CourtListener 10283070•People v. Morlett CA4/3
Texto completo
Filed 11/25/24 P. v. Morlett CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G062510
v. (Super. Ct. No. 13HF1149)
OSCAR LUIS MORLETT, III, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Michael A. Leversen, Judge. Affirmed.
James M. Crawford, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Eric A.
Swenson and Junichi P. Semitsu, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* * *
Oscar Luis Morlett, III (Morlett) was convicted of murdering his
stepmother. The two lived together, and one day, when no one else was home,
he bludgeoned her to death with a pickaxe. His defense at trial was insanity.
Morlett raises two issues on appeal: first, he argues that the
court wrongly admitted a confession obtained in violation of his Miranda
rights; second, he argues that the court failed to instruct the jury on
provocation, both in the form of voluntary manslaughter and second degree
murder.
We agree with the trial court’s conclusion that Morlett’s
confession was voluntary. He was properly informed of his Miranda rights
before the confession, and although he did not explicitly waive those rights,
the context clearly shows that he understood them and chose to proceed
without an attorney.
We also conclude that there was insufficient evidence to justify a
voluntary manslaughter or provocation instruction based on a heat-of-passion
theory. There simply was no evidence of provocation. Therefore, there was no
error in omitting such an instruction. Accordingly, we affirm the judgment.
FACTS
I.
MORLETT MOVES IN WITH HIS FATHER, BUT IS THEN TOLD HE MUST LEAVE,
PROMPTING HIS ANGER TOWARD HIS STEP MOTHER
In the Summer of 2013, Morlett, 20 years old, was kicked out of
his biological mother’s home where he had been residing. After several weeks
of homelessness, his father took him in. He took Morlett’s younger brother in
at around the same time. Morlett’s father was married to Jeanne Morlett at
2
the time, who also lived there.1 While living there, Morlett was provided free
food and clothes. According to Morlett’s younger brother, Jeanne was kind
and helpful to both of them. Morlett and Jeanne seemed to have a “cordial”
relationship.
Not long after Morlett had moved in, however, he received
upsetting news: his father and stepmother were planning to downsize and
move into a smaller unit. As a result, Morlett grew angry and felt that they
were pushing him out of the house.
Morlett felt that Jeanne was the one who wanted to kick him out
of the house and send him to a charitable mission, which sparked or
exacerbated his anger toward her. He then began expressing that antipathy
to others. For instance, on June 25, 2013, he posted a social media message
stating, “I really am hating on my stepmom! And fuck her Honda Hybrid!”
Morlett’s comments about Jeanne became violent. On or around
July 13, he posted on social media: “I fucking hate that bitch. I just wanted to
be like O.J. Simpson. Fucken furious about step parents!” Around that same
time, he also wrote on social media that he was about “to roll back on being . .
. ratted out by Jeanne . . . bitch ass, trying to sell secrets over the phone.”
Morlett’s vitriol manifested itself in non-verbal ways as well. Not
long before the murder, he put patchouli or “Kama Sutra” oil into her water
bottle because he “wanted to make her sick.” After realizing what Morlett
had done, Jeanne told her husband to talk to him about it, which he did.
1 Because Jeanne shared the same surname as the defendant, we
refer to her by first name.
3
Finally, just two days before the murder, Morlett expressed his
desire to kill Jeanne to his neighbor. Morlett went to the neighbor’s home to
try to meet up with the neighbor’s then-16-year-old son, who had befriended
Morlett weeks earlier. The neighbor invited Morlett inside to chat and to
provide him support, knowing he had just turned 21 years old and was
struggling. At one point during their conversation, Morlett angrily blurted
out, “I hate my fucking stepmom,” and said he wanted to kill her. He seemed
“very paranoid” and, at one point, remarked that he believed Jeanne was a
spy.
II.
MORLETT KILLS JEANNE
On the morning of August 9, 2013, Jeanne, Morlett, his father,
and his younger brother were all inside the house. Morlett’s younger brother
recalled that Morlett seemed fine when he saw him that day. That morning,
father left the house while Jeanne was still in bed and Morlett was watching
television on the couch. At one point, Jeanne came downstairs to make coffee,
said hello to Morlett’s younger brother, and then went back upstairs. By
10:30 a.m., Morlett’s brother had left for work, leaving Jeanne and Morlett as
the only two remaining in the residence. At no point that morning (or at any
time before) did father or younger brother observe any tension or argument
between Morlett and Jeanne.
