CourtListener 10277409•In re E.D. CA5
Texto completo
Filed 11/19/24 In re E.D. CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
In re E.D., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile
Court Law.
KERN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN F088168
SERVICES,
(Super. Ct. No. JD142047-00)
Plaintiff and Appellant,
v. OPINION
A.D. et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
THE COURT*
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Kern County. Susan M. Gill,
Judge.
Margo A. Raison, County Counsel, and Ana M. Ovando, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Marissa Coffey, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Respondent A.D.
Richard L. Knight, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Respondent L.O.
-ooOoo-
* Before Meehan, Acting P. J., Snauffer, J. and DeSantos, J.
Appellant Kern County Department of Human Services (department) appeals from
the juvenile court’s order at a Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.261 hearing
where a permanent plan of another planned permanent living arrangement (APPLA) was
ordered for the now six-year-old child, E.D. (the child), who is the subject of this
dependency case. The department contends the juvenile court erred when it failed to find
that the child was adoptable. We agree with the department’s contention. Therefore, we
reverse the juvenile court’s order and remand for a new selection and implementation
hearing consistent with section 366.26.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Initial Removal
In May 2021, the department received a referral alleging general neglect against
the child’s mother, L.O. (mother). The referral alleged the child, at two years of age, had
a knot on the top of his head, and mother and her boyfriend were heard engaging in
domestic violence. A social worker responded to mother’s home where the child and his
three-year-old sister, A.D. (collectively, the children), were living. The floor of mother’s
home was covered with roaches, baby bottles, food, trash, and toys. The refrigerator had
spoiled food and containers with dead roaches. The children were taken into protective
custody by the social worker on May 14, 2021.
The social worker interviewed mother about the circumstances surrounding the
children’s removal on May 17, 2021. Mother denied that she had any domestic violence
in her current or past relationships, and she also denied that her boyfriend was living in
her home. Mother claimed that the child needed to be reevaluated for autism and
dyslexia. She stated that he had been showing “ ‘signs’ ” of autism because he made
random noises and would not make eye contact.
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code unless
otherwise indicated.
2.
Regarding discipline in the home, mother explained that she had to sit with the
child during timeouts. Mother also insisted that the scratches on the child’s body were
caused by the children “ ‘messing with a cat.’ ” She stated the children fought “all the
time,” and she attributed the bumps on the child’s head to a fall. Mother indicated that
she planned to follow up on the child’s injuries during his next physical, but she had not
scheduled an appointment with his physician. The social worker inquired about mother’s
use of physical discipline, and she denied using any form of physical punishment on the
children.
On that same date, the children’s care provider informed the social worker that she
was concerned about multiple marks on the child’s arms and legs. The care provider
indicated that the child kept saying “ ‘mom crash me.’ ” The children had to be
supervised and redirected throughout the day because they would fight with each other.
The child showed the social worker a mark on his right thigh and said, “ ‘mommy push
me.’ ” As the social worker photographed and measured the marks on him, the child
repeated, “ ‘[m]ommy crash me, mommy push me, and mommy scratch me.’ ”
The social worker documented several injuries to the child. There was a
three-inch linear mark on the front of his right thigh, which appeared to be in the shape of
a clothes hanger or folded cable. A two-inch mark on his left inner thigh was in the shape
of an “S.” The back of his right leg had two linear red marks at approximately two inches
long from a belt or rectangular object. His right calf had linear and loop marks from
one to two inches in length. There were also several linear scars on his arms at
approximately one-half to one inch long, and a dark linear mark was noted on his left
armpit. The child had several scratches on his face, a bruise on his left eyelid, and a
laceration to his upper lip. The social worker did not observe any marks or bruises on the
child’s sister.
The department filed a petition alleging the child was described by section 300,
subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (e). The petition alleged the child was at substantial risk of
3.
suffering nonaccidental serious physical harm inflicted by mother. The petition detailed
the injuries observed by the social worker along with the inadequate conditions in
mother’s home. The petition further alleged that the child had suffered severe physical
abuse by mother. A petition was also filed for A.D., which alleged that she was described
by section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b)(1). At a continued detention hearing held on
May 21, 2021, the juvenile court ordered the children removed from mother’s custody,
and it set a combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing for June 25, 2021.
Jurisdiction and Disposition
The department’s jurisdiction and disposition reports recommended that the
allegations in the amended petition be found true and family reunification services be
provided to mother and the child’s father, A.D. (father). The children remained placed
together in a resource family home. The child’s sibling was found to be in need of mental
health services, and she did not appear to be developing appropriately for her age.
The disposition report noted that the child appeared to be developmentally on
target for his age, but he did not appear to be behaving in an age-appropriate manner.
The results of a developmental screening for the child indicated that no further
evaluations were necessary. The care provider was informed that any further assessments
would require the parents’ consent. A mental health screening conducted on June 11,
2021, found that the child was in need of further services for his emotional and mental
health needs.
In June 2021, the children’s care provider gave a 14-day notice for removal of the
children because the children would go outside and scream. The care provider was
concerned that her neighbors would call the police, but the department was able to
resolve the issue to allow the children to remain in the same home. On July 13, 2021, the
care provider explained that the children were fighting less often, and they were no
longer hitting each other with objects. The children’s mental health services were noted
to be helping, but the children still had a difficult time following directions. The care
4.
provider explained that she was not committed to adopting the children, but she would
provide care while the parents attempted to reunify.
