In re V.R. CA2/3

CourtListener 10031544Calctapp5 de ago. de 2024

Abrir fonte

Texto completo

Filed 8/5/24 In re V.R. CA2/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(a). This
opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115(a).

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE

In re V.R., a Person Coming B321166
Under the Juvenile Court Law.

LOS ANGELES COUNTY Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF Super. Ct. No. CK72824D
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff,

v.

S.C.,

Defendant and Appellant;
R.R.,
Defendant and Respondent.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed.
Elizabeth Klippi, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Liana Serobian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Respondent.
No appearance by the Department of Children and Family
Services.
_______________________________________

INTRODUCTION

S.C. (mother) appeals from an order terminating
dependency jurisdiction over her daughter V.R. (the minor) and
awarding sole legal and physical custody to the minor’s father,
R.R. (father). (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 362.4.)1 Mother claims the
court abused its discretion in awarding father sole legal custody
of the minor. We disagree and affirm.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

1. Petitions Concerning the Minor’s Half Siblings
In 2008, a court sustained a petition under section 300
alleging that mother had a history of engaging in violent
altercations in one of the minor’s half sibling’s presence, placing
her and mother’s other child at risk of physical and emotional
harm. The two children were placed in the home of the maternal
grandparents. Mother was permitted to live in the same home
and the children remained under the supervision of the
Department of Children and Family Services (Department).
In January 2010, the Department filed another petition on
behalf of mother’s two children, alleging that mother had a

1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and

Institutions Code.

2
history of illicit drug abuse including methamphetamine, was a
current user of marijuana, and had been under the influence of
drugs while the children were in her care. The Department also
filed a petition on behalf of mother’s third child in connection
with mother’s drug use. The three children (the minor’s half
siblings) were detained.
In October 2010, a court found that mother was not in
compliance with the case plan and terminated family
reunification services. The minor’s half siblings were placed with
the maternal grandmother. In 2012, the maternal grandmother
became the legal guardian of the minor’s half siblings.
2. The 2012 Petition and Related Proceedings
In May 2012, the Department received a referral alleging
that a domestic violence dispute had taken place between mother
and father. Mother called the maternal grandmother and asked
her to pick mother up. When the maternal grandmother arrived,
mother ran outside carrying the minor (an infant) and was
bruised and crying. The police arrived, but mother refused to file
a report.
The maternal grandmother told a social worker that father
had threatened mother that if she ever involved the Department
with the minor or ever left him or took the minor from him, he
would shoot the maternal grandmother, the minor’s half siblings,
and mother. Mother denied that she had called the maternal
grandmother and that there was any domestic violence between
her and father but admitted that she and father had argued.
Father also admitted that they had argued but denied any
violence.
The court authorized a removal order and the minor was
detained. The Department filed a petition alleging that mother

3
and father have a history of engaging in violent altercations in
the minor’s presence and endangering the minor and her half
siblings, and that father has a history of substance abuse and is a
current abuser of marijuana. (§ 300, subds. (a), (b), (j).)
At the detention hearing, the court found that a prima facie
case for detaining the minor had been established. The court
ordered the Department to provide mother and father with family
reunification services and ordered monitored visits. At the
jurisdiction hearing, mother and father pleaded no contest to the
amended petition that omitted the allegations under section 300,
subdivisions (a) and (j). At the disposition hearing, the court
found by clear and convincing evidence that a substantial danger
to the minor existed and there were no reasonable means to
protect her without removal from the parents’ custody. The court
ordered family reunification services for father only, noting that
section 361.5, subdivision (b)(10) applied to mother.2 The court
also ordered visitation for both parents.
In November 2012, the minor was placed with the maternal
grandmother.
In the six-month status report, the Department stated that
father had completed a parenting course and participated in

2 This subdivision states that reunification services need not be

provided when the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence,
“[t]hat the court ordered termination of reunification services for any
siblings or half-siblings of the child because the parent or guardian
failed to reunify with the sibling or half sibling after the sibling or half
sibling had been removed from that parent or guardian pursuant to
Section 361 … and that, according to the findings of the court, this
parent or guardian has not subsequently made a reasonable effort to
treat the problems that led to removal of the sibling or half sibling of
that child from that parent or guardian.” (§ 361.5, subd. (b)(10)(A).)

