CourtListener 10007965•In re Michael C. CA2/5
Texto completo
Filed 7/19/24 In re Michael C. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re MICHAEL C. et al., Persons B329287
Coming Under the Juvenile Court
Law
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP03343A-C)
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
N.N. et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Temporary Judge. Dismissed in
part and affirmed in part.
Law Offices of Vincent W. Davis & Associates and
Vincent W. Davis, for Defendant and Appellant N.N.
Law Office of Robert McLaughlin and Robert McLaughlin,
under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and
Appellant K.R.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel and Sally Son, Senior Deputy County
Counsel for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________
As relevant here, N.N. (mother) has three children,
Michael C. (born April 2013), Mia M. (born December 2016), and
Kylie R. (born December 2020). K.R. (father) is the father of
Kylie only.
Mother appeals the juvenile court’s orders declaring her
three children dependents under Welfare and Institutions Code1
sections 300, subdivision (b), and removing the children from her
custody under section 361. Father appeals solely from the
dispositional order denying his request under section 361.2 for
custody of Kylie, which father intends to exercise in New York
where he currently resides.
The Los Angeles County Department of Children and
Family Services (the Department) filed a motion to dismiss
mother’s appeal, along with a request for judicial notice.
We dismiss mother’s appeal and affirm the court’s
disposition orders.
The parties are familiar with the facts and our opinion does
not meet the criteria for publication. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule
8.1105(c).) We accordingly resolve the cause before us, consistent
1 All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code unless otherwise indicated.
2
with constitutional requirements, via a written opinion with
reasons stated. (Cal. Const., art. VI, § 14; Lewis v. Superior
Court (1999) 19 Cal.4th 1232, 1261–1264 [three-paragraph
discussion of issue on appeal satisfies constitutional requirement
because “an opinion is not a brief in reply to counsel’s
arguments”; “[i]n order to state the reasons, grounds, or
principles upon which a decision is based, [an appellate court]
need not discuss every case or fact raised by counsel in support of
the parties’ positions”].)
DISCUSSION
A. Mother’s Appeal is Dismissed
In her opening brief, mother challenges the sufficiency of
the evidence supporting the court’s jurisdictional findings and its
orders removing all three children from her custody.
At the adjudication hearing on March 23, 2023, the court
declared the children dependents based on the following amended
jurisdictional allegations:
b-1, d-1, j-1: “[Father] sexually abused the child Mia.
On or about 8/18/22 and on prior occasions, [father]
fondled and digitally penetrated the child’s vagina,
causing the child pain. The mother failed to protect
the child when she knew of [father’s] sexual abuse of
the child. The mother allowed [father] to frequent
the child’s home and to have unlimited access to the
child. . . .”
3
b-2, j-2: “On 8/19/2022, [mother] created a
detrimental and endangering situation for the five-
year old child Mia in that [mother] failed to provide
appropriate supervision for the child, resulting in the
child wandering the streets alone wearing only
underwear and a blanket wrapped around herself.
Such a detrimental and endangering situation
established for the child by the mother, and the
mother’s failure to provide appropriate supervision
for the child, endangers the child’s physical health
and safety, and creates a detrimental home
environment, placing the child and the child’s
siblings, [Michael and Kylie], at risk of serious
physical harm, damage and danger.”
b-5, j-3: “[Mother and father] have a history of
engaging in physical and verbal altercations while in
the presence of the children. On prior occasions in
2021, the mother and father engaged in verbal
altercations. On prior occasions in 2021, the father
attempted to punch the mother . . . . On 2/7/22, the
mother and father engaged in a verbal and physical
altercation where the father punched the mother
once with a closed fist on the left side of her head.
The father shoved the mother by the base of her neck,
causing the mother to hit the fence with her
back. . . . Such violent conduct . . . endangers the
children’s physical health and safety, creates a
detrimental home environment and places the
4
children at risk of serious physical harm, damage and
danger.”
The Department moved to dismiss mother’s appeal, arguing
that all of mother’s contentions on appeal were either moot or
nonjusticiable. In support of its motion to dismiss, the
Department requests judicial notice of the following post-appeal
orders by the juvenile court:
1. On July 27, 2023, the juvenile court terminated
dependency jurisdiction over Michael and made a
custody order giving both parents joint legal custody,
Michael’s father sole physical custody, and mother
monitored visits. The custody order took effect on
October 13, 2023, when the juvenile court lifted its stay.
2. On November 2, 2023, the juvenile court terminated
dependency jurisdiction over Mia and made a custody
order giving both parents joint legal custody, Mia’s
father sole physical custody, and mother monitored
visits. The custody order took effect on December 22,
2023, when the juvenile court lifted its stay.
3. On February 27, 2024, the juvenile court terminated
Kylie’s suitable placement order, and placed Kylie in
mother’s home, subject to Department supervision.