The juvenile court sustained the allegations under section 300, subdivision (b)(1)
and dismissed the allegations under section 300, subdivisions (a) and (e) on August 26,
2021. At the continued disposition hearing held on December 6, 2021, the court ordered
the children to remain in out-of-home care with family reunification services to be
provided to mother and father. A six-month review hearing was set for June 6, 2022.
Family Reunification Period
In its report for the six-month review hearing, dated May 24, 2022, the department
recommended that family reunification services be continued for mother and terminated
for father. During the review period, the children’s placements were disrupted on
four occasions due to behavior issues and sibling fighting. The children were moved to
different resource family homes on December 29, 2021, February 16, 2022, March 28,
2022, and May 13, 2022.
In February 2022, the child accused the new care provider of pinching him and
pulling his hair when she picked up the children. The children were in the process of
transferring to a local behavioral services provider at the time of the placement change.
The care provider explained that the children needed constant redirection, and separation
was the only way to stop the children’s fighting. In March 2022, the social worker made
an unsuccessful attempt to contact father about mental health services for the children.
The department filed a request to authorize a mental health assessment, treatment,
and services for the child on March 17, 2022. The request was made after the child’s
father refused to authorize mental health treatment for the child. The social worker
attempted to contact the attorneys for the child, mother, and father about the request, but
none of the attorneys responded in the two weeks following her attempts. The request
explained that the child, at three years of age, was exhibiting defiant behavior, constantly
5.
fighting, and hitting his sister. The juvenile court granted the department’s request on
March 21, 2022.
In April 2022, the care provider stated that the child listened more than his sister,
and she had to constantly tell his sister not to hit. The children were doing better at
saying “sorry” to each other. The social worker asked the care provider about the child
wearing “pull ups,” and the care provider stated that the child was hesitant to use the
toilet. It was explained that the child was out of diapers once he left his first placement.
The care provider provided the social worker a 14-day notice after the child hit another
child at day care, and he also threw a toy at her son’s face, which led to the children’s
next placement.
There were no problems or concerns noted at the child’s physical and dental
examinations on February 2, 2022. The child was not receiving any mental health
services or psychotropic medications, and it was determined that the child needed further
services. The child’s sister was attending weekly meetings with her therapist, and she
was prescribed psychotropic medications.
At the six-month review hearing held on June 6, 2022, the juvenile court noted
that a determination was made that the child did not need mental health services, and it
requested that he be reevaluated for mental health treatment. The court acknowledged
that the children lost placements due to their challenging behaviors. The court ordered
continued family reunification services for mother, and father’s family reunification
services were terminated. A 12-month review hearing was set for July 12, 2022.
The report prepared for the 12-month review hearing recommended that mother’s
family reunification services be continued. The children remained in their same resource
family home, and the care provider stated that they could consider adoption if the parents
failed to reunify. The care provider indicated the child was being provided mental health
services at their home. The children were becoming more attached and comfortable in
the care provider’s home after a few weeks in placement.
6.
On July 7, 2022, mother explained that her visits were challenging because the
child distanced himself and threw tantrums when things did not go his way. Mother
requested that the child be “reassessed” due to his behaviors. She stated that the child’s
sister was doing “ok” while continuing her behavioral health services. At the 12-month
review hearing, mother’s family reunification services were continued, and an 18-month
review hearing was set for November 10, 2022.
The department’s report for the 18-month review hearing, dated October 31, 2022,
recommended that mother’s family reunification services be terminated. In
September 2022, the child’s “needs and services plan” indicated that he was receiving
mental health services. He was continuing to struggle with exaggerated negative
emotions when receiving correction for his defiant behaviors. He did not take any
medications, and he functioned appropriately for his age. The report stated that the child
was not receiving mental health services, but a referral for mental health services
determined that he needed further services.
In October 2022, the children’s care provider reported that the children were
stable. However, they became hyperactive and did not get along on the way home from
their supervised visits with mother. The social worker observed the child to be happy and
in a good mood during her home visit. The child stated that he liked living with his care
provider. An adoption review by a social services supervisor found the children to be
appropriate for adoption and guardianship planning.
During the review period, mother tested positive for methamphetamine on
two occasions, and she failed to appear for drug tests. She enrolled in substance abuse
treatment, and her anticipated completion date was in February 2023. Mother missed
approximately one-third of her supervised visits, which were scheduled for two times per
week for two hours. She gave birth to the children’s sibling, O.G., in August 2022.
The initial 18-month review hearing was continued to January 24, 2023, to
coincide with the contested disposition hearing for O.G. A supplemental report, dated
7.
January 20, 2023, recommended that the children be returned to mother’s custody and
family maintenance services be provided to mother. Mother completed her substance
abuse counseling on December 20, 2022, and she provided negative drug test results from
October 2022 through December 2022. At the 18-month review hearing, the juvenile
court placed the children in mother’s care, and family maintenance services were to be
provided to mother.
Supplemental Petition
On February 6, 2023, the social worker completed an in-person contact at
mother’s residence. Mother informed the social worker that she found the child and sister
alone in the bathroom together, and the child was about to touch his sister in the vaginal
area with his hand. The child was asked about how he learned this behavior, and he
reported that a boy at his foster home told him to touch his sister.
The social worker spoke to the child about the incident privately, and he stated that
he was told to touch his sister inappropriately by a boy at his foster home. The child
denied that he was being hurt or touched inappropriately. His sister later told the social
worker that a boy in their foster home told the child to touch her in the private area. The
sister affirmed that she felt comfortable living with her mother.
