Simone v. Jameson CA4/3

CourtListener 10292820Calctapp13 de dez. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 12/13/24 Simone v. Jameson CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

ELIJAH POMAIKA SIMONE,

Plaintiff and Respondent, G062695

v. (Super. Ct. No. 30-2016-00832256)

LELA JAMESON, as Personal OPINION
Representative, etc.,

Defendant and Appellant.

Appeal from a postjudgment order of the Superior Court of
Orange County, Randell L. Wilkinson, Judge. (Retired judge of the Orange
Super. Ct. assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to art. VI, § 6 of the Cal.
Const.) Affirmed. Request for judicial notice granted.
Horvitz & Levy, David M. Axelrad, John F. Querio, Gaspard
Rappoport; Cullins & Grandy and Douglas D. Cullins, for Defendant and
Appellant.
The Simon Law Group, Brad M. Simon; Williams Iagmin and Jon
R. Williams, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* * *
Bruce Jameson hit Elijah Pomaika Simone with his car, severely
injuring him. Simone’s lawsuit against Jameson in the Orange County
Superior Court (the Personal Injury Action) resulted in a judgment which
included approximately $1.6 million in prejudgment interest.
After Jameson died, Simone obtained authority from the probate
court in Arkansas to bring an action on behalf of Jameson’s estate (the
Estate) in the Los Angeles County Superior Court against Jameson’s auto
insurance provider (the Bad Faith Action). During that litigation, the parties
entered a stipulation regarding the amount of the judgment in the Personal
Injury Action, which failed to include the $1.6 million in prejudgment
interest. The parties to that action dispute whether this omission was a
mistake.
Simone subsequently applied for renewal of the judgment in the
Personal Injury Action. The Estate contends the trial court abused its
discretion by (1) denying its motion to vacate renewal of the judgment; and
(2) improperly permitting accrual of interest on the prejudgment interest
amount. We conclude these contentions lack merit and therefore affirm the
trial court’s order denying the motion to vacate renewal of the judgment.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
In April 2015, Jameson’s car struck Simone while Simone was
riding his bicycle, causing severe injury. Jameson was insured by State Farm

2
Mutual Auto Insurance Company (State Farm) with a single person liability
limit of $25,000. In January 2016, Simone filed the Personal Injury Action in
the Orange County Superior Court.
On March 28, 2017, Simone submitted a settlement offer,
pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 998, which was rejected by
Jameson.1 When Jameson passed away during the pendency of the trial, the
Estate was substituted as defendant. In August 2018, the jury returned a
verdict in Simone’s favor for $10,942,481.07.
The trial court entered a judgment in Simone’s favor for
$10,942,481.07 plus “costs and interest in [an] amount to be determined at
future hearing/s.” The memorandum of costs Simone filed included, in item
16, “other” costs in the amount of $1,600,899.96, pursuant to Civil Code
section 3291, which provides for interest on the judgment in the amount of 10
percent per annum calculated from March 28, 2017, the date Simone’s section
998 settlement offer was rejected.
The Estate did not challenge Simone’s claim for prejudgment
interest, and the trial court awarded Simone his costs, including prejudgment
interest. In May 2019, State Farm paid the costs and stated policy limit to
Simone, resulting in a remaining balance of $10,917,481.
After Jameson passed away, probate was opened in his home
state of Arkansas, and his widow, Lela Jameson, was appointed as general
administrator of the Estate. In February 2020, Simone was appointed by the
Arkansas probate court as a special administrator for the Estate to pursue an

1All further statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure unless otherwise indicated.

3
insurance bad faith action against State Farm after Lela Jameson refused to
do so or assign those rights to Simone.
Prior to trial in the Bad Faith Action, the parties stipulated that
the net verdict in Simone’s favor in the Personal Injury Action was
$10,942.481.07 and that the remaining balance after State Farm’s payments
to Simone was $10,917,481. This stipulation did not include the section 998
prejudgment interest in the amount of $1,600,899.96 which Simone was
awarded in the Personal Injury Action.
In August 2022, the court held a bench trial and found in favor of
the Estate in the amount of $10,917,481, which did not include the
$1,600,899.96 in prejudgment interest. After the trial court judge retired, the
issue of the correct prejudgment interest calculation to be included in the
judgment was disputed by the parties and briefed before another judge. The
judge declined to enter judgment not conforming to the minutes and instead
adopted State Farm’s proposed judgment which omitted the prejudgment
interest. The validity of the stipulation in the Bad Faith Action, along with
various other issues, is currently on appeal in the Second District Court of
Appeal.
Simone later filed an application for renewal of judgment in the
Personal Injury Action. This application included the section 998 pre-
judgment interest. The Estate filed a motion to vacate the renewal of
judgment, arguing, inter alia, Simone was not entitled to the section 998
prejudgment interest because the stipulation in the Bad Faith Action had
omitted it. The trial court denied the Estate’s motion to vacate renewal of the
judgment.