4
individual counseling. Father was also participating in couple’s
counseling and a six-month anger management class. The
Department stated that father was in compliance with the court
ordered programs and recommended that family reunification
services continue and that the court calendar a supplemental
progress report in three months to address father’s progress and
the possible return of the minor to father.3 The court adopted this
recommendation.
In a progress report, the Department stated that father
maintained a consistent visitation schedule with the minor and
completed all court-ordered counseling, classes, and drug testing.
Father reported being ready to have the minor returned to his
custody. Mother and father were no longer living together. The
Department recommended that the minor be released to father
and receive family maintenance services and the court so
ordered. The court also ordered continued monitored visits for
mother and that father could not supervise the visits, nor could
mother reside with father.
In a status report, the Department stated the minor was
doing well with father. Mother’s visits with the minor were
inconsistent. Between March and May 2013, mother had regular
visits with the minor at the maternal grandmother’s home. In
May, mother reported that she and the maternal grandmother
were no longer on speaking terms. As of the date of the
Department’s report, mother had not visited the minor for two

3 The status report attached certificates reflecting mother’s

participation in individual counseling and completion of parenting and
domestic violence classes. It also attached the results of 13 drug tests
taken by mother, of which one was positive for methamphetamine.

5
months. The Department recommended that the court terminate
jurisdiction and award sole legal and physical custody of the
minor to father, and that mother be allowed monitored visitation.
In September 2013, the court awarded custody of the minor
to the father and ordered supervised visitation for mother.
3. The 2014 Petition and Related Proceedings
In August 2014, the Department received a referral
alleging that mother and father had participated in two armed
robberies and that the minor was present at the first of these.
Mother and father were arrested in connection with the
robberies. The minor was initially released into the care of the
paternal grandmother but was placed with the maternal
grandmother in September 2014.
Mother told the Department that she and father had
decided to take the minor to the beach and some neighborhood
kids tagged along. She stated she was unaware that the kids
were committing robberies. Mother also admitted that her visits
with the minor were supposed to be monitored by the paternal
grandmother but sometimes only father monitored her visits, and
that she sometimes stayed over at the paternal grandmother’s
home.
In September 2014, the Department filed a section 300
petition alleging that mother and father failed to protect the
minor because they committed robberies while the minor was
under their care and supervision and because father had a
history of illicit drug use and was a current user of marijuana.
(§ 300, subd. (b).)
At the detention hearing, the court found that a prima facie
case for detaining the minor had been established. The court

6
ordered the Department to provide family reunification services
and monitored visits for both parents.
In the jurisdiction/disposition report, the Department
stated that mother continued to deny being involved in the
robberies but acknowledged the minor was present that day.
Mother also denied that she or father used drugs. She stated that
father had a marijuana card but would not smoke around the
minor and that she did not observe him under the influence.
Mother also admitted she had been living with father. Father
denied the robberies and denied the minor was present. He
admitted to smoking marijuana twice a day but denied using
drugs around the minor.
In December 2014, the court sustained the petition. The
court ordered family reunification services and monitored
visitation for the parents, including during their incarceration.4
In the six-month status review report, the Department
reported that both parents had been convicted of second degree
robbery and sentenced to three years in prison. Mother had
completed parenting classes, domestic violence classes, and anger
management classes at her incarceration facility and had
completed a few visitations with the minor. Father had not
completed any classes and was not in compliance. At the six-
month review hearing, the court ordered further family
reunification services.
The 12-month status review report stated mother was in
partial compliance and father was not in compliance. The minor
was doing well in the maternal grandmother’s care and got along

4 Father appealed these findings and orders, which were affirmed on

appeal. (In re V.R. (Aug. 11, 2015, B260998) [nonpub. opn.].)

