CourtListener 10291331•In re J.V. CA5
Texto completo
Filed 12/10/24 In re J.V. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re J.V., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.
STANISLAUS COUNTY COMMUNITY F087670
SERVICES AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. JVDP-23-000129)
Plaintiff and Appellant,
v. OPINION
L.H. et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Stanislaus County. Annette Rees,
Judge.
Thomas E. Boze, County Counsel, and Mark Gabriel R. Doronio, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Michelle L. Jarvis, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Respondent L.H.
Jacob I. Olson, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Respondent J.V.
-ooOoo-
Appellant Stanislaus County Community Services Agency (agency) appeals from
the juvenile court’s order at a six-month review hearing held pursuant to Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.21, subdivision (e).1 As recommended by the agency, the
juvenile court ordered additional family reunification services for L.H., (mother) as to her
child, J.V. (the child). However, the agency contends the court erred when it failed to
find that the agency made reasonable efforts to return the child home for part of the six-
month review period. Mother requests that we dismiss the appeal for lack of standing
because the agency cannot show how it has been aggrieved by the court’s order. We
reverse the juvenile court’s finding that reasonable efforts were not made by the agency
and affirm the other findings.
PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL SUMMARY
Initial Removal
In July 2023, the agency received a referral shortly after the child’s birth alleging
that mother tested positive for illegal substances throughout her pregnancy. At the time
of the referral, mother had an open family reunification case for his sibling, N.V.2
Mother and the child tested negative for substances at the time of the delivery.
The social worker assigned to N.V.’s reunification case reported that mother tested
positive for methamphetamine in November 2022, December 2022, May 2023, and June
2023. N.V. was removed in March 2023 due to concerns for medical neglect and
substance abuse by mother and the child’s father, Jesus V. (father). The child’s two older
siblings were also removed in March 2023 while they were living with mother under a
family maintenance plan.
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2 We grant the agency’s April 16, 2024 request for judicial notice of the records
from N.V.’s companion case No. F087568. (Evid. Code, §§ 451, subd. (a), 459.) Both
appeals involve the same factual background and legal argument.
2.
Emergency response social workers from the agency responded to the hospital to
make contact with mother and the child. Mother did not appear to know how to care for
the child, and she was not quick to react when the child starts choking. Hospital staff
indicated that father appeared to be on drugs because he was yelling and being
aggressive. Mother was confrontational throughout the interview, and she denied that she
used any drugs during her pregnancy. Mother was living in emergency shelters, and she
was unable to provide a safe alternative plan for the child. The child was taken into
protective custody pursuant to a warrant, and he was placed in a resource family home
with N.V.
The agency filed an original petition alleging the child was described by section
300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (j). The petition alleged the child was at substantial risk of
suffering serious physical harm due to mother and father’s substance abuse. The petition
further alleged that the child was at substantial risk of neglect based upon mother and
father’s previous neglect of siblings that resulted in dependency proceedings in 2017,
2020, and 2023.
At a continued detention hearing held on July 31, 2023, the juvenile court ordered
the child detained from mother and father’s custody, and a combined jurisdiction and
disposition hearing was set for August 31, 2023.
Jurisdiction and Disposition
The agency’s jurisdiction and disposition report recommended the allegations in
the original petition be found true and family reunification services be provided to mother
and father. Mother’s social history described her as a 26-year-old high school graduate,
who was currently unemployed. She denied having any difficulties in school, and she
hoped to attend college to become a therapist or ultrasound technician. Mother admitted
to past marijuana use, but she denied using any other drugs.
The report documented the agency’s reasonable efforts to assist mother in
overcoming the problems that led to the child’s removal. On July 28, 2023, mother was
3.
provided with referrals for a domestic violence assessment, individual counseling,
parenting education, parent child labs, and an anger management assessment. Mother
was already connected to a mental health clinician for N.V.’s case. On August 9, 2023,
mother’s clinician explained that she was consulting with her supervisor about
recommending a psychological evaluation. Hair follicle tests from August 15, 2023,
revealed a positive result for methamphetamine, and mother missed multiple substance
abuse assessments.
