CourtListener 10296504•People v. Moreno CA4/1
Texto completo
Filed 12/18/24 P. v. Moreno CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THE PEOPLE, D082974
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Super. Ct. No. SCS320086)
ISRAEL MORENO, JR.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
David M. Gill, Judge. Affirmed.
Robert L. S. Angres, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Daniel Rogers, Alana R. Butler, and Amanda Lloyd, Deputy Attorneys
General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Israel Moreno, Jr. appeals the judgment after a jury convicted him of
the first degree murder of Marquis Hargrove (Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a))1
and found true the allegation that he personally used a firearm causing great
bodily injury and death to another (§ 12022.53, subd. (d)). Moreno makes two
main contentions on appeal. First, when the trial court was instructing the
jury, it failed to read CALCRIM No. 640 aloud. Moreno argues that although
the written version of the instruction was provided to the jury, we must
presume the jury was not aware of the instruction. He further contends that
this error was prejudicial and requires reversal of the judgment. Second,
Moreno contends that the trial court incorrectly stated the law in its written
response to jury questions during deliberations, and its amended response
did not cure the prejudicial error.
We conclude that the trial court’s failure to read the instruction to the
jury was not prejudicial error. We further conclude that Moreno forfeited his
argument regarding the trial court’s response to the jury questions because
his counsel agreed with both the initial and amended response. We therefore
affirm the judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In 2023, Moreno was charged with one count of murder (§ 187, subd.
(a)) after he shot and killed Hargrove, his friend and the romantic partner of
his cousin. The information further alleged that Moreno personally used and
discharged a firearm in the commission of the murder, causing great bodily
injury and death to another (§§ 12022.5, subd. (a); 12022.53, subd. (d)). After
an 11-day trial, a jury found him guilty of first degree murder and found the
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
gun enhancement within the meaning of section 12022.53, subdivision (d) to
be true.
A. The Prosecution’s Case
Moreno’s cousin Jovana A. met Marquis Hargrove when she was 16
years old. They started a romantic relationship and had a son together in
2020. They were together for about four years before Hargrove was killed.
The couple had a toxic relationship that involved physical and emotional
abuse. Hargrove often got violent and hit Jovana, disrespected her, and tried
to prostitute her. At one point, Jovana obtained a restraining order against
Hargrove, and at another point, Hargrove obtained a temporary restraining
order against Jovana and was awarded temporary custody of their son.
Moreno, Jovana, and their families were all very close. Moreno met
Hargrove through Jovana. Moreno and Hargrove were “like brothers” for a
long time. In November 2020, Moreno and Hargrove had a falling out when
they and Jovana were detained during a traffic stop and a gun was found in
the car. Moreno was released but Hargrove and Jovana were arrested.
Hargrove accused Moreno of being a snitch, which upset Moreno.
Moreno was aware of Hargrove’s abuse and tried more than once to
convince Jovana to leave him. At some point when Jovana and Hargrove
were temporarily broken up, the two got into another argument. Hargrove
had broken Jovana’s phone, so Jovana was using her cousin’s phone, and
Hargrove threw it out the window. He called Jovana and her cousin names.
Apparently in response to this event, Moreno got angry and threatened to
“smoke” Hargrove for disrespecting his two cousins.
At some point the rift between Moreno and Hargrove seemed to be
repaired, and in October 2021, Moreno, Jovana, Hargrove, Jovana’s close
friend Emily S., and Hargrove’s friend Maximo G. all went out together one
3
night. They drove to a hotel, where they started drinking and smoking
marijuana. The five of them became intoxicated and continued partying
throughout the night, heading to some parties, a night club, and finally
another house party at around 2:00 or 3:00 a.m. Hargrove was carrying a
gun on him that night.
At the last house party, Hargrove started dancing with another woman,
and Jovana got upset and walked out. Hargrove, Moreno, Emily, and
Maximo followed Jovana out of the house and down the street. While the
group was following Jovana, Hargrove hid his gun behind a truck tire.
Jovana was crying and everyone was trying to calm her down.
Jovana and Hargrove soon started arguing as they walked down the
street. According to Maximo, Jovana started hitting Hargrove. After about
10 minutes of the group chasing Jovana, Hargrove told Moreno, “go get my
gun.” So Moreno walked back, retrieved the gun from behind the truck tire,
placed it in his waistband, and then rejoined the group. Right after Moreno
returned, Maximo saw Hargrove grab Jovana by the neck and push her.
