In re E.M. CA2/5

CourtListener 10121958Calctapp19 de set. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 9/19/24 In re E.M. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re E.M., a Person Coming B327713
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County Super.
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Ct. No. 22CCJP01780)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

O.M.,

Defendant and Appellant.

C.C. et al.,

Respondents.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Lisa A. Brackelmanns, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Lindsey M. Ball, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Appellant O.M.
Leslie A. Barry, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Respondent C.C.
Jonathan Grossman, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Minor E.M.
___________________________

In this dependency matter, O.M. (father) contends the
juvenile court erroneously relied upon Family Code section 3044
and otherwise abused its discretion in terminating jurisdiction
over the child (E.M.) with an order granting sole legal and
physical custody to C.C. (mother). Finding no error, we affirm.1
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Dependency Petition, Jurisdiction, and
Disposition
On May 9, 2022, the Department filed a petition under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivisions (a) and
(b)(1)2 to protect nine-month-old E.M. (born July 2021).
According to the petition, on April 13, 2022, both parents engaged
in an altercation with E.M.’s two paternal uncles, during which
father pushed, punched, choked, brandished a knife, and
repeatedly attempted to stab the uncles in the presence of the
child, after which authorities arrested father for assault with a
deadly weapon (counts a-1 and b-1 of the petition). The petition
further alleged that father and mother had a history of violent

1 Respondents are mother and the minor child. The Los
Angeles Department of Children and Family Services (the
Department) has advised this court that it takes no position on
this appeal.

2 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.

2
interactions with each other (counts a-2 and b-3), that father had
a past hospitalization for psychiatric illness after which he failed
to participate in mental health treatment (count b-2), and that
father abused marijuana (count b-4).
On May 10, 2022, the juvenile court ordered E.M. into the
Department’s temporary placement and custody, with separate,
monitored visitation for each parent. The juvenile court further
ordered the Department to provide reunification services,
including drug testing for father.
On August 22, 2022, the juvenile court held an adjudication
and disposition hearing and sustained all allegations regarding
the parents’ physical fight with the uncles, father’s repeated
attempts to stab the uncles in the presence of E.M., and the
parents’ history of domestic violence. The juvenile court
dismissed the remaining counts relating to father’s marijuana
use and mental health issues, finding no “nexus” established
between those allegations and risk of harm to the child, and that
the concerns raised by the dismissed allegations could
nevertheless be addressed in the case plan. The juvenile court
found E.M. subject to its jurisdiction pursuant to section 300,
subdivisions (a) [risk of serious physical harm inflicted
nonaccidentally] and (b)(1) [risk of serious physical harm due to
failure to protect].
During the disposition phase of the proceeding, the juvenile
court received in evidence several items documenting mother’s
attendance and active engagement in a safety-focused parenting
program, a domestic violence women’s support group, and
individual counseling focused on conflict management,
maintenance of a child-safe home, and the Department’s
involvement. Additionally, mother reported having moved into a

3
separate residence away from father. Mother testified that she
had learned about the “cycle of domestic violence” in her domestic
violence classes, that she was no longer in a relationship with
father because she believed the relationship was unhealthy for
her and “especially” for E.M., and that if E.M. were released to
her custody, she would phone 911 if father came to her home.
The juvenile court observed, “Mother is displaying insight
as to not only the different types of domestic violence but the
cycle of domestic violence and the importance of protecting
[E.M.] . . . and [mother] is developing those protective capacities.”
The juvenile court released E.M. to mother with several
conditions, including that the Department verify father was not
residing in mother’s home, that mother allow unannounced visits
by the Department, that the parents’ communications be through
the online platform Talking Parents, and that mother must call
911 and inform the social worker if father comes to her home.
The juvenile court concluded it was “premature” to order
unmonitored visits with father in light of his history of aggressive
behavior and his “need[] to engage in services.” The juvenile
court ordered a case plan for father, requiring his participation in
drug testing as well as enrollment in a 52-week domestic violence
batterer’s intervention program, a parenting program, and
individual counseling. The juvenile court ordered mother to
continue with the services outlined in her case plan, and ordered
conjoint counseling with father if mother and father planned to
reconcile.