Another social worker completed an in-person contact with the children and
mother on March 14, 2023. Two adult males were home at the time, and mother was
running errands while the children watched a movie. The social worker spoke to the
sister privately in her room, and she asked if she liked living with her mother. The sister
responded, “ ‘Yes, but [the child] was doing nasty things to me so my mom makes him
sleep in the living room now, but he still sneaks in my room.’ ”
When asked for further clarification, the sister shared that the child touches her
private parts while she is asleep. The last time the child touched her private parts was the
day prior. The sister did not tell mother about the latest incident because mother was
sleeping, and she believed mother would be mad if she woke her. The social worker
8.
explained to the sister that it was important to tell mother when these things happen. The
sister explained that she was spanked or locked in the bathroom with “Penny Wise” when
she gets in trouble. She stated that “Penny Wise” lives in the toilet and eats people.
Next, the social worker interviewed the child privately in the sister’s room. The
child was asked if he liked living with mother, and he stated that he no longer lived with
his former care provider because he was doing “ ‘nasty things.’ ” He indicated that he
had to sleep in the living room because he was doing “ ‘nasty things’ ” to his sister while
they shared the same bed. The child also shared that he goes in time out or with “Penny
Wise” when he gets in trouble. The social worker informed the adult males that the home
needed to be cleaned as she left the home.
On March 15, 2023, the department received a referral alleging that the child was
sexually abusing his sister, but the referral was evaluated out without further explanation.
The following day, a social worker met with mother to discuss her case plan and the
referral that was evaluated out. Mother shared that the children received mental health
services at a clinic, but she was unsure of their last appointment. The social worker
encouraged mother to schedule an appointment with the children’s therapist “ASAP.”
Mother was informed about the sister’s disclosure of inappropriate touching by the
child at night time. The social worker advised that a safety plan needed to be
implemented where either the child or sister slept with mother to prevent any future
incidents. Mother became upset and yelled,
“ ‘Your safety plan is stupid! This happened in the day time too!
[The child] pees in the bed! It’s not fair that I have to get peed on every
night for something that you guys let happen! My kids were molested in
that home and you guys didn’t do anything about it! Now I’m being
punished! When your stupid safety plan doesn’t work and it keeps
happening I hope you get fired!’ ”
The social worker attempted to explain the purpose of the safety plan to mother,
but she left after mother continued to yell and scream at her. On March 20, 2023, the
9.
sister denied that the child had touched her since her initial disclosure on March 14, 2023.
The sister initially claimed that she was sleeping in her own room while the child slept in
the living room. However, she corrected herself to state that she was sleeping in her
mother’s room while the child slept in her room.
During a home visit on March 30, 2023, the social worker observed a twin size
mattress and cereal on the living room floor. Mother stated that the children last met with
their therapist approximately two months earlier. The children’s therapist had been
attempting to meet with mother and the children, but mother did not make herself
available. Mother agreed to contact the children’s therapist as soon as possible. The
sister stated that she slept in her own room while the child slept in the living room. She
continued to deny that the child was still attempting to touch her inappropriately. The
child reported that he slept in the living room, and he denied that he was doing “nasty
things” to his sister.
In May 2023, the child’s mental health services were closed due to missed
appointments, inconsistent attendance, and his mother not returning phone calls from the
mental health staff. The child had not attended a mental health appointment since
February 9, 2023. On June 13, 2023, the social worker observed mother’s home to be
unsanitary, and the children lacked proper beds and bedding. The child had several
scratches and a bruise, and the sister admitted to scratching him. Mother and the child
would not explain how he received the bruise. The conditions of the home were not
improved during a home visit on the following day.
On June 15, 2023, the department placed the children and their younger sibling,
O.G., into protective custody due to the conditions of the home. A supplemental petition
pursuant to section 387 was filed alleging the previous disposition was ineffective in the
protection of the child. The petition alleged that the home was found to pose a health and
safety hazard. At the detention hearing held on June 26, 2023, the juvenile court ordered
10.
the children and O.G. detained from mother’s custody, and a combined jurisdiction and
disposition hearing was set for July 24, 2023.
The department’s jurisdiction report recommended that the allegations in the
supplemental petition be found true, and the disposition report recommended that no
additional family reunification services be provided to mother. The child and O.G. were
placed together in a resource family home, and the sister was placed in a different
resource family home. The report stated that the child was receiving mental health
services without any additional details, and it also indicated that he appeared to be
developmentally on target for his age. However, notes in the child’s health and education
passport stated that he had learning delays and special needs, and his care provider
reported signs of autism.
The department also recommended that the court not set a section 366.26 hearing
for the sister, at six years old, because it did not believe that she was a proper subject for
adoption or guardianship. An adoption review was completed on July 12, 2023, which
determined that the child, at five years old, and O.G., at 11 months old, appeared
appropriate for adoption and guardianship planning. The report noted that a preadoptive
placement needed to be located for the child and his siblings “right away.”
On August 18, 2023, the juvenile court sustained the allegations in the section 387
petition, ordered the children removed from mother’s custody, and denied additional
family reunification services for mother. The court found that there was clear and
convincing evidence that the sister was not a proper subject for adoption and no one was
willing to accept legal guardianship, and she was ordered to be placed in foster care with
a permanent plan of placement with a fit and willing relative. A section 366.26 hearing
was set for the child and O.G. on December 12, 2023.