Maximo then left the group because “it was just too much.” He started
walking in the opposite direction and called his mother for a ride home.
Emily testified that as the couple was fighting that night, Jovana
“would push [Hargrove], and he would retaliate with slapping her or pushing
her off.” Jovana got very upset and accused Hargrove of trapping her by
getting her pregnant. She attempted to slap Hargrove in the face, but he
backhanded her across her face before she could touch him, causing her head
to turn.
Hargrove and Jovana continued arguing, and Hargrove told her that he
was done with her and was going to take her son away. Hargrove continued
grabbing Jovana by her arms and shoving her back. Emily testified that she
4
and Moreno repeatedly tried to intervene but could not “get [Hargrove] off
[Jovana]” because he “was already too upset.” Emily and Moreno told
Hargrove to leave Jovana alone because she was calming down, but he would
not. Hargrove was also repeatedly shaking Jovana with “extreme force.” He
was “egging her on,” trying to make her sound “like a lunatic.”
As the group walked down the street, Emily heard Moreno tell
Hargrove that if he did not leave Jovana alone, “I’m going to pop you,” which
Emily understood to mean shoot him. The four stopped on a street corner as
Hargrove and Jovana continued arguing. Both were saying they did not want
to be with each other anymore, and Hargrove again threatened Jovana that
she would not see her son anymore. Jovana then tried to run at Hargrove to
hit him in the face, but Hargrove backhanded her across her face again before
she could touch him, causing her to twirl and almost fall.
It was at this point Emily heard the first gunshot and turned to see
both Moreno and Hargrove running. She saw Moreno with a gun and heard
two more shots, then she ran to Jovana. Jovana screamed at Moreno to stop.
Hargrove was between two cars trying to run to Moreno, and Emily thought
“he was going to beat [] Moreno’s ass.” Moreno then turned around and shot
Hargrove again. Emily saw Moreno shoot twice and then run away after
Hargrove fell down. Hargrove got up and ran towards Jovana, then fell
again. Emily saw blood on Hargrove and called 911.
When police officers arrived at the scene of the shooting, Hargrove was
lying on his back on the ground bleeding. Jovana and Emily were both near
him; Jovana was hysterically crying and both women were screaming.
Hargrove was taken to the hospital with multiple gunshot wounds. He was
rushed to an operating room but pronounced dead about 45 minutes later.
5
At the scene, officers found six nine-millimeter casings along with
Hargrove’s cell phone. They later found Hargrove’s gun and confirmed that
all six of the casings found at the scene came from the gun.
The medical examiner found eight perforating gunshot wounds in
Hargrove’s body, with five of the entrance wounds on the front of his body
and three on the back. The examiner testified that all eight of the
perforating gunshot wounds could be accounted for even if only six bullets
were used, because two of them were aligned with other wounds and thus
likely caused by one bullet each.
After Moreno was arrested and while he was incarcerated, the police
observed a tattoo on his lower body of Hargrove’s nickname “Kece” with an
“x” through it.
B. The Defense
Moreno testified on his own behalf. He grew up with Jovana, who was
his cousin, and had a close relationship with her. Moreno met Hargrove
through Jovana, who started dating Hargrove when she was 16 years old,
and he and Hargrove became good friends. The relationship between
Hargrove and Jovana was good at first, but at some point Hargrove began
physically and mentally abusing Jovana. At first, he “would just manhandle
her,” and then later he started smacking her. Moreno witnessed Hargrove
abusing Jovana both when Hargrove was drinking and when he was sober,
and he described Hargrove as a bully who always carried a gun. Moreno
tried unsuccessfully to convince Jovana to leave Hargrove.
About a year before the shooting, Moreno and Hargrove had a falling
out after the traffic stop where Hargrove was arrested for possession of a
firearm. Hargrove posted on social media that Moreno was a snitch, and
Moreno responded by saying he saw Hargrove crying when he was being
6
handcuffed. The two stopped speaking for a few months but eventually
restored their friendship after Hargrove apologized.
Before they became friends again, Moreno and Hargrove argued via
text message about Hargrove refusing to return Moreno’s cousin’s phone after
breaking Jovana’s phone. Moreno called Hargrove a “bitch,” and Hargrove
said, “At this point, you’re causing deaths.” Moreno understood that to mean
Hargrove was going to try to kill him, one of his cousins, or all three of them,
so Moreno responded that he would “smoke” Hargrove. Hargrove responded
to the text with laughing emojis and did not take Moreno’s threat seriously.