Around that time, Morlett made the decision to kill Jeanne. He
went outside to retrieve a foot long pickaxe with a wooden handle from the
backyard and then returned inside. He put on gloves to avoid leaving
fingerprints on the axe.
4
Armed with the pickaxe, Morlett entered Jeanne’s room and
yelled at her, “you’ve always stole my story, you’ve always been a rat to me,
you’ve always, you know, been a negative influence in my life and . . . I want
to take you to heaven.” As Jeanne started screaming, Morlett used the
pickaxe to “bash[]” and “whack[]” her left thigh and then her right thigh
before eventually hitting her “[a]ll over.”
Morlett tried “to cut her vital organs and veins from inside,”
hoping to “get her spinal cord and the upper tissue under her armpits.” He
wanted to make it “[q]uick and painless.” He recalled that it was “raining”
blood everywhere, creating a “blood of sunrise.”
Morlett left Jeanne’s body on a tarp, which he described as “a
black Astroturf looking thing.” He then returned the pickaxe to where he
found it, burned his gloves, and left the scene.
Shortly afterward, Morlett dialed 911 from his cell phone to
report that he saw someone “attack[] [his stepmother] right in front of [him]”
during a home invasion. He claimed he managed to escape out the back door.
When the call was disconnected, the dispatcher called Morlett’s cell phone,
but was sent to voicemail.
Morlett then biked to Saddleback Church. Two people saw him
and approached him out of concern that he may have fallen and hurt himself.
Morlett told them that his stepmother had been attacked by gardeners, that
he had to flee for his life, and that he needed to use a phone because he had
“no access to electronics.” Two of the witnesses saw dried blood on Morlett’s
hand and blood stains on his fingernail beds.
Morlett then used one of the community center’s telephones to
call 911 again. This time, he reported to the dispatcher that he “was chased
out of [his] house. . . by a couple gardeners in a truck. He said he did not
5
know the gardeners who attacked Jeanne, but they were driving a tan Toyota
truck with black rims. He then told the dispatcher that he “d[id]n’t have any
telecommunications or electronics” and was just “sitting [t]here like a duck.”
First responders arrived at the house around 11:20 a.m. and soon
discovered Jeanne’s bloodied, unresponsive body on the ground. She had
sustained 17 puncture wounds, including a fatal hack to her lungs, all of
which caused her to bleed to death. A subsequent autopsy revealed that she
had suffered blunt force trauma to her face, jaw, neck, chest, abdomen, and
thighs.
Officers also found significant blood evidence at the scene of the
crime. Stains from bloody fingers had been smeared on the walls and on the
doorframe of the master bedroom. Blood stains on the carpet and stairs
became progressively fainter as the trail led away from the victim’s body.
Blood was also found in various locations within the house—a sleeveless shirt
in the bedroom, the sink in the upstairs bathroom separate from the master
bedroom, and bloody paper towels in the trash can. And finally, officers
recovered the murder weapon—the pickaxe—which also had blood stains on
the head of the axe.
A subsequent forensic investigation tied Morlett to the crime.
DNA samples obtained from the victim matched Morlett’s DNA. Blood found
on the sleeveless shirt contained DNA consistent with both Jeanne and
Morlett. Blood from paper towels in the trash can contained a DNA profile
that “was consistent with [Morlett].” Blood found on Morlett’s sock contained
DNA consistent with Jeanne’s DNA. The forensic specialist who collected
Morlett’s DNA swabs observed that Morlett’s hands also had notable cuts and
bruises.
6
III.
THE POLICE INTERVIEW
Investigator A. Quilantan of the Orange County Sheriff’s
Department arrived at Saddleback Church to meet with Morlett. Morlett was
then transported to the Sheriff’s headquarters for an interview with
Investigator Quilantan, Investigator Montano, and Deputy Hansen.
At the outset of the interview, Investigator Quilantan read
Morlett his Miranda rights, and Morlett indicated that he understood each of
those rights, though he did not secure an explicit waiver of those rights.
