CourtListener 10045075•People v. Beard CA2/8
Texto completo
Filed 8/15/24 P. v. Beard CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
THE PEOPLE, B331653
Plaintiff and Respondent, Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. TA156406-01
v.
KENDRA CHANNEL BEARD,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Allen J. Webster, Judge. Affirmed as modified.
S.R. Balash, Jr., under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, William H. Shin and Lindsay Boyd, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
Appellant Kendra Channel Beard was charged with three
counts of assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily
injury in violation of Penal Code section 245, subdivision (a)(4).1
Each count named a separate victim: Brigette C. (count one),
Jonah C. (count two), and Ashley N. (count three). The alleged
date of the offenses was November 14, 2021.
On April 1, 2022, Beard pleaded no contest to count one in
return for a negotiated sentence and dismissal of the remaining
counts. In exchange for her plea and her agreement to pay
restitution as to all three counts for all three victims, Beard was
sentenced to two years of formal probation with specified
conditions.
The incident occurred when Ashley N. told Beard she was
too drunk to drive with children in her car. Beard became irate
and tried to run over the victims with her car. The car ran over
Brigette’s legs. Brigette was dragged 20 feet by the car. All the
victims suffered cuts, bruises, and lacerations and were taken to
the hospital.
A hearing to determine the amount of restitution was held
on May 5, 2023. The trial court awarded $16,540.46 to Brigette
C. (count one) and $5,430 to Ashley N. (count three).
The evidence in support of the award of $16,540.46 to
Brigette C. was a letter from Lincoln Financial Group that paid
Brigette C. short-term disability benefits beginning November 29,
2021, 15 days after the assault involving Beard. The People
calculated the amount due as $14,361.59, the 40 percent of
Brigette’s salary not covered by her disability insurance. The
People also presented receipts for medical insurance Brigette
bought after she lost her job. That amount came to $2,178.87 for
1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
2
a grand total of $16,540.46. The record does not indicate why
Brigette lost her job. Brigette did not testify at the hearing. The
trial court adopted the requested amount of $16,540.46 and
ordered Beard to pay that amount in restitution to Brigette.
As for Ashley N., she testified she was wearing a $3,200
necklace and an $800 pair of shoes when she was “drug 30 feet by
a car.” When she was taken to the hospital, the necklace was not
on her neck. Ashley could not explain the loss other than she was
wearing the necklace and she hasn’t seen it since. Nor did the
security guards see it on the hospital grounds when she asked
them about it the next day. Ashley testified “I” paid $3,000 for
the diamond charm and $200 for the chain. When the trial court
asked her how long she had the necklace, Ashley testified her
“fiancé bought it before he died, so maybe like a year. I got it for
Christmas.” She stated she wanted it back because “[i]t had
sentimental value. Like I said, my fiancé died and it was a gift.”
As to the shoes, Ashley also testified she was wearing $800
shoes that day and after the assault the shoes were completely
ruined and one was missing. She had purchased them to wear to
her deceased fiancé’s September 25, 2021 funeral and she was
wearing them for only the second time when she was assaulted.
Ashley also testified that her son’s glasses were lost and her two
cell phones were broken during the assault. She claimed loss of
earnings totaling $960, calculated at $320 a day at $40 an hour.
She works as an executive staffing coordinator for a concierge
nursing company. The trial court awarded Ashley N. a total of
$5,430.
Beard objected to restitution for Ashley’s diamond necklace,
Ashley’s shoes, and Brigette’s medical insurance payments and
the portion of her salary not covered by her disability insurance.
3
Beard argued that Brigette’s loss of earnings and job loss were
not connected to the assault. Beard also contended that Ashley’s
valuation of the necklace was suspect because she also testified it
was a gift from her fiancé.
In responding to Beard’s objections, the trial court stated:
“If you wanted to, you basically could have, I guess, gone to a[n]
appraiser with respect to the diamond necklace and charm and
get [an] estimate as to what the value of some of these things
are. Same with these shoes like anything else. And it’s here.
And if you wanted to, you could have basically subpoenaed the
information to see if it’s true or false. [¶] But I mean, the bottom
line is, all this happened to these ladies. And apparently they
happened to these lady because of your client. So all of this stuff
is missing and we don’t know why it was missing or wasn’t
missing. But one thing it seems to suggest that, had this incident
not occurred, your client wouldn’t be . . . in this court and these
items wouldn’t have been missing. [¶] So I just think you got to
take the victim as you find them. And she had all these things
on. And she seems to be very explicit about, you know, how much
was lost. And it’s tragic. This whole thing is tragic. But, you
know, it is what it is. [¶] And so the court believes that they’re
not catty and they’re not trying to get a lot money out of this case.
They’re just trying to be made whole. [¶] The court understands
and accepts your objections for the record, I guess it is. But that’s
basically the court’s finding, okay.”
This appeal followed.