4
DISCUSSION
I.
RENEWAL OF THE JUDGMENT
A judgment creditor may renew a judgment upon filing a renewal
application and paying the filing fee. (§ 683.150, subd. (a); Gov. Code,
§ 70626, subd. (b)(3); Estate of Douglas (2022) 83 Cal.App.5th 690, 694–695
[renewal is a purely ministerial act that does not create a new judgment or
modify a current judgment but serves only to extend a judgment’s
enforceability].) A judgment debtor may file a noticed motion to vacate the
renewed judgment within 60 days after notice of renewal (§ 683.170, subd.
(b)) on “any ground that would be a defense to an action on the judgment,
including the ground that the amount of renewed judgment as entered
pursuant to this article is incorrect” (id., subd. (b)).
A. Standard of Review
The judgment debtor bears the burden of proving, by a
preponderance of the evidence, that he or she is entitled to vacation of
renewal of the judgment. (Fidelity Creditor Service, Inc. v. Browne (2001) 89
Cal.App.4th 195, 199 (Fidelity).)
An order denying a motion to vacate renewal of a judgment is
appealable as an order after an appealable judgment. (§ 904.1, subd. (a)(2);
Jonathan Neil & Associates v. Jones (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 1481, 1487.) On
appeal, we review the denial of the motion to vacate for abuse of discretion,
taking the evidence in a light most favorable to the court’s decision. (Fidelity,
supra, 89 Cal.App.4th at p. 199.) We defer to the trial court’s resolution of
any factual conflicts in the evidence. (Rubin v. Ross (2021) 65 Cal.App.5th
153, 161.) Questions of law are reviewed de novo. (Ibid.)

5
B. The Trial Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion
The Estate appeals the trial court’s denial of its motion to vacate
renewal of the judgment in the Personal Injury Action. The Estate argues
Simone was not entitled to prejudgment interest in the amount of
$1,600,899.96 when renewing the judgment because he stipulated to a
judgment in the Bad Faith Action which precluded it. The Estate contends
the trial court’s denial of its motion to vacate the renewal of the judgment
was therefore an abuse of discretion. We disagree.
Here, the trial court reasonably concluded the Estate failed to
meet its burden by a preponderance of the evidence to demonstrate
entitlement to vacation of the renewal of judgment. The trial court noted the
judgment in the Personal Injury Action specifically awarded Simone
prejudgment interest accruing from March 28, 2017, the date he served a
statutory offer to compromise which the Estate had rejected. The trial court
further noted the Estate “had an opportunity to challenge that interest but
failed to do so” in its motion to tax costs. Therefore, there was no valid basis
to challenge the renewal of judgment, and the trial court correctly found
Simone “properly included the interest in the application for renewal of
judgment.” Based on this record, we cannot say the trial court abused its
discretion.
Moreover, the scope and effect of a pretrial stipulation entered
into between different parties in a separate action, based on a different
theory of liability, and pending in another appellate district is, to say the
least, not properly before us. We decline to address issues whose resolution
are unnecessary to deciding this appeal. (Shaw v. County of Santa Cruz
(2008) 170 Cal.App.4th 229, 259 [“we do not see these matters as necessary to
our appellate decision and we accordingly decline to resolve them”].)

6
Therefore, we affirm the trial court’s denial of the Estate’s motion
to vacate renewal of the judgment.
II.
INTEREST ON THE PREJUDGMENT INTEREST
The Estate also argues the trial court erred in permitting the
accrual of compound interest on the prejudgment interest portion of the
renewed judgment, in violation of Civil Code section 3291. Not so. A review of
the trial court’s order demonstrates its ruling is correct.
As our Supreme Court has concluded, “Prejudgment interest
accrued under Civil Code section 3291 is not part of the judgment, and a
plaintiff may not obtain interest on this prejudgment interest.” (Hess v. Ford
Motor Co. (2002) 27 Cal.4th 516, 533.) Thus, prejudgment interest is not
added to the final judgment amount in order to avoid postjudgment interest
accruing on Civil Code section 3291 prejudgment interest. Accordingly, the
statute does not permit any compounding of interest, that is, interest on
interest.
Simone argues he never sought interest on the prejudgment
interest and the trial court’s order granting renewal of the judgment never
awarded such compound interest. Simone contends the court’s order correctly
applied section 998 and Civil Code section 3291 to confirm that the accrual
date for simple interest, at the rate of 10 percent per annum, was March 28,
2017. Moreover, the amount of the underlying judgment in the Personal
Injury Action was the same both before and after Simone’s motion to renew.
We agree with Simone that the trial court did not erroneously approve
compound interest on the prejudgment interest amount.
Furthermore, the Estate did not properly preserve this issue for
appeal. In its motion to tax costs in the Personal Injury Action, the Estate

7
failed to contest either the award of prejudgment interest to Simone, or that
such interest began to accrue on March 28, 2017, when his section 998 offer
was rejected. In fact, the Estate abandoned an appeal of the judgment and
never subsequently challenged any aspect of the award of interest. An
appellate court will generally not reverse a judgment where the issue was not
raised in the first instance at trial. (JRS Products, Inc. v. Matsushita Electric
Corp. of America (2004) 115 Cal.App.4th 168, 178.) We therefore reject this
claim of error.
DISPOSITION
We affirm the trial court’s postjudgment order denying the
Estate’s motion to vacate renewal of the judgment.
On November 21, 2023, Lela Jameson filed a motion for judicial
notice of records filed in the Bad Faith Action in the Los Angeles County
Superior Court Case no. 20STCV14579. A court may take judicial notice of
“[r]ecords of . . . any court of this state.” (Evid. Code, § 452, subd. (d).)
Accordingly, the motion for judicial notice is granted.

SANCHEZ, J.
WE CONCUR:

GOETHALS, ACTING P. J.

DELANEY, J.

8

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.