Mother’s proposed case plan included completing individual counseling, a clinical
assessment, couples counseling, a substance abuse assessment, and drug testing. The
agency was concerned that mother did not understand the agency’s concerns and her
children’s needs, and it was anticipating a recommendation for a psychological evaluation
from mother’s clinical assessment.
On August 25, 2023, the agency submitted additional information, which included
the clinical assessment recommending a psychological evaluation. The assessment noted
that mother provided conflicting answers and resisted the assessment process. The
evaluator determined that she had a pattern of angry outbursts when responding to
questions. The assessment recommended that mother complete anger management and a
psychological evaluation to determine whether she could benefit from further services.
At the jurisdiction and disposition hearing held on August 31, 2023, mother was
present and represented by counsel. The juvenile court found the allegations in the
original petition true, removed the child from the parents’ custody, and ordered family
reunification services for mother and father. The court approved the reunification case
plan, which required mother to complete individual counseling, a psychological
evaluation, couples counseling, substance abuse assessment, and drug testing. A six-
month review hearing was set for February 13, 2024.
4.
Six-Month Review Period
In its report for the six-month review hearing, filed January 31, 2024, the agency
recommended that family reunification services be continued for mother and terminated
for father. The child remained placed in a resource family home with his older sibling,
N.V. Mother missed several individual counseling sessions, and she was refusing to do
in-person sessions with her clinician. Her clinician noted that mother became verbally
aggressive when the clinician advised her to be in a confidential session for her phone
sessions. Couples counseling did not begin because mother and father were no longer an
intact couple. Mother refused substance abuse services despite a positive hair follicle test
for methamphetamine in August 2023. She tested negative for all substances during four
random drug tests from August 2023 through January 2024.
The social worker completed monthly contacts with mother, and the objectives and
responsibilities of mother’s case plan were discussed each time. Mother was provided
with a planner and pens to help manage dates and appointments. A referral was
submitted to intensive family reunification services on mother’s behalf, but the referral
was closed because mother was not responsive. Mother’s progress was described as
poor, and the agency did not know if mother could successfully address her mental health
issues. Mother often reported being stressed and overwhelmed. The agency
recommended termination of mother’s family reunification services because she did not
demonstrate that she could make changes to mitigate risks to the child.
The report for the psychological evaluation was completed on December 14, 2023,
by Dr. Tiffany Anderson, who is a psychologist. The clinical interviews of mother were
completed by Dr. Anderson on October 24, 2023, and November 22, 2023. During the
evaluation, mother’s thought process was often tangential and required several follow-up
questions to gather sufficient information. Mother also appeared to be irritated or
frustrated at times.
5.
An intelligence assessment indicated that mother’s cognitive functioning was
extremely low, and her reading comprehension was comparable to a fourth grader.
Mother explained that she had an individualized education plan as a child for “ADHD,
anxiety, and seizures.” She admitted to past marijuana use, but she claimed that she was
clean for “many months.” Her childhood was described as traumatic due to ongoing
physical abuse and neglect by her father, but mother exhibited few posttraumatic stress
symptoms. There were invalid results on the standardized measure to assess different
mental health concerns, which prevented Dr. Anderson from assigning any mental health
diagnoses.
Dr. Anderson provided mother a provisional diagnosis of “Intellectual Disability,
Mild.” The diagnosis was based upon mother’s difficulty understanding questions during
the evaluation, special education services as a child, and “extremely low” cognitive
abilities. Additional testing and communication with close personal contacts of mother
was necessary to verify the severity of her disability. A comprehensive evaluation
through the local regional center was recommended to gain additional insight into her
likely intellectual disability and determine her eligibility for services. Such services had
the potential to give mother the additional support needed to parent successfully.
