CourtListener 10033709•Ha v. Maeder CA4/3
Texto completo
Filed 8/6/24 Ha v. Maeder CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
JANE HA,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G062000
v. (Super. Ct. No. 30-2022-01264588)
AIVY TRAN MAEDER et al., OPINION
Defendants and Appellants.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Elizabeth Grace, Temporary Judge. (Pursuant to Cal. Const., art. VI, § 21.)
Affirmed.
Doll Amir & Eley, Michael M. Amir and Lloyd Vu for Defendants
and Appellants.
Bird, Marella, Boxer, Wolpert, Nessim, Drooks, Lincenberg &
Rhow, Ekwan E. Rhow, Thomas R. Freeman, Nick Purcell, Joyce J. Choi;
Bird Marella Rhow Lincenberg Drooks & Nessim, Ekwan E. Rhow, Thomas
R. Freeman, Christopher J. Lee and Joyce J. Choi for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* * *
1
This appeal is from the denial of an anti-SLAPP motion. The
underlying action arises from a dispute over ownership of a medical spa
between two business partners. The dispute became so heated that,
according to the complaint, confederates of Dr. Peter Newen (one of the
business partners) came to the business to belligerently harass plaintiff Jane
Ha (the other business partner). This allegedly involved defaming Ha to
employees and patients, as well as physically disrupting the business by,
among other things, stealing supplies and products, and taking over the
telecommunications system.
For reasons that are not apparent in our limited record, in this
action Ha has sued the confederates of Dr. Newen, not Dr. Newen himself.
She asserted causes of action for aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary
duties, defamation, and intentional interference with prospective economic
advantage. As damages, she alleged that defendants’ actions scuttled a
purchase offer from a venture capital firm that would have personally netted
her $30 million.
Defendants filed an anti-SLAPP motion, which the trial court
denied. Defendants contend their alleged actions were protected activity
because they involved, among other things, telling patients and employees
that it was illegal for Ha to own a medical spa because she did not have a
medical license. The unlicensed practice of medicine, defendants argue, is an
“issue of public interest” to which they contributed. (Code Civ. Proc.,
1
“SLAPP” is an acronym for “strategic lawsuit against public
participation.” (Equilon Enterprises v. Consumer Cause, Inc. (2002) 29
Cal.4th 53, 57.)
2
2
§ 425.16, subd. (e)(4).) The trial court found that the alleged speech, in
context, arose out of a business dispute and lacked any meaningful
connection to an issue of public interest. We agree and affirm the order.
FACTS
I. The Complaint
The complaint alleges as follows:
Ha and Dr. Newen co-own two businesses together. The first is
TIC Aesthetic, LLC (TIC), a medical spa. Ha owns 49 percent, and Dr.
Newen owns 51 percent. However, they have equal voting power and are the
only two members on the board of directors. The second is IPSC, LLC (IPSC),
a surgery center. Ha and Dr. Newen are each 50 percent owners. Dr. Newen
wholly owns a related entity, Image Plastic Surgery Center, a Medical
Corporation (Image Plastic Surgery), which is a plastic surgery business.
The three entities operated as an integrated business. IPSC
owns the surgery center where the business operates. TIC administratively
operates the medical spa facilities in Irvine, San Clemente, Huntington
Beach, and Downey. Where appropriate, we will collectively refer to these
entities as the businesses.
The businesses grew rapidly. TIC, which was founded in 2019,
took in $15 million in revenue in 2021. Image Plastic Surgery also grew from
a fledgling business to a multimillion-dollar business. As a result of this
success, multiple private equity firms became interested in purchasing the
businesses.
2
All statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.
3
One firm in particular, Alium Capital Partners LLC (Alium),
showed significant interest in purchasing the businesses, and submitted a
letter of intent (LOI) to purchase TIC and its affiliated entities, IPSC, and
Image Plastic Surgery on December 29, 2021. The LOI stated that Alium
was impressed with TIC’s rapid growth and accompanying success and was
“‘equally struck by the amazing culture and true team environment exhibited
by the management team.’” The LOI valued “Alium’s offer to purchase TIC
and the affiliated entities at $68 million, [comprised of] $53 million in cash
and an additional $15 million in incentives based on” the businesses
achieving their projected earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and
amortization in 2022 and 2023.
According to the complaint, “Despite the obvious benefits to TIC
and [Image Plastic Surgery] from this potential sale, Dr. Newen became
increasingly spiteful of Ms. Ha and of the fact that she would financially
benefit as a result. Exacerbated by personal issues and his increasing alcohol
use, he also became jealous of the observations made by Alium, which
recognized Ms. Ha’s central role in the success of the businesses.”
As a result, Dr. Newen recruited defendants in carrying out a
campaign of harassment to try and oust Ha from the businesses. The
defendants include Aivy Tran Maeder, Jennifer Lee Quach, James Shin,
Ashley Roh, and Yen T. Lu also known as Kaitlyn Lu.