7
well with her half siblings. The maternal grandmother informed
the Department that she took the minor to visit mother at the
detention center several times and that mother consistently
called and wrote to the minor. Father did not call or write to the
minor. In January 2016, the court found that continued
jurisdiction was necessary, that mother was in compliance with
the case plan, and that father was not in compliance with the
case plan. The court ordered further family reunification services.
In the 18-month status review report, the Department
recommended that the court terminate family reunification
services for mother and father. In June 2016, the court conducted
a contested hearing as to father and terminated his family
reunification services. The court continued the hearing as to
mother to allow for her transportation to the court. In a last
minute information to the court, the Department stated that
mother did not intend to appear at the hearing and recommended
again that the court terminate family reunification services for
mother. In August 2016, the court terminated family
reunification services for mother and ordered a section 366.26
hearing.5
In the section 366.26 report, the Department stated that
the maternal grandmother had been the minor’s primary
caretaker since she was six months old and was committed to
keeping the minor and her half siblings together. The

5 Mother filed a notice of intent to file writ petition that day stating

that she intended to challenge the findings and orders made by the
court. The writ was deemed non-operative. (S.C. v. Superior Court
(B277150, Oct. 13, 2016).)

8
Department recommended that jurisdiction be terminated and
that the maternal grandmother be granted legal guardianship.
In April 2017, the court appointed the maternal
grandmother as the minor’s legal guardian and terminated
dependency jurisdiction over the minor.
4. Section 388 Petitions
In November 2018, mother filed a section 388 petition
requesting that she be granted custody of the minor. The request
was denied because it did not state any new evidence or show a
change of circumstances.
In July 2019, father filed a section 388 petition asking for
the minor to be placed in his custody. Father stated he was on a
“straight road,” had a job and housing, and would be able to put
the minor in a better school. He also stated the minor wanted to
be with him. The court ordered a hearing and directed the
Department to prepare a report. In its response to the section 388
petition, the Department reported that father had yet to complete
either the courses previously ordered by the court or random drug
and alcohol testing. He was unemployed, was a current
marijuana user, and had been inconsistent in his visits with the
minor. The Department recommended that no family
reunification services be provided and that the petition be denied.
In October 2019, the court denied father’s petition.
Father filed another section 388 petition in February 2020.
Father stated that he had maintained a job, had a stable home,
had completed job training, parenting, and substance abuse
courses, and had participated in counseling. Father also claimed
that mother and the maternal grandmother had kept him from
seeing the minor and that the minor told him concerning things
about her home life and the maternal grandmother during their

9
visits. Further, according to father, mother vandalized his home
and stabbed him in March 2018. He asked that his claims against
the maternal grandmother be investigated, that the minor be
removed from the maternal grandmother, and that he be
awarded sole custody. His petition attached proof of enrollment
and attendance for individual counseling, certificates of
completion for the courses, and proof of enrollment in truck
driving school. The court ordered a hearing and asked the
Department to prepare another report. The hearing was
continued due to Covid-19. In the meantime, father filed a third
section 388 petition. The court ordered another hearing and
asked the Department to prepare a report.
In its response to the third section 388 petition, the
Department stated father maintained a suitable residence, had
maintained employment prior to Covid-19, and had the support of
his fiancée and extended family. Father reported that he had not
spoken with mother since she stabbed him two years earlier, a
crime for which she went to prison.6 Father stated that mother
had married and he did not know where she was. The

6 Because the Department’s report only contained a current criminal

history for father, not for mother, father’s statements in his section 388
petition and to a social worker are the only evidence that mother
stabbed him. However, the record supports that mother was
incarcerated in September 2019, as the court issued an “Order for
Prisoner’s Appearance at Hearing Affecting Parental Rights” for
mother to attend the hearing on father’s first section 388 petition. The
Department’s response to father’s first section 388 petition, filed
October 2, 2019, also identified mother’s address as a correctional
facility. The Department reported mother’s address as unknown in its
response to father’s third section 388 petition, filed October 8, 2020,
suggesting that mother was no longer incarcerated by that time.

