CourtListener 10125080•In re Emma A. CA2/7
Texto completo
Filed 9/25/24 In re Emma A. CA2/7
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SEVEN
In re EMMA A. et al., Persons B334544
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 21CCJP03705 D&E)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
ARTURO A. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Daniel Zeke Zeidler, Judge. Affirmed.
Roni Keller, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant Arturo A.
Donna P. Chirco, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant Annel L.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Veronica Randazzo, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________
INTRODUCTION
Arturo A. and Annel L. appeal from the juvenile court’s
orders terminating their parental rights to Emma A. and
Ysabella A. under Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26.1
Arturo and Annel argue the court erred in terminating their
parental rights because, according to Arturo and Annel, the
court’s orders would interfere with their children’s sibling
relationships and the court should have applied the sibling
relationship exception to adoption (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(v)).
Because the court did not err in ruling that exception did not
apply, we affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Emma Tests Positive for Methamphetamine at Birth,
and the Juvenile Court Removes Her and Ysabella
from Annel and Arturo
Annel has four children. Arturo is the father of Ysabella
(now five years old) and Emma (now three years old). Jose L. is
the father of Jesus L. (now 12 years old) and Victoria L. (now
10 years old), although Jesus and Victoria are not the direct
subjects of this appeal. When Annel gave birth to Emma in
1 Statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code.
2
July 2021, she and Emma tested positive for methamphetamine.
Annel admitted to hospital staff that she had used
methamphetamine “for many years,” but said that she stopped
“days before” giving birth to Emma “to see if [she] could test
negative for drugs.” Annel told a social worker from the
Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
that she had three other children who were living with relatives.
Annel reported that she and Arturo were living in a car and that
Arturo has schizophrenia and “hears voices and sees things that
are not there.”
Jose told the social worker that he and Annel separated
four or five years ago because “there was ongoing conflict within
the relationship.” Jose said that he was “not surprised” Annel
exposed her newborn baby to drugs during the pregnancy, that he
“always suspected” Annel used drugs, and that he believed Annel
left their children with relatives when she went out to use drugs.
The Department could not locate Arturo and conducted a due
diligence search for him. During most of the dependency case,
the Department did not know where Arturo was.2
Further investigation by the Department revealed that
Annel left the children at least three times without making a
plan for their care, twice for two months and once for one month.
Annel admitted to the social worker that she has left the children
for “months at [a] time” because she “was binge smoking meth”
and did not want to expose the children to “drug induced
behaviors.” Elizabeth C., a paternal aunt, stated that Arturo has
2 A Department investigator told the court at the detention
hearing that he had not been able to find Arturo and that a
family member reported that, when Arturo learned about the
case, he said he wanted “nothing to do with the government.”
3
used drugs “for most of his life,” that Annel and Arturo had a
history of domestic violence, and that Annel would leave the
children for “weeks” to “get high.”
In October 2021 the court sustained an amended petition
under section 300, subdivisions (b) and (j), finding that Annel had
a history of domestic violence with Jose and Arturo; that Annel’s
history of using, and current use of, drugs placed Emma at risk of
physical harm and rendered Annel incapable of providing regular
care for her children; that Annel left the children in the care of
relatives without making a plan for their ongoing care and
supervision, and Jose and Arturo failed to protect their children;
and that Arturo’s mental health problems and history of
substance abuse rendered him incapable of providing regular
care for his children. The court declared all four children
dependent children of the juvenile court, removed Jesus and
Victoria from Annel and placed them with Jose under the
supervision of the Department, and removed Ysabella and Emma
from Annel and Arturo and placed them under the care and
supervision of the Department for suitable placement.
The Department placed Ysabella with Cleotilde R., the
children’s maternal grandmother, and maintained Emma’s
placement with Elizabeth, with whom Ysabella had been living
since the court detained her shortly after her birth. The court
ordered Annel to complete a substance abuse prevention
program, parenting classes, and individual counseling and to
submit to random on-demand testing.