4
B. Six-month Status Report, Review Hearing, and
Exit Order
1. The Department’s Six-month Status Report
On February 10, 2023, the Department filed a written
status report, which detailed that mother completed her
parenting and domestic violence classes, was communicating
well with the Department and in-home outreach counselor, was
steadily employed, had enrolled E.M. in childcare, and had
continued to increase her knowledge about child development.
The Department further reported that E.M. was “doing well” in
mother’s home, was “bonding” with mother, and played happily
and consistently with other children in his daycare program.
The Department also reported that father was not doing so
well. From the time of E.M.’s detention in May 2022 to the end of
2022, father missed over 20 drug tests. In January 2023, father
again missed multiple drug tests, and, on several occasions, was
a no-show for drug testing after confirming with the social worker
that he would appear. On occasions where father showed up for
drug testing, he tested positive for marijuana metabolite, without
the hoped-for steady decrease. In November 2022, father tested
positive for methamphetamine in addition to marijuana and
amphetamine. The Department further reported that Father
failed to comply with other aspects of his case plan. Father’s
domestic violence program terminated him for excessive absences
and lack of cooperation, father failed to qualify for a certificate of
completion of his parenting class due to his excessive absences,
and father’s individual counseling program similarly terminated
its services to father due to his excessive absences and lack of
cooperation.

5
Although father had “positive and safe interactions” with
E.M. when he attended his monitored visits, his attendance was
inconsistent, and he was frequently late. The Department
recommended terminating jurisdiction with a family law order
giving mother sole physical custody of child, with parents having
joint legal custody and father continuing to have monitored visits.
2. The Six-month Review Hearing
At the outset of the February 21, 2023 review hearing, the
juvenile court advised the parties, “The court is in receipt of the
[Department’s] report prepared for today’s hearing. The child is
released to the mother. The recommendation is to terminate
jurisdiction with the family law order giving mother sole
physical, joint legal, monitored visits for father. There was a
positive test for meth and levels of marijuana have been going
up.” The Department submitted on its report and minor’s
counsel indicated agreement with the Department’s requests.
Mother, however, requested “sole legal [custody]” in light of
“father not participating in services and also the domestic
violence.”
Following mother’s request for sole legal custody, the
juvenile court inquired of minor’s counsel whether she thought it
best for the child to be placed in joint custody of both parents or
to be placed in mother’s sole legal custody, and minor’s counsel
advised the court that she (minor’s counsel) believed the child’s
best interest would be served by an order granting mother sole
legal custody: “I do agree with [mother’s counsel]. Father has
this domestic violence background that was part of the case.
He has shown he has not benefitted from his domestic violence
program, as is reported by the program itself, so I do believe it’s
in [child’s] best interest. And I also believe there’s a presumption

6
under Family Code 3044 against father under these
circumstances for sole legal custody to mother.” Father
advocated in favor of joint legal custody, arguing it was in E.M.’s
best interest. In granting mother sole legal custody, the juvenile
court said nothing regarding Family Code section 3044 and
expressed agreement with mother and minor’s counsel, both of
whom had just advocated that granting mother sole legal custody
was in the child’s best interest, stating: “All right. Thank you.
I think at this point I do agree with [mother’s counsel and minor’s
counsel] based on father’s lack of participation in his case plan.
But I am going to attach the – in terms of the legal custody, I am
going to give mother sole legal at this time. However, I am going
to attach a JV-206 [form explaining reasons for monitored
visitation] and if he does choose to participate in these services he
can go back to the family law court and request a modification.”
3. The Juvenile Court’s Written Order and Attachment
Indicating Father’s Noncompliance with Programming,
Counseling, and Drug Testing
Consistent with its oral ruling, the juvenile court signed a
family law custody order granting sole legal and physical custody
to mother and monitored visitation to father. The attached JV-
206 form set forth that father had failed to: complete or make
substantial progress in parenting classes, drug testing, the 52-
week domestic violence intervention program, psychological
assessment, psychiatric evaluation, and individual counseling.
The form stated, “Completion of one of the programs above might,
but need not, constitute a significant change of circumstances for
purposes of modifying this final custody order.”
That same day, the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction.
On February 27, 2023, father filed a timely notice of appeal.

7
II. DISCUSSION
Father appeals the grant of sole legal custody to mother,
contending the juvenile court erroneously applied the Family
Code section 3044 presumption and further abused its discretion
by denying him joint custody based only on his failure to
complete his reunification programs. Because the record
indicates the custody and termination order did not rely upon or
invoke Family Code section 3044 and was within the juvenile
court’s discretion, we affirm.
A. Standard of Review
“ ‘[T]he juvenile court has broad discretion to make custody
orders when it terminates jurisdiction in a dependency case.’
[Citation.] We review a custody (or ‘exit’) order . . . for abuse of
discretion, and will not disturb the order ‘unless the juvenile
court “ ‘ “exceeded the limits of legal discretion by making an
arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd determination.” ’ ” ’
[Citation.] ‘ “ ‘The appropriate test for abuse of discretion is
whether the juvenile court exceeded the bounds of reason. When
two or more inferences can reasonably be deduced from the facts,
the reviewing juvenile court has no authority to substitute its
decision for that of the juvenile court.’ ” ’ [Citation.]” (In re N.M.
(2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 1090, 1094.)
B. Principles Governing Juvenile Court “Exit
Orders”
Section 362.4 authorizes the juvenile court, when
terminating dependency jurisdiction, to issue a custody and
visitation order, which will in turn be the basis for opening a
family law court file and will remain in effect until modified
or terminated by subsequent court order. Section 302,
subdivision (d) provides that the juvenile court’s post-termination