Selection and Implementation Hearing
The department filed another request for an order authorizing a mental health
assessment, treatment, and services for the child on October 30, 2023. A declaration
11.
attached to the request stated that the child was in need of mental health counseling
because he hit other children and suffered with enuresis. The juvenile court granted the
order to authorize mental health treatment for the child on the date it was filed.
The initial section 366.26 report, dated December 1, 2023, recommended that the
child be placed in foster care with a permanent plan of placement with a fit and willing
relative. The child, at five years of age, was placed in a resource family home where the
care provider desired to adopt him. Since his second removal from mother in June 2023,
his placement was changed on two occasions. On June 22, 2023, the child and O.G. were
moved to a different resource family home because he had hit O.G. and presented
“concerning behaviors.” The child was subsequently moved from the resource family
home that he was sharing with O.G. on September 26, 2023. A separate placement was
located for the child, and he remained in that resource family home as of the date of the
report.
A physical examination was completed of the child on November 2, 2023, and
there were no significant medical concerns noted. A developmental evaluation was also
completed by a physician, and the child demonstrated age-appropriate development in the
areas of personal, social, fine motor, language, and gross motor skills. The child began
receiving wraparound services from the department on a weekly basis on May 31, 2023.
He also met with a youth partner each week to work on anxiety, disruptive behavior,
self-awareness, self-esteem, and physical and verbal aggression. The child’s care
provider also participated in bi-weekly meetings.
The child was participating in both individual and collaborative group therapy
once per week. He was currently working on disruptive and self-injurious behavior,
lying, disobeying rules, frustration, aggression, excessive energy, inattentiveness,
impulsivity, social skills, and emotional behavior. The wraparound social worker and
care provider noted that the child was doing well in his conduct as of November 7, 2023.
He was enrolled in school where his academic performance indicated that he was
12.
developing in the areas of reading and writing. The child was also making satisfactory
progress in the areas of following school rules, speaking and listening, and physical
development. Areas in need of further growth were noted as listening without
interrupting, age-appropriate attention span, and playing well with others.
The report noted that mother participated in approximately 21 of her
40 opportunities to visit with the child since June 21, 2023. Visitation notes indicated
that mother engaged appropriately with the child, and no concerns were noted before or
after visits. According to the child’s care provider, the child did not ask about mother or
visitation when he was at home. The child was able to transition after visits without
issue. The social worker opined that the relationship between mother and the child had
diminished into a visiting relationship, and she believed the parent-child relationship
between them was minimal.
On November 7, 2023, the social worker spoke to the child about his feelings
regarding his current care provider becoming his long-term foster parent. The different
permanent plan options were explained to the child, but he did not appear to understand
their differences. He reported that he liked living with the care provider, and he wanted
to remain with his care provider. When asked to rate how certain he was about wanting
to stay with the care provider on a scale of one to 10, he responded “ ‘50.’ ” The care
provider indicated that the child referred to her as “ ‘mom.’ ” The child also informed his
wraparound social worker that he wanted to stay in his current placement if he could not
be returned to his mother.
The department’s assessment determined that termination of parental rights would
not be detrimental to the child. However, its initial report did not recommend termination
of parental rights because the child had only been placed with the new care provider for a
short time. The social worker stated that the child was not generally adoptable based on
his age and participation in mental health services. The department did recommend that
parental rights be terminated and a plan of adoption be ordered for O.G.
13.
The section 366.26 hearing was continued to April 5, 2024, for the department to
comply with ICWA. A supplemental report, dated April 4, 2024, provided an update on
the child’s status. On February 6, 2024, the social worker completed a home visit to the
care provider’s home. The child’s teacher informed the care provider that the child had a
bad day in the classroom because he was being disruptive. The child had to be calmed
down by the care provider over the phone while he was in class. The care provider noted
that the child was doing well in the home without any disruptive behavior. He recently
graduated from the wraparound program in January 2024. The care provider disciplined
the child by having his television time taken away or limited in options.
The social worker interviewed the child in private, and he reported that he wanted
to take his belongings and live in a different home. He stated that he wanted to live with
either his siblings, in a former resource family home, or in another home. He claimed
that his current care provider and “everyone” were mean. The child stated that he was
slapped on the face and hands “every day,” but he also reported that he was last hit one
week prior.
The child indicated that he was not allowed to eat snacks or breakfast when he was
in trouble. The social worker was unable to observe any bruises or scratches on the child,
and she encouraged him to follow rules at school and home. At the conclusion of the
home visit, the care provider reported that she wanted to adopt the child because her
adoptive son had learned to care for him and they played well together.
On March 7, 2024, another social worker completed a home visit at the child’s
placement. The care provider and the child were returning home after mother’s
scheduled visit was cancelled. The care provider’s adoptive son and the child were
rushed into the home by the care provider in a “very stern and directive manner.” Both of
the boys were asked if they needed to use the restroom, and only the adoptive son
responded in the affirmative. The care provider explained that the child will sometimes
wet himself if he is not reminded.
14.
The social worker went upstairs to see the bedroom that the child shared with the
adoptive son. The child told the social worker that he was doing “good.” The adoptive
son came into the bedroom, and he attempted to grab the television remote while the
child was showing the social worker what he likes to watch on television. The care
provider yelled for the adoptive son to leave the room, and she had to pull him out of the
room by his arm.
Once they were speaking privately again, the social worker asked the child if he
liked living in the home. He responded in the negative, and he claimed she was “mean”
towards him when he had difficulty sleeping because of his fear of the dark. The child
indicated that he would not want to live in the home forever because the care provider
was “mean.” The social worker attempted to clarify how the care provider was “mean,”
and he eventually stated that she did not let him play with his toys or watch television.