4
B. Annel Complies with Her Case Plan and Regains
Custody of Ysabella and Emma
Over the next 12 months Annel completed her court-
ordered programs and largely tested clean, though she missed a
few tests. The social worker reported Ysabella and Emma were
thriving in the home of their respective caregivers, and the court
maintained the girls’ placements at the six-month review
hearing. In the spring of 2022 Ysabella got very sick and was in
the hospital for five weeks. Doctors diagnosed Ysabella with
autoimmune encephalitis, and Annel assisted Cleotilde with
caring for Ysabella, who required “a very strict regimen” of
medications. The court placed Ysabella with Annel on the
condition Annel and Ysabella both reside with Cleotilde.3 In
September 2022 Jose drove under the influence of alcohol (and
with a suspended license) while he was on his way to pick up his
children, hit a car, and attempted to flee the scene of the
accident.
At the 12-month review hearing in October 2022, the court
placed Jesus and Victoria with Cleotilde. The court also
permitted Emma to have overnight visits with Annel at
Cleotilde’s home, where the other siblings were also staying. The
court later allowed Emma to have an extended visit with Annel
for two months.
In January 2023 the court found Annel had complied with
her case plan, placed Emma with Annel, and maintained
Ysabella’s placement with Annel in Cleotilde’s home. With
respect to Jesus and Victoria, the court sustained allegations in
3 We augment the record to include the juvenile court’s
July 14, 2022, January 11, 2023, and February 17, 2023 minute
orders. (Cal. Rules of Court, rules 8.155(a)(1)(A), 8.410(b)(1).)
5
an amended petition that Jose drove under the influence of
alcohol, removed Jesus and Victoria from Jose, and placed them
with Annel under the supervision of the Department. The
following month, the court terminated its jurisdiction over
Ysabella and released her to Annel.
C. Annel Relapses and Loses Custody Again
In June 2023 Annel left the children at Cleotilde’s home
without notifying anyone or instructing anyone how to care for
the children, including how to administer Ysabella’s medications.
The following day, Ysabella suffered a seizure and required
immediate medical attention, but Cleotilde did not know where
Annel (who had taken the children’s food stamps) was or how to
reach her. Cleotilde believed Annel had run off with Arturo to
use drugs.
The Department filed a supplemental petition under
section 387 regarding Jesus, Victoria, and Emma and a new
petition under section 300, subdivision (b), regarding Ysabella.
The Department alleged, among other things, Annel endangered
the children’s physical health, safety, and well-being when she
left them without making a plan for their ongoing care and
supervision.4 At the hearing on the petitions, no one knew where
Annel and Arturo were. Counsel for the children informed the
court that the children had not seen Annel for almost two weeks.
The court detained all four children from Annel, placed Jesus and
Victoria with Cleotilde, Ysabella with a foster parent, and Emma
with Elizabeth and ordered twice monthly sibling visits.
4 The new petition under section 300, subdivision (b), also
alleged Arturo had a history of substance abuse, which rendered
him incapable of providing regular care for Ysabella.
6
The court later sustained the allegations in the petitions
under sections 300, subdivision (b), and 387. The court removed
all four children from Annel and found (or repeated prior
findings) that placing Emma or Ysabella with Arturo would pose
a substantial danger and risk of detriment to them. The court set
a selection and implementation hearing for Emma and Ysabella
under section 366.26.
In August 2023 Annel, on her own, filed a petition under
section 388, asking the court to grant her six months of
reunification services for Emma. Annel claimed that she “made
the choice of not having Arturo . . . in [her] life” and that she
would “keep trying” to improve herself for her children. The
court denied the petition because Annel was “represented by
counsel.” Four months later, counsel for Annel filed a petition
under section 388, which the court also denied.
In September 2023 the Department placed Ysabella back in
Cleotilde’s home. In November 2023 the court ordered the
Department to arrange weekly sibling visits. The social worker
reported that, though the Department gave Annel a written
visitation schedule, she sometimes did not show up or arrived
late. The social worker stated the sibling visits occurred once a
week at Cleotilde’s home. The reports did not include any details
of the sibling visits.
D. The Court Terminates Arturo’s and Annel’s
Parental Rights
In January 2024 the court placed Jesus and Victoria with
Jose and ordered him to ensure visits for the children at
Cleotilde’s house. The court stated Annel could participate in
7
conjoint counseling with the older children if she was in therapy
and the therapists recommended it.
