Kim v. Uber Technologies, Inc.

CourtListener 10123130Calctapp20 de set. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 8/30/24; Certified for Publication 9/20/24 (order attached)

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

MACKENZIE YOUNG JAY B331247
KIM,
Los Angeles County
Plaintiff and Appellant, Super. Ct. No. 20STCV25305

v.

UBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC.,
et al.,

Defendants and Respondents.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Cherol Nellon, Judge. Affirmed.
The Wallace Firm, Bradley S. Wallace; and Matthew J.
Kita for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Perkins Coie, Steven Williamson, Julie L. Hussey and
Gregory F. Miller for Defendants and Respondents.

_____________________________
SUMMARY
The plaintiff in this lawsuit seeks to hold Uber
Technologies, Inc. and related companies vicariously liable for
injuries he suffered when he was struck by an automobile driven
by Ralph Wilson. Mr. Wilson had been driving for Uber for
several hours that evening and had turned his Uber driver app to
“offline”—meaning he was not available to receive requests for
rides—about four minutes before the accident and more than a
mile away from the location of the accident. Mr. Wilson testified
that “I cut off my Uber” and “I went to McDonald’s, and then I
went home, and then is the accident.”
The Uber parties moved for summary judgment on the
ground they had no duty to plaintiff because Mr. Wilson was
acting in his own personal capacity, not as an Uber driver, at the
time of the accident. Plaintiff presented evidence that Uber
drivers can go from “offline” to “available” within 30 seconds and
are able to see an Uber map showing areas of high demand for
rides even when they are “offline”; and that Mr. Wilson’s
recollection of what he was doing during the hours before the
accident was contradictory and inconsistent with Uber’s records.
Plaintiff argued those inconsistencies reflected adversely on
Mr. Wilson’s credibility and there was a triable issue of fact as to
whether he “was operating his vehicle with the intention of
switching back to ‘available’ status at the time of his collision
with Plaintiff.”
The trial court found plaintiff’s arguments speculative; that
what Mr. Wilson was doing before the incident was irrelevant to
establishing whether he was acting as an Uber driver at the time
of the incident; and there was no evidence indicating he was not
done driving for the night. The court therefore granted the Uber
parties’ motion for summary judgment.
We affirm the judgment.

2
FACTS
1. Undisputed Facts: The Parties, the Uber App and
the Accident
Plaintiff Mackenzie Young Jay Kim was a pedestrian in a
traffic accident that occurred at about 2:28 a.m. on January 19,
2020, on Santa Monica Boulevard near Bundy Drive. Ralph
Davis Wilson III was the driver. Mr. Wilson is a defendant in
this lawsuit but not a party to this appeal.
As is generally known, Uber uses technology (the Uber app)
to connect riders with drivers who use their personal vehicles.
The rider version of the Uber app and the driver version are
different. Drivers are “available” to accept riders after they go
“online” by logging into the Uber driver app. (All further
discussion of the “Uber app” refers to the driver app.)
Uber uses data from the Uber app to determine whether a
driver can accept and provide rides. Data from the Uber app
shows the driver’s status in one of four categories: “available,”
which means the driver can receive a ride request; “en route,”
which means the driver is traveling to pick up a rider after a ride
request was accepted; “on trip,” which means the driver is
transporting a rider after pickup; and “offline,” which means the
driver is not available to receive a ride request in the Uber app.
Data from the Uber app provides GPS coordinates
indicating where the driver is located when the driver becomes
“available” to receive trip requests, is “en route,” “on trip,” or goes
“offline.” Uber’s records reflect every trip Mr. Wilson made on
the night of the accident. The Uber app data “showed that
Wilson was not logged ‘online’ to the [Uber app] at the time and
location of the Subject Accident” (and Mr. Wilson admits he was
not logged into the Uber app at the time of the accident, was not
transporting anyone and was not on his way to pick up a
rideshare rider at the time of the accident).

