CourtListener 10003547•People v. Renfroe CA4/3
Texto completo
Filed 7/15/24 P. v. Renfroe CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G063292
v. (Super. Ct. No. RIF2102015)
JAMES DAVID RENFROE, OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside, Dean
Benjamini, Judge. Affirmed.
Kenneth H. Nordin, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Melissa
Mandel and A. Natasha Cortina, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
* * *
Defendant James David Renfroe appeals from a judgment
following a jury trial in which he was found guilty of committing various sex
crimes against two minors, involving two separate incidents. The jury was
1
given an instruction consistent with Evidence Code section 1108 and People
v. Villatoro (2012) 54 Cal.4th 1152 (Villatoro) that permitted the jury to draw
an inference that Renfroe had a propensity to commit the other sex crimes
charged in this case if it found that any charged sex crime had been proven
beyond a reasonable doubt. Renfroe contends it was error to give this
instruction without first performing a section 352 analysis. We agree that
the court seems to have been unaware of its discretion to reject the
instruction, and thus it failed to exercise its discretion. However, we
conclude the error was harmless and affirm the judgment.
FACTS
1. Thirty-three year-old Renfroe engages in a sexual relationship with 16-
year-old JD12
In 2020, Renfroe sold marijuana products online as the self-styled
“the main plug” (a “plug” is a term for a drug dealer). Sixteen-year-old JD1
was a high school junior and cheerleader. She lived with her parents and
older sister.
JD1 met Renfroe through his online drug sales. JD1, who had
been smoking marijuana since middle school, first purchased marijuana from
1
All further statutory references are to the Evidence Code unless
otherwise stated.
2
In order to protect the privacy of the victims, who are both
minors and victims of sex crimes, we refer to them as JD1 (Jane Doe 1) and
JD2 (Jane Doe 2).
2
Renfroe in October of 2020. JD1 met Renfroe in person “around the corner by
[her] house.” They started communicating through “Snapchat,” a social
media platform, and developed a friendship of sorts. JD1 started hanging out
with Renfroe in person. They spent a lot of time together.
By November 2020, JD1 had developed romantic feelings for
Renfroe, and they started dating. JD1 did not have a car or a driver’s license
so Renfroe would pick her up from her house. They went out to dinner, and
they would go shopping. Renfroe also dropped her off and picked her up at
the high school, including from her cheerleading practice. He did this a few
days a week. They did not go to Renfroe’s home because he was married.
JD1 fell in love with Renfroe. He made her feel special, told her he had
feelings for her and not his wife, and JD1 believed that they would get
married.
JD1 told Renfroe that she was 16 years old less than a month
into their dating relationship and Renfroe told her that he was 33, sometime
in November or December 2020. Renfroe expressed surprise that she was 16
but did not say anything or suggest that they should not date because of her
age. JD1’s parents knew that she was dating but they did not know it was
Renfroe.
On January 29, 2021, JD1’s mother discovered marijuana in her
bedroom, and they got into an argument. JD1’s mother went into JD1’s room
to ask her to join her doing some errands when she smelled marijuana and
saw it on JD1’s dresser. JD1’s mother took it and JD1 tried to take it back
from her. JD1’s sister stepped in and took the bag from JD1 and handed it
over to their mother. JD1’s mother then left to complete an important errand
and contacted her husband.
3
Meanwhile, JD1 called Renfroe to pick her up. When JD1’s
mother returned home from her errand she noticed a white Tesla pulling
away as she pulled in. Then JD1 walked out through front door of her house
with a bag in her hand. She told her mother that she was leaving as she was
speaking to someone on the phone. JD1’s mother could hear her ask the
person on the phone, “Where are you?” and saw her daughter walk a few
houses down the street. The car she had previously noticed, the white Tesla,
had returned. JD1’s mother was a few steps behind JD1 and now on the
phone with her husband. When JD1 started to get into the Tesla her mother
tried to pull her out of the car. JD1’s mother physically held the car door open
and put her body between the car door and car so the door could not close.
She told JD1 and Renfroe that she was going to call the police and she took
photos of them in the car.
JD1’s mother had never seen Renfroe before and she had no idea
that JD1 had been dating a 33-year-old man. JD1’s mother repeatedly yelled
at Renfroe, “She’s only 16.” She told Renfroe, “Do not take her” and said that
she was “going to get in the vehicle too.” Renfroe just looked directly at JD1’s
mother and did not say anything. JD1 began to kick her mother out of the
way and the car sped away. JD1’s mother immediately called 911, relaying
what happened including that she told Renfroe that her daughter was 16
years old. She also provided the police with the pictures she took, and they
were able to identify Renfroe using facial recognition software.