The court proceeded to the selection and implementation
hearing for Ysabella and Emma. Counsel for Annel asked the
court to order legal guardianship in lieu of adoption for the girls
because “there would be a substantial interference with their
sibling relationship with one another and with their older two
siblings.” Counsel for Annel claimed that, while Annel would
continue to visit the two older children and Ysabella, visits with
Emma would “likely disappear” given the “fraught” relationship
between Annel and Elizabeth. Counsel for Annel pointed out
that the Department did not provide a plan for the caregivers to
facilitate sibling visitation. Counsel for Arturo joined Annel’s
request the court apply the sibling relationship exception to
adoption. Counsel for the children argued against applying the
sibling relationship exception and asked the court to terminate
Annel’s and Arturo’s parental rights. The court commented that,
because there was no information in the reports about the sibling
relationships, there was not much “to support the sibling bond
exception.”
The court observed that the only period Emma lived with
Annel was from October 2022 to June 2023 and that Emma had
spent almost her entire life outside of the home of any of her
siblings. The court acknowledged that Ysabella had “existing
close and strong bonds” with Jesus and Victoria and that she
shared “significant common experiences” with them. The court
found, however, that it would not be detrimental to Ysabella or
Emma if the sibling relationships ended as a result of the court
terminating Annel’s and Arturo’s parental rights and that the
benefit of the sibling relationships did not outweigh the
8
permanence of adoption. The court terminated Annel’s and
Arturo’s parental rights and transferred the children’s care,
custody, and control to the Department for adoptive planning and
placement.5 Annel and Arturo timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
A. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
“To guide the court in selecting the most suitable
permanent arrangement” for children who cannot reunify with
their parents, section 366.26 “lists plans in order of preference
and provides a detailed procedure for choosing among them.”
(In re Caden. C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614, 630; see § 366.26,
subd. (b).) “According to that procedure, the court must first
determine by clear and convincing evidence whether the child is
likely to be adopted. [Citation.] If so, and if the court finds that
there has been a previous determination that reunification
services be terminated, then the court shall terminate parental
rights to allow for adoption. [Citation.] But if the parent shows
that termination would be detrimental to the child for at least
one specifically enumerated reason, the court should decline to
terminate parental rights and select another permanent plan.”
(Caden C., at pp. 630-631; see § 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)-(vi),
(4)(A); In re Celine R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53 (Celine R.); In re
J.S. (2017) 10 Cal.App.5th 1071, 1080.)
One of the exceptions to “the normal requirement of
adoption” allows the juvenile court “to consider the sibling
relationship in deciding whether a compelling reason exists to
5 The Department designated Cleotilde as Ysabella’s
adoptive parent and Elizabeth as Emma’s adoptive parent.
9
choose something other than adoption.” (Celine R., supra,
31 Cal.4th at pp. 53, 54; see § 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(v); In re
Elizabeth M. (2018) 19 Cal.App.5th 768, 781 (Elizabeth M.); In re
J.S., supra, 10 Cal.App.5th at p. 1080.) “The purpose of the
sibling exception is to preserve long-standing sibling
relationships that serve as ‘anchors for dependent children whose
lives are in turmoil.’” (Elizabeth M., at p. 781; see In re Isaiah S.
(2016) 5 Cal.App.5th 428, 437.) The sibling relationship
exception applies when the juvenile court concludes there would
be “substantial interference with a child’s sibling relationship,
taking into consideration the nature and extent of the
relationship, including, but not limited to, whether the child was
raised with a sibling in the same home, whether the child shared
significant common experiences or has existing close and strong
bonds with a sibling, and whether ongoing contact is in the child’s
best interest, including the child’s long-term emotional interest,
as compared to the benefit of legal permanence through
adoption.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(v); see Elizabeth M., at
p. 781; In re D.O. (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 166, 173.) “‘To show a
substantial interference with a sibling relationship the parent . . .
must show the existence of a significant sibling relationship, the
severance of which would be detrimental to the child.’”
(Elizabeth M., at p. 781; see In re L.Y.L. (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th
942, 952.)