During the initial portion of the interview, Morlett echoed what
he said during his second 911 call: that he feared the gardeners had done
something to Jeanne. He said that after he left the house, Jeanne called him
and her voice “sounded really faint and scared”. He claimed he was worried
because he recalled seeing gardeners in the backyard. Those gardeners,
according to Morlett, would “throw gang signs” and “would show like too
much enthusiastic [sic] about how they liked to be a gardener.” He also
suggested the “very Hispanic” gardeners might have done something to
Jeanne because she was white, as they “would hate and discriminate on a
white society population, especially in a neighborhood like that.”
Morlett then claimed that as he headed to Saddleback, he “saw
the gardeners and a few of their gardening trucks.” One truck, in particular,
“popped out” to him—a “very tan Toyota” with black tinted rims.
Asked why Morlett had blood on his hands, he responded that he
enjoyed tattooing himself. Because of his recent tattooing, he told officers that
they would find blood “all over [his] towel” that he lays over his bed. Asked to
explain the blood on his shoes, he said that the stains were just dirt and that
he hadn’t cleaned his shoes in six months. When the investigator clarified
7
that blood was on the bottom of his shoes as if he had “stepped in blood”—and
that it was “not a speck of blood, but a lot of blood”—Morlett simply
responded, “I wasn’t there.”
After steadfastly denying involvement, the investigators then
informed Morlett that Jeanne had died from the attack. He began crying and
asked, “Who would do something like that?” Very shortly thereafter, Morlett
invoked his right to counsel. Investigators immediately stopped questioning
him and placed him under arrest for Jeanne’s murder. Investigators Montano
and Quilantan then left the room to grab some paperwork, while Deputy
Hansen stayed behind with Morlett.
While waiting for the investigators to return with paperwork,
Morlett spontaneously told Deputy Hansen that “I did fuck that bitch up.”
Deputy Hansen asked, “Well why didn’t you tell the investigators that?”
Morlett responded, “I’m not talking to the investigator.” Deputy Hansen
replied, “Well I mean you can talk to me without a lawyer if you want. It’s
your, your decision.” He then asked, “Why’d you fuck her up?” Morlett
responded, “‘Cause she was – she had me ratting on, on my best friend. . . . .
She had me ratting on a few friends, that I didn’t want to rat on.” Deputy
Hansen then said, “I don’t want to make—I don’t want it to be like I’m sitting
here questioning you ‘cause you asked for a lawyer, you know what I mean?
So—” Morlett replied, “Yeah. Well I know, I’m guilty-I’ll still fight it ‘cause I
have the money to but. . . .”
Deputy Hansen then asked Morlett how he “fucked her up,” to
which Morlett replied, “I saw dad rape her and then . . . I saw Oscar rape her
and then I went ‘cause I didn’t want her to tell on ‘em and I finished her. A
brutality a sick one.” He stated that he beat her with a pick axe. He then
8
asked that the investigators be brought back in so he could “retell the story
and get it straight.”
Investigator Quilantan returned, stating, “Um, when we last left
here, you had said you wanted to talk to a lawyer.” Morlett: “yeah.”
Investigator Quilantan: “I read you your rights earlier and you said you
understood ‘em and said that, uh, you agreed to talk. Then you told us you
didn’t want a lawyer. I was told by our deputy out in the hallway that you
wanted to talk now.” “Is that true?” Morlett stated that it was.
Morlett then explained that he “nailed that bitch” because,
among other things, “she wanted to send me to a mission in Tustin” and “she
was trying to sell . . . my family’s house.” He continued to express a litany of
grievances about all the ways that Jeanne annoyed or angered him. He
blamed her for tearing up and bankrupting his family: “that bitch got us poor,
swore us poor.” He referred to Jeanne as “ugly,” a “bitch,” and a “prostitute
stepmom” who made them poor. He complained that she “microscoped” his
life choices. After he saw her “c[o]me down all slutty looking,” he remarked
that she was “not the girl [he] wanted [his] dad to be with,” and so he had to
“prove that [he] can do what [he] needed to do.”
Morlett then proceeded to let investigators know how he killed
Jeanne. Despite the severity of his attacks on her vital organs and spine, he
claimed that he only wanted to hurt her and did not think that she would die;
in fact, he “knew she would survive” since she was “snoring” when he left her.