To avoid detection by the police, Renfroe stopped at a parking lot
to switch cars to a truck that he also drove. Renfroe and JD1 then went to a
hotel in Riverside where they stayed for three or four days. This was the first
time that JD1 had intercourse with Renfroe.
4
After staying another night at a different hotel, JD1 moved into
an apartment that Renfroe rented for her. She lived at the apartment from
February through May or June of 2021. Renfroe was there most days out of
the week, but he would leave at night to return to his family home. JD1
estimated that they engaged in intercourse weekly and they similarly
engaged in oral sex with each other and Renfroe digitally penetrated her
vagina. Other than his wife, JD1 considered them to be in an exclusive
dating relationship.
JD1 also helped Renfroe with packaging and selling drugs.
Renfroe paid her. Renfroe was growing mushrooms in the apartment. JD1
also accompanied Renfroe when he sold mushrooms. They smoked marijuana
together.
During this time, JD1 continued to attend school. Her social
media account, which Renfroe followed, had pictures of her cheering at
various high school games including some in April when she was still living
in Renfroe’s apartment.
2. Renfroe tried to engage in sexual activity with 13-year-old JD2 and
obtained nude photos and videos of her genitalia
In May 2021, while Renfroe still had JD1 in the apartment and
his wife and son at home, he initiated contact with 13-year-old JD2. JD2,
who was born in 2008, had just turned 13 years old and was in 7th grade. At
the time, she had a “Snapchat” account, which was a social media platform
where she could text or “snap” others and add random people online. JD2
posted pictures of herself and where she went to let people know where she
was. She would accept friend requests from random people and begin
5
chatting with them. Most of the people that JD2 chatted with were around
her age or younger. “It was really random if someone was older.”
Sometime during the first week of May 2021, Renfroe contacted
JD2 through Snapchat. With a username of “the main plug” he added her
through “Quick Add” as a friend and started chatting with JD2. When JD2
was first contacted by Renfroe, she thought he was someone her age. She did
not have a particular intention when communicating with him. Because JD2
did not know what the reference to plug meant she asked a friend who told
her that it meant a drug dealer. Renfroe’s posts depicted vape pens, edibles
and roll ups. JD2 asked Renfroe his age and he told her he was 34 years old.
Renfroe’s Snapchats started out just being kind to JD2. He
chatted and asked JD2 about herself for a couple of days before asking
whether she wanted to buy drugs. He asked, “Do you want to buy the stuff I
have on my story?” JD2 could see on his Snapchat “story” that he had
various marijuana products. She asked him whether he sold to 13-year-olds
because she was 13. Renfroe said that he did not mind selling to any age.
JD2 had never handled or used these products before. Although she knew
what marijuana was and had seen people smoke marijuana, JD2 had not
been personally interested in marijuana until Renfroe offered. She also knew
that she was not old enough to buy marijuana because she was 13 years old
and that was why she asked if he sold to her age group.
JD2 initially declined because she did not have money to pay
Renfroe. When she told him so, he responded, “There’s other ways you can
pay me.” When JD2 asked Renfroe how, he told her by having sexual
relations with him, sending him nudes, or giving him oral sex like other girls
did. JD2 thought about it and decided she would like to meet up with
Renfroe. She did not agree to have sex (intercourse) with him, but she did
6
agree to perform oral sex for a vape pen. Renfroe indicated that either was
fine with him, that others had performed oral sex and that it felt good.
JD2 and Renfroe did not make any specific plan at that point, but
Renfroe contacted her the next day by text and asked when they would meet
up. Around this time, they also discussed where they would meet and agreed
it would be at a mall on May 17, 2021. Renfroe broached the possibility of a
threesome with his “homegirl.” Thereafter, JD2 changed her mind about oral
sex and offered to provide “nudes,” meaning she would send Renfroe nude
pictures of herself.
Renfroe agreed to the offer of nude photos but said it would have
to be “a lot of pictures to pay it off.” He directed what kind of pictures and
videos JD2 should take. She took the photos of herself in mid-May 2021.
After JD2 sent Renfroe photos of herself, he agreed to deliver the vape pen
but said that she would need to get a battery. JD2 did not know what
Renfroe meant at first and a friend explained. Renfroe told her that she
would have to send more photos in order to get the battery for “free.” JD2
sent Renfroe more photos. In all, JD2 sent photos of herself completely nude,
specific nude portions of her body, including her genitalia and of herself in
various sexual poses specified by Renfroe. Renfroe also insisted that she
video herself masturbating “and to make sure it was really wet.” Renfroe
asked for and obtained seven videos of JD2. Renfroe, in turn, sent JD2 an
unsolicited photo of his penis. JD2 did not want to see his penis. Renfroe
also sent two face shots, one with him wearing sunglasses and the other
without sunglasses.