10
Department recommended that father’s petition be granted, that
jurisdiction be reinstated, and that father be offered family
reunification services and be ordered to participate in random
drug and alcohol testing and a 12-step program. The court
adopted these recommendations.
In a status report dated March 2021, the Department
stated that father had three unexcused “no shows” as well as two
positive results from drug testing. The report also stated that the
minor had expressed a desire to remain with the maternal
grandmother because she wanted to remain close to her half
siblings and to be able to continue having visits with mother. The
Department recommended that family reunification services be
terminated.
In April 2021, mother filed a section 388 petition asking the
court to modify the 2017 order granting maternal grandmother
guardianship of the minor. Mother stated that she had completed
domestic violence group counseling, parenting classes, Alcoholics
Anonymous/Narcotics Anonymous (AA/NA), and that she was
participating in individual counseling. She attached certificates
of completion for the courses and counseling. Mother asked the
court to terminate the legal guardianship and return the minor to
her, reinstate her reunification services, and/or grant her
unmonitored visits. Mother stated the requested actions would
benefit the minor because the minor needs her mother in her life
and because mother had “made positive changes in [her] life,
[was] ready to be the positive role model that [the minor] needs,
and [was] able to provide her with a safe, stable, and healthy
environment.” The court denied mother’s section 388 petition
without a hearing.

11
Several days later, the Department filed a last minute
information for the court following a child abuse and neglect
allegation from father. According to father, the maternal
grandmother allowed mother to enter the home and take the
minor whenever she wanted, without supervision. The
Department reported that the maternal grandmother had
expressed feeling exhausted due to the demands of the
Department and felt she was being treated “like a criminal.”
Several times, she stated that she was done being a legal
guardian, but then recanted. The maternal grandmother stated
that she wished for circumstances to return to normal. According
to the maternal grandmother, mother and father are not good
people, do not deserve to reunify with the minor, and simply view
her as a trophy. The maternal grandmother stated that mother
and father fight over who gets more visits, which results in
mother getting upset and taking the minor with her. Mother
called the maternal grandmother names, such as “fucking bitch,”
and entered the home whenever she wanted.
The maternal grandmother reported that, on March 21,
2021, mother took the minor for over four hours and brought her
home late, and that on March 24, 2021, mother took the minor at
noon and returned after 9:00 p.m. The maternal grandmother did
not consent but could not stop mother because she was afraid of
mother’s abuse. The maternal grandmother stated that mother
cursed at her, told her “ ‘shut the fuck up mother fucken [sic]
bitch,’ ” pushed her, threw her into a door, and stormed inside
her house. The Department advised the maternal grandmother to
call the police when this happens, but the maternal grandmother
reported the police would not do anything because she no longer
had her guardianship documents.

12
On April 28, 2021, mother filed another section 388
petition, this time seeking modification of the order dated April 5,
2021, denying her previous section 388 petition without a
hearing. The petition stated that mother had completed courses
and that unspecified allegations against her were not true.
Mother asked for custody and unmonitored visits. Mother stated
she had proof that the requested actions would benefit the minor
but did not identify any such proof. The court denied the petition
without a hearing.
Mother appealed the order denying her second section 388
petition without a hearing. We affirmed the order. (In re V.R.
(Dec. 6, 2022, B312319) [nonpub. opn.].)
5. Subsequent Proceedings
5.1. Permanency Planning, Section 388 Petitions
In June 2021, the court held a contested permanency
planning review hearing. The court found that father’s
compliance with the case plan was substantial and that returning
the minor to his care and custody would not create a substantial
risk to her safety and well-being. Accordingly, the court
terminated the suitable placement order and ordered the minor
placed in father’s custody with family maintenance services.
Father immediately filed a section 388 petition seeking to
terminate the maternal grandmother’s legal guardianship of the
minor. The court granted the petition.
Mother also filed a section 388 petition requesting “to be
heard” regarding the court’s decision to place the minor with
father. The court summarily denied mother’s petition because it
did not state any change of circumstance, nor did it attach