The evaluation recommended that mother’s service providers consider adjusting
their communication styles to meet mother’s needs. This adjustment would increase the
likelihood that mother could learn and retain important information. It was also
recommended that mother be given a substantial amount of time to learn and demonstrate
her skills. Dr. Anderson indicated that mother’s case plan had not been tailored to her
specific needs as a parent with an intellectual disability. The case plan needed to be
modified with the understanding that services may need to be in place for longer than
typically expected. Infant mental health services were also recommended to help prepare
mother for parenting a young child.
6.
In December 2023, a new referral was sent for intensive family reunification
services, and a parent partner was assigned to mother. The report noted that the agency
proactively engaged with mother’s service providers once it learned of mother’s need for
more tailored services. In January 2024, mother’s clinician reported that mother became
frustrated multiple times when she tried to explain and correct any misconceptions or
miscommunications. After further prompts, mother responded, “I know how to take my
children for their [appointments], don’t talk to me like I’m a retard.”
At the six-month review hearing held on February 13, 2024, mother was present
and represented by counsel. The agency’s counsel submitted on the six-month review
hearing report and requested that the court find that reasonable services were provided.
The child’s counsel submitted on the recommendation, but she indicated that she would
be opposed to additional services if mother still struggled to make progress by the next
review hearing. Mother’s counsel requested that the court make a finding that reasonable
services were not provided to be consistent with N.V.’s case. She acknowledged that
mother was connected with an intensive family reunification worker and was working
hard to address her issues.
The court allowed the agency’s counsel to provide an update on the changes to
mother’s case plan in relation to mother’s “cognitive difficulties.” Counsel for the
agency represented that everything recommended in the psychological evaluation was
implemented in both the child’s case and N.V.’s case. The cases involved the same social
worker, and the agency wanted both case plans to look similar because the children were
similar ages and on a similar timeline for reunification. The agency implemented
following services once the psychological evaluation came out: regional center
application assistance, parent partner to help with medical appointments, and
communication with mother’s mental health clinician about the evaluation results.
The juvenile court allowed mother’s counsel to respond to the agency, and her
counsel requested that the court find reasonable services were not provided until the case
7.
plan was modified for the psychological evaluation recommendations. The juvenile court
agreed, and it ruled as follows, “It does appear that although for the bulk of this reporting
period I would not find reasonable services given the results of the psych eval on mom,
however, beginning December 14, 2023, the Agency immediately embarked on shoring
up those referrals and encumbrances, and I would find from that date forward there is
evidence of reasonable services.”
After its ruling, the juvenile court adopted the agency’s recommendation to
continue family reunification services for mother, and it modified the recommended
findings to state that the agency complied with the case plan by making reasonable efforts
to make it possible for the child to safely return home beginning December 14, 2023. A
12-month review hearing was set for August 6, 2024, and father’s family reunification
services were terminated.
The agency’s counsel entered an objection to the finding, and he requested that the
finding for reasonable services apply to the entire period. The juvenile court noted the
agency’s objection, and it concluded by stating, “I certainly don’t find any bad faith
action on the part of the Agency, but once those results of the psych eval were reviewed,
that the services -- immediately services needed to be reasonably tailored given
[mother]’s situation. But certainly from December 14th forward.”
DISCUSSION
A. Standing
The agency contends that the juvenile court erred when it refused to find that
reasonable services were provided for the entire six-month review period. Mother argues
the agency was not aggrieved by the juvenile court’s order.3 Thus, she claims the agency
lacks standing to appeal the orders from the six-month review hearing. In support of her
3 Father joined the argument made in mother’s respondent’s brief in lieu of filing a
separate brief.
8.
contention, she requests that we take judicial notice of a May 7, 2024 minute order from
N.V.’s case where the juvenile court made “interim IV-E findings” pending the next
hearing. We grant mother’s request for judicial notice filed on May 31, 2024, but we
disagree that the finding impacts the agency’s standing to appeal the reasonable services
finding.4
“ ‘ “In juvenile dependency proceedings, as in civil actions generally [citation],
only a party aggrieved by the [order or] judgment has standing to appeal. [Citations.]” ’
[Citations.] ‘To be aggrieved, a party must have a legally cognizable interest that is
injuriously affected by the court’s decision.’ ” (In re D.M. (2012) 205 Cal.App.4th 283,
293, 294.) Standing to appeal is construed liberally, and doubts are resolved in its favor.