Later he acknowledged that he was “trying to cut her vital organs and veins
from the inside” and “tried to get her spinal cord and upper tissue under her
armpits” so that it would be “quick and painless.”
9
Morlett told the officers they wouldn’t find his fingerprints
because he wore gloves that he burned. When the investigators asked where
the murder weapon was, he told them he left the pickaxe outside, next to the
air conditioner. Investigators immediately used this information to tell other
officers at the crime scene to look for the axe.
At the end of the interview, Morlett admitted, “Yeah, I fucked up.
I know that. But it doesn’t make me guilty inside.”
IV.
MORLETT COMMENTS ON THE KILLING WHILE IN CUSTODY
On September 6, 2013, while in custody, Morlett spoke to his
father on the telephone for the first time since killing his wife. Father asked
his son, “Are you aware of what you did?” Morlett replied, “Heck yeah . . . .
And I know it was hard . . . for both . . . for all of us.” Morlett went on, “And
that there’s much love to be looking forward to. I don’t want to make anymore
[sic] mistakes. I just want to be right. And for that, I want to say I’m sorry for
the hardships that we had to go through. And I just wanted, you know, be
able to have the family on my back and no one else. No, no other people. I just
want to have the family on my back and know that what I did was okay.”
Father responded, “What you did was okay? Is that what you just
said? . . . `What did you just say?” Morlett then added that he is “on a lot of
medications” and that he was “sorry that [he] did that.” During that same
conversation, father asked his son whether he had anything to say to
Jeanne’s sister. Morlett responded, “Tell them I fucking did her wrong and
she did us wrong. She . . . swore us broke and I didn’t want to accept that.”
On October 3, 2013, Morlett spoke to his mother, stating: “The
fact that I did what I did is . . . I thought it was a second life I was living and
I didn’t want to, so I took the actions that I took. I would still do it again. I
10
just know that I’m going to waste a lot of time here. It’s not like I’m sorry
now. I don’t say sorry, but I have got to stand up for myself.”
Ten days later, Morlett again called his mother to apologize and
said, “I fucked up.” Later in that conversation, appellant and his mother had
this exchange:
“[Morlett]: I know what I did was wrong. It’s the worst sin you
can do and I still know what I did and the reason why I did it. I just want to
change. . . . just want to be supported also.
“[Mother]: You are . . . why did you do what you did?
“[Morlett]: Because there’s creation in death, Mom.” Later he
said, “I’m so much fucking smarter than this . . . and I have to go out because
of some stupid bitch step mom . . . that doesn’t know how to be a mom, and
didn’t know how to be there for us and swore us broke, and now all I have to
is [sic] take it . . . .
“[Mother]: Take what? What did you take?
“[Morlett]: I took it in the desire to hurt somebody and I hurt
someone bad.”
On November 13, 2013, Morlett again spoke to his mother. He
said that he and Jeanne first began arguing after he once saw her naked and
he “didn’t like her body.” He mentioned that she had “[c]onspiracies about
certain friends I hung out with, and certain drugs that I did.” He also
expressed frustration that she had $11,000 to buy a Honda, “but not enough
to support two sons.” He castigated Jeanne as “the laziest person [he had]
ever known,” noting that she had never gone to San Diego once to meet his
aunt or uncles. When mother started to say that these grievances didn’t
justify his actions, he responded, “I’m not trying to make it right.”
11
In June 2014, while in custody, Morlett wrote a letter to his
friend that stated, in part, “Well, I have known Jeanne Morlett for over 15
years. There’s nothing really good I can really say besides good cooking. I
wanted a going away birthday present and I got one. Fuck that bitch.”
In 2015, Morlett met on three occasions with Dr. Flores, the
licensed psychologist hired by the prosecution. In those meetings, Morlett
stated that Jeanne wanted to sell the house, kick him out, and send him to a
homeless shelter, all of which he felt was disrespectful. Additionally, he
stated Jeanne was suicidal. He acknowledged these were all part of his
motive in killing Jeanne.