3
Mr. Wilson last logged off in the Uber app at 2:24 a.m. on
January 19, 2020, at specified GPS coordinates in West Los
Angeles, and the accident occurred more than one mile from
where Mr. Wilson’s status changed to “offline.” 1 “Wilson testified
that he was ‘done driving [for Uber] for the night’ when he struck
Plaintiff.” 2
An Uber representative testified that drivers “could have
the app open on their phone and still be off-line related to
accepting trip requests”; drivers could switch from “offline” to
“available” by tapping a button on their screens, and could toggle
back and forth within 30 seconds; and drivers are able to view a
map showing “surge areas” while they are in offline status.
(“Surge pricing” occurs in areas where many people are
requesting rides at the same time (because of bad weather, rush
hour, or special events) and there are not enough cars on the road
to take them all.)
2. Mr. Wilson’s Evidence
Mr. Wilson’s deposition testimony and interrogatory
answers concerning where he drove and for how long on the night
of January 18, 2020, before he went offline at 2:24 a.m. on

1 Plaintiff admits Mr. Wilson’s status changed to “offline”
more than a mile away from the collision, but disputes whether
Mr. Wilson himself turned off the Uber app. Uber representative
Todd Gaddis was asked at his deposition, “Are you able to
determine, based on your review of these four rows of app status
data for 2:24 a.m. . . . , whether the row was activated by the
driver doing something within the app versus the app
automatically doing something on its own?” and Mr. Gaddis
answered, “No, I cannot.” But there is no evidence to suggest the
Uber app “d[id] something on its own.”

2 Mr. Wilson remained offline until February 11, 2020.

4
January 19, were inconsistent with each other and with Uber’s
records. We describe this evidence because plaintiff relies on it to
show there are fact issues for a jury to decide.
In verified answers to plaintiff’s special interrogatories on
December 15, 2020, Mr. Wilson stated he was on his way home
from picking up food at McDonald’s when the accident happened.
He also stated he did not recall how many hours he had been
driving before the accident. He stated he drove for Uber for
about 30 to 40 minutes before the accident, turned the Uber app
off and went home, and once he got home, he realized he was
hungry and left his house a few minutes later to pick up
McDonald’s.
At his deposition on November 11, 2021, Mr. Wilson
testified he left home sometime after midnight after being home
all day, drove two short trips for Uber in West L.A., then cut off
his app and went to the McDonald’s drive-through and bought
food for himself, his daughter and her friend, around 2:00 a.m.,
and was on his way home from McDonald’s when the accident
occurred. He said he was driving for Uber for “[p]robably close to
two hours” before he went to McDonald’s. (Uber’s data show
Mr. Wilson was driving for Uber for almost five hours before he
went offline at 2:24 a.m.)
Mr. Wilson also testified the McDonald’s was at
11920 Wilshire Boulevard, five minutes away from where he
dropped off his passenger, and that it was about 15 to 20 minutes
from the drop-off of his last passenger to McDonald’s and then to
the accident location. (Uber records together with Google Maps
evidence from plaintiff show Mr. Wilson was in the vicinity of
1747 Beloit Avenue in West Los Angeles when he went offline, a
location 1.6 miles from the McDonald’s.)

5
3. The Arguments and the Trial Court’s Ruling
Uber argued it could not be vicariously liable for
Mr. Wilson’s alleged negligence because the undisputed material
facts demonstrated that Mr. Wilson was not on the Uber platform
at the time of the accident, but rather was acting within his own
personal capacity, so plaintiff could not establish a necessary
element of his case: that Mr. Wilson was acting in the course and
scope of his employment.
Plaintiff argued there was a dispute as to whether
Mr. Wilson was acting as an Uber driver at the time of the
accident, based on the evidence that Uber drivers can freely
toggle between “offline” and “available,” and Mr. Wilson “would
have been able to view a map showing ‘surge areas,’ ” and could
have used that information to drive to the location of a surge to
get the benefit of a heightened price. Plaintiff also argued it was
unclear whether Mr. Wilson was driving for Uber at the time of
the accident because of the inconsistencies between his
recollections of what he was doing before he went offline and
Uber’s records of his activity that day, affecting his credibility.
Both parties also presented public policy arguments to the
trial court.
The trial court granted summary judgment, concluding
plaintiff did not meet his burden of showing a dispute as to a
material fact. The court declined to entertain plaintiff’s first
argument—that Mr. Wilson could have been driving to a surge
area after he went offline—as speculation. The court observed
“[a]dditionally,” that “case law, statute, and public policy” did not
support a framework in which a rideshare company “would
effectively be liable for employees whenever they drive their cars
with a phone connected to the internet.”
The court also rejected plaintiff’s second argument—the
inconsistencies between plaintiff’s recollection of his activity