(In re K.C. (2011) 52 Cal. 4th 231, 236, 255.) For purposes of standing, an aggrieved
person “is one whose rights or interests are injuriously affected by the decision in an
immediate and substantial way, and not as a nominal or remote consequence of the
decision.” (Ibid.)
To determine whether the agency was aggrieved by the juvenile court’s order, we
must first examine the role of the agency in the instant proceedings. “ ‘The county’s
social services agency plays a “hybrid” role in dependency proceedings, exercising both
executive and judicial functions.’ ” (In re M.C. (2011) 199 Cal.App.4th 784, 809.) In its
role as an arm of the court, the county social services agency “provides essential
information to the court.” (In re Ashley M. (2003) 114 Cal.App.4th 1, 7.) In particular, it
“prepare[s] social study reports and make[s] recommendations to assist the court,” (M.C.,
supra, 199 Cal.App.4th at p. 810), including recommendations regarding the plan for
return of the child to their parents and for achieving legal permanence if efforts to reunify
4 The appellate court moreover may take judicial notice of the records of any court
of this state, provided that each party has a reasonable opportunity to address the
propriety of taking judicial notice and the tenor of notice to be taken. (Evid. Code, §§
459, subd. (a)–(c), 452, subd. (d))
9.
fail. (§ 358.1, subd. (b).) In exercising its duties, the county social services agency “ ‘
“stands in loco parentis to the minor in a proceeding whose primary consideration is the
minor’s welfare.” ’ ” (In re Jennifer G. (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 752, 759.)
In addition, a social services agency “assumes a role akin to the prosecutor in ... a
juvenile delinquency proceeding. [Citations.] In that role, the social services agency
generally is responsible for initiating dependency proceedings on a minor’s behalf.” (In
re G.B. (2018) 28 Cal.App.5th 475, 487.) When a child is removed from their parent
during a dependency proceeding, the juvenile court is generally required to order the
agency to provide reunification services to the child and parent. (§ 361.5, subd. (a); see
also § 362, subd. (d).) At each review hearing, the juvenile court must determine the
extent of the agency’s compliance with the case plan in making reasonable efforts.
(§ 366, subd. (a)(1)(B).)
A court has discretionary authority under section 352 to extend reunification
services beyond the 18-month review period where “deprivation of reasonable services”
impedes the court’s ability to properly evaluate the prospects for family reunification.
(Michael G. v. Superior Court (2023) 14 Cal.5th 609, 636.) Furthermore, to be eligible to
receive federal foster care maintenance payments (42 U.S.C. §§ 671(a)(15), 672, 674),
agencies must make reasonable efforts “to effect the safe reunification” of families. (45
C.F.R. 1356.21(b).)5
Given the agency’s statutory duty to make recommendations to the juvenile court
regarding reunification, its financial obligation to make reasonable efforts to reunify the
child and mother during the reunification period, and its duty to consider the child’s need
for prompt resolution, we conclude the agency had a cognizable interest that was
5 Absent a statutory exception, federal law requires state plans for their foster care
system to provide that “reasonable efforts shall be made to preserve and reunify
families.” (42 U.S.C. § 671(a)(15)(B).) These efforts include the provision of
reunification services. (42 U.S.C. §§ 629, 629a(a)(7).)
10.
injuriously affected by the orders in this case. An erroneous finding that reasonable
services were not provided would have an adverse impact on the agency’s ability to
request termination of reunification services at a subsequent review hearing while
standing in loco parentis to the child. (See In re D.R. (2010) 185 Cal.App.4th 852, 859
[the agency had a cognizable legal interest that was injuriously affected when the juvenile
court denied the agency’s motion to terminate de facto parent status].)