Finally, after deputies obtained a search warrant to search
Morlett’s cell phone, they discovered that his phone contained a message that
read: “Jeanne E. Cobb is a bitch! . . . Ain’t no recipe in your life worth having
in my life. I would see over your engraved body and be as serena to the nail
coffin that [sic] your soul.”
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The Orange County District Attorney filed an information
charging Morlett with one count of first degree murder of Jeanne Morlett
(Pen. Code, § 187, subd. (a))2. The information alleged that appellant
personally used a deadly weapon—a pickaxe—within the meaning of section
10222, subdivision (b)(1).
In 2015, defense counsel declared a doubt pertaining to
appellant’s competency to stand trial. The trial court suspended proceedings
and appointed two separate doctors to evaluate him. After reviewing the
2 All statutory references are to the Penal Code unless stated
otherwise.
12
reports of both doctors, the trial court found that he was not mentally
incompetent under section 1368 and ordered criminal proceedings reinstated
as of February 2016.
Later that year, defense counsel again raised a doubt as to
appellant’s competency. After an in camera hearing to hear an offer of proof,
the trial court again suspended proceedings and ordered follow-up
evaluations. The court then found that he was a mentally incompetent person
under section 1367, subdivision (a).
In 2018, after a restoration of competency hearing, the trial court
found Morlett to be mentally competent to stand trial pursuant to section
1368 and reinstated criminal proceedings.
Morlett’s first trial commenced on September 14, 2022. The jury
was unable to reach a unanimous decision as to whether he was guilty of first
degree murder: 11 believed he was guilty of first degree murder, while one
did not. The trial court declared a mistrial.
The retrial commenced in February 2023.
Appellant did not dispute that he killed Jeanne. His primary
defense was that he suffered from schizophrenia when he killed her and that
his psychosis affected his ability to understand what he was doing.
The jury found appellant guilty of first degree murder and found
it true that he personally used a deadly weapon during the commission of the
offense.
The sanity phase of the trial commenced on March 13, 2023. The
jury concluded that appellant was sane at the time he committed the offense.
The trial court sentenced appellant to 25 years to life, followed by
a determinate sentence of one year in state prison for the personal use of a
deadly weapon enhancement. Morlett timely appealed.
13
DISCUSSION
I.
MORLETT’S CONFESSION WAS PROPERLY ADMITTED
Morlett’s first contention is that his entire police interview, which
was played at trial, was erroneously admitted. He argues that investigators
failed to secure a knowing and intelligent Miranda waiver. Morlett also
contends that Deputy Hansen’s interaction with Morlett after Morlett
invoked his right to counsel violated the bright line rule of Edwards v.
Arizona (1981) 451 U.S. 477, 485 (Edwards), which requires that law
enforcement cease all questioning as soon as a suspect invokes the right to
counsel. Finally, he contends the confession was involuntary. “On review of a
trial court’s decision on a Miranda issue, we accept the trial court’s
determination of disputed facts if supported by substantial evidence, but we
independently decide whether the challenged statements were obtained in
violation of Miranda.” (People v. Davis (2009) 46 Cal.4th 539, 586; see also
People v. Winbush (2017) 2 Cal.5th 402, 452 (Winbush) [same standard for
voluntariness more generally].) We conclude Morlett’s contentions have no
merit.
A. Morlett’s Confession Was Not Obtained in Violation of Miranda
The Fifth Amendment provides that “[n]o person shall be . . .
compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself . . . .”
Consequently, a criminal conviction may not be founded upon an involuntary
confession. (Winbush, supra, 2 Cal.5th at p. 452.) To protect that right, under
Miranda, prior to subjecting a suspect to custodial interrogation, law
enforcement must advise the suspect of the right to remain silent, that
anything said can be used against the suspect in a court of law, that the
suspect has the right to an attorney, and if the suspect cannot afford an
14
attorney, one will be appointed free of charge. (People v. McCurdy (2014) 59
Cal.4th 1063, 1086.)
Once the required advisement is given, a suspect may waive
those rights either explicitly or impliedly. (People v. Cruz (2008) 44 Cal.4th
636, 667 (Cruz).) “A valid waiver need not be of predetermined form, but
instead must reflect that the suspect in fact knowingly and voluntarily
waived the rights delineated in the Miranda decision.” (Ibid.) The burden is
on the prosecution to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the
waiver was knowing and voluntary. (People v. Nelson (2012) 53 Cal.4th 367,
374-375.) In determining whether that was the case, courts examine the
totality of the circumstances. (People v. Williams (2010) 49 Cal.4th 405, 425.)