Two days before the shooting, Moreno saw Hargrove punch Jovana in
the lip hard enough that her head cocked back. This made Moreno angry, but
he did not say anything because he was scared of Hargrove. Hargrove was
much bigger than Moreno and had his gun on him at all times.
On October 30, Moreno, Hargrove, Jovana, Emily, and Maximo were at
the house party when Jovana became angry with Hargrove for dancing with
another girl and walked out of the house. Moreno and Hargrove found
Jovana and Emily in an alley near a parking lot, where Jovana was crying.
Jovana said she wanted to leave, but Hargrove told her, “You’re not going
nowhere,” and the two began arguing. Jovana ran at Hargrove, but he
forcefully backhanded her before she got to him. Jovana never actually hit
Hargrove, but he smacked her about four times. He threw her around and
she fell a few times. At one point, she got up after falling and started
sprinting away from the group.
Moreno suggested to Hargrove that he get Jovana and Emily an Uber
to Emily’s house to get Jovana away from the situation. Hargrove responded,
“Nah, fuck that. She’s not going nowhere.” The group eventually caught up
to Jovana, who had fallen again, and Hargrove laughed at her. Jovana tried
7
to run at him again, and Hargrove slapped her a few more times. Moreno
and Emily repeatedly tried but failed to separate Hargrove and Jovana. They
also repeatedly yelled at Hargrove not to hit Jovana, but he did not stop
hitting her. At some point that night, Moreno told Hargrove: “If you touch
[Jovana] again, I’ll pop you.”
Jovana tried to run at Hargrove one more time, and Hargrove punched
her, causing her whole body to turn. This is when Moreno pulled out
Hargrove’s gun, which Hargrove had hidden and then told Moreno to retrieve
from the truck earlier in the night. Moreno was concerned for Jovana’s safety
and thought Hargrove was going to continue beating her. He pointed the gun
at Hargrove, intending to scare him. Hargrove saw the gun and came at
Moreno, trying to grab the gun. Moreno got scared, thinking that if Hargrove
took the gun from him, he would shoot Moreno, so he shot Hargrove twice.
Hargrove took two steps back, then made an angry growl and charged at
Moreno. Moreno shot two more times and then ran away. As Moreno was
running, Hargrove was catching up to him. Moreno thought Hargrove was
going to try to tackle him, take the gun from him, and shoot him, so Moreno
turned around fast and shot two more times before turning back around and
running down the street.
Moreno ran back to the house party and told a woman he did not know
that he needed a ride home and it was an emergency. She asked him why he
had a gun and told him to get rid of it, so he threw it out the window as she
was driving him home. When he arrived home, he told his parents what
happened and called the police to tell them he shot someone in self-defense.
He then drove to the police station with his parents to turn himself in. He
helped the police locate the gun and then was arrested.
8
While in custody, Moreno tattooed Hargrove’s nickname on his right
upper thigh and struck it out. He struck the name out because he was mad
at himself, Hargrove, and Jovana for the situation he was in. Moreno stated
the tattoo was a reminder of the mistakes he made and a reminder not to
make the same mistakes again.
C. Jury Instructions and Questions
At the close of evidence, the prosecution submitted a packet of proposed
jury instructions. Defense counsel did not submit any additional
instructions, stating that he thought what the prosecution submitted covered
what he needed to request. Before counsel gave their closing arguments, the
court and counsel for the parties had a final jury instruction conference
where they reviewed all of the proposed instructions, including CALCRIM
No. 640: “Deliberations and Completion of Verdict Forms: For Use When
Defendant Is Charged With First Degree Murder and Jury Is Given Not
Guilty Forms for Each Level of Homicide.” The court stated: “Then comes
640, which deals with the sequencing of their decision-making. I think that’s
okay.” No further comments regarding CALCRIM No. 640 were made during
this conference.
The trial court instructed the jury, stating at the outset: “And you will
receive from me when you go to the jury room a complete set of the
instructions in writing, so that’s arguably my most important responsibility
to make sure you are accurately, completely and correctly instructed on the
applicable law. [¶] Understanding that some of the instructions you receive
here now orally in the courtroom are in the written set, some of those
instructions may or may not apply depending on your finding concerning
what facts have been proved to you by the evidence.” The court further
9
instructed the jury: “[O]ne of the first things you should do is review in some
detail the written instructions that you will have with you . . . .”