The result requested by mother would prevent the agency from correcting an
improper finding that reasonable services were not provided despite that finding’s ability
to support an extension of services at a future review hearing. (See In re T.G. (2010) 188
Cal.App.4th 687, 696 [Father permitted to challenge reasonable services finding based
upon the adverse consequences that finding would pose at future review hearings.].) The
fact that the juvenile court made interim findings related to the agency’s federal funding
under Title IV-E Social Security Act, title 42 United States Code sections 670-679c in
N.V.’s case does not eliminate any negative impacts from the previous finding.
In sum, the agency was aggrieved when the juvenile court declined to accept the
agency’s recommended finding that reasonable efforts were made for the entire period.
Based on the foregoing, we conclude the agency has standing to challenge the juvenile
court’s orders.
B. Reasonable Services
“Family reunification services play a critical role in dependency proceedings.
[Citations.] At the dispositional hearing, the court is required to order the agency to
provide child welfare services to the child and his or her parents. (§ 361.5, subd. (a).)
Services ‘may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the
child and family and to prevent reabuse of children.’ (§ 300.2.) Reunification services
should be tailored to the particular needs of the family.” (In re M.F. (2019) 32
Cal.App.5th 1, 13 (M.F.).)
11.
At each review hearing, “if the child is not returned to his or her parent, the
juvenile court is required to determine whether ‘reasonable services that were designed to
aid the parent … in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the
continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent .…’
(§§ 366.21, subds. (e)(8) & (f)(1)(A), 366.22, subd. (a)(1).) The ‘adequacy of
reunification plans and the reasonableness of the [Agency’s] efforts are judged according
to the circumstances of each case.’ [Citation.] To support a finding that reasonable
services were offered or provided to the parent, ‘the record should show that the
supervising agency identified the problems leading to the loss of custody, offered services
designed to remedy those problems, maintained reasonable contact with the parents
during the course of the service plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist the parents in
areas where compliance proved difficult .…’ ” (M.F., supra, 32 Cal.App.5th at p. 14.)
In making this determination, we bear in mind that “[i]n almost all cases it will be
true that more services could have been provided more frequently and that the services
provided were imperfect. The standard is not whether the services provided were the best
that might be provided in an ideal world, but whether the services were reasonable under
the circumstances.” (In re Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 547.) We review the
juvenile court’s findings for sufficiency of the evidence. (Amanda H. v. Superior Court
(2008) 166 Cal.App.4th 1340, 1345.) “ ‘ “If there is substantial evidence supporting the
judgment, our duty ends and the judgment must not be disturbed.” ’ [Citation.]” (Ibid.)
Where, as here, the trial court concluded that the party with the burden of proof
did not carry the burden, “the question for a reviewing court becomes whether the
evidence compels a finding in favor of the appellant as a matter of law. [Citations.]
Specifically, the question becomes whether the appellant's evidence was (1)
‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’ and (2) ‘of such a character and weight as to leave no
room for a judicial determination that it was insufficient to support a finding.’ [Citation.]”
(In re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528.)
12.
The agency contends that the court based its decision on the misguided assumption
that the social worker was required to have known of mother’s intellectual disability at
the outset of the proceedings. It argues that the court’s ruling that the initial case plan
was inadequate is inconsistent with the court’s previous approval of that plan. Mother
does not respond to the agency’s reasonable services argument on the merits. We
recognize that this decision was an implied concession of the ultimate issue, but we will
still address the juvenile court’s finding that reasonable efforts were not made. (See In re
Ramone R. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 1339, 1351 [a failure to respond to an argument is an
implicit concession].)
In the present case, the child was removed from mother’s care due to both parents’
substance abuse and past neglect of the child’s siblings. The objectives and
responsibilities of mother’s case plan included individual counseling, couples counseling,
substance abuse assessment, drug testing, and a psychological evaluation. Mother was
already connected to a mental health clinician at the outset of the proceedings, and the
juvenile court approved mother’s case plan at the disposition hearing held on August 31,
2023.