The question we face here is whether Morlett impliedly waived
his Miranda rights. At the outset of the interview, Investigator Quintalan
recited to Morlett his Miranda rights, and Morlett stated he understood each
of those rights. He was never asked to explicitly waive those rights.
However, an explicit waiver is not required. “A suspect’s
expressed willingness to answer questions after acknowledging an
understanding of his or her Miranda rights has itself been held sufficient to
constitute an implied waiver of such rights.” (Cruz, supra, 44 Cal.4th at p.
667.) “Where the prosecution shows that a Miranda warning was given and
that it was understood by the accused, an accused’s uncoerced statement
establishes an implied waiver of the right to remain silent.” (Berghuis v.
Thompkins (2010) 560 U.S. 370, 384.) The issue, therefore, turns on whether
Morlett understood his Miranda rights.
We begin with the obvious: he said he understood those rights.
Morlett counters that, notwithstanding his acknowledgment, he
was in obvious mental distress at the time and had a history of mental illness
15
that undermined his professed understanding of his rights. When he was first
encountered at the church, he was observed to be making “groaning, crying
sounds.” After he called 911 at the church, he went behind the counter and
laid down in a fetal position, “kind of rocking back and forth.” He had a
history of a recent 5150 hold. His commentary during the interview was at
times odd. And he informed the investigators that he was on anti-psychotic
medication.
The flaw in Morlett’s argument is that whether he understood his
rights is ultimately a factual issue, and while he can point to what he
describes as “substantial evidence” that he did not understand his rights,
there was contrary substantial evidence, and we must ultimately resolve that
factual conflict in favor of the court’s ruling. There is, of course, the fact that
he said he understood his rights. He also said, “I’m already going through
court process actually right now. I have investigators and lawyers and
attorneys already . . . .” (See People v. Lessie (2010) 47 Cal.4th 1152, 1169
[prior criminal cases tends to show understanding of Miranda rights].)
Moreover, over the course of the interview, Morlett demonstrated a capacity
to rationally follow the conversation. While he at times made odd comments,
Morlett demonstrated an understanding of what was being told to him and
asked of him. (See People v. Cunningham (2015) 61 Cal.4th 609, 645 [“Even if
some of defendant’s behavior was irrational or bizarre, there is no evidence
his ‘abilities to reason or comprehend or resist were in fact so disabled that
he was incapable of free or rational choice.’”].) But perhaps most telling of all
is the fact that when he was told that Jeanne died, he actually invoked his
right to an attorney. The fact that he knew to invoke his right demonstrated
that he understood it. Because he understood his Miranda rights and yet
chose to speak with investigators, he impliedly waived those rights.
16
B. Introduction of the Post-Invocation Portion of the Interview Did Not Violate
Edwards
Next, Morlett contends that the portion of the interview after he
invoked his right to counsel (which includes all of his admissions) should
have been excluded under Edwards, supra, 451 U.S. 477. Edwards sets forth
a bright line rule that once a suspect unambiguously invokes the right to an
attorney, law enforcement must cease the custodial interrogation until
counsel is present. (Id. at p. 484-485.) However, even Edwards acknowledged
that this rule applies “unless the accused himself initiates further
communication, exchanges, or conversations with the police.” (Ibid.)
“‘ An accused “initiates” further communication, exchanges, or
conversations of the requisite nature ‘when he speaks words or engages in
conduct that can be “fairly said to represent a desire” on his part “to open up
a more generalized discussion relating directly or indirectly to the
investigation.”’’’ (People v. San Nicolas (2004) 34 Cal.4th 614, 642.) “‘[W]here
reinterrogation follows, the burden remains upon the prosecution to show
that subsequent events indicated a waiver of the Fifth Amendment right to
have counsel present during the interrogation.’’’ (People v. Sims (1993) 5
Cal.4th 405, 440.)
Here, Morlett unambiguously invoked his right to counsel once he
was told that Jeanne had died. He said, “Where’s my lawyer? I need a lawyer.