The day after, on May 14, 2021, Renfroe drove to JD2’s home to
deliver the vape pen and the charger. The plan was for him to leave it on the
lawn in front of JD2’s home because JD2 told Renfroe that she lived with her
7
parents and that she did not want to get caught. However, when Renfroe
tossed the vape package out of his car it landed on the street not JD2’s lawn.
Renfroe texted JD2, “hurry up and pick up the pen so that you don’t get
caught by your parents.” JD2 retrieved the unopened vape pen and charger
from the street in front of her home and hid it in her room. She did not open
it. She knew that if her mother found out about it she would be in trouble.
Renfroe texted her later to confirm her receipt, which she did.
Thereafter, JD2 became scared because Renfroe continued to ask
her “if [she] wanted to meet up still.” She was worried that he would come by
her home, so she told her mother what had happened. Her mother, in turn,
contacted her father, although she did not tell him how JD2 paid for the vape
pen.
The next morning, JD2’s father, who thought Renfroe wanted
money, posed as JD2 on her phone and texted Renfroe, “How much do I owe
you?” Renfroe responded, “Aren’t we meeting up?” JD2’s father suggested
Sunday or Monday. During this exchange, Renfroe explained why he did not
want to communicate with his phone number, noting he had to stay “lowkey
on snap” because if JD2 texted him on his number “I’ll get caught up.”
Renfroe also became suspicious that he was not texting with JD2 and asked
for a picture of her with the phone. After being reassured, Renfroe asked JD2
to “send pics.” In the text exchange Renfroe also volunteered, “I still have
some of those pics you sent me. I’m looking forward to it.”
Meanwhile, JD2’s mother also contacted the police. They, in turn,
took control over JD2’s phone. The police, posing as JD2, agreed to meet with
Renfroe at 4:30 p.m., on Sunday after she finished her homework. Renfroe
expressed concern about her parents taking her phone and someone “knowing
about this shit.” Renfroe confirmed the plan to “meet up so [she] could give
8
[him] head,” and offered to do the same for her. He also offered to pick JD2
“around the corner from [her] house” but the police texted that she would
walk there. They agreed to meet at the top of a parking structure near a
movie theatre at a mall.
Renfroe initially drove up to the top of the parking structure
where there is nothing to do except park. He made a slow U-turn, drove down
to a lower level, and parked his car. He texted JD2 and told her that he
parked in a lower level because he had seen a cop. The police located Renfroe
in a white Tesla and arrested him.
A search of Renfroe’s car uncovered a firearm, a loaded nine-
millimeter semi-automatic handgun, pre-rolled marijuana cigarettes,
marijuana oil, edibles, marijuana vape pen cartridges, psilocybin mushrooms,
and a scale. Additionally, the officers recovered Renfroe’s phone with the
main plug’s account. The photo of Renfroe’s penis sent to JD2 appeared to
have been taken from inside the Tesla.
A search of Renfroe’s home pursuant to a warrant uncovered
approximately two pounds of psilocybin mushrooms and panels of processed
marijuana in various forms, such as concentrates, vape pens, vape chargers,
and pre-rolled cigarettes. The quantity and packaging were consistent with
sales. The pictures of JD2 were the only child pornography found in
Renfroe’s possession.
3. After his release from custody, Renfroe continued to engage in sexual
activity with JD1
In May 2021, JD1 learned from a friend of Renfroe’s that Renfroe
had been arrested. When Renfroe was released, he told her that “he was
caught selling drugs.” He said that he got caught selling to a girl but did not
9
mention her age or that it involved nude photos. Later, Renfroe told her that
girl was younger but did not say how old she was. He maintained that he did
not know. JD1 also understood eventually that something was sexually
promised for the drugs. She was disappointed and was packing to leave
when Renfroe told her to pack up all of her belongings because he was going
to take her home out of concern the police might come to the apartment.
Renfroe explained that the police were at his home with his wife.
At this point, Renfroe and JD1’s relationship began to unravel.
On June 5, 2021, at the instigation of her sister, JD1 demanded $20,000 from
Renfroe or she would go to the police station and report him. She did not
want to threaten Renfroe, but she was upset and confused. She did not like
being away from Renfroe and continued to have feelings for him. A text
exchange followed where JD1 pointed out that Renfroe knew that she was
underage and Renfroe countered that this was not her and that she had a
fake identification. He then complained, “All for money. I made a mistake.”
