CourtListener 10292378•Mitchell v. William Warren Group CA2/2
Texto completo
Filed 12/12/24 Mitchell v. William Warren Group CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
OLIVER B. MITCHELL III, B335504
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 23STCV10822)
WILLIAM WARREN GROUP, ORDER MODIFYING
INC., OPINION AND DENYING
REHEARING
Defendant and
Respondent. NO CHANGE IN THE
JUDGMENT
THE COURT:
It is ordered that the opinion filed herein on November 21, 2024,
be modified as follows:
1. On page two, under the “Procedural Background”
heading, replace the first full paragraph, beginning
“Plaintiff sued the Group,” with:
Plaintiff sued the Group in April 2022 (the original
complaint). In January 2023, the trial court
sustained the Group’s demurrer and motion to strike
plaintiff’s complaint on the ground that it failed to
allege sufficient facts on several elements critical to
state each cause of action. Plaintiff was given an
opportunity to amend his complaint to allege the
necessary facts, but he failed to file any amended
pleading and, in May 2023, the trial court “dismissed
[the action] without prejudice” “pursuant to” Code of
Civil Procedure section 581, subdivision (f).
2. At the end of the last sentence of the above-inserted
paragraph, insert the following footnote:
All further statutory references are to the Code of
Civil Procedure unless otherwise indicated.
3. On page two, in the first sentence of the paragraph
beginning “Three days after,” delete “May 2023” before
“dismissal” and insert “order” after “dismissal,” so that
the sentence reads:
Three days after that dismissal order, plaintiff sued
the Group again.
2
4. On page two, in the second sentence of the paragraph
beginning “Three days after,” which begins “Plaintiff’s
119-paragraph complaint,” replace “prior lawsuit” with
“original complaint,” so that the beginning of the
sentence reads:
Plaintiff’s 119-paragraph complaint (the new
complaint) alleged the same eight claims as in the
original complaint—namely, . . .
5. On page three, replace the first sentence of the
paragraph beginning “In June 2023,” with:
The Group filed a demurrer again, as well as a
motion to strike the punitive damages allegations.
6. On page three, replace the third sentence of the
paragraph beginning “In June 2023,” which begins “The
court reasoned,” with:
The court reasoned that because the bulk of the new
complaint’s allegations copied those in the original
complaint that was dismissed, res judicata precluded
re-litigation of those allegations.
7. On page three, in the fourth sentence of the paragraph
beginning “In June 2023,” which begins “The court
nevertheless,” replace “last case” with “original
complaint” and add “also” between “were” and
“insufficient,” so that the full sentence reads:
3
The court nevertheless recognized that the new
complaint alleged two acts occurring after the
original complaint was filed and that the res judicata
bar did not apply to those acts; while the allegations
of these acts were also insufficient by themselves to
state any of the eight claims in the new complaint,
the court recognized that those allegations might
support other claims and granted plaintiff leave to
amend to articulate those other claims.
8. On pages three and four, in the first sentence of the
paragraph beginning “After the 30-day window,” add
“new” between “plaintiff’s” and “complaint,” delete “Code
of Civil Procedure” after “pursuant to,” and delete the
footnote appearing at the end of the sentence, so that
the full sentence reads:
After the 30-day window closed, the Group filed an ex
parte application seeking dismissal of plaintiff’s new
complaint pursuant to section 581, subdivision (f)(2).
9. On page four, in the last sentence of the first paragraph,
which begins “When plaintiff did not appear,” add “new”
between “plaintiff’s” and “complaint,” so that the full
sentence reads:
When plaintiff did not appear at the continued
hearing despite being properly served with notice of
the new hearing’s date and time, the trial court
4
granted the application and dismissed plaintiff’s new
complaint with prejudice.
10. On page four, in the first sentence of the third
paragraph under the “Discussion” heading beginning “A
trial court may dismiss,” add “or granted a motion to
strike” after “sustained a demurrer,” so that the full
sentence reads:
A trial court may dismiss a complaint with prejudice
if it has sustained a demurrer or granted a motion to
strike with leave to amend and the plaintiff does not
file an amended complaint within the allotted time.