“[O]n May 5, 2022, Defendants Maeder and Quach—who have no
authority relating to TIC—held an impromptu meeting of TIC employees at
the direction of Dr. Newen and proceeded to yell at and threaten TIC staff
during normal business office hours in the presence of patients and social
media influencers. Soon after, the police were called on to the premises due to
4
the threats and harassment of Defendants Maeder and Quach. All TIC staff
were instructed to leave the premises by Ms. Ha in order to ensure the safety
of TlC staff.” “At Dr. Newen’s direction, Defendant Quach also told IPSC and
TIC employees and patients that Ms. Ha had been fired as CEO of IPSC, and
that Defendant Quach had taken over as interim CEO, despite no such action
having been properly taken by IPSC’s Board. Defendant Quach then became
hostile to TIC employees and made offensive and inappropriate remarks in
the presence of patients such that those employees were uncomfortable,
anxious, and unable to do their jobs. Defendant Maeder became even more
hostile, verbally threatening, abusing, and screaming at TIC employees,
causing them to fear for their safety to the point where law enforcement
needed to again become involved and TIC employees hid in the stairwell.”
“On May 6, 2022, Defendants tampered with the surveillance
systems, computers, phones, and other electrical devices that facilitate the
operations of TIC.”
“On May 10, 2022, Defendant Roh was observed moving TIC
surveillance cameras, while Defendant Lu was observed recording employees
in the workplace without their consent. It was also discovered that Defendant
Lu attempted to steal pharmaceutical drugs from TIC and facilitated the
tampering of security surveillance systems, computers, iPads, phones, and
medical records. Although Defendants Roh and Lu were terminated from TIC
on May 11, 2022, as a result of their behavior, they continued to misrepresent
themselves as employees and injectors of TIC, and placed inventory orders,
illegally accessed electronic medical records, and engaged with patients
purportedly on behalf of TIC, including by performing injections. Defendants
Roh and Lu were acting without any corporate authority and under the
5
illegal direction of Dr. Newen in order to control TIC against Ms. Ha’s rights
and wishes and to sabotage the sale to Alium.”
“Defendant Shin gave Dr. Newen access to TIC’s phone account,
which allowed Dr. Newen to secretly forward Ms. Ha’s calls to Defendant
Maeder. Defendant Maeder then defamed Ms. Ha to a patient who called
looking for her, saying that Ms. Ha was breaking the law and running a
fraudulent company. Defendant Shin has also misrepresented himself as a
technology manager for TIC in order to gain control over its accounts and
electronics. He has misappropriated and now illegally controls TIC’s
intellectual property including the imagecenter.info domain and email server,
cyber security admin dashboards, and patient records and photos. Defendant
Shin is not an employee of TIC and had no authority to be interfering with its
operations. Instead, he did so at Dr. Newen’s direction in order to damage the
company and sabotage the potential sale to Alium.”
As to defamation, the complaint alleges, “Defendant Maeder told
TIC employees that Ms. Ha was stealing money from Dr. Newen and
otherwise breaking the law, was ‘churning’ patients, and was holding Dr.
Newen ‘hostage.’ Defendant Quach also told employees that Ms. Ha had been
fired as CEO of IPSC and that Defendant Quach had been named interim
CEO, when no such termination had been properly effected.” “On May 12,
2022, Dr. Newen instructed his assistant, Defendant Shin, to reroute
customer calls to Ms. Ha’s number to Defendant Maeder. He then instructed
Ms. Maeder to inform TIC customers that Ms. Ha was not qualified to be
CEO of TIC, was participating in improper and illegal activities, was
‘running a fraudulent company,’ and was practicing medicine without a
6
license. Defendant Maeder’s defamation of Ms. Ha resulted in a customer
threatening to report TIC to the Better Business Bureau.”
II. Procedural History
The complaint was filed in June 2022, asserting causes of action
for aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duties, defamation, and
intentional interference with prospective economic advantage. After
answering the complaint, defendants filed an anti-SLAPP motion to strike
the complaint.
The court denied the motion. Citing FilmOn.com Inc. v.
DoubleVerify Inc. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 133 (FilmOn), the court concluded “that
the context of the allegations here, arising from a dispute between two
business partners, do not ‘contribute to the public debate’ regarding
unlicensed practice of medicine.” Because the court concluded that the
complaint was not based on protected conduct, the court did not proceed to
the second step of the anti-SLAPP analysis to determine whether Ha had
produced evidence demonstrating a probability of prevailing on the merits.
Defendants appealed from the order denying the anti-SLAPP motion.
DISCUSSION
Defendants argue that the conduct described in the complaint
qualifies as a public issue because they constitute “communications regarding
the qualifications and conduct of those providing medical services to the
public.” We review the court’s ruling de novo and conclude it did not err in
denying the anti-SLAPP motion. (Geiser v. Kuhns (2022) 13 Cal.5th 1238,
1250.)
