CourtListener 10269677•In re J.P. CA2/2
Texto completo
Filed 11/8/24 In re J.P. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re J.P., a Person Coming B334183
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
22CCJP02453A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
JOSE P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Cathy Ostiller, Judge. Affirmed.
Jane B. Winer, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Tracey Dodds, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_____________________________________
Presumed father Jose P. (Father) appeals a juvenile court
order terminating his reunification services at the 18-month
permanency review hearing. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366.22.)1 He
contends that the court abused its discretion by (1) denying him
further services, and (2) finding no reason to believe that the
Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) applies to the child.
The record shows no abuse of discretion. Father refused to
participate in services. No further services had to be provided
because he made no progress. The ICWA issue is moot because a
full ICWA inquiry was already ordered. We affirm.
FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
Case History Described in Father’s First Appeal
The facts in this first section are taken from our opinion in
In re J.P. (Apr. 8, 2024, B329638 [nonpub. opn.]):
J.P. was born in 2018 to Father and A.V. (Mother). He was
taken into protective custody by Los Angeles County Department
of Children and Family Services (DCFS) in June 2022, when
Mother was arrested while driving a stolen vehicle with J.P.
riding unsecured inside of it. Father was incarcerated and could
not take custody of J.P. Mother and Father have extensive arrest
histories, starting at age 15.
1 Undesignated statutory references in this opinion are to
the Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
J.P. was placed with his paternal grandmother (PGM), who
denied Indian ancestry when questioned in court. Mother and
Father also denied Indian heritage.
In September 2022, the court sustained one count against
Mother for endangering J.P. Father submitted to dependency
jurisdiction. J.P. was removed from parental custody. The court
ordered reunification services and monitored visits. Because
Father was incarcerated for much of J.P.’s life, the court ordered
him to participate in individual counseling to address the impact
of incarceration on J.P., as well as substance abuse issues.
Father was released from custody in October 2022. He met
with the social worker (CSW) to discuss resources and the case
plan. She advised him to sign up for medical benefits to receive
therapy, offered transportation assistance, and showed him how
to access links to service agencies. He was homeless but called
and saw J.P. CSW was unable to obtain Father’s phone number
from Mother or PGM, though Mother said that he needed to
“sober up.” Father texted CSW in February 2023, but did not
reply when she asked him for an update on his counseling.
The court ordered Father to meet with CSW and submit to
a drug test. Father told CSW he felt no responsibility for the
dependency proceeding; he had no insight into the impact of his
recidivism on J.P.’s well-being. Father agreed to participate in a
parenting program and monitored visits until he made progress
on understanding case issues. He then failed to show up for a
scheduled intake appointment with a service provider.
At the six-month review hearing in March 2023, Father
blamed DCFS for failing to get him into a counseling program.
The court ruled that he must participate in services before
moving in with PGM and J.P. The court continued reunification
3
services and found that DCFS made reasonable efforts to return
J.P. to a safe home.
Father appealed the ruling. We concluded that he received
reasonable services and was responsible for his failure to
participate. The court’s refusal to allow Father to live with PGM
was proper because it would pose a detriment to J.P. We wrote
that ICWA imposes a continuing duty to ask extended family if
the child is, or may be, Indian. At the six-month stage of the
proceeding, there was still time to identify relatives having
information relevant to the ICWA inquiry.
The 12-Month Hearing
In August 2023, DCFS reported that Mother was arrested
in a hotel room with a stolen motorcycle, firearms, ammunition,
and drug paraphernalia. At the request of DCFS, the court
ended Mother’s unsupervised visits with J.P. and required that
her visits be monitored.
In September 2023, DCFS reported that Mother’s therapist
ended treatment after she stopped attending sessions in March.
Mother planned to enroll in a substance abuse program and
hoped to be released from prison by the end of 2023. Four-year-
old J.P. continued to live with PGM; he speaks English and
Spanish. He had tantrums and aggression from post-traumatic
stress disorder (PTSD). PGM said that her authority was
undermined by Mother, who contradicted PGM’s disciplinary
measures, lied to PGM, and falsely told J.P. that PGM wanted to
take him away from Mother.