The court then read the instructions to the jury, paraphrasing many of
them.2 Apparently by inadvertence, the court did not read CALCRIM
No. 640 to the jury along with the rest of the instructions. Neither party
objected to this omission from the court’s oral instructions.
The prosecutor then gave her closing argument. Near the end, she
stated: “Now, what the Court didn’t read to you – and I imagine that he will –
is the last instruction that you’re going to get in your packet tells you how to
deal with the verdict forms”—seemingly referencing CALCRIM No. 640. It
appears the court never gave the last instruction orally, but provided it to the
jury in written form. Neither party raised the issue again.
During deliberations, the jury sent one note to the court seeking
clarification on the law and a second note requesting testimony readback.
The jury’s first note had three questions: (1) “In considering 1st degree
murder, do we need to consider express v. implied malice?”; (2) “Is the
definition of express malice the same as willful, deliberate, and pre-
meditated?”; and (3) “Do we have to unanimously agree on expressed [sic] v.
Implied [malice] for 1st degree murder?” The court conferred with counsel for
both parties, and everyone eventually agreed with the following response:
“Responses to Jury Note #1: Question #1: Yes. See Cal Crim Instruction 520.
Question #2: No. See Cal Crim instruction 521. Question #3: No[.]”
The next morning, the prosecutor informed the trial court and defense
counsel on the record that, after researching the issue, she believed the
2 We caution the trial court against paraphrasing the standard
CALCRIM instructions. Even a minor deviation can result in an inadvertent
misstatement of the law. Courts should avoid straying from the text of the
written instructions.
10
response to the jury was an incorrect statement of law. The court agreed.
The prosecutor proposed a corrected response, which defense counsel agreed
with. The court adopted the prosecution’s proposed response and sent the
following to the jury: “FURTHER RESPONSE TO JURY NOTE #1: 1. All
murder requires you to find that the Defendant acted with malice. Malice
may be expressed or implied. A finding of first-degree murder requires a
finding of express malice as well as that it was committed willfully,
deliberately, and with premeditation. A complete statement of the elements
of murder in the first and second degree can be found in CALCRIMs in 520
and 521, read in conjunction with the entirety of jury instructions you were
provided. 2. No. See CALCRIM 520 and 521. 3. Yes. See answer #1.”
D. Jury Verdict and Sentencing
After receiving the further response to jury note number one, the jury
deliberated for a few more hours before returning a verdict. The jury found
Moreno guilty of first degree murder in violation of section 187, subdivision
(a), and found true the allegation that he had intentionally and personally
discharged a firearm proximately causing great bodily injury and death
within the meaning of section 12022.53, subdivision (d). The trial court
sentenced him to 25 years to life in prison on the murder conviction, with an
additional 25 years to life in prison imposed consecutively for the
enhancement.
DISCUSSION
Moreno contends that his conviction must be reversed because (1) the
trial court failed to read CALCRIM No. 640 to the jury; (2) the court
incorrectly stated the law in its written response to the first jury note issued
11
during deliberations; and (3) even if each error is not sufficiently prejudicial
on its own, the cumulative impact of the errors requires reversal.
Standard of Review
We review a claim of instructional error de novo. (People v. Rivera
(2019) 7 Cal.5th 306, 326.) The same standard of review applies to any
supplemental instruction given in response to a jury question. (People v.
Franklin (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 881, 887, fn. 4.)
Analysis
A. The Court Did Not Commit Prejudicial Error by Failing to Orally Instruct
Jury as to CALCRIM No. 640
Moreno’s first contention is that the trial court committed prejudicial
error when it failed to read instruction CALCRIM No. 640 aloud to the jury
along with the other instructions. The People respond that Moreno has
forfeited this argument because he failed to object to the omission or bring it
to the trial court’s attention at the time it happened, and the manner of the
instruction does not implicate his substantial rights. They further contend
that even if the argument was not forfeited, there was no error, as the jury
was provided with a written copy of CALCRIM No. 640.