6
before he went offline and Uber’s records—as immaterial. The
court found “no dispute or confusion as to whether Wilson had his
Uber app active at the time of the incident,” and noted
additionally that Mr. Wilson’s mention that his last ride was in
the UCLA area matched Uber’s location data for where he turned
off his Uber app. “What Wilson was doing prior to the incident is
irrelevant beyond establishing whether he was acting as an Uber
driver at the time of the incident. All evidence supports a finding
that he was not acting as an Uber driver at the time of the
incident,” and “there is no evidence provided that indicated
Wilson was not done driving for the night.” The trial court added
that “this again presents a dangerous argument that imbues
liability on rideshare companies for negligence committed by
rideshare agents even when ‘offline,’ and not transporting
passengers.”
Judgment was entered in favor of the Uber parties and
plaintiff filed a timely notice of appeal.
DISCUSSION
1. The Standard of Review
A defendant moving for summary judgment must show
“that one or more elements of the cause of action . . . cannot be
established, or that there is a complete defense to the cause of
action.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd. (p)(2).) Summary
judgment is appropriate where “all the papers submitted show
that there is no triable issue as to any material fact and that the
moving party is entitled to a judgment as a matter of law.” (Id.,
subd. (c).)
Our Supreme Court has made clear that the purpose of the
1992 and 1993 amendments to the summary judgment statute
was “ ‘to liberalize the granting of [summary judgment]
motions.’ ” (Perry v. Bakewell Hawthorne, LLC (2017) 2 Cal.5th

7
536, 542.) It is no longer called a “disfavored” remedy. (Ibid.)
“Summary judgment is now seen as ‘a particularly suitable
means to test the sufficiency’ of the plaintiff’s or defendant’s
case.” (Ibid.) On appeal, “we take the facts from the record that
was before the trial court . . . . ‘ “We review the trial court’s
decision de novo, considering all the evidence set forth in the
moving and opposing papers except that to which objections were
made and sustained.” ’ ” (Yanowitz v. L’Oreal USA, Inc. (2005)
36 Cal.4th 1028, 1037.)
2. Contentions and Conclusions
We begin with a preliminary comment. Plaintiff criticizes
the trial court for several of its observations, such as that under
plaintiff’s theory, a rideshare company “would effectively be liable
for employees whenever they drive their cars with a phone
connected to the internet.” Plaintiff asserts the trial court’s
summary judgment was “based on public-policy perspectives as
opposed to the existence of a triable issue of fact,” and that we
should not “bless the trial court’s decision to ignore the summary
judgment standard of review.”
We do not see the trial court’s ruling as “based on public-
policy perspectives.” It was based on the absence of any dispute
on the material facts. Our review of the record compels us to
agree with the trial court’s assessment that “[a]ll evidence
supports a finding that [Mr. Wilson] was not acting as an Uber
driver at the time of the incident,” and “there is no evidence
provided that indicated Wilson was not done driving for the
night.” Since that is so, the trial court’s ruling was entirely
consonant with the statutory requirements for summary
judgment we have just described.
We turn to plaintiff’s arguments for a contrary conclusion.

8
Plaintiff’s first contention is that “[a] jury should have
determined whether [Mr.] Wilson was acting ‘in the course of
Uber’s business’ when he hit [plaintiff] with his car.” The core of
plaintiff’s argument is that the Uber app was always open on
Mr. Wilson’s phone, so when he went offline at 2:24 a.m., he
could have been looking for a surge, he could have seen a surge
(had there been one, of which there is no evidence), and he could
have been driving toward a surge area in offline status when the
collision occurred, intending to switch to “available” status when
he got there. There are too many “could haves” in this
speculative scenario, and there is no support for it in the
evidence.
The evidence plaintiff relies on is the undisputed evidence
on surge pricing and that Mr. Wilson never closed the Uber app
on his phone. Plaintiff cites Uber’s records showing the times of
all Mr. Wilson’s statuses and locations while driving for Uber for
the five weeks preceding and on the night of the collision. These
records show, plaintiff says, that Mr. Wilson frequently toggled
between “available” and “offline” while he was driving. Plaintiff
also cites Mr. Wilson’s affirmative response to the question, “So if
your app is on and you’re in the available status, prepared to
accept a ride, you can see the red surge zones on the—the map on
the app screen, and you can drive towards it to try to pick up
rides in the surge zone area?” (Italics added.) Mr. Wilson
answered, “Yes, if I want to.” He also testified that “you can
make more money picking up a ride in a surge versus no surge.”
Plaintiff tells us that “most importantly, [plaintiff] presented
evidence that Wilson toggled between ‘available’ and ‘offline’
multiple times during the five hours the [sic] he drove for Uber on
the night of the collision.”