13
evidence supporting mother’s statement that she had been
attending counseling and parenting classes.
5.2. December 2021 Progress Hearing
The Department submitted a status review report in late
November 2021. During the preceding months, father had
secured employment and stable housing. Further, father’s family
(his wife, his wife’s mother, and the paternal grandparents)
provided extensive support for both father and the minor. Father
expressed frustration, however, at being forced to facilitate the
minor’s visitation with mother, given that the minor did not want
to visit with her.
As to mother, the Department observed that she was
focused on visiting with the minor and expressed the desire to
reunify with her. Yet, mother refused to verify her compliance
with recommended services and was evasive in her responses to
the Department’s social workers. The Department advised
mother to attend a high-conflict co-parenting program to aid with
future custody issues and to seek a modification of the criminal
protective order to allow for peaceful contact with father
regarding the minor. There is no indication mother took any
action, however.
Finally, the Department reported that the minor appeared
to be doing well in father’s custody. The minor said she was
happy and comfortable in father’s home and felt loved by her
family. The minor reported feeling scared of mother and her new
partner and generally refused to visit with mother during her
scheduled visitation times. During the preceding months, the
minor only visited with mother briefly on two occasions with a
monitor.

14
In a last minute information in mid-December 2021, the
Department reported the minor was still refusing to engage in
monitored visits with mother. Three attempted visits had
occurred. At the first visit, the minor said she did not want to
visit with mother. They visited very briefly. On a second occasion,
mother and the minor again visited only briefly. Mother pushed
the minor to explain why she did not want to visit. When the
minor became emotional and appeared worried, the monitor
ended the visit. At the third visit, the minor said she did not want
to visit with mother but did interact with mother for some time,
discussing various subjects. The minor became agitated, however,
and the visit concluded. The Department recommended that
mother’s visitation schedule (then nine hours per week) be
reduced. The Department recommended continued family
maintenance services.
On December 16, 2021, the court held a review hearing
under section 364. The court found continuing jurisdiction was
necessary, ordered the parents to attend a high-conflict co-
parenting program, and ordered the Department to assist mother
in visiting the minor.
5.3. March 2022 Progress Hearing, Case Closure
In a last minute information for the court, the Department
reported that father had enrolled in and was attending a high-
conflict co-parenting class and was participating in conjoint
therapy sessions with the minor. Mother, by contrast, had not
enrolled in any classes or other services, was not drug testing as
required, and had refused to meet with the Department social
worker. Father expressed frustration that mother was still
demanding to visit with the minor and that mother had gone to
the minor’s school and removed father’s wife from the child’s

15
school profile. When questioned, mother said she was afraid of
going back to prison and had opted not to request visits with the
minor and not to participate in court-ordered programs “because
she does not want drama in her life, return to prison, nor have
problems with the law as far as getting accused of things she has
not done.” “Per mother, she has stopped requesting visits to avoid
the drama with the father and his retaliation.”
The Department observed that “there is a lot of hatred and
animosity issues between bio-mother and bio-father that have not
been resolved. It is clear that mother and father are unable to
separate the negative past behaviors in the relationship and co-
parent.” Conflict issues continued to arise, despite father’s
completion of the high-conflict co-parenting class. The
Department recommended that the court terminate family
maintenance services and terminate dependency jurisdiction. The
Department further recommended that father be granted sole
physical custody of the minor and that the parents share legal
custody of her, with monitored visitation for mother.
At the hearing on March 17, 2022, minor’s counsel
requested that the court close the dependency case in light of
mother’s refusal to meet with the Department’s social workers
and her decision to forgo visitation with the minor. Father joined
in that request. The Department recommended that the court
terminate jurisdiction, noting co-parenting and custody issues
would be better addressed in the family law court. The
Department also stated that although there was some evidence
father and his family were somewhat alienating mother, it had
no concerns about the minor’s safety in father’s custody. It
therefore recommended that the court order sole physical custody
with father and joint legal custody. Mother’s counsel requested