The child affirmed that he felt safe in the home, and he explained that he was not able to
watch television when he gets in trouble. The social worker noticed that the child was
moving around in place, and he prompted the child to use the restroom.
The care provider told the social worker that the child did not have any issues in
the home, but he was described as “very hyper.” The school contacted the care provider
almost daily because the child was either disrupting class or wetting himself. The care
provider explained that she disciplined the child by depriving him of his toys or
television. The social worker asked if the care provider was committed to adoption, and
she responded in the affirmative. The supplemental report continued to recommend that
the child remain placed in foster care with a permanent plan of placement with a fit and
willing relative.
On April 5, 2024, the section 366.26 hearing was continued at the department’s
request due to a pending ICWA inquiry. The department submitted a
second supplemental report, dated May 17, 2024, which recommended that the parental
15.
rights of mother and father be terminated and a plan of adoption be selected for the child.
The child remained placed in the same resource family home.
The emotional and mental health needs section of the report did not indicate that
the child was receiving mental health services since graduating from wraparound
services. However, he continued to display disruptive behavior in class. Mother agreed
to allow the child to repeat Kindergarten as recommended by his school due to a low
academic performance and maturity level. Two interventionists were present in the
child’s classroom for two hours per day to assist, elevate, and redirect the child’s
disruptive and physical behaviors.
On May 6, 2024, the social worker interviewed the child about his feelings on the
care provider becoming his adoptive parent. The child did not appear to understand the
differences between the different permanent plan options due to his age. The child
reported that he liked his current placement, and he wanted to remain with his current
care provider. The social worker observed the care provider refer to the child as “ ‘my
baby.’ ”
The social worker’s adoption assessment described the child as a “five-year-old,
sweet, outgoing and happy male.” The report opined that the child was “specifically
adoptable” due to his age, behavioral concerns in school, and history of placement
changes. The child had been in his current placement for almost eight months, and the
care provider expressed her commitment to adoption. The report noted that it would be
“somewhat difficult but not impossible to secure another pre-adoptive home for him.” It
concluded that the child would benefit from the permanency and stability of adoption,
and a permanent plan of adoption was recommended for the child.
The assessment of the child’s current care provider as a prospective adoptive
parent described her as a 57-year-old female, who lives with two children under legal
guardianship (14-year-old boy and 15-year-old boy), three adoptive children
(five-year-old boy, 14-year-old girl, and 15-year-old girl), and one additional foster child
16.
(15-year-old girl). The care provider’s home was a certified foster family agency
approved home in Kern County.
She lived in her current home since 2021, and the home had five bedrooms and
three bathrooms. One bedroom belonged to the child and five-year-old adoptive son.
Her criminal background check included no history that had not already been exempted.
She also had no substantiated child welfare history. The care provider indicated that she
did not have any major health issues that would prevent her from caring for the child.
The care provider was motivated to adopt the child in order to expand her family.
She loved the child, and she saw him as part of her family. Her desire was to provide
stability for the child, and she had fully integrated him into her family. The interaction
between the child and the care provider was observed to be positive. She acknowledged
her understanding of the legal and financial responsibilities of adoption, and she was
committed to a plan of adoption. The care provider was willing to assume responsibility
for the child into adulthood.
On May 21, 2024, the juvenile court held a contested section 366.26 hearing.
Mother, father, and the care provider were present for the hearing. Counsel for the
department informed the parties that it was submitting on its reports, and she was
prepared to call the adoption social worker to testify. The juvenile court responded that it
had “some concerns” about the child. Mother’s counsel intended to make an offer of
proof from mother and brief argument.
The adoption social worker testified on behalf of the department. She testified that
the resource family approval department went out to the care provider’s home in April to
mitigate any of the child’s concerns that the care provider was being “mean” to him. The
social worker and her supervisor also went out to the home in May to address any
potential concerns. The department determined that the child was referring to the care
provider as “mean” because she was enforcing consequences in response to his behavior
17.
at school. The decision was made by the social worker and her supervisor to leave the
child in the care provider’s home after completing their investigation.
The juvenile court began to conduct its own cross-examination of the social
worker based upon the child’s prior statement that he wanted to leave the care provider’s
home. The social worker confirmed the timeline of events that were detailed in the
department’s reports concerning her interactions with the child and his care provider. The
juvenile court asked the social worker if she was concerned about the child previously
reporting that he did not want to be in the care provider’s home, and she responded, “We
went to the home and discussed and he mentioned no concerns.” The juvenile court then
went on to ask,
“Okay. So you got a little guy who’s in a home and he’s telling
people, I don’t like being here, the caregiver is mean to me, and nobody
does anything about it. Don’t you think maybe he finally, eventually says,
“Okay, fine, I’m fine”? I’m asking for your opinion, because I have
concerns here. It doesn’t sound like anybody is listening to [the child], and
it doesn’t sound like [the child] knows anybody is listening to him. And the
caregiver might be the greatest person on earth, but we’ve got a kid who’s
got some concerns and nobody’s telling him, I’m hearing you, I’m listening
to you. Do you understand why I am concerned?”
The social worker responded in the affirmative, and the juvenile court proceeded
to ask if she could provide anything to alleviate its concerns. The social worker
responded as follows:
“We went out to the home in May. He said there’s no concerns. His
concerns are just in school, not in the home. He is a child that’s very happy,
very outgoing. He’s playful. He’s jumping all around, and there’s always
discipline for everything, but it’s appropriate discipline.
