CourtListener 10318838•In re T.R. CA2/5
Texto completo
Filed 1/22/25 In re T.R. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re T.R., et al., Persons B333226, B337336
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP02383A–E)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
I.R.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Mary E. Kelly, Judge. Affirmed.
Cristina Gabrielidis, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Peter Ferrera, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________________________
I. INTRODUCTION
The juvenile court terminated jurisdiction over siblings
T.R.1, N.R., Z.R., J.R., and O.R. (the children) and issued a
juvenile custody order granting mother T.Z. full legal and
physical custody of and father I.R. monitored visits with the
children. Father contends the court abused its discretion in
ordering his visits be monitored.2 We affirm.
II. BACKGROUND
On July 18, 2023, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (Department) filed a Welfare and
1 T.R. turned 18 in September 2024 and is not a subject of
this appeal.
2 In separate appeals, father appealed from the court’s
jurisdiction and disposition findings and orders (case no.
B333226) and its juvenile custody order (case no. B337336). We
granted father’s motion to consolidate these appeals and
consolidated them in appeal case number B333226.
2
Institutions Code section 3003 petition that alleged, as later
sustained as to father, counts under subdivisions (a) and (j).
The sustained a-1 count alleged:
“[F]ather . . . physically abused . . . [N.R.] On 6/9/2023, . . .
father forced [then 13-year-old N.R.] to crouch down against a
wall twice for approximately 10–13 minutes each time. As a
result, the child felt pain, stated that he was going to pass out,
and causing [sic] the child’s knees to bruise and dislocate. On a
prior occasion on or about May 2023, . . . father pulled [N.R.] out
of the bed by the child’s shoulders, causing the child’s shoulder to
dislocate and inflicting bruising to the child’s shoulders. . . .
[M]other . . . knew of . . . father’s physical abuse of [N.R.] and
failed to protect the child by allowing . . . father to continue to
reside in the children’s home and have unlimited access to the
children. Such physical abuse was excessive and caused [N.R.]
unreasonable pain and suffering. Such physical abuse of [N.R.]
by . . . father, and . . . mother’s failure to protect, endangers the
child’s physical health and safety, creates a detrimental home
environment and places [N.R.] and the child’s siblings, [T.R.,
Z.R., J.R., and O.R.] at risk of serious physical harm, damage,
danger, physical abuse and failure to protect.”
The sustained a-2 count alleged:
“[F]ather . . . has a history of violent and assaultive
behavior, in the presence of the children. On 6/23/2023, . . .
father placed the adult sibling, [Na.R.] in a chokehold, in the
family home and in the presence of the children. . . . [F]ather
placed his right hand over the adult sibling’s mouth and his left
hand over her throat, and . . . father bit the adult sibling,
3 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise stated.
3
inflicting bite marks and injuries to her neck. As a result, the
adult sibling [M.R.] intervened and . . . father pinn[ed] both
[M.R.] and [Na.R.] to the floor. The minor [T.R.] then intervened
to defend his siblings and placed his father in a chokehold. As a
result of the incident, . . . father was arrested and convicted for
243(D) PC-BATTERY WITH SERIOUS BODILY INJURY. . . .
[F]ather’s violent and assaultive behavior endangers the
children’s physical health and safety, creates a detrimental home
environment, and places the children at risk of serious physical
harm, damage, and danger.”4
The sustained j-1 count alleged father’s physical abuse of
N.R. alleged in count a-1 and mother’s knowledge of and failure
to protect N.R. from that abuse endangered N.R.’s physical
health and safety, created a detrimental home environment and
placed N.R. and his siblings, T.R., Z.R., J.R., and O.R. at risk of
serious physical harm, damage, danger, physical abuse, and
failure to protect.
At the September 26, 2023, jurisdiction hearing, the
juvenile court stated it was “appalled” that father disciplined
N.R. by making him do “wall-sits” given N.R.’s medical
condition—N.R. suffered from Ehlers Danlos Syndrome which
caused his joints to dislocate very easily with any type of strain or
force. The court described father’s discipline as “very egregious,”
“completely inappropriate,” and “akin to torture.”
4 As to mother, the juvenile court dismissed count a-1 and
sustained count b-1 (failure to protect) that was based on the
conduct alleged in count a-1. The court also purported to dismiss
count b-2 (failure to protect) as to mother, but that count did not
include allegations about mother.