“‘The court is specifically directed to consider the best
interests of the adoptive child, not the siblings, and must
ultimately determine whether adoption would be detrimental to
the adoptive child, not the siblings.’” (Celine R., supra,
31 Cal.4th at p. 54; see In re D.O., supra, 247 Cal.App.4th at
p. 174.) “The parent has the burden of proving the statutory
10
exception applies.” (Elizabeth M., supra, 19 Cal.App.5th at
p. 781; see In re J.S., supra, 10 Cal.App.5th at p. 1080.)
“We will apply the substantial evidence standard of review
to evaluate the evidentiary showing with respect to factual
issues, such as whether the child has a close and strong bond
with a sibling . . . . [Citations.] However, a challenge to the trial
court’s determination of questions such as whether, given the
existence of a sibling relationship, there is a compelling reason
for determining that termination of parental rights would be
detrimental to the child ‘“is a quintessentially discretionary
determination.”’” (In re J.S., supra, 10 Cal.App.5th at p. 1080;
see In re D.O., supra, 247 Cal.App.4th at p. 174.) Thus, when the
juvenile court “concludes the benefit to the child derived from
preserving the sibling relationship is not sufficiently compelling
to outweigh the benefit achieved by the permanency of adoption,
we review that determination for abuse of discretion.”
(Elizabeth M., supra, 19 Cal.App.5th at p. 782; see In re
Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 640 [reviewing for abuse of
discretion the juvenile court’s determination “whether
termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child
due to the child’s relationship with his parent”].) “In reviewing
factual determinations for substantial evidence, a reviewing court
should ‘not reweigh the evidence, evaluate the credibility of
witnesses, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.’ [Citation.] The
determinations should ‘be upheld if . . . supported by substantial
evidence, even though substantial evidence to the contrary also
exists and the trial court might have reached a different result
had it believed other evidence.’” (Caden C., at p. 640.)
11
B. The Juvenile Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in
Declining To Apply the Sibling Exception to Adoption
1. Emma
Substantial evidence supported the juvenile court’s implied
finding Emma did not have a significant relationship with any of
her siblings. As the court observed, in Emma’s young life of two
and a half years she spent only eight months in Annel’s care
while Jesus, Victoria, and Ysabella also lived with Annel in
Cleotilde’s home. Emma spent almost all of her life in Elizabeth’s
home, separate from her siblings. (See Celine R., supra,
31 Cal.4th at p. 61 [where the children lived apart from their
older sibling since they were very young, “the conclusion was
virtually compelled that they had not been ‘raised with [their
sibling] in the same home’ and had not ‘shared significant
common experiences or [had] existing close and strong bonds with
[her]’”].) Emma did participate in the sibling visits the court
ordered in June 2023. But Annel and Arturo, who had the
burden to prove the sibling relationship exception applied
(Elizabeth M., supra, 19 Cal.App.5th at p. 781), did not present
evidence that Emma engaged meaningfully with her siblings
during these weekly to biweekly visits or that she was bonded,
much less significantly bonded, to her siblings. (See In re L.Y.L.,
supra, 101 Cal.App.4th at p. 952 [“there was no evidence [the
child], other than being sad, would suffer detriment if the
[sibling] relationship ended”]; cf. In re C.B. (2010)
190 Cal.App.4th 102, 129 [where “both children testified to the
importance of their relationship with their older sister,” the court
“recognized that they had been raised together for much of their
lives and had shared common experiences”].)
12
The court also acted within its discretion in ruling any
benefit to Emma from her sibling relationships did not outweigh
the stability and permanence she would derive from adoption. As
discussed, because Annel and Arturo did not show Emma’s
sibling relationships were significant, the court did not err in
concluding any interference with those relationships as a result
of the court terminating Annel’s parental rights would not be
detrimental to Emma. As Emma’s primary caregiver for most of
her life, Elizabeth had developed “a natural parent-child
relationship” with Emma, and Emma thrived in her care. Given
Emma’s young age and the upheaval she had already
experienced—living away from her parents and siblings since
birth, returning to Annel’s care after more than one year, and
moving back to Elizabeth’s home after Annel abandoned her—the
stability Elizabeth would provide through adoption was
particularly important. (See In re Valerie A. (2007)
152 Cal.App.4th 987, 1014 [“application of [the sibling
relationship] exception will be rare, particularly when the
proceedings concern young children whose needs for a competent,
caring and stable parent are paramount”].)