“We have reminded the caregiver. She insisted to adopt him. She
wants to adopt him. And he seems to be fine in the home.”
After testimony was provided by mother and father regarding their visitation with
the child, the hearing proceeded with closing arguments from counsel. Mother’s counsel
argued that the department’s position that the child was “specifically adoptable” allowed
18.
the parties to “look into the adoptive home.” Her counsel asserted that the child was not
“specifically adoptable by this particular family. And while he may be able to remain
there, it should be in some other capacity, such as long-term foster care and, obviously,
his situation could be reassessed in a future date. But I think the facts support a finding
as I’m suggesting to the Court concerning his adoptability.”
The child’s counsel initially requested that the court find an exception to adoption
applies, and he proceeded to state the following:
“My request would be long-term foster care based on just the length
of time that the foster placement has been in place. I think the Department
has examined the home and has looked into things because the caretaker
has had—she has other children in her care and has adopted other children.
I don’t really have specific concerns with her, but because it is—there have
been these recent issues and concerns expressed by [the child], I just think
it would be better to have eyes on and be able to monitor that situation until
we know more in the future. So that’s my position today.”
The department’s counsel argued that there was clear and convincing evidence that
the child was likely to be adopted based upon the current care provider’s commitment to
adopt him despite his behaviors.
After hearing argument from all counsel, the juvenile court proceeded to its ruling
on the section 366.26 hearing. The court began with its determination on the beneficial
parent-child relationship exception to adoption, and it did not find that mother met her
burden to prove the exception. Next, the court turned to the issue of adoptability by
reasoning as follows:
“The question I have is whether—I mean I don’t think there’s any
question that [the child] is just specifically adoptable. The question in my
mind is whether this is—whether it’s in his best interests to terminate
parental rights and put him on the road to adoption in this home.
“This may be the perfect home for him. It may be that whatever his
issues were previously were such that he’s overcome them or they’ve
overcome them, but I cannot, given the state of the evidence, say I’m going
to terminate parental rights forever and say that he’s going to be adopted by
19.
this family when I don’t have confidence that that is really where he feels
safe and loved.
“So I’m not saying he needs to be removed, but I am saying that
when he expresses concern, he needs to understand that those concerns are
being heard and he needs to understand that we don’t want him to be in a
place where he doesn’t feel safe. We don’t want him to be in a place where
he feels that he’s not loved and nurtured.
“Now the most recent evidence is that he is feeling loved in this
place, but what I don’t know is whether he’s just given up saying, I’m not
comfortable here, or whether something has changed there. And I don’t
have evidence to satisfy that, so I can’t terminate parental rights for [the
child], at this point.”
The juvenile court concluded its ruling by explaining that it wanted the child to
have permanency and stability, but it did not want the child to be in a home forever that
he had concerns about. After its ruling, the department’s counsel asked for clarification
as to the exception that the court was applying. The court then stated, “I find that [the
child] is not generally adoptable and that there is not clear and convincing evidence that
he would be adopted at this time. There is not clear and convincing evidence he would
be adopted by this family.”
In making its findings, the juvenile court noted that it was not requesting for the
child to be moved from the care provider’s home, but it wanted the department to give
more attention to the statements the child makes in his placement. The court went on to
find that the child’s current placement was necessary and appropriate. The court found
that there was not clear and convincing evidence that the child was likely to be adopted,
and ordered APPLA as the permanent plan for the child. The department filed a timely
notice of appeal on June 6, 2024.
DISCUSSION
The department challenges the sufficiency of the evidence to support the juvenile
court’s finding that the child was not adoptable. The department contends the record
supports a finding that the child was likely to be adopted, there were no legal
20.
impediments to adoption, and the court erred when it considered the child’s best interest
outside of the context of the exceptions to adoption.
A. Legal Principles
Once the juvenile court sets a hearing pursuant to section 366.26 to select and
implement a permanent plan for a dependent child, the department must prepare an
assessment, frequently referred to as an adoption assessment. “Such an adoption
assessment provides the information necessary for the juvenile court to determine
whether it is likely the child will be adopted [citation] and to consequently order
termination of parental rights.” (In re G.M. (2010) 181 Cal.App.4th 552, 559.) The
assessment must include “[a] preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment
of any identified prospective adoptive parent .…” (§ 366.21, subd. (i)(1)(D).) “A child’s
current caretaker may be designated as a prospective adoptive parent if the child has lived
with the caretaker for at least six months, the caretaker currently expresses a commitment
to adopt the child, and the caretaker has taken at least one step to facilitate the adoption
process. (§ 366.26, subd. (n)(1).)” (G.M., at p. 559.)
At the section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile court must determine by clear and
convincing evidence whether it is likely the minor will be adopted. (§ 366.26,
subd. (c)(1).) If the court finds a likelihood of adoption, the court must terminate parental
rights absent evidence termination would be detrimental to the minor under one of the
exceptions to adoption (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)–(vi)) that are not applicable here.
(See In re Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53.)