We agree with the People that even if Moreno did not forfeit his
contention regarding the trial court’s failure to orally instruct the jury as to
CALCRIM No. 640, there was no prejudicial error because the correct and
complete written version of the instruction was given. For example, the
Supreme Court has concluded that a trial court’s failure to orally instruct the
jury on the rule that it could not find a defendant had committed an
unadjudicated offense based solely on uncorroborated accomplice testimony
was “of no moment” because “[t]he court gave the jury a written instruction
that properly and fully stated the law.” (People v. Bryant, Smith and Wheeler
12
(2014) 60 Cal.4th 335, 454–455 (Bryant).) The court explained: “Because
ultimately the jury was properly instructed, we cannot conclude any error
occurred . . . .” (Id. at p. 455.) The Supreme Court has also found harmless
error where a trial court orally instructed the jury with an incomplete version
of a jury instruction (People v. Garceau (1993) 6 Cal.4th 140, 189 (Garceau)
[“[t]he error was harmless, because the jury received the correct version of
CALJIC No. 3.19 in its written form”]) and where it misread a word (People v.
Crittendon (1994) 9 Cal.4th 83, 137–139 (Crittendon) [inadvertent misreading
of instruction not prejudicial where it did not omit element and jury received
correct written version of the instruction]).
In People v. Mills (2010) 48 Cal.4th 158 (Mills), the Supreme Court also
found no reversible error where a trial court misread three different jury
instructions, including one where the court inserted words into a legal
definition in the instruction and thus “told the jury the opposite of the correct
definition,” because the jury received the correct instructions in written form.
(Id. at p. 200.) The Supreme Court concluded that “[t]he risk of a discrepancy
between the orally delivered and the written instructions exists in every trial,
and verdicts are not undermined by the mere fact the trial court misspoke.”
(Ibid.) “We of course presume that jurors understand and follow the court’s
instructions. This presumption includes the written instructions. To the
extent a discrepancy exists between the written and oral versions of jury
instructions, the written instructions provided to the jury will control.” (Id.
at pp. 200–201 [cleaned up].)
These cases are controlling here. Although the trial court did not read
CALCRIM No. 640 when giving oral instructions, the jury was given a
“written instruction that properly and fully stated the law.” (Bryant, supra,
60 Cal.4th at pp. 454–455; see also Mills, supra, 48 Cal.4th at pp. 200–201
13
[where “a discrepancy exists between the written and oral versions of jury
instructions, the written instructions provided to the jury will control”].)
Moreover, the trial court told the jury: “[O]ne of the first things you should do
is review in some detail the written instructions that you will have with
you[.]” After reading the instructions aloud, the court again advised the jury
to review the written instructions: “I would urge you early on in your
deliberations to take a look at these instructions in some detail. You will
have them in writing. Take a look at them and see if you have any questions
because I certainly will make every effort to make sure you have a complete
understanding of the applicable law.” This further supports the conclusion
that there was no prejudicial error.
Moreno resists this conclusion by relying heavily on People v. Murillo
(1996) 47 Cal.App.4th 1104 (Murillo), where the Court of Appeal determined
that the reasoning of Garceau and Crittendon does “not apply where the trial
court fails to read an instruction it had said it would use.” (Murillo, at
p. 1107.) The court there concluded: “Because it is not possible to determine
if the jurors actually read their written copy of [the instruction], we must
assume they did not, and approach the case as though the instruction was
not given at all.” (Ibid.) Moreno urges us to apply the same logic here.
Murillo does not help Moreno for several reasons. First, the Murillo
court’s statement that it must assume the jury did not read their written
copy of the instruction at issue is contrary to well-settled law that we must
“ ‘credit jurors with intelligence and common sense’ . . . and presume they
generally understand and follow instructions.” (People v. McKinnon (2011)
52 Cal.4th 610, 670; see also People v. Ramos (2008) 163 Cal.App.4th 1082,
1088 [in determining where there has been error in jury instructions, we
must consider the instructions as a whole and assume that the jurors are
14
intelligent and capable of understanding and correlating all instructions
given].) Second, despite its conclusion that the court’s failure to read the
instruction was error, the Murillo court found the error harmless because, as
here, the jury was given “other instructions covering essentially the same
ground,” and courts must view the instructions given as a whole. (Murillo,
supra, 47 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1108–1109.)