16
that the court continue jurisdiction and facilitate mother’s
visitation with the minor in a therapeutic setting.
The court found dependency jurisdiction was no longer
necessary and terminated jurisdiction, ordering sole legal and
physical custody to father. The court noted that mother had
limited contact with the Department and had not progressed
beyond monitored visitation. The court stayed the order and
directed counsel to prepare the necessary exit orders. The court
ordered mediation regarding the terms of the custody order.
The court entered the final parentage and custody orders
on April 21, 2022. Pursuant to mediation, father and mother
agreed to a parenting plan with custody and visitation schedules,
including monitored visitation for mother at the minor’s option.
Mother timely appeals.

DISCUSSION

Mother does not challenge the termination of dependency
jurisdiction, the award of sole physical custody of the minor to
father, or the requirement that her visitation with the minor be
monitored. Indeed, mother only challenges the court’s order to
the extent it awards sole, rather than joint, legal custody of the
minor to father. We conclude the court did not err.
Our colleagues in Division Four of this court recently
summarized the applicable law. “Section 362.4 governs the
termination of juvenile court jurisdiction and related orders. The
statute authorizes a juvenile court to make ‘exit orders’ regarding
custody and visitation upon terminating dependency jurisdiction
over a child. (§ 362.4, subd. (a); In re Chantal S. (1996) 13 Cal.4th
196, 203; In re Kenneth S., Jr. (2008) 169 Cal.App.4th 1353,
1358.) These exit orders remain in effect until modified or

17
terminated by a subsequent order of the superior court. (§ 362.4,
subd. (b); see also Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.700.)
“ ‘[I]n making exit orders, the juvenile court must look at
the best interests of the child.’ (In re John W. (1996) 41
Cal.App.4th 961, 973; see also In re T.S. (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th
503, 513 (T.S.) [‘When making a custody determination under
section 362.4, “the court’s focus and primary consideration must
always be the best interests of the child.” ’], quoting In re
Nicholas H. (2003) 112 Cal.App.4th 251, 268 (Nicholas H.).) The
court must be guided by the totality of the circumstances and
issue orders that are in the child’s best interests. (In re
Chantal S., supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 201; In re Roger S. (1992)
4 Cal.App.4th 25, 30–31.) Because juvenile dependency
proceedings arise when children are subject to or at risk of abuse
or neglect, ‘[t]he presumption of parental fitness that underlies
custody law in the family court just does not apply. … Rather the
juvenile court, which has been intimately involved in the
protection of the child, is best situated to make custody
determinations based on the best interests of the child without
any preferences or presumptions.’ (In re Jennifer R. (1993)
14 Cal.App.4th 704, 712, (Jennifer R.); accord Chantal S., supra,
13 Cal.4th at p. 206.)
“ ‘[T]he juvenile court has broad discretion to make custody
[and visitation] orders when it terminates jurisdiction in a
dependency case (§ 362.4).’ (Nicholas H., supra, 112 Cal.App.4th
at p. 265, fn. 4.) We review the juvenile court’s exit orders for an
abuse of that discretion. (See, e.g., In re Maya L. (2014)
232 Cal.App.4th 81, 102; Jennifer R., supra, 14 Cal.App.4th at
p. 711; see also In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295, 318.) We
will not disturb the juvenile court’s decision ‘ “ ‘unless the trial