In determining adoptability, the juvenile court assesses the child’s age, physical
condition and emotional state and how these characteristics affect a prospective parent’s
willingness to adopt the child. (In re Sarah M. (1994) 22 Cal.App.4th 1642, 1649
(Sarah M.).) To be considered adoptable, the child need not be in a prospective adoptive
home and there need not be a prospective adoptive parent waiting to adopt. The fact a
prospective adoptive parent has expressed interest in adopting the child is evidence the
21.
child’s age, physical condition, mental state, and other matters relating to the child are not
likely to dissuade adoption of the minor. A prospective adoptive parent’s willingness to
adopt generally indicates the minor is likely to be adopted within a reasonable time either
by the prospective adoptive parent or by some other family. (In re R.C. (2008) 169
Cal.App.4th 486, 491 (R.C.).)
The “ ‘likely to be adopted’ standard is a low threshold.” (In re J.W. (2018) 26
Cal.App.5th 263, 267.) “[A] child may only be found to be difficult to place for adoption
if there is no identified or available prospective adoptive parent for the child because of
the child’s membership in a sibling group, or the presence of a diagnosed medical,
physical, or mental handicap, or the child is seven years of age or older.” (§ 366.26,
subd. (c)(3).)
In assessing adoptability, some courts have divided children into two categories:
those who are “generally adoptable” and those who are “specifically adoptable.” A child
is “generally adoptable” if the child’s traits, e.g., age, physical condition, mental state and
other relevant factors do not make it difficult to find an adoptive parent. A child is
“specifically adoptable” if the child is adoptable only because of a specific caregiver’s
willingness to adopt. (R.C., supra, 169 Cal.App.4th at pp. 492–494.) “ ‘When a child is
deemed adoptable only because a particular caretaker is willing to adopt, the analysis
shifts from evaluating the characteristics of the child to whether there is any legal
impediment to the prospective adoptive parent’s adoption and whether he or she is able to
meet the needs of the child.’ ” (Id. at p. 494.) For example, a married person, not
lawfully separated, may not adopt a child without the consent of the spouse. (Sarah M.,
supra, 22 Cal.App.4th at p. 1650, citing Fam. Code, § 8603.)
B. Standard of Review
Where, as here, the juvenile court concluded that the party with the burden of
proof did not carry the burden, “the question for a reviewing court becomes whether the
evidence compels a finding in favor of the appellant as a matter of law. [Citations.]
22.
Specifically, the question becomes whether the appellant’s evidence was
(1) ‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’ and (2) ‘of such a character and weight as to leave
no room for a judicial determination that it was insufficient to support a finding.’ ” (In re
I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528.)
C. Analysis
“At the selection and implementation hearing under section 366.26, the trial court
determines whether the child is adoptable on the basis of clear and convincing evidence.”
(In re Josue G. (2003) 106 Cal.App.4th 725, 732.) “A prospective ‘family’s suitability to
adopt is irrelevant to the issue whether the minor[] [is] likely to be adopted,’ which is the
only issue at the selection and implementation hearing. [Citation.] ‘The sole issue at the
selection and implementation hearing is whether there is clear and convincing evidence
that the child is adoptable. [Citations.] In resolving this issue, the court focuses on the
child—whether his age, physical condition and emotional state make it difficult to find a
person willing to adopt him. [Citation.]’ ” (Id. at p. 733.)
“Where the social worker opines that the minor is likely to be adopted based solely
on the existence of a prospective adoptive parent who is willing to adopt the minor, an
inquiry may be made into whether there is any legal impediment to adoption by that
parent .…” (Sarah M., supra, 22 Cal.App.4th at p. 1650.) However, “ ‘[g]eneral
suitability to adopt is a subjective matter which does not constitute a legal impediment to
adoption. If inquiry into the suitability of prospective adoptive parents were permitted in
section 366.26 hearings, we envision that many hearings would degenerate into
subjective attacks on all prospective adoptive families in efforts to avoid termination of
parental rights. Such a result is not envisioned by the statutory scheme.’ ” (Ibid.,
fn. omitted.)
“ ‘[T]he question of a family’s suitability to adopt is an issue which is reserved for
the subsequent adoption proceeding.’ ’’ (R.C., supra, 169 Cal.App.4th at p. 494, citing In
re Scott M. (1993) 13 Cal.App.4th 839, 844; In re Marina S. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 158,
23.
166 [“[T]here is no requirement that an adoptive home study be completed before a court
can terminate parental rights.”].) The question before the juvenile court is whether the
child is likely to be adopted within a reasonable time, not whether any particular adoptive
parents are suitable.
The department contends that the juvenile court based its refusal to terminate
parental rights on a best interest determination without consideration of any legal
impediments or statutory exceptions to adoption. Mother asserts that the department’s
evidence was contradicted and there was room for the juvenile court to make its
determination that adoption is not in the child’s best interest under section 366.26,
subdivision (h)(1), as there are concerns that adoption by the care provider was not in the
child’s best interest. Father joins in the arguments set forth in mother’s brief.
To the extent that the juvenile court found that the child was not adoptable because
it did not have confidence that the child felt safe and loved in the care provider’s home,
such concerns were not relevant to the child’s adoptability.2 The record demonstrated
that the care provider was certified as a resource parent, and she had previously adopted
other children who were still living in the home. The department had already completed
its investigation into the child’s previous complaints, and it determined that he made the
allegations because he was upset about the care provider’s provision of consequences for
his disruptive behavior at school. At the time of the hearing, the child had reaffirmed his
desire to remain in the home, and he reported that he felt safe in the care provider’s home.
2 The juvenile court’s potential concerns could have been alleviated by continuing
the hearing for further investigation by the child’s court appointed counsel. (See
section 317, subd. (e)(2) [“If the child is four years of age or older, counsel shall
interview the child to determine the child’s wishes and to assess the child’s well-being,
and shall advise the court of the child’s wishes.…”].)