2. Ysabella
The juvenile court also did not abuse its discretion in
concluding Ysabella’s sibling relationships did not outweigh the
stability and permanence Cleotilde could provide by adopting her.
Ysabella did spend more time with Jesus and Victoria than
Emma did, and the court acknowledged Emma developed strong
relationships with her older siblings. Nevertheless, like Emma,
Ysabella had already experienced considerable instability caused
by moving multiple times over the course of this case, from
13
Annel’s home to a maternal aunt’s home, to Cleotilde’s home, to a
foster home after Annel abandoned her, and back to Cleotilde’s
home. The juvenile court acted well within its discretion in
ruling Ysabella’s best chance at growing up in a stable and
permanent home was with Cleotilde as her parent. (See
Elizabeth M., supra, 19 Cal.App.5th at pp. 775, 783 [where the
children had lived in many homes during the dependency
proceedings, “the court was fully justified in finding the sense of
security and belonging that adoption would bring outweighed any
possible disruption in [the children’s] relationship with their
brothers”]; see also Celine R., supra, 31 Cal.4th at p. 61 [“even if
adoption would interfere with a strong sibling relationship, the
court must nevertheless weigh the benefit to the child of
continuing the sibling relationship against the benefit the child
would receive by gaining a permanent home through adoption”].)
In addition, Ysabella’s medical condition required a high level of
care that a stable and permanent home would ensure. (See In re
Dakota H. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 212, 229 [substantial evidence
supported the juvenile court’s finding the mother’s “loving
parental relationship” with her autistic child did not outweigh his
“exceptional needs for a stable home and highly competent
caregiver”].)
Annel and Arturo argue that the Department’s reports did
not outline a plan for future sibling visitation and that the court
should have disregarded the caregivers’ assurances they would
facilitate sibling visitation. Annel and Arturo, however, had the
burden to show the caregivers would not facilitate future
visitation. (See In re D.O., supra, 247 Cal.App.4th at p. 176
[“it was appellants’ burden to establish there would be
substantial interference, not the [child protective agency’s]
14
burden to establish there would not”].) Annel and Arturo did not
make that showing.
The record does not show the court considered the
caregivers’ commitment to arranging sibling visitation in the
future. But even if the court had considered the likelihood of
future sibling visits, it did not err. (See In re D.O., supra,
247 Cal.App.4th at p. 175 [in considering whether to apply the
sibling relationship exception, the court may consider the
caregiver’s “proven history of, and expressed commitment to,
sibling visits”].) Cleotilde will likely be Ysabella’s adoptive
parent, and when the court placed Jesus and Victoria with Jose
in January 2024, the court ordered Jose to ensure the older
children continued to have visits at Cleotilde’s. And Elizabeth
has committed to ensuring Emma maintains her relationship
with Ysabella, has taken Emma to Cleotilde’s home for sibling
visits, and has stayed in frequent contact with Cleotilde
regarding visits. Contrary to Annel’s assertion she was the
“common thread” that allowed the children to live together and
maintain a relationship, it was Cleotilde who facilitated, and will
facilitate, contact among the siblings. Before Annel relapsed,
many of her visits with the children and the sibling visits took
place in Cleotilde’s home, Cleotilde allowed Annel and all four
children to live with her for the eight months Annel had custody
of them, and Cleotilde took care of the children after Annel left
without arranging for their care. Indeed, during the six months
after Annel’s relapse, Annel did not visit Emma at all and visited
the three oldest children only three times. The record does not
support Annel’s assertion that preserving her parental rights
would maintain the relationship between Emma, Ysabella, and
their older siblings. (See Elizabeth M., supra, 19 Cal.App.5th at
15
p. 782 [sibling relationship exception did not apply where
“nothing in the record suggested [the children’s] relationship with
their brothers, whatever it may have been, would be severed if
they were adopted by their current caregivers”]; D.O., at p. 175
[“it is not a foregone conclusion that terminating parental rights
will substantially interfere with a sibling relationship”].)
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders terminating Annel’s and
Arturo’s parental rights are affirmed.
SEGAL, J.
We concur:
MARTINEZ, P. J.
STONE, J.
16
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.