8
custody orders (commonly known as “exit orders”) may only be
modified upon a showing of changed circumstances and the best
interests of the child. (In re Anna T. (2020) 55 Cal.App.5th 870,
871-872.)
“In making exit orders, the juvenile courts must look at the
best interests of the child.” (In re John W. (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th
961, 973.) “The juvenile court has a special responsibility to the
child as parens patriae and must look to the totality of the child’s
circumstances when making decisions regarding the child.”
(In re Chantal S. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 196, 201 (Chantal S.).)
“Although both the family court and the juvenile court
focus on the best interests of the child, significant differences
exist. In juvenile dependency proceedings the child is involved in
the court proceedings because he or she has been abused or
neglected. Custody orders are not made until the child has been
declared a dependent of the court and in many cases, such as this
one, the child has been removed from the parents upon clear and
convincing evidence of danger. The issue of the parents’ ability to
protect and care for the child is the central issue. The
presumption of parental fitness that underlies custody law in the
family court just does not apply to dependency cases. Rather the
juvenile court, which has been intimately involved in the
protection of the child, is best situated to make custody
determinations based on the best interests of the child without
any preferences or presumptions.” (In re Jennifer R. (1993)
14 Cal.App.4th 704, 712 [rejecting application, in dependency
juvenile court, of a former family law presumption for joint legal
custody].)
An award of sole legal or physical custody to one parent
“does not serve to ‘terminate’ the other’s parental rights or due

9
process interest in parenting.” (In re Marriage of Brown & Yana
(2006) 37 Cal.4th 947, 958.) To the contrary, as directly
contemplated by the juvenile court below, when one parent
obtains sole custody, the other parent retains the right to request
modification in the future based on changed circumstances.
C. The Juvenile Court Acted Within Its Discretion
and Did Not Rely on the Family Code Section 3044
Presumption
Relying on the single and brief reference to Family Code
section 30443 by minor’s counsel, father argues that the juvenile
court improperly relied on the statute in making its custody
ruling and exit order. This contention is unsupported by the
record.
Minor’s counsel mentioned the statutory presumption in
one sentence, as, at best, a subsidiary argument, and the juvenile
court never followed up on it. Nor did the juvenile court
mention the presumption in making its order. Critically, the
juvenile court did mention other factors wholly consistent with
its consideration of the “totality of the . . . circumstances”
(Chantal S., supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 206), including father’s
positive test for methamphetamine, repeated positive tests for
marijuana metabolite, and failure to comply with virtually all of
the counseling and programming elements of his case plan.
The juvenile court also recited that it had read and received the
Department’s six-month report, which detailed father’s multiple

3 Family Code section 3044, applicable in family law matters,
provides a rebuttable presumption against joint or sole custody
where there has been a court finding of domestic violence.
We have previously held this presumption inapplicable to
dependency proceedings. (In re C.M. (2019) 38 Cal.App.5th 101,
108.)

10
failures to comply with his case plan, including his failures to
show up for drug testing and his repeated positive tests for
controlled substances. The juvenile court directly mentioned
father’s failure to engage in services in both its oral ruling and
the attachment to its written ruling. On these facts, we will not
assume the juvenile court relied on an inapplicable presumption
simply due to counsel’s brief mentioning. (Cf. In re Julian R.
(2009) 47 Cal.4th 487, 499 [we presume the trial juvenile court
was aware of, and followed, applicable law].)
Father’s reliance on In re N.M., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th
1090, is misplaced. There, the juvenile court indicated its
custodial order was based in part on “reward[ing]” good parental
behavior, which was improper because “[a]n exit order must serve
the best interests of the children, not reward or punish one
parent or another for failing to comply with the case plan.”
(Id. at pp. 1094-1095.) There is no indication that the juvenile
court below sought to mete out rewards or punishment in its
analysis.
DISPOSITION
The order is affirmed.

DAVIS, J.*
We Concur:

BAKER, Acting P. J. MOOR, J.

* Judge of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the
California Constitution.

11

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.