24.
The care provider understood the responsibilities of adopting, and she was
committed to provide for the child until he reached adulthood. Because the juvenile
court’s determination was not directed to any legal impediments which would preclude
the care provider from adopting the child, it erred when it refused to terminate parental
rights. In fact, the juvenile court stated at the outset of its ruling that, “I don’t think
there’s any question that [the child] is just specifically adoptable.” Such a statement
makes it clear that the court believed that the care provider was able and willing to adopt
the child. Accordingly, the record was uncontradicted that there were no legal
impediments to the care provider’s ability to adopt the child.
Next, mother claims that the juvenile court’s finding was supported because the
child had a history of concerning behaviors and mental health needs. While such
concerns may raise issues as to the child’s general adoptability, they would not prevent
the child from being considered specifically adoptable by his current care provider or
another prospective adoptive parent. “ ‘ “[I]t is only common sense that when there is a
prospective adoptive home in which the child is already living, and the only indications
are that, if matters continue, the child will be adopted into that home, adoptability is
established.…” ’ ” (In re J.W., supra, 26 Cal.App.5th at p. 268.) “Very few children in
the dependency system are without problems. To deny [the child] the chance to
permanently become a member of the family that loves him and that he loves, simply
because he has special needs, would derail the entire concept of permanent planning. The
evidence shows that the placement is working and that [the child] is adoptable.” (Id. at
pp. 268–269.)
In assessing the adoptability of a high-needs child, “the assessment of the
adoptability of [the] child must necessarily include some consideration of whether the
prospective adoptive parents can meet that child’s needs, since if the prospective adoptive
parents cannot meet the child’s needs, the child cannot properly be found to be
adoptable.” (In re Carl R. (2005) 128 Cal.App.4th 1051, 1062 (Carl R.).) However, the
25.
juvenile court’s focus was not on the ability of the care provider to meet the child’s needs,
but it based its decision on the subjective statements of a five-year-old child. The care
provider had demonstrated a competent and commendable ability to address the needs of
a child who had experienced multiple placement disruptions and removals from his
mother. Accordingly, there was no room for a judicial determination that there was
insufficient evidence to support a finding that the child was likely to be adopted.
Finally, mother asserts that the juvenile court’s finding should be upheld because it
was not in the child’s best interest to be adopted by his current care provider. At all
proceedings under section 366.26, “the court shall consider the wishes of the child and
shall act in the best interests of the child.” (§ 366.26, subd. (h)(1).) However, unless the
child is age 12 or over and objects to the termination of parental rights, this does not
mean that the court must follow the child’s wishes, because what a child wants is not
necessarily determinative of his or her best interest. (§ 366.26, subds. (c)(1)(B)(ii), (h);
In re Joshua G. (2005) 129 Cal.App.4th 189, 201.)
Furthermore, the juvenile court must consider the best interest of the child only in
the context of whether one of the exceptions in section 366.26, subdivision (c)(1)(A) and
(B) applies. (In re Tabatha G. (1996) 45 Cal.App.4th 1159, 1165.) “The purpose of the
specified exceptions is to ensure that termination of parental rights is in the child’s best
interests and is the least detrimental alternative.” (Carl R., supra, 128 Cal.App.4th at
p. 1070.) A child’s “feelings about adoption are necessarily considered when determining
whether the parent-child relationship exception to termination of parental rights
applies .…” (In re Scott B. (2010) 188 Cal.App.4th 452, 472, fn. 4.)
Where no exception is applicable, as in the present case, it is in the child’s best
interest to terminate parental rights. (Carl R., supra, 128 Cal.App.4th at p. 1070.)
Accordingly, the juvenile court was not permitted to consider whether the child’s best
interest would be served by selecting an alternative permanent plan. “The Legislature has
determined what is in a child’s best interests by implementing the procedures,
26.
presumptions, and time lines in the dependency scheme. [Citations.] The Legislature has
provided five exceptions to terminating parental rights, and a general exception for the
best interests of the child is not among them. Whether such an exception should exist is a
question for the Legislature, not this court.” (Ibid.)
In sum, the juvenile court erred when it determined that the question to be
resolved was “whether it’s in [the child’s] best interests to terminate parental rights” after
it already found that the parent-child relationship exception to adoption was inapplicable.
There is simply no general “best interest” exception to the termination of parental rights
and the legislative preference for adoption. (In re Jamie R. (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 766,
774.) Accordingly, the court erred when it failed to find that the child was likely to be
adopted and ordered a plan other than adoption.3
Although we could decide the issue of the child’s adoptability on the record
developed at the time of the hearing, we decline to do so. For this court to determine the
child’s adoptability as it existed six months ago without any consideration of the child’s
continued progress in the care provider’s home in the interim would serve no one. We
therefore remand the matter to the juvenile court for a determination on the child’s
adoptability in light of the authority set forth in this decision.
DISPOSITION
The order determining APPLA to be the appropriate permanent plan is reversed.
The juvenile court is directed to conduct a new section 366.26 hearing consistent with the
authority presented in this opinion. The parties may introduce such additional relevant
evidence as they deem necessary, including but not limited to, evidence of the child’s
current circumstances and any developments that might have occurred during the
pendency of this appeal.
3 We also note that the juvenile court improperly selected a permanent plan of
APPLA for the five-year-old child, which is not authorized for children under the age of
16. (See section 366.26, subd. (c)(4)(B)(ii).)
27.
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.