4
At the October 25, 2023, disposition hearing, the juvenile
court declared the children dependents of the court and ordered
them removed from father and placed with mother. The court
ordered father to participate in a 52-week domestic violence
program, a developmentally appropriate parenting course, and
individual counseling to address case issues “to identify triggers
and source of angry outburst, to learn healthy ways to
communicate, and to identify purposeful and appropriate
discipline for children who are special needs or struggle with
chronic medical conditions.”5 It granted father monitored
visitation with the children with a Department-approved
monitor, not to include mother.
In a December 15, 2023, Last Minute Information for the
Court, the Department informed the juvenile court that father
did not want to reunify with the children and was “content” with
mother having physical custody. Once the case was closed, father
wanted to move to Colorado. He was applying for a new job and
asked the Department if he could visit the children once a month
if he was hired. Currently, father was visiting the children once
a week.
Father had completed 16 of his 52 domestic violence classes
and was participating in a parenting class. He had not enrolled
in individual counseling. Father understood he needed to
complete his court-ordered services for the Department to
liberalize visits with the children prior to closing the case.
5 The “Court-Ordered Case Plan” form does not list O.R. The
court’s disposition order for O.R., however, stated, “Court ordered
disposition case plan is signed by the Court and filed this date.
Said order is incorporated herein.”
5
In its April 10, 2024, report for the section 364 status
review hearing, the Department reported that father was
employed as a long-haul truck driver and traveled between
various states. Father was homeless and living in his truck.
Father was in partial compliance with his court-ordered
services. He visited with the children consistently and his visits
were reported to be engaging—he would inquire about school,
church, and the children’s interests. The visitation monitor had
not reported any concerns. Father did not want to reunify with
the children as mother was able to meet their needs, but he did
want to have unmonitored visits with them.
During the reporting period, father “continue[d] to
minimize the incident that took place and [felt] that the
Department and Court [were] making more of the situation than
it [was]. Father [had] shown little remorse. Despite him having
completed over half of his domestic violence classes.”
Father had attended 35 of 52 domestic violence classes and
had missed no classes. The progress note stated father showed
positive participation in group sessions and good comprehension
of the program’s curriculum. Father also had attended 35 of 52
parenting classes. A progress letter stated father displayed
positive participation and progress. Father had not enrolled in
individual counseling. He explained he was having difficulty
finding a therapist who would meet with him monthly due to his
work schedule.
The Department did not believe it was appropriate to
liberalize father’s visits with the children. Father continued to
have a peaceful contact order from his criminal case and T.R. did
not want to visit with father due to father’s assault on Na.R. and
father’s lack of accountability for his actions. Moreover, during
6
the initial investigation and in subsequent months, father made
statements that suggested he did not believe his disciplinary
methods were inappropriate or that he had impulse control or
anger management issues. Father believed the Department’s
concern about the children’s safety was “blown out of proportion”
and “the reasons for this case to be open should be dismissed.”
J.R. and O.R. enjoyed spending time with father, but were
unable to understand the severity of the events that led to the
dependency case as they did not witness them. N.R. and Z.R.
chose not to visit father at times. When they visited, they
appeared to enjoy their time with father.
In an April 24, 2024, Last Minute Information for the
Court,6 the Department recommended the juvenile court
terminate jurisdiction and family maintenance services and issue
a family law order giving mother sole legal and primary physical
custody and granting father monitored visits with the children.
At the April 24, 2024, section 364 hearing, father’s counsel
joined the Department’s recommendation that the juvenile court
terminate jurisdiction, but requested father have unmonitored
visitation with the children. Father testified he was in week 36
of his 52-week parenting course and his domestic violence
program. Only time barriers prevented him from completing
more classes. He had not participated in any individual
counseling.
In his parenting course, father learned to take
accountability, there were alternative ways to discipline, how
6 The information is stamped as having been filed on
April 25, 2024. At the section 364 hearing on April 24, 2024, the
juvenile court stated the information was marked and received
into evidence and e-filed that day.
7
parenting is and should be done, and how to express concerns
and needs. In his domestic violence class he also learned not to
get angry; how to notice red flags, set boundaries, and protect
himself from losing his family, freedom, and finances; and to be
more aware of his actions. He also learned that physical
discipline is unacceptable and there should be alternative forms
of discipline.