During the six-month reunification period, mother missed several individual
counseling sessions, and she refused to complete in-person sessions with her clinician.
The social worker completed monthly contacts with mother, and she discussed the
objectives and responsibilities of mother’s case plan during each contact. Mother was
provided a planner to assist her in managing appointments, and a referral was submitted
to intensive family reunification services. However, the referral to intensive services was
closed due to mother’s failure to respond.
On October 24, 2024, mother started to participate in her clinical interview for the
psychological evaluation, and Dr. Anderson completed the report on December 14, 2023.
The report concluded that mother suffered from a mild intellectual disability based upon
the various assessments completed by Dr. Anderson. The evaluation recommended that
13.
mother be given a substantial amount of time to learn and demonstrate her skills. Dr.
Anderson indicated that mother’s case plan was not previously tailored to her specific
needs as a parent with an intellectual disability, and the case plan needed to be modified
because mother’s services may require an extended period of time.
In response to the psychological evaluation, the agency connected mother to
intensive family reunification services and a parent partner. The agency was also
proactively engaging mother’s service providers to specifically tailor her case plan as
recommended by the evaluation. At the six-month review hearing, the juvenile court
refused to find that reasonable services were provided for the entire period due to the
results of mother’s psychological evaluation. The court acknowledged that the agency
“immediately” shored up its efforts after the evaluation was received on December 14,
2023, and it found that reasonable services were provided after that date.
As discussed previously, the record must demonstrate that the agency, “identified
the problems leading to the loss of custody, offered services designed to remedy those
problems, maintained reasonable contact with the parents during the course of the service
plan, and made reasonable efforts to assist the parents in areas where compliance proved
difficult....” (In re Riva M. (1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 403, 414.) Here, the agency identified
neglect and substance abuse as the problems leading to the loss of custody, and it offered
services to fix those problems. The social worker took numerous steps to help assist
mother when compliance proved difficult throughout the reunification period.
The juvenile court’s comments suggest that the agency should have been aware of
mother’s cognitive deficits prior to the completion of the evaluation, however, the case
plan approved by the court included a recommendation for a psychological evaluation.
During the social worker’s contacts with mother, she identified herself as a high school
graduate with no difficulties in school, and she claimed that she would be attending
college. The agency had identified concerns with mother’s understanding of her situation
14.
at the time of disposition, and it requested that a psychological evaluation be completed
as part of her case plan.
In sum, there were simply no facts present for the court to infer that mother’s
intellectual disability was apparent prior to the completion of the psychological
evaluation. A social worker does not have the expert qualifications of a mental health
professional such as a psychologist or therapist to make such a diagnosis in the first
instance. Accordingly, a case plan tailored to mother’s cognitive difficulties was not
necessary until such a diagnosis was rendered by Dr. Anderson.
Therefore, we conclude the evidence compelled the court to find that the agency
made reasonable efforts to return the child to his home for the entire review period. The
agency made continued efforts to connect mother to services despite her lack of
cooperation and compliance during the review period. In making its finding, the juvenile
court improperly focused on the ineffectiveness of the services that were provided to
mother due to her undiagnosed cognitive disability. The court should have considered the
agency’s extensive efforts in light of the limited information available to it regarding
mother’s intellectual capacity. Under the circumstances there was no room for a
determination that reasonable services were not provided prior to December 14, 2023.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order of February 13, 2024, is reversed only with regard to its
finding that the agency had not complied with the case plan by making reasonable efforts
to make it possible for the child to safely return home prior to December 14, 2023, and
that finding is vacated. The matter is remanded to the juvenile court to enter a new
finding that the agency had complied with the case plan by making reasonable efforts to
make it possible for the child to safely return home for the entire review period. In all
other respects, the order is affirmed.
15.
FRANSON, Acting P. J.
WE CONCUR:
MEEHAN, J.
DE SANTOS, J.
16.
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.