7
The anti-SLAPP statute provides: “A cause of action against a
person arising from any act of that person in furtherance of the person’s right
of petition or free speech under the United States Constitution or the
California Constitution in connection with a public issue shall be subject to a
special motion to strike, unless the court determines that the plaintiff has
established that there is a probability that the plaintiff will prevail on the
claim.” (§ 425.16, subd. (b)(1).) “Section 425.16, subdivision (b)(1) requires
the court to engage in a two-step process. First, the court decides whether
the defendant has made a threshold showing that the challenged cause of
action is one arising from protected activity. . . . [Citation.] If the court finds
such a showing has been made, it then determines whether the plaintiff has
demonstrated a probability of prevailing on the claim.” (Equilon Enterprises
v. Consumer Cause, Inc., supra, 29 Cal.4th at p. 67.) Section 425.16,
subdivision (e) defines an “‘act in furtherance of a person’s right of petition or
free speech . . . in connection with a public issue’” as including four
categories, only one of which is relevant here: “any other conduct in
furtherance of the exercise of the constitutional right of petition or the
constitutional right of free speech in connection with a public issue or an
issue of public interest.” (Id., subd. (e)(4).) Subdivision (e)(4) is sometimes
called the catchall provision.
“The inquiry under the catchall provision . . . calls for a two-part
analysis rooted in the statute’s purpose and internal logic. First, we ask
what ‘public issue or . . . issue of public interest’ the speech in question
implicates—a question we answer by looking to the content of the speech.
[Citation.] Second, we ask what functional relationship exists between the
speech and the public conversation about some matter of public interest. It is
8
at the latter stage that context proves useful.” (FilmOn, supra, 7 Cal.5th at
pp. 149-150.) This is because “virtually always, defendants succeed in
drawing a line—however tenuous—connecting their speech to an abstract
issue of public interest.” (Id. at p. 150.) “But the catchall provision demands
‘some degree of closeness’ between the challenged statements and the
asserted public interest.” (Ibid.) “‘[I]t is not enough that the statement refer
to a subject of widespread public interest; the statement must in some
manner itself contribute to the public debate.’” (Ibid.)
“Our courts have ably distilled the characteristics of ‘a public
issue or an issue of public interest.’” (FilmOn, supra, 7 Cal.5th at p. 149.) In
particular, public issues often fall under the following categories: statements
about a person or entity in the public eye, “conduct that could directly affect a
large number of people beyond the direct participants [citations] or a topic of
widespread, public interest [citation].” (Rivero v. American Federation of
State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th
913, 924.) Additionally, “the focus of the speaker’s conduct should be the
public interest rather than a mere effort ‘to gather ammunition for another
round of [private] controversy. . . .’” (Weinberg v. Feisel (2003) 110
Cal.App.4th 1122, 1132-1133.)
Here, we are not persuaded that the speech in question was
about an issue of public interest. Defendants contend the relevant public
interest is “the qualifications and conduct of those providing medical services
to the public.” In support of the notion that this is an issue of public interest,
defendants rely principally on Yang v. Tenet Healthcare, Inc. (2020) 48
Cal.App.5th 939 (Yang). There, a doctor sued a hospital and various
individuals for defamation (id. at p. 943) because the defendants made public
9
statements that the doctor “was not ‘qualified or competent,’ that she
‘rendered care below applicable standards of practice,’ that her ‘ethics’ were
‘below acceptable standards,’ and that she was ‘dangerous’ to her patients
and others.” (Id. at p. 947.) The court held that the public issue implicated
was “the qualifications, competence, and professional ethics of a licensed
physician.” (Ibid.)
What distinguishes Yang from the present case, however, is that
Yang involved actual medical procedures negligently performed by a
physician. (See Healthsmart Pacific, Inc. v. Kabateck (2016) 7 Cal.App.5th
416, 428-429 [allegations of a conspiracy among doctors to install counterfeit
hardware in thousands of patients in exchange for a personal kickback
implicated a public issue].) The present case, by contrast, involves a claim
that Ha violated regulations prohibiting a nonphysician from owning a
medical spa. There is no indication in the record that Ha personally
performed medical services. Whether the ownership structure of a particular
medical spa violated such regulations simply is not an issue of widespread
public interest. Moreover, it is clear from the record that defendants were
not attempting to participate in a public debate, but instead were allegedly
attempting to wrest control of the business from Ha, which is a purely private
affair. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in denying the anti-SLAPP
motion.
10
DISPOSITION
The order denying defendants’ anti-SLAPP motion is affirmed.
Ha is entitled to costs incurred on appeal.
SANCHEZ, J.
WE CONCUR:
GOETHALS, ACTING P. J.
DELANEY, J.
11
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.