Father learned that the incident with N.R. was
inappropriate. There were other ways he could have disciplined
N.R. such as taking away digital devices, restricting activities, or
verbal warnings. His actions in the incident with Na.R. were
“totally inappropriate” and he was remorseful.
Father had apologized to the children multiple times in
monitored visits. He recalled them responding, “[I]t’s okay. We
understand.”
The juvenile court stated father’s testimony did not
persuade it to grant father unmonitored visits with the children.
The court found father’s testimony vague and unspecific. Father
had not testified about the cycle of domestic violence and so had
“learned nothing from that.” Although father testified he learned
physical discipline was unacceptable and claimed the children
said everything was fine, T.R. did not want to visit with father
because father had not taken accountability for his actions.
The juvenile court noted there was an existing criminal
protective order and said, “I don’t believe that that means that
father can have unmonitored contact with these children, and I
don’t believe that father has learned—that father’s participation
in the programs at this time warrants it.”
The juvenile court awarded mother sole legal and physical
custody of the children. It granted father monitored visits with
8
the children three times a week for three hours and a visit on
Father’s Day for three hours. The court explained to father that
a file would be opened in family court immediately after the
dependency case was closed. Father could go to family court to
seek any future modifications of the visitation order. The
juvenile court terminated and stayed termination of jurisdiction
pending receipt of a juvenile custody order.
On April 30, 2024, the juvenile court received and signed
the juvenile custody order. The court awarded mother legal and
physical custody of the children. Father was granted monitored
visits with the children in compliance with the criminal
protective order three times a week for three hours. The juvenile
custody order provided that father’s visitation would be
supervised because he had not completed and/or made
substantial progress in his domestic violence program, parenting
classes, and individual counseling. The court lifted the stay and
terminated jurisdiction.7
III. DISCUSSION
Father contends the juvenile court’s custody order granting
him monitored visitation was an abuse of discretion. We
disagree.
“When the juvenile court terminates its jurisdiction over a
dependent child, section 362.4 authorizes it to make custody and
visitation orders that will be transferred to an existing family
court file and remain in effect until modified or terminated by the
superior court.” (In re Roger S. (1992) 4 Cal.App.4th 25, 30, fn.
7 The juvenile custody order concerned all the children. The
court’s minute orders did not include T.R.
9
omitted.) “‘[T]he juvenile court has broad discretion to make
custody [and visitation] orders when it terminates jurisdiction in
a dependency case (§ 362.4).’ ([In re ]Nicholas H. [(2003)] 112
Cal.App.4th [251,] 265, fn. 4.) We review the juvenile court’s exit
orders for an abuse of that discretion. (See, e.g., In re Maya L.
(2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 81, 102; [In re ]Jennifer R. [(1993)] 14
Cal.App.4th [704,] 711; see also In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7
Cal.4th 295, 318.)” (In re J.M. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 95, 112–
113.)
At the disposition hearing, the juvenile court ordered father
to participate in a 52-week domestic violence program, a
parenting course, and individual counseling to address case
issues including identifying appropriate discipline for children
who struggle with chronic medical conditions. It determined that
father’s visitation with the children should be monitored. By the
time of the section 364 hearing six months later, father had
diligently participated in his domestic violence program and
parenting course having attended 36 of 52 sessions, but he had
not yet completed them. Father also had not enrolled in
individual counseling.
In its section 364 status report, the Department
recommended against liberalizing father’s visitation with the
children. It reported father continued to minimize his conduct
that led to the dependency case, made statements that suggested
he did not believe his disciplinary methods were inappropriate,
and believed the Department’s concern about the children’s
safety was “blown out of proportion.” The juvenile court found
father’s testimony at the section 364 hearing about his insight
into his conduct unpersuasive.
10
In light of father’s incomplete performance of his domestic
violence program and parenting course, his failure to enroll in
individual counseling, and his lack of insight about the
inappropriateness of his disciplinary methods, the juvenile court
did not abuse its discretion in declining to liberalize father’s
visitation with the children to unmonitored. (In re C.W. (2019) 33
Cal.App.5th 835, 863; In re Nicholas H., supra, 112 Cal.App.4th
at p. 265.)
IV. DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
KIM (D.), J.
We concur:
BAKER, Acting P. J.
MOOR, J.
11
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.