Father did not comply with court orders or answer calls
from CSW or letters mailed to him. PGM said she was unable to
motivate Father to make progress toward reunification. CSW
submitted several referrals for him for parenting classes. In July
4
2023, he walked into a clinic and enrolled in counseling. DCFS
sought to pay for the services, but Father failed to show up for
sessions or respond to messages. “DCFS continue[d] to have
great concerns as to father’s ability to maintain a safe and stable
environment for the child.”
PGM monitored visits for Father, when he communicated
with her, and said his visits are good. She hoped he could move
in with her and J.P. DCFS did not liberalize visits because
Father made no progress in his case plan and showed no interest
in mitigating case issues to ensure J.P.’s safety and regain
custody.
A hearing was held in September 2023, but because Mother
and Father were incarcerated, the court continued the hearing to
secure their attendance.
In last-minute reports, DCFS wrote that Mother was
released from prison in October 2023. She admitted to a relapse
and to using methamphetamine, but said she was no longer using
drugs. PGM facilitated monitored visits between Mother and J.P.
Father showed up unexpectedly at one visit, after PGM had not
seen or spoken to him “in a while.” J.P. attended counseling for
PTSD and PGM was learning how to respond to his behavior.
Mother restarted therapy sessions. DCFS asked the court to
terminate reunification services.
After several continuances, the court held the 12-month
hearing on November 27, 2023. Father was not present. The
court observed, “Father really does not seem to be taking much of
an interest in this case.” Mother argued that her recent
incarceration prevented her from securing services, as did an
injury sustained in a car accident and financial constraints. She
had resumed counseling. Father asked the court to find that he
5
did not receive reasonable services. He blamed his inability to
comply with the case plan on his lack of housing.
The court found that continued jurisdiction was necessary
because the conditions that justified dependency still exist and
returning J.P. to parental custody would create a substantial risk
of detriment. The court found that Mother made partial progress
in completing the case plan; Father’s progress was unsubstantial.
DCFS made reasonable efforts to return J.P. to a safe home and
complete steps needed to finalize his permanent placement. The
court continued reunification services and ordered DCFS to
provide Father with housing assistance. Parental visits had to be
monitored.
The 18-Month Hearing
In December 2023, DCFS reported that PGM did not want
to be J.P.’s legal guardian, to avoid conflict with Mother. PGM
declined further mental health therapy for J.P.; his current
therapist was leaving and PGM’s choices were limited because
she requires a Spanish-speaking therapist. J.P. continued to act
out, and kicked PGM. PGM had not enrolled J.P. in school.
Mother was in therapy, hoping to overcome criminal
thinking, break old patterns, and create new opportunities by
getting a job and going to school. She had housing through her
probation, which was scheduled to end in October 2024. She
visited J.P. three times a week and arrived with food for him.
In November 2023, while CSW was meeting PGM and J.P.,
Father stopped by to see J.P. CSW gave Father her business
card and asked for his phone number. He replied that he does
not have a phone or an address. CSW reminded him that the
court ordered him to participate in counseling, and DCFS would
help him with housing.
6
CSW wrote that during her meeting with Father, “he
appeared jittery, [and was] unable to remain [ ] standing; he
exhibited rapid speech, and appeared to be under the influence.”
PGM said it would be unsafe for Father to have unmonitored
visits “ ‘because he is using drugs.’ ”
Father came to the DCFS office. He and CSW reviewed the
most recent court order and case plan. Father said he previously
enrolled in therapy but was unable to pay for it. He asked about
housing and paying for classes. CSW gave Father a resource
package for housing and services. They discussed enrolling in
therapy with financial support from DCFS, and drug testing. He
was given contact information for his attorney and agreed to
meet with CSW once a month.
In December 2023, CSW gave Father bus passes, a referral
to Turning Point for therapy, and referrals to two organizations
for housing. DCFS advised the court that Father just made
contact and had not progressed toward meeting case plan goals.
It recommended termination of parental reunification services.
In a report for the January 2024 hearing, DCFS wrote that
J.P. continues to live with PGM, who provides for all his needs.
She planned to enroll J.P. in kindergarten if he remains placed
with her. Mother participated in twice-weekly counseling. She
had a new job. DCFS opined that Mother’s recent arrest
demonstrated limited insight or change, making her unable to
provide J.P. with a safe and stable home.