11. On page four, in the citation following the first
sentence of the third paragraph under the “Discussion”
heading, delete “(2)” after “581, subd. (f),” and add
“(Cano)” after “Cano v. Glover (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th
326,” so that the full citation sentence reads:
(§ 581, subd. (f); Cano v. Glover (2006) 143
Cal.App.4th 326, 329-330 (Cano); Leader v. Health
Industries of America, Inc. (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th 603,
613-614.)
12. On page four, in the first sentence of the paragraph
beginning “First plaintiff argues,” replace “in the first
place” with “to his new complaint,” so that the full
sentence reads:
5
First, plaintiff argues that the trial court
“misapplied” the doctrine of res judicata when
sustaining the demurrer to his new complaint; had
the demurrer been overruled, plaintiff continues, he
would never have been required to file an amended
complaint.
13. On page five, in the first full sentence of the first
paragraph, beginning “Although plaintiff’s attack,” add
“to the allegations cut-and-pasted from the original
complaint while declining to apply res judicata to the
‘new or additional facts’ set forth in the new complaint”
to the end of the sentence, so that the full sentence
reads:
Although plaintiff’s attack on the underlying
demurrer ruling is cognizable (Shaw v. Los Angeles
Unified School Dist. (2023) 95 Cal.App.5th 740, 753),
it falters on the merits because the trial court
correctly applied res judicata to the allegations cut-
and-pasted from the original complaint while
declining to apply res judicata to the “new or
additional facts” set forth in the new complaint.
14. On page five, in the sentence beginning “There is no
dispute that” in the first paragraph, replace “operative
complaint in the prior litigation” with “original
complaint,” so that the full sentence reads:
6
There is no dispute that the original complaint and
the new complaint involve the same causes of action
between the same parties.
15. On page five, replace the last sentence of the first
paragraph, beginning “Thus, the trial court correctly
applied” with the following:
To be sure, and as noted in plaintiff’s petition for
rehearing, the order dismissing the original
complaint states that it was “dismissed without
prejudice” and “[a] dismissal without prejudice . . . is
not a bar to another action by the plaintiff on the
same cause.” (Gagnon Co. v. Nevada Desert Inn, Inc.
(1995) 45 Cal.2d 448, 455; Williams v. City of
Oakland (1973) 30 Cal.App.3d 64, 69.) But dismissal
of plaintiff’s original complaint without prejudice
was, as a matter of law, not permitted when he failed
to amend his pleading following a demurrer for
failure to allege sufficient facts to state a cause of
action and a successful motion to strike. Pursuant to
section 581, subdivision (f)—the provision expressly
cited by the trial court in the dismissal order—once
the court exercised its discretion to dismiss plaintiff’s
original complaint, dismissal with prejudice was
required. (Cano, supra, 143 Cal.App.4th at pp. 329-
330; Wells, at p. 789; Haidet v. Del Mar Woods
Homeowners Assn. (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 530, 536
[“if a court exercises discretion to dismiss, it must do
so with prejudice”]; see also Kruss v. Booth (2010) 185
7
Cal.App.4th 699, 713, fn. 14 [describing Cano as “a
gloss on” section 581, subdivision (f) which, unlike the
other subdivisions, is silent as to dismissal with or
without prejudice].) Thus, res judicata applied to the
allegations repeated from the (effectively)
prejudicially dismissed, original complaint in the new
complaint.
16. On page five, in the first sentence of the paragraph
beginning “Second, plaintiff argues,” delete “October 16,
2023” before “order sustaining the demurrer” and add
“to his new complaint” between “sustaining the
demurrer” and “with leave to amend,” so that the full
sentence reads:
Second, plaintiff argues that the trial court erred in
denying his 41-page motion to reconsider the order
sustaining the demurrer to his new complaint
without leave to amend; had it been granted, plaintiff
continues, he would never have been required to file
an amended complaint.
* * *
There is no change in the judgment.
Appellant’s petition for rehearing is denied.
8
——————————————————————————————
ASHMANN-GERST, Acting P.J. CHAVEZ, J. HOFFSTADT, J.