“A reviewing court must ‘ “decide on a case-by-case basis
whether subsequent events in a juvenile dependency matter
make a case moot and whether [its] decision would affect the
outcome in a subsequent proceeding.” ’ ” (In re D.P. (2023) 14
Cal.5th 266, 276.) Because the juvenile court has terminated
dependency jurisdiction over Michael and Mia, mother has not
5
appealed the court’s termination or custody orders, and mother
has not filed any opposition to the Department’s motion to
dismiss, we agree that the portions of mother’s appeal pertaining
to those two children are moot. (In re Gael C. (2023) 96
Cal.App.5th 220, 223–224 [dismissing appeal of jurisdiction and
disposition orders as moot, where parent did not appeal
subsequent termination of dependency jurisdiction and related
custody order].) Even if we were to reach the merits of mother’s
appeal as to the two older children, there was substantial
evidence to support the appealed findings and orders, based on
the children’s statements to social workers, regarding domestic
violence observed between mother and father and mother
permitting father to sleep in the same bed as Mia after reports of
sexual abuse.
Mother’s appeal of the order removing Kylie from her
custody is also moot, because Kylie has been returned to mother’s
custody. (In re N.S. (2016) 245 Cal.App.4th 53, 60 [mootness
turns on “whether the appellate court can provide any effective
relief if it finds reversible error”].)
The only contention remaining in mother’s appeal is
whether there is substantial evidence to support dependency
jurisdiction over Kylie. However, the Department argues
mother’s entire appeal should be dismissed, based on her failure
to provide a summary of the significant facts in her brief and to
articulate any cogent legal challenge to the second jurisdictional
finding – that mother failed to adequately supervise Mia.
Mother did not file any response to the Department’s
motion to dismiss, did not file a reply brief in support of her
appeal, and did not request oral argument in this case. “A failure
to oppose a motion may be deemed a consent to the granting of
6
the motion.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.54(c).) We agree with
the Department that mother has forfeited any argument that we
should reach the merits of her jurisdictional challenge. We see no
reason in the current context to exercise our discretion to reach
the merits of mother’s appeal. (In re D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p.
287; In re Gael C., supra, 96 Cal.App.5th at pp. 224–225.)
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Court’s Order
Denying Father’s Request for Custody
“When a juvenile court orders removal of a child from the
custodial parent, it must determine whether there is a
noncustodial parent who wants to assume custody. If so, the
court must ‘place the child with the [noncustodial] parent unless
it finds that [such] placement . . . would be detrimental to the
safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the
child.’ (§ 361.2, subd. (a).) A finding of detriment must be made
by clear and convincing evidence. [Citation.] We review the
juvenile court’s finding of detriment for substantial evidence,
‘bearing in mind the heightened burden of proof’ in the trial
court.” (In re Solomon B. (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 69, 74–75.)
Father has not appealed the jurisdictional findings against
him. Nevertheless, father argues that aside from his status as an
offending parent, there was insufficient evidence of detriment for
the court to deny his request under section 361.2 to grant him
custody of Kylie in New York. Father argues that his alleged
sexual abuse of Kylie’s five-year old half-sibling Mia was not
frequent or severe enough to support a finding that granting him
custody of Kylie in New York would place her at risk of harm. He
also argues that any risk posed by the domestic violence between
7
him and mother was eliminated because he and mother have
ended their relationship and he has moved to New York.
Father’s argument misses the mark. Even accounting for
the heightened burden of proof needed to support the trial court’s
determination that placing Kylie in father’s custody would be
detrimental to her safety, protection, and her physical and
emotional well-being, the record includes substantial evidence to
support the court’s order denying father’s request for custody of
Kylie under section 361.2. Kylie’s young age, evidence of violence
in father’s relationship with mother, and evidence that father
sexually abused Mia, provides ample support for the court’s
denial of father’s request. The correctness of the juvenile court’s
decision is further supported by the larger context, which
included the absence of any real effort by father to engage with
the Department outside of limited monitored visits, his move to
New York just two months before the court’s disposition order,
and his refusal to participate in any services during the six
months leading up to the last part of the disposition hearing.
Kylie was only 22 months old when she was detained from
parental custody in August 2022, and father was not in contact
with the Department until the day before his arraignment on
October 19, 2022. He initially wanted a paternity test, stating
that mother had told him Kylie was not his child. After the court
ordered monitored visits between father and Kylie, father’s
girlfriend refused to monitor the visits and father could not
identify an alternate monitor for the Department. The
Department arranged for video calls, monitored by Kylie’s
caregiver, but father was not able to follow the visitation
schedule despite efforts to accommodate him. The caregiver
reported that on at least one video call, father appeared to be
8
under the influence (his eyes were red) and he was distracted
because he was walking around.
Father did have consistent and positive in-person
monitored visits from November 2022 through March 2023, but
absent a court order, he declined to participate in any programs
such as sexual abuse prevention or domestic violence batterers
programs despite the pending allegations against him. Instead,
he purchased a home and planned to move to New York with
Kylie, although he was open to receiving family maintenance
services in New York if Kylie was released to his care. His last
in-person visit before moving to New York took place on
March 22, 2023, and after that he was inconsistent with
telephone visits.
The record evidence is sufficient to support the court’s
determination that placing Kylie with father posed a risk of
detriment.
DISPOSITION
Mother’s appeal is dismissed. The disposition orders are
affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
We concur:
BAKER, Acting P.J. KIM, J.
9
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.