9
In the first place, none of the above is evidence that, when
he toggled between “available” and “offline,” Mr. Wilson was in
fact driving toward a surge zone in offline status—on the night of
the collision or at any other time. Moreover, and “most
importantly,” the evidence does not show “that Wilson toggled
between ‘available’ and ‘offline’ multiple times during the five
hours the [sic] he drove for Uber on the night of the collision.”
Quite the opposite: The evidence shows he went to offline status
once—for six seconds, from 12:40:58 a.m. to 12:41:06 a.m.—
during the almost five hours he drove for Uber that night. 3
In short, there is nothing here for a jury to decide;
plaintiff’s claim of what Mr. Wilson “could have” done is complete
speculation, and juries are not permitted to speculate.
Plaintiff asserts the data showed “a triable issue of fact as
to whether [Mr. Wilson] was actually ‘done driving’ at 2:24 a.m.,”
or whether he was “toggl[ing] back-and-forth between ‘available’
and ‘offline’ ” consistent with his “recent behavior.” Plaintiff says
Uber’s records show Mr. Wilson frequently toggled between
“available” and “offline” while he was driving, “with gaps between
the two that were much longer than the four-minute interval
between 2:24 a.m. and 2:28 a.m.,” and at times he drove much

3 Similarly, plaintiff follows that misstatement of the
evidence with the statement that “[t]o increase the amount of
money he made from Uber, Wilson would identify himself as
‘offline’ in his Driver App, and drive towards a ‘surge zone.’ ”
That misstates the evidence, too. The only evidence plaintiff cites
is the undisputed fact that 7.5 percent of Mr. Wilson’s earnings
during the five weeks before the accident were bonuses for surge
rates. This is evidence he sometimes drove to or in surge zones,
but it is not evidence he “would identify himself as ‘offline’ in his
Driver App” while doing so.

10
later than 2:28 a.m. For this plaintiff cites 60 pages of earnings
records for Mr. Wilson, but does not identify where in that data
any particular items supporting the assertion can be found. In
any event, whether he intended to drive later (and there is no
evidence of that) is irrelevant to his status at the time of the
accident, when he was indisputably offline and unable to receive
or accept requests for rides.
Plaintiff also insists a jury should have determined
whether Wilson is a credible witness, because his testimony
about how long he had been driving and where he drove before he
went offline (see ante, at pp. 5-6) was contradictory and conflicted
with Uber’s records. Plaintiff concludes that “[b]ecause a
reasonable juror could conclude that Wilson is not a credible
witness, a reasonable juror could also conclude that Wilson was
not ‘done driving for the night.’ ” As we have already stated,
what Mr. Wilson planned to do later in the night is irrelevant;
Uber’s records confirm exactly where and when Mr. Wilson went
offline, that is, at 2:24 a.m. and more than a mile from the
accident site. (Cf. Morales-Simental v. Genentech, Inc. (2017)
16 Cal.App.5th 445, 461 [“any credibility issues surrounding [the
employee-driver]’s testimony were not material to the resolution
of the . . . issue on which the [summary judgment] motion
turned”]; Richards v. Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control
(2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 304, 319 [“Summary judgment generally
cannot be denied based on lack of credibility alone.”].)
Plaintiff’s insistence that Mr. Wilson could not have both
gone to McDonald’s, bought food, and driven to the accident site
in the four or five minutes after he went offline, does not change
the undisputed fact that he went to offline status at 2:24 a.m. at a
location in West Los Angeles that was a mile or so from the scene

11
of the accident, and called 9-1-1 to report he hit a pedestrian at
2:28 a.m. The rest is immaterial. The undisputed material facts
show Mr. Wilson was not acting as an Uber driver at the time of
the accident.
DISPOSITION
The judgment in favor of the Uber parties is affirmed. The
Uber parties to recover costs on appeal.

GRIMES, J.
WE CONCUR:

STRATTON, P. J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

12
Filed 9/20/24
CERTIFIED FOR PUBLICATION

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

MACKENZIE YOUNG JAY B331247
KIM,
Los Angeles County
Plaintiff and Appellant, Super. Ct. No. 20STCV25305

v. ORDER CERTIFYING
OPINION FOR
UBER TECHNOLOGIES, INC., PUBLICATION
et al.,
[No Change in Judgment]
Defendants and Respondents.

THE COURT:
The opinion in the above-entitled matter filed on
August 30, 2024, was not certified for publication in the Official
Reports. For good cause, it now appears that the opinion should
be published in the Official Reports and it is so ordered.
There is no change in the judgment.

____________________________________________________________
STRATTON, P. J. GRIMES, J. VIRAMONTES, J.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.