9
Filed 11/21/24 Mitchell v. William Warren Group CA2/2 (unmodified opinion)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
OLIVER B. MITCHELL III, B335504
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 23STCV10822)
WILLIAM WARREN GROUP,
INC.,
Defendant and
Respondent.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Cherol Nellon, Judge. Affirmed.
Oliver B. Mitchell III, in pro. per., for Plaintiff and
Appellant.
Bremer, Whyte, Brown & O’Meara, Kyle P. Carroll, and
Sukayna Jaidi for Defendant and Respondent.
******
Oliver B. Mitchell III (plaintiff) argues that the trial court
erred in dismissing his complaint with prejudice when he did not
file an amended complaint after the court granted him leave to do
so following the sustaining of a demurrer. This ruling was not an
abuse of discretion, so we affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Facts
In November 2019, plaintiff signed a monthly rental
contract with StorQuest for a 5-foot by 10-foot storage unit.
StorQuest is the business name used by William Warren Group,
Inc. (the Group). He owed $136 per month.
When a Los Angeles city ordinance went into effect in the
early days of the COVID-19 pandemic that placed a moratorium
on evictions, plaintiff stopped paying rent in August 2020. By
May 2022, plaintiff owed $3,257 in unpaid rent; by October 2023,
that amount had risen to $6,509.15.
II. Procedural Background
Plaintiff sued the Group in 2022, and the trial court
dismissed the operative complaint without prejudice when
plaintiff opted not to file an amended complaint after the court
sustained a demurrer with leave to amend.
Three days after that May 2023 dismissal, plaintiff sued
the Group again. Plaintiff’s 119-paragraph complaint (the new
complaint) alleged the same eight claims as in the prior lawsuit—
namely, (1) sexual harassment under the Unruh Act (Civ. Code, §
51), (2) sex discrimination under the Unruh Act (ibid.), (3) gender
2
violence (id., § 52.4), (4) breach of contract, (5) negligence, (6)
conversion, (7) civil conspiracy, and (8) intentional infliction of
emotional distress. Plaintiff sought compensatory and punitive
damages as well as declaratory and injunctive relief.
In June 2023, the Group filed a demurrer to the new
complaint as well as a motion to strike its punitive damages
allegations. After a full round of briefing and a hearing, the trial
court in October 2023 sustained the demurrer with leave to
amend. The court reasoned that the bulk of the new complaint’s
allegations copied those in the previously dismissed complaint
and that res judicata precluded re-litigation of those allegations.
The court nevertheless recognized that the new complaint alleged
two acts occurring after the last case was filed and that the res
judicata bar did not apply to those acts; while the allegations of
these acts were insufficient by themselves to state any of the
eight claims in the new complaint, the court recognized that
those allegations might support other claims and granted
plaintiff leave to amend to articulate those other claims. The
court granted plaintiff 30 days to file an amended complaint. In
light of this disposition, the court simultaneously denied as moot
plaintiff’s earlier-filed motion to amend the new complaint to add
a claim seeking to rescind a settlement agreement plaintiff
signed in this case.
Twenty-one days later, plaintiff filed a motion asking the
trial court to reconsider its ruling on the demurrer, which the
trial court denied. Plaintiff did not file an amended complaint
within 30 days of the demurrer ruling.
After the 30-day window closed, the Group filed an ex parte
application seeking dismissal of plaintiff’s complaint pursuant to
3
Code of Civil Procedure section 581, subdivision (f)(2).1 When
plaintiff did not appear at the scheduled hearing despite being
properly served, the trial court continued the hearing for a week.
When plaintiff did not appear at the continued hearing despite
being properly served with notice of the new hearing’s date and
time, the trial court granted the application and dismissed
plaintiff’s complaint with prejudice.
Plaintiff filed this timely appeal.
DISCUSSION
Plaintiff’s chief argument on appeal is that the trial court
erred in dismissing his new complaint with prejudice.
This argument lacks merit.