Most importantly, the Murillo decision was issued several years before
the Supreme Court decided Bryant and Mills. Moreno fails to address those
holdings, which we must follow. (People v. Gonzales (1993) 20 Cal.App.4th
1607, 1610 [“As an intermediate appellate court, we are bound to follow the
precedent of our Supreme Court.”].) Instead, he vaguely argues that the
People only cite cases holding that the misreading or partial omission of an
instruction does not result in error when the jury receives a correct written
copy of the same instruction, which he claims is distinguishable from the
instant case. The Supreme Court did not distinguish between the two
scenarios, however, and we see no material difference between them. If a
trial court does not commit reversible error where it misreads multiple
instructions, arguably confusing the jury (Mills, supra, 48 Cal.4th at p. 200),
and it commits no error where it omits entire sentences from an instruction
(Garceau, supra, 6 Cal.4th at p. 189), we cannot find error where it did not
provide any incorrect instructions but merely neglected to read aloud a
correct instruction that was given to the jury in writing. This is particularly
true where the court carefully reminded the jurors to review the written
instructions early in their deliberations. Here, as in Bryant, the “court gave
the jury a written instruction that properly and fully stated the law.”
(Bryant, supra, 60 Cal.4th at p. 455.) We therefore conclude the trial court
15
did not commit prejudicial error in failing to orally instruct the jury as to
CALCRIM No. 640.
B. Moreno Forfeited His Claim that the Trial Court’s Responses to the Jury
Question Constituted Prejudicial Error
Moreno next contends the trial court erred by (1) incorrectly stating the
law in its initial written response to a jury note during deliberations, and
(2) when attempting to correct the error, failing to inform the jury it should
disregard the initial response. The People do not dispute that the court’s
initial response incorrectly stated the law, but they argue that Moreno
forfeited this argument because he agreed on both the initial response and
the amended response that was sent to the jury after the prosecutor brought
the error to the court’s attention.
We again agree with the People. The Supreme Court has repeatedly
held that where a defendant contends the trial court should have provided
additional or different instructions in response to the jury’s inquiry, “his
counsel’s acquiescence in the trial court’s response forfeits the claim of error
on appeal.” (People v. Rogers (2006) 39 Cal.4th 826, 877 (Rogers); see also
People v. Castaneda (2011) 51 Cal.4th 1292, 1352 (Castaneda) [defendant
forfeited argument on appeal regarding trial court’s purported instructional
error “by agreeing with the trial court concerning the appropriate response to
the jury’s question”]; People v. Rodrigues (1994) 8 Cal.4th 1060, 1193
(Rodrigues) [“Inasmuch as defendant both suggested and consented to the
responses given by the court, the claim of error has been waived.”].)
Here, the parties discussed the first proposed response to jury note
number one at length. The jury’s first note had three questions: (1) “In
considering 1st degree murder, do we need to consider express v. implied
malice?”; (2) “Is the definition of express malice the same as willful,
16
deliberate, and pre-meditated?”; and (3) “Do we have to unanimously agree
on expressed [sic] v. Implied [malice] for 1st degree murder?” Defense
counsel stated in response to the jury’s questions: “I think the answer is yes,
no, no.” The trial court conferred with counsel for both parties, and everyone
eventually agreed with the following response, which mirrored defense
counsel’s thoughts: “Responses to Jury Note #1: Question #1: Yes. See Cal
Crim Instruction 520. Question #2: No. See Cal Crim instruction 521.
Question #3: No[.]” Defense counsel thus agreed with the first, incorrect
response.
When the parties appeared before the court the next morning, the
prosecutor stated on the record that she believed the response to the jury was
incorrect. The court stated the jurors had been advised “that they would be
receiving further instructions from the Court” regarding their questions.
After the prosecutor read her proposed language to the court, defense counsel
stated: “Your Honor, we are in agreement with that proposed language to
correct the misstatement made yesterday.” The court thus adopted the
prosecution’s proposed response and sent the supplemental response to the
jury. Defense counsel did not object to any part of this response, nor did he
request to add any further clarification to it, including a supplemental
instruction to the jury to disregard the previous response.3 We must
therefore conclude that this “acquiescence in the trial court’s response forfeits
the claim of error on appeal.” (Rogers, supra, 39 Cal.4th at p. 877; see also
3 The court and the parties apparently believed it was self-evident that
the court’s supplemental response superseded the first response, which is
arguably supported by the fact that the supplemental response changed the
“no” answer for question 3 to a “yes” answer. Although the issue is forfeited,
we agree it would have been preferable for the trial court to explicitly instruct
the jury to disregard the first response.
17
Castaneda, supra, 51 Cal.4th at p. 1352; Rodrigues, supra, 8 Cal.4th at
p. 1193.)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
BUCHANAN, J.
WE CONCUR:
DATO, Acting P. J.
DO, J.
18
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.