He then threatened JD1 by pointing out that she tried to hide evidence for
him, and he had never told her to do that. JD1 had tried to hide all the
marijuana and mushrooms that were at the apartment at a friend’s house.
After the text conversation, JD1’s sister encouraged her to go to
the police, to protect others. JD1 entered into an immunity agreement over
her attempt to extort money from Renfroe and her participation in his drug
sales operation. She agreed to testify truthfully and maintained that she did.
The jury returned a mixed verdict. On count 1, contacting a
minor with the intent to commit a lewd or lascivious act on a child under 14
years of age (Pen. Code, §§ 288.3, 288, subd. (a)), the jury found Renfroe not
guilty. On count 3, attempted lewd or lascivious act with a child under 14
(Pen. Code, § 288, subd. (a)), the jury found Renfroe not guilty. On the
10
remaining counts, the jury found Renfroe guilty. Those included: count 2,
going to meeting with minor for lewd purposes (Pen. Code, § 288.4, subd. (b));
count 4, possession of controlled substance for sale (Health & Saf. Code,
§ 11378); count 5, using a minor to perform prohibited act (Pen. Code, §
311.4, subd. (c); count 6, carrying a loaded firearm (Pen. Code, § 25850 subd.
(c)(7)); count 7, unlawful sexual intercourse with a minor more than three
years younger (Pen. Code, § 261.5); count 9, oral copulation with a person
under 18 (Pen. Code, § 287, subd. (b)(1)); and count 10, sexual penetration
3
with a person under 18 (Pen. Code, § 289, subd. (h)).
The court selected count 2 as the principal count and sentenced
Renfroe to the middle term of three years in state prison. On each of the
remaining counts, the court imposed one-third of the middle term of two
years, which was eight months, to run consecutive to the principal term. The
court also imposed a two-year enhancement on count 7 pursuant to Penal
Code section 12022.1 (crime committed while released from custody), run
consecutively. The total sentence was 8 years 4 months. Renfroe appealed.
DISCUSSION
Renfroe raises a single issue of instructional error on appeal. In
particular Renfroe claims it was error to provide the jury an instruction
based on CALCRIM No. 1191B, which is in turn based on section 1108.
Section 1108 provides, “In a criminal action in which the defendant is
accused of a sexual offense, evidence of the defendant’s commission of another
sexual offense or offenses is not made inadmissible by Section 1101, if the
3
Prior to trial, the court dismissed count 8, attempting to
dissuade a witness from reporting a crime.
11
evidence is not inadmissible pursuant to Section 352.” (Id., subd. (a).)
Section 1108 is an exception to the usual rule that propensity evidence is
inadmissible. (§ 1101, subd. (a); Villatoro, supra, 54 Cal.4th at pp. 1159-
1160.) The twist here is that the predicate act relied on to prove propensity is
itself one of the charged crimes in the present case. In other words, instead of
relying on a previous conviction or bad act, the jury was permitted to rely on
any one of the sexual offenses proven in this case to establish a propensity to
commit the other sexual offenses charged in this case.
The instruction at issue reads as follows:
“The People presented evidence that the defendant committed
the crimes of Attempted Lewd or Lascivious Act: Child Under 14 Years (Pen.
Code §§ 664/288(a)); Using a Minor to Perform Prohibited Act (Pen. Code
§ 311.4(c)); Oral Copulation With Person Under 18 (Pen. Code § 287( b)(1));
and Sexual Penetration With Person Under 18 (Pen. Code § 289(h)) charged
in Counts 3, 5, 9, and 10.
“If the People have proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the
defendant committed one or more of these crimes, you may, but are not
required to, conclude from that evidence that the defendant was disposed or
inclined to commit sexual offenses, and based on that decision, also conclude
that the defendant was likely to commit and did commit the other sex
offenses charged in this case.
“If you find that the defendant committed one or more of these
crimes, that conclusion is only one factor to consider along with all the other
evidence. It is not sufficient by itself to prove that the defendant is guilty of
another crime. The People must still prove each charge and allegation
beyond a reasonable doubt.” (CALCRIM No. 1191B.)
12
Renfroe contends the court erred by providing this instruction
without first conducting a section 352 analysis, as set forth in Villatoro,
4
supra, 54 Cal.4th 1152.
In Villatoro, a four to three decision, the court considered
whether section 1108 permits the use of charged sexual offenses as predicate
offenses to prove propensity to commit other charged sexual offenses (i.e., the
same situation we have here). (Villatoro, supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 1160.)