This is not okay, guys. I’m getting a lawyer.” At that point, the investigators
complied with their legal obligation and immediately ceased the
interrogation. They left the room and Deputy Hansen was left in the room to
supervise Morlett while the investigators gathered the paperwork to arrest
and transfer Morlett to jail.
17
After the investigators left, Morlett initiated a conversation with
Deputy Hansen. Morlett stated, without prompting, “What am I being
charged with?” Deputy Hansen replied, “Oh, that’s – they have to tell you
that, man. I’m not allowed to – I don’t even have all that stuff. I’m just here.”
That is when Morlett spontaneously said, “I did fuck that bitch up.” Deputy
Hansen then clarified what Morlett said: “You did fuck her up? Is that what
you said?” Morlett: “yeah.” Deputy Hansen: “Well why didn’t you tell the
investigators that?” Morlett: “I’m not talking to the investigator.” Deputy
Hansen: “Well I mean you can talk to me without a lawyer if you want. It’s
your, your decision.” Morlett: “No, they already did their job.” Deputy
Hansen: “Why’d you fuck her up?” Morlett: “Cause she was – she had me
ratting on, on my best friend.” “She had me ratting on a few friends, that I
didn’t want to rat on.” Deputy Hansen: “I don’t want to make – I don’t want it
to be like I’m sitting here questioning you ‘cause you asked for a lawyer, you
know what I mean? So . . . .” Morlett: “Yeah. Well I know, I’m guilty . . . .”
Deputy Hansen went on to ask some specifics of how Morlett did it.
It is quite clear from that conversation that Morlett reinitiated
the conversation and voluntarily proceeded without an attorney. Deputy
Hansen started by saying he could not give Morlett information and that he
was “just here.” That is when Morlett—without any prompting from Deputy
Hansen—admitted to assaulting Jeanne. Hansen then cautioned Morlett
twice that he had invoked the right to an attorney and was not subject to
further questioning, but Morlett persisted in admitting what he did. This
conclusion is further buttressed by the fact that when Deputy Hansen had
the investigators return, Investigator Quintalan specifically reminded
Morlett that he had invoked his right to counsel and asked Morlett if he had
changed his mind and wanted to talk now. Morlett said he did. Investigator
18
Quintalan then repeated the question “just to make sure,” and Morlett once
again agreed to resume talking. Because Morlett voluntarily and knowingly
reinitiated conversation without counsel, there was no violation of Edwards
in admitting the remainder of the interview.
C. Morlett’s Admissions Were Voluntary
Morlett’s final argument is that his admissions were involuntary
due to coercion by the investigators. “The prosecution has the burden of
establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that a defendant’s confession
was voluntarily made. [Citations.] In determining whether a confession was
voluntary, ‘ “[t]he question is whether defendant’s choice to confess was not
‘essentially free’ because his [or her] will was overborne.”’ [Citation.]” (People
v. Carrington (2009) 47 Cal.4th 145, 169.) “To determine whether a statement
was voluntary or coerced, we examine the totality of the circumstances.
[Citation.] Coercive police activity is a necessary predicate but does not itself
compel a finding that a resulting confession is involuntary. [Citation.] . . . The
Fifth Amendment is not ‘concerned with moral and psychological pressures to
confess emanating from sources other than official coercion.’’’ (People v.
Bradford (1997) 14 Cal.4th 1005, 1041.)
Morlett’s argument is largely derivative of his previous two
arguments. He states, “In the present case, Morlett had undergone a
psychotic episode at the time of the underlying offense. By the time police
arrived, Morlett was psychotic, had been acting unusual, and made numerous
bizarre comments to both persons present at the church and the police. All
objective inidic[ia] of the psychotic episode. Nevertheless, after transporting
Morlett to the station, Investigator Quilantan proceeded to question Morlett
without securing a knowing, intelligent and voluntary waiver of his rights
under Miranda and then allowed a deputy to question Morlett after he
19
unequivocally requested the assistance of counsel. Together with Morlett’s
severe psychotic disorder, the improper tactics and techniques employed by
these deputies in securing statements from Morlett overcame his free will
and rendered his resulting confession involuntary.”