Father did not comply with court orders or the case plan.
He belatedly sought out CSW at the end of November 2023 and
obtained referrals for housing and therapy, and bus passes. CSW
scheduled a drug test for Father, but when he arrived at the lab,
he lacked identification and was unable to test. He had a
7
monitored visit with J.P. on December 15, 2023. He was
homeless but did not want shelter services.
Father’s lack of engagement meant that safety issues were
unaddressed. He did not demonstrate his ability to overcome the
problems that led to J.P.’s dependency. He had minimal contact
with J.P. and was unmotivated to comply with court orders.
DCFS feared for five-year-old J.P.’s physical and emotional safety
if he were released to Father. Father had not tested for drugs
but has a history of substance abuse. He could not provide J.P.
with a consistent, safe, and stable environment.
J.P. said he missed his parents and seemed happy during
their visits. He adapted well in PGM’s home, and she
communicates responsibly with DCFS, but she no longer wished
to be J.P.’s legal guardian. DCFS recommended termination of
family reunification services.
Father did not appear at the hearing on January 2, 2024,
despite having notice from his attorney. Counsel for J.P. believed
that services should be terminated. Though Mother visited J.P.
regularly, her arrest for grand theft during the dependency case
showed limited insight and inability to provide J.P. with a safe
and stable home. Father was not enrolled in services and did not
test for drugs.
DCFS noted that PGM’s unwillingness to serve as J.P.’s
guardian was caused by Mother’s adversarial behavior. Father
has been “disengaged with his very simple case plan” since the
inception of the case. When CSW finally saw Father at PGM’s
home, by chance, he appeared to be under the influence. PGM
allowed Father to visit J.P. while in a state of apparent
intoxication and would not control Father if he lived with her,
placing J.P. at high risk.
8
Mother argued that she was progressing in counseling
following her most recent stint in prison. She tested negative for
drugs for the probation department and in her transitional living
program. Father requested custody of J.P., in PGM’s home, or
additional reunification services.
The court found that DCFS made reasonable efforts to
return J.P. to a safe home and finalize his placement. Mother
made substantial progress to alleviate the causes leading to J.P.’s
removal; she was given additional reunification services and
monitored visits. Father’s progress was “unsubstantial.” The
court found, “Father has received all reunification services to
which he is entitled.” It terminated his services because he “has
not been engaged in services, and he . . . appears to be under the
influence and struggling with sobriety at this time.”
DISCUSSION
1. Termination of Reunification Services
Father contends that the court abused its discretion by
ending his reunification services at the 18-month hearing. He
agrees that discretion is abused if the court “ ‘ “exceeded the
bounds of reason.” ’ ” (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295,
318–319.) We determine whether the order is supported by
substantial evidence. (Fabian L. v. Superior Court (2013) 214
Cal.App.4th 1018, 1028.)
For J.P., who was three and a half years old when he was
removed from parental custody, “court-ordered services shall be
provided beginning with the dispositional hearing and ending 12
months after the date the child entered foster care.” (§ 361.5,
subd. (a)(1)(A).) Services “may be extended up to a maximum
time period not to exceed 18 months after the date the child was
9
originally removed” from custody. (Id., subd. (a)(3)(A).) The
court extended services for Father and Mother to 18 months.
At the 18-month hearing, the court may extend services
upon a showing that it would serve the child’s best interests and
the parent is “making significant and consistent progress in
establishing a safe home for the child’s return.” (§ 366.22, subd.
(b)(1).) There must be “a substantial probability that the child
will be returned to the physical custody” of the parent within the
extended period; consistent and regular visits with the child; and
the parent must make “significant and consistent progress in the
prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the child’s
removal.” (Id., subd. (b)(3)(A)–(B).) Eighteen months is generally
the outer statutory time limit for services. (In re Damian L.
(2023) 90 Cal.App.5th 357, 371.)
After reviewing the entire case history, we conclude that
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s findings, and
its order terminating Father’s reunification services was not an
abuse of discretion. When the hearing was held in January 2024,
19 months after J.P. was removed from parental custody, Father
had made no progress to resolve problems leading to dependency
jurisdiction. He was not receiving treatment. His visits with J.P.
were sporadic. J.P.’s attorney opposed further services because
Father was not in therapy or testing for drugs.