4
DISCUSSION
A. Applicable Law
Section 1202.4, subdivision (f) provides as follows: “[I]n
every case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a
result of the defendant’s conduct, the court shall require that the
defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount
established by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed
by the victim or victims or any other showing to the court.”
A defendant has the right to a restitution hearing where the
standard of proof is preponderance of the evidence. (People v.
Holmberg (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 1310, 1319.) Section 1202.4
does not, by its terms, require any particular kind of proof.
Indeed, a victim’s uncorroborated statement of loss and the value
of the loss is acceptable proof. (People v. Gemelli (2008)
161 Cal.App.4th 1539, 1543; People v. Prosser (2007)
157 Cal.App.4th 682, 686, 690.) Once a victim makes a prima
facie showing of economic losses incurred as a result of the
defendant’s criminal acts, the burden shifts to the defendant to
disprove the amount of loss claimed by the victim. The defendant
has the burden of rebutting the victim’s statement of loss, and to
do so, may submit evidence to prove the amount claimed exceeds
the repair or replacement cost of damaged or stolen property.
(People v. Fulton (2003) 109 Cal.App.4th 876, 886.) “The purpose
of an order for victim restitution is threefold, to rehabilitate the
defendant, deter future delinquent behavior, and make the victim
whole by compensating him for his economic losses. . . . [¶] The
order is not, however, intended to provide the victim with a
windfall.” (In re Anthony M. (2007) 156 Cal.App.4th 1010, 1017.)
An order of restitution is reviewed for abuse of discretion
and will not be reversed unless it is arbitrary or capricious.
5
(People v. Shelly (2022) 81 Cal.App.5th 181, 199.) No abuse of
discretion will be found where there is a rational and factual
basis for the amount of restitution ordered. “ ‘When a trial
court’s factual determination is attacked on the ground that there
is no substantial evidence to sustain it, the power of an appellate
court begins and ends with the determination as to whether, on
the entire record, there is substantial evidence, contradicted or
uncontradicted, which will support the determination.’ ” (People
v. Superior Court (Jones) (1998) 18 Cal.4th 667, 681.) We do not
reweigh or reinterpret the evidence; rather, we determine
whether this is sufficient evidence to support the inference drawn
by the trier of fact. (People v. Gemelli, supra, 161 Cal.App.4th at
pp. 1545–1546.)
B. Analysis
Beard argues that Brigette did not establish that she lost
her job or became disabled as a result of the assault, thereby
failing to show that her losses were linked to the assault. The
letter from Lincoln Financial did not state the cause or type of
disability. There was no evidence as to why she lost her job,
which forced her to purchase her own medical insurance. Beard
contends Brigette’s entire restitution award is not supported by
substantial evidence.
We conclude that the trial court reasonably inferred that
Brigette’s absence from work was due to the injuries she
sustained during the assault where she was dragged by a car for
20 feet after her legs were run over. The letter confirming her
disability payments was issued 15 days after the assault. The
letter from Lincoln Financial Group, coupled with the timing of
the letter, is a rational, factual and sufficient basis supporting
the award.
6
We agree with Beard, however, as to the lack of evidence of
a connection between Brigette’s job loss and the assault. There
are a myriad of reasons why a person becomes unemployed and
we are not willing to choose one from the paucity of evidence in
the record. Her job loss may or may not have been due to her
injuries and absence from work. We decline to speculate. We
conclude the evidence is insufficient to attribute the economic
damages resulting from her job loss to the assault. In that
regard, we vacate the award of $2,178.87 attributed to the
purchase of medical insurance after Brigette’s job loss.
As to Ashley’s diamond necklace, Beard argues Ashley’s
contradictory testimony (she purchased it for $3,200 and her
deceased fiancé gave it to her as a gift) was false in that both of
her statements could not be true. Beard contends $3,200 should
not have been awarded to Ashley for the loss of the necklace.
We do not find Ashley’s testimony necessarily
contradictory. She was asked to state a value for the diamond
necklace. No one has disputed that she owned and wore a
diamond necklace when she was assaulted and that the necklace
disappeared from her neck immediately after the assault.
Whether she purchased it herself or her fiancé gave it to her is
immaterial. If it was a gift to her it was still worth $3,200. The
necklace was lost as a result of the assault and the value she
ascribed to it was undisputed. As to Ashley’s shoes, the court
closely questioned her about the condition of her shoes, heard the
testimony, and found it credible. We will not reweigh the trial
court’s assessment of her testimony.
Finally, Beard argues in her reply brief that she attempted
to call Brigette to the stand and was cut off by the trial court. We
do not read the transcript that way. Beard, through counsel,
7
never told the court she wanted and intended to proceed with an
examination of Brigette. More important, we do not consider new
arguments made by a party for the first time in a reply brief.
(United Grand Corp. v. Malibu Hillbillies, LLC (2019)
36 Cal.App.5th 142, 158.)
DISPOSITION
The order for restitution is reduced by $2,178.87 only and is
otherwise affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
GRIMES, J.
VIRAMONTES, J.
8
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.