18
court has exceeded the limits of legal discretion by making an
arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd determination.’ ” ’ (In re
Stephanie M., supra, 7 Cal.4th at p. 318.)” (In re J.M. (2023) 89
Cal.App.5th 95, 112–113.)
Considering the evidence before the court, the court did not
abuse its discretion by determining that sole legal custody with
father was in the minor’s best interest. First, the court found that
mother had not made any significant progress in the court-
ordered services. Specifically, although mother was focused on
visiting with the minor and expressed the desire to reunify with
her, mother refused to verify her compliance with recommended
and court-ordered services and was evasive in her responses to
the Department’s social workers. The Department advised, and
the court subsequently ordered, that mother attend a high-
conflict co-parenting program to aid with future custody issues.
Mother did not enroll in any classes or other services, was not
drug testing as required, and refused to meet with the
Department social worker. These facts support the juvenile
court’s decision not to grant joint legal custody. (See In re
Maya L. (2014) 232 Cal.App.4th 81, 103 [affirming sole legal
custody to father where mother was uncooperative with the
Department]; In re Jennifer R., supra, 14 Cal.App.4th at p. 713
[affirming sole legal custody with father where mother “did not
follow through on [program] referrals” and “fail[ed] to make
progress in overcoming the problems leading to [the child’s]
removal”].)
Additionally, the record indicates that the minor was doing
well in father’s care. The minor said she was happy and
comfortable in father’s home and felt loved by her family. Father
had secured employment and stable housing and his family (his

19
wife, his wife’s mother, and the paternal grandparents) provided
extensive support for both father and the minor. And father took
seriously the recommendations of the Department and the orders
of the court. He enrolled in and was attending a high-conflict co-
parenting class and was participating in conjoint therapy with
the minor. Indeed, after the minor was placed in father’s home,
the Department consistently observed the minor to be happy and
well cared for and saw no reason for concern over her safety and
well-being. (See In re Maya L., supra, 232 Cal.App.4th at p. 103
[affirming sole legal custody with father based on “overwhelming
evidence that father provided excellent care for [child]” and the
Department “consistently reported it had no concerns regarding
father’s ability to care for the child”].) This additional evidence
also supports the court’s finding that sole legal custody with
father was in the minor’s best interest.
It is also relevant that, during the final period of the
Department’s supervision, mother stopped requesting the
opportunity to visit with the minor. Mother expressed concern
about the high level of conflict with father (her refusal to
participate in a high-conflict co-parenting class notwithstanding),
said she was afraid of going back to prison, and opted not to
request visits with the minor and not to participate in court-
ordered programs “because she does not want drama in her life,
return to prison, nor have problems with the law as far as getting
accused of things she has not done.” This additional evidence also
supports the court’s decision to award father sole legal custody of
the minor.
Mother argues that the court erred by ignoring the
Department’s recommendation to grant joint legal custody. She
seems to suggest that in the absence of joint legal custody, she

20
may be unable to visit with the minor or obtain information about
the minor directly from the minor’s school. But the terms of
mother’s visitation are set forth in the custody and visitation
order and mother may request the family court’s assistance in
enforcing her visitation rights irrespective of her custody rights.
Additionally, mother fails to explain why it would be in the
minor’s best interest for mother to retain educational rights,
especially in light of mother’s failure to pursue visitation with the
minor during the final months of the Department’s supervision.
Finally, mother cites In re Roger S. (1992) 4 Cal.App.4th
25, as persuasive authority. The case is inapposite, however, as it
involved a juvenile court’s refusal to accept evidence from a
parent in connection with the hearing on final custody and
visitation orders. (Id. at pp. 30–31.) The Court of Appeal held
that the court erred by failing to consider evidence relevant to the
best interest of the child. (Id. at p. 31.) Here, no such concern is
present as mother did not offer, and thus the court did not refuse,
any evidence at the hearing.
In sum, ample evidence supports the court’s determination
that the minor’s best interest is served by father’s sole legal
custody. Mother presents no persuasive evidence or argument to
the contrary.

21
DISPOSITION

The order is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

LAVIN, J.
WE CONCUR:

EDMON, P. J.

EGERTON, J.

22

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.