Father optimistically opines that he “met the challenge” of
engaging in the case plan. The record does not support his view.
From the time he was released from prison in 2022 until services
ended in 2024, Father squandered the opportunity to fulfill a
simple case plan requiring participation in counseling and drug
testing. No onerous requirements were imposed, such as a year-
long parenting class or drug treatment programs.
10
Only a minimal effort was needed, but Father was
unwilling to do even the minimum, despite meeting with the
CSW and receiving resources to find housing, get transportation,
and have therapy. He said he felt no responsibility for the
dependency proceeding, even if his incarceration prevented him
from taking custody of J.P. when Mother was arrested. He had
no insight into the impact of his conduct on his young son.
Counseling appointments were made, but Father did not show
up. He blamed everyone but himself for his situation.
Father had ample time to demonstrate his desire to comply
with court orders and ability to transcend his history of
criminality and substance abuse. Instead, he waited until the
eve of the 18-month hearing to exhibit a newfound interest in the
case. The record discloses no possibility that Father can provide
J.P. with a safe and stable home in the foreseeable future.
CSW had a chance meeting with Father in November 2023.
She saw that he was “jittery” and appeared to be under the
influence of drugs. Moreover, PGM said that J.P. would not be
safe with Father because Father “is using drugs.”
Father discounts DCFS’s evidence about recent drug use
because it appeared in a last-minute report. However, he did not
object or attempt to deny its truth below. Father forfeited his
right to challenge the evidence on appeal. The court credited the
evidence, finding that Father is “struggling with sobriety at this
time.” We cannot reweigh the evidence or substitute the juvenile
court’s findings with our own. (In re Stephanie M., supra, 7
Cal.4th at pp. 318–319.) Father could have undergone drug
testing to refute CSW’s and PGM’s statements about apparent
drug abuse, but he chose not to test. The court could reasonably
11
infer that Father’s failure to appear for counseling or drug tests
can be attributed to drug use.
Father writes that refusing to extend services for six more
months exceeds the bounds of reason because the case was
continued for Mother to receive additional services while she
participated in the case plan. However, “the court does not
consider the parents as one unit, but instead treats each of them
on his or her own merits.” (In re Katelynn Y. (2012) 209
Cal.App.4th 871, 877.) “ ‘In deciding whether to terminate the
services of one parent who has failed to participate or make
progress toward reunification, the court is not constrained by a
consideration of the other parent’s participation in services.’ ”
(Ibid.; In re Jesse W. (2007) 157 Cal.App.4th 49, 59–60 [court
need not continue services for one parent when reunification
services continue for the other parent]; In re Gabriel L. (2009)
172 Cal.App.4th 644, 651 [court has discretion to terminate
services for one parent even if ordering services for the other
parent].)
2. Compliance With ICWA
Father challenges the court’s finding that there is no
reason to know that J.P. is an Indian child. He seeks remand for
the court to order DCFS to conduct further inquiry into Father’s
family history. (§ 224.2.) We take judicial notice that on July 2,
2024, the court ordered DCFS “to follow up and conduct an ICWA
inquiry for father and his relatives,” “inquire with all appropriate
relatives” about possible Indian ancestry, and report on its ICWA
inquiry. The court also ended J.P.’s foster placement and
returned him to Mother.
DCFS argues that Father’s ICWA claim is moot, in light of
the court’s July 2024 order. “A reviewing court must ‘ “decide on
12
a case-by-case basis whether subsequent events in a juvenile
dependency matter make a case moot.” ’ ” (In re D.P. (2023) 14
Cal.5th 266, 276.) We “ ‘ “decide actual controversies.” ’ ” (Ibid.)
A case becomes moot when superseding events make it
impossible to grant the appellant any effective relief because
there is no “ongoing harm.” (Ibid.)
There is no actual controversy to decide. The ICWA
inquiry Father seeks on appeal is underway, perhaps even
completed. We cannot direct the court to issue an order when it
has already issued that order. We decline Father’s invitation to
exercise discretion to address a moot issue.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
CHAVEZ, J.
HOFFSTADT, J.
13
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.