A trial court may dismiss a complaint with prejudice if it
has sustained a demurrer with leave to amend and the plaintiff
does not file an amended complaint within the allotted time. (§
581, subd. (f)(2); Cano v. Glover (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 326, 329-
330; Leader v. Health Industries of America, Inc. (2001) 89
Cal.App.4th 603, 613-614.) We review such a dismissal for an
abuse of discretion. (Gitmed v. General Motors Corp. (1994) 26
Cal.App.4th 824, 827.) Because it is undisputed that plaintiff did
not file an amended complaint within the allotted time, the court
acted squarely within its discretion in dismissing the new
complaint with prejudice.
Plaintiff resists this conclusion with what boils down to
four further arguments.
First, plaintiff argues that the trial court “misapplied” the
doctrine of res judicata when sustaining the demurrer in the first
place; had the demurrer been overruled, plaintiff continues, he
1 All further statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure unless otherwise indicated.
4
would never have been required to file an amended complaint.
Although plaintiff’s attack on the underlying demurrer ruling is
cognizable (Shaw v. Los Angeles Unified School Dist. (2023) 95
Cal.App.5th 740, 753), it falters on the merits because the trial
court correctly applied res judicata. The species of res judicata
relevant here—namely, claim preclusion—“‘prevents relitigation’”
in a second suit “involv[ing] (1) the same cause of action (2)
between the same parties (3) after a final judgment on the merits
in the first suit.” (DKN Holdings LLC v. Faerber (2015) 61
Cal.4th 813, 824-825.) There is no dispute that the operative
complaint in the prior litigation and the new complaint involve
the same causes of action between the same parties. A prior
dismissal for failure to file an amended pleading after sustaining
a demurrer constitutes a preclusive “‘judgment on the merits to
the extent that [the demurrer] adjudicates that the facts alleged
do not constitute a cause of action,’” but not to the extent that
‘“new or additional facts are alleged that cure the defects’” in that
prior pleading. (Wells v. Marina City Properties, Inc. (1981) 29
Cal.3d 781, 789.) Thus, the trial court correctly applied res
judicata to the allegations adjudicated in the prior lawsuit while
declining to apply res judicata to the “new or additional facts” set
forth in the new complaint.
Second, plaintiff argues that the trial court erred in
denying his 41-page motion to reconsider the October 16, 2023
order sustaining the demurrer with leave to amend; had it been
granted, plaintiff continues, he would never have been required
to file an amended complaint. This argument also falters on the
merits. The court ruled that plaintiff’s motion for reconsideration
was untimely (because it was filed more than 10 days after the
challenged ruling), and not a proper motion for reconsideration
5
because it “simply re-argue[d] the demurrer” rather than
presenting new facts or new law, as required by section 1008.
Plaintiff does not challenge either of those findings; nor could he,
as they are both correct. Instead, plaintiff urges that the court
erred in reading only the first 15 pages of his 40-page motion.
This was consistent with the Rule of Court limiting such motions
to 15 pages. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.1113(d).) What is more,
nothing in the last 25 pages alters the motion’s untimeliness or
its failure to do anything beyond re-argue the demurrer.
Third, plaintiff argues that the trial court did not “afford[]”
him “an opportunity to correct any potential deficiency through
an amended complaint,” and thereby violated due process, equal
protection, and the First Amendment. We need not delve into the
complexities of his constitutional claims because their factual
premise is incorrect. The record unequivocally establishes that
plaintiff was afforded an opportunity to “correct any potential
deficiency through an amended complaint.” He simply elected
not to use it.
Fourth and finally, plaintiff argues that the trial court
violated due process because the court had “conspicuous animus
towards” him and “seemed impulsive.” For support, plaintiff cites
the fact that the court ruled against him on the merits. Because
adverse rulings are not, without more, evidence of judicial bias
(e.g., Brown v. American Bicycle Group, LLC (2014) 224
Cal.App.4th 665, 674), plaintiff’s argument is without any factual
foundation.
6
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. The Group is entitled to its costs
on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS.
______________________, J.
HOFFSTADT
We concur:
_________________________, Acting P. J.
ASHMANN-GERST
_________________________, J.
CHAVEZ
7
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.