmed tests at least for a number of months
following that April 17th test, I don’t see how I can find that that presumption has been
rebutted.” The court therefore found that W.P. “has suffered serious physical harm both
as a result of mom’s failure or inability to adequately protect and by her inability to
provide regular care due to her substance abuse, and on that basis [W.P.’s] 300(b)-1
allegation is sustained.”
The juvenile court additionally concluded that the allegations of the petition could
be sustained on the ground minors faced a substantial risk of physical harm as a result of
mother’s substance abuse. The court noted that mother was high-functioning and that
parents “are able to provide for their children, both of whom, by all accounts, appear to
be thriving.” There was no evidence “from any witness that has known and interacted
with Mom outside the context of this case that they believe that she uses
8
methamphetamine.” But the court concluded that “in at least one important regard, it
appears that she’s not able to manage her use, and that’s an inability to control when she
uses. She continued to use after [W.P.’s] birth when she knew she would be tested. She
was unable, more importantly it appears, to stop using while pregnant.”
The juvenile court acknowledged that, under California law, “substance abuse
without more is not a sufficient ground to assert jurisdiction.” But “this does not . . .
appear to be a case where a parent or guardian takes specific steps to control the use of a
dangerous substance and ensure that it doesn’t affect the children. Instead, in this case,
we don’t have admission to use and we don’t have an apparent ability to control when use
occurs.” The court additionally observed that mother “managed to go a number of
months without submitting to laboratory-confirmed testing,” and her explanation for the
positive tests “has been pretty thoroughly refuted by the evidence in this case and similar
evidence in [I.P.’s] case.” In light of this evidence, the court assumed “that there’s a
possibility that Mom may still be using and that she does not have the ability to control
when she uses, and I find that evidence is sufficient to sustain the [300](b)-1 allegations
in both [minors’] petitions and that they are at substantial risk.”
The juvenile court adjudicated minors dependent children of the court and placed
them in parents’ care under the Department’s supervision. Parents were provided family
maintenance services, and a review hearing was set.
Mother timely appealed. The matter was fully briefed in this court on October 11,
2024.
DISCUSSION
Mother challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional ruling, arguing that there was
insufficient evidence that minors were at substantial risk of harm as a result of her
substance abuse and that the juvenile court erred in applying the presumption of a
detrimental condition under section 355.1. Mother also contends that the juvenile court
applied the wrong legal standard in accepting expert testimony that the positive drug tests
9
were the result of mother’s use of methamphetamine, rather than her prescribed
medication as she claimed. We need not address mother’s argument regarding the
juvenile court’s consideration of the expert testimony because, as the Department
concedes, even assuming that mother used methamphetamine, the evidence was
insufficient to support jurisdiction on the record in this case.
A juvenile court has jurisdiction to declare a child a dependent of the court under
subdivision (b)(1) of section 300 when the child “has suffered, or there is a substantial
risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of any of the
following: [¶] (A) The failure or inability of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately
supervise or protect the child. [¶] . . . [¶] (D) The inability of the parent or guardian to
provide regular care for the child due to the parent’s or guardian’s mental illness,
developmental disability, or substance abuse.” A child welfare agency bears the burden
to prove jurisdiction by a preponderance of the evidence. (§ 355, subd. (a); In re I.J.
(2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.) We review jurisdictional findings for substantial evidence,
reviewing the record in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s determination and
drawing all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the court’s findings and
orders. (In re I.J., supra, at p. 773.)
Our state Supreme Court has made clear that substance abuse by a parent, standing
alone, is not sufficient to establish dependency jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivision (b)(1)(D). (In re N.R. (2023) 15 Cal.5th 520, 550, 555-556.) “[D]ependency
jurisdiction under section 300[, subdivision ](b)(1)(D) requires more than just the
identification of substance abuse by a parent or guardian. A court must also find that the
parent or guardian is unable to provide regular care for a child and that as a result, the
child has suffered serious physical harm or illness or is at significant risk of suffering
serious physical harm or illness.” (Id. at p. 556.) The term “ ‘substance abuse’ [bears] its
ordinary meaning—essentially, the excessive use of drugs or alcohol.” (Id. at p. 531.)
10
As the Department concedes, even assuming mother used drugs during and after
her pregnancy with W.P., there was a lack of substantial evidence showing a nexus
between her substance abuse and substantial harm or risk of harm to minors. The
Department did not present evidence that W.P. suffered physical harm or illness as a
result of exposure to drugs. It was not shown that prenatal drug exposure was the reason
he was born premature or that he suffered any withdrawal or other symptoms as a result
of his exposure. Although mother initially breastfed W.P., he was 10 months old by the
time of the January 2024 hearing and had reportedly been consuming only formula (no
breast milk) since his two-month doctor’s visit. There was no evidence that anyone had
observed mother acting as if she were under the influence, that minors were not being
properly cared for, or that they were exposed to unsafe conditions. The social worker
reported that the family home was clean, safe, and appropriate; that minors appeared
happy, healthy, and developmentally on track; and that parents were attentive to minors’
needs. On this record, there is a lack of substantial evidence that mother was unable to
provide regular care for minors or that they were subject to a substantial risk of serious
physical harm. (In re N.R., supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 558.)
We also conclude that substantial evidence fails to support the application of the
detrimental condition presumption in section 355.1 in this case. That section provides in
relevant part: “Where the court finds, based upon competent professional evidence, that
an injury, injuries, or detrimental condition sustained by a minor is of a nature as would
ordinarily not be sustained except as the result of the unreasonable or neglectful acts or
omissions of either parent, . . . that finding shall be prima facie evidence that the minor is
a person described by subdivision (a), (b), or (d) of Section 300.” (§ 355.1, subd. (a).)
This statutory presumption applies when a child is “ ‘diagnosed as being born under the
influence of a dangerous drug’ ” or when a child tests positive at birth and also suffers
severe medical problems as a result of the drug. (In re J.A. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 1036,
11
1049; In re Troy D. (1989) 215 Cal.App.3d 889, 897; In re Monique T. (1992)
2 Cal.App.4th 1372, 1378-1379.)
In this case, the Department presented no competent professional evidence that
W.P. was born addicted to amphetamine or methamphetamine, that he was under the
influence of either drug, or that he suffered from withdrawals or other adverse effects.
While his meconium tested positive for methamphetamine and amphetamine at birth, the
Department did not introduce evidence identifying the level of those substances in W.P.’s
meconium or whether or how their presence gave rise to a serious injury or detrimental
condition. While we have no difficulty imagining that the use of methamphetamine
during pregnancy could result in a detrimental condition within the meaning of the
statute, the Department did not present such evidence in this case. Accordingly, the
juvenile court should not have applied the detrimental condition presumption in
section 355.1. (In re B.D. (2024) 103 Cal.App.5th 315, 329; In re J.A., supra,
47 Cal.App.5th at p. 1049.)
We appreciate the juvenile court’s concern about mother’s positive tests, the lack
of evidentiary support for her explanations, and her failure to regularly test. If new facts
or evidence concerning mother’s ability to care for minors emerge, the Department may
file a new section 300 petition. (In re Janet T. (2001) 93 Cal.App.4th 377, 392.) On the
record before us, however, the jurisdictional findings under section 300, subdivision (b)
must be reversed. (In re N.R., supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 558.)
12
DISPOSITION
The jurisdictional findings and orders of the juvenile court are reversed. The
disposition and all subsequent orders are vacated.
/s/
FEINBERG, J.
We concur:
/s/
DUARTE, Acting P. J.
/s/
BOULWARE EURIE, J.
13
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.