The problem with this argument is that it is largely dependent on
claims about Morlett’s psychological condition rather than any coercive
activity by the investigators. The failure to secure an express Miranda waiver
is not itself coercive activity. And in the remainder of the interview, the
investigators did not use any heavy handed or coercive tactics. The tone of
the interview was generally friendly. As the trial court stated, “There was no
coercive activity. No heavy-handedness, no promises made. The tone of the
interview was easy. There was no raising of the voices.” And as we already
noted above, notwithstanding occasional bizarre statements, Morlett
generally demonstrated a rational thought process and understanding during
the interview. Accordingly, Morlett’s statements were voluntary, and their
admission did not violate the Fifth Amendment.
II.
THERE WAS NO ERROR IN REFUSING TO INSTRUCT THE JURY ON PROVOCATION
Morlett’s final arguments center on the court’s refusal to give
instructions regarding provocation—specifically, a voluntary manslaughter
instruction as a lesser included offense, as well as an instruction on how
provocation impacts the degree of murder (i.e. CALCRIM No. 522). We
conclude it was appropriate to refuse both instructions.
20
At trial, defense counsel requested both CALCRIM No. 522 and
an instruction on voluntary manslaughter.3 When questioned by the court
about his theory of voluntary manslaughter, defense counsel explained that
the provocation in this case “lasts over a period of time, beginning on 5/31,
when Mr. Morlett was apparently, according to the evidence, kicked out of his
[biological] mom’s house.” Counsel then observed that Morlett’s father and
Jeanne were downsizing, and there would not be room for Morlett in the new
house. Counsel also relied on the incident where Morlett put patchouli oil in
Jeanne’s water. The court denied the requested instructions, concluding that
none of this evidence demonstrated provocation.
“A heat of passion theory of manslaughter has both an objective
and a subjective component.” (People v. Moye (2009) 47 Cal.4th 537, 549
(Moye).) “‘To satisfy the objective or “reasonable person” element of this form
of voluntary manslaughter, the accused’s heat of passion must be due to
“sufficient provocation.”’’’ (People v. Gutierrez (2002) 28 Cal.4th 1083, 1144.)
“The provocative conduct by the victim may be physical or verbal, but the
conduct must be sufficiently provocative that it would cause an ordinary
person of average disposition to act rashly or without due deliberation and
reflection.” (Moye, supra, 47 Cal.4th 537 at p. 550.)
3 CALCRIM No. 522 states: “Provocation may reduce a murder
from first degree to second degree [and may reduce a murder to manslaughter].
The weight and significance of the provocation, if any, are for you to decide. [¶]
If you conclude that the defendant committed murder but was provoked,
consider the provocation in deciding whether the crime was first or second
degree murder. [Also, consider the provocation in deciding whether the
defendant committed murder or manslaughter.]”
21
“To satisfy the subjective element of this form of voluntary
manslaughter, the accused must be shown to have killed while under ‘the
actual influence of a strong passion’ induced by such provocation.” (Moye,
supra, 47 Cal.4th at p. 550.) “‘“However, if sufficient time has elapsed
between the provocation and the fatal blow for passion to subside and reason
to return, the killing is not voluntary manslaughter . . . .”’’’ (Ibid.)
Second degree murder, unlike voluntary manslaughter, does not
have an objective element. The question is simply whether the defendant was
so subjectively provoked that he acted without premeditation. (People v.
Jones (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 995, 1000-1001.)
There was no evidence of any sort of provocation here. Certainly,
from an objective standpoint, the events described by defense counsel do not
even come close to the sort of provocation that would cause a person of
ordinary disposition to lash out rashly. Even from a subjective perspective,
there was nothing that happened the morning of the killing that suddenly
provoked Morlett to act. Everything described by defense counsel occurred
well before the killing, after which Morlett had plenty of time to cool down.
The testimony from Morlett’s father and brother showed that Morlett was
acting normally the morning of the killing. As defense counsel made clear in
his opening statement: “There will be no evidence of any kind that [Morlett
and Jeanne] had arguments. There will be no evidence of any kind that they
fought actively.” This simply was not a provocation case; it was an insanity
case. The court was correct to refuse provocation instructions.
22
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
SANCHEZ, J.
WE CONCUR:
O’LEARY, P. J.
DELANEY, J.
23
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.