Concluding that it does, the majority relied on the fact that the statute
simply refers to “another” sexual offense and draws no distinction between
charged and uncharged offenses. (Id. at pp. 1160-1161.) The Attorney
General argued that section 1108’s reference to section 352 was an implicit
distinction between charged and uncharged offenses, since evidence of
charged offenses cannot be excluded under section 352. (Villatoro, at p.
1162.) In rejecting that argument, the Villatoro majority concluded that the
court has discretion under section 352 to prohibit the jury from making a
propensity inference. (Villatoro, at p. 1163 [“nothing precludes a trial court
from considering section 352 factors when deciding whether to permit the
jury to infer a defendant’s propensity based on this evidence”].) “‘Even where
a defendant is charged with multiple sex offenses, they may be dissimilar
enough, or so remote or unconnected to each other, that the trial court could
apply the criteria of section 352 and determine that it is not proper for the
jury to consider one or more of the charged offenses as evidence that the
4
Section 352 provides, “The court in its discretion may exclude
evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the probability
that its admission will (a) necessitate undue consumption of time or (b) create
substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of
misleading the jury.”
13
defendant likely committed any of the other charged offenses.’” (Id. at p.
1163.)
The problem here, Renfroe insists, is that the court did not seem
to be aware of its discretion under section 352. When the prosecutor
requested that CALCRIM No. 1191B be given, the court commented, “I’ll just
say I’m not a big fan of 1191B, of using [section] 1108 . . . in the same case,
but that’s the way the law is.” “If that’s going to be argued, I think this is an
appropriate instruction . . . .” These comments suggest that the court felt
that its hands were tied. The court did not engage in any sort of analysis to
determine whether CALCRIM No. 1191B was appropriate in light of the
circumstances of the present case. “A court necessarily abuses its discretion
when it fails to exercise its discretion at all . . . .” (People v. Choi (2021) 59
Cal.App.5th 753, 766.)
The Attorney General contends the court implicitly exercised its
discretion under section 352, relying primarily on Villatoro. There, the trial
court had not explicitly analyzed giving an instruction under the rubric of
section 352. (Villatoro, supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 1168.) However, the trial
court had cited a case in which a section 352 analysis was required. That
was sufficient for our Supreme Court to find that the trial court had
implicitly considered section 352: “‘[W]e are willing to infer an implicit
weighing by the trial court on the basis of record indications well short of an
express statement.’” (Villatoro, at p. 1168.)
The record in the present case, however, differs significantly from
the record in Villatoro. Here, the court’s statements suggest it was unaware
of its discretion to deny the requested instruction. And unlike Villatoro, the
court cited no cases that could implicitly suggest the court had performed the
appropriate analysis. Accordingly, the court erred.
14
Nevertheless, we conclude the error was harmless. For
instructional errors that do not amount to a deprivation of due process, we
review the error under the standard prescribed by People v. Watson (1956) 46
Cal.2d 818, 836, pursuant to which we reverse only if it is reasonably
probable that the appellant would have obtained a better result in the
absence of the error. (People v. Beltran (2013) 56 Cal.4th 935, 955.)
There is nothing in the record to suggest that this instruction
made any difference in the outcome of the trial. Multiple aspects of the
record support this conclusion.
The actual discussion of the propensity jury instruction by the
prosecution was very brief, occupying just four lines in the reporter’s
transcript. It was not mentioned at all by defense counsel, nor was it
mentioned by the prosecutor in rebuttal.
The instruction itself made clear that, even if the jury elected to
draw an inference of propensity, such an inference was not sufficient to prove
guilt. It properly informed the jury that the prosecutor still had the burden
of proving the elements of each crime beyond a reasonable doubt.
Rather than focusing on this instruction, the focus of the parties’
arguments was on the credibility of the witnesses who claimed to have told
Renfroe the ages of the minors (i.e., JD1, JD1’s mother, and JD2). The jury
did not ask any questions about the instruction.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the particular concern of
failing to perform a section 352 analysis is that the jury could be inflamed by
otherwise inadmissible evidence (or, in this case, inappropriate inferences).
(People v. Williams (2013) 58 Cal.4th 197, 270 [“‘“The ‘prejudice’ referred to
in . . . section 352 applies to evidence which uniquely tends to evoke an
emotional bias against defendant as an individual and which has very little
15
effect on the issues”’”].) Here, however, the jury seems to have been highly
discerning. Far from throwing the book at Renfroe, it found him not guilty on
the more serious charges involving sexual crimes against a minor under 14
5
years old. This suggests the jury was not inflamed by emotion, but instead
closely parsed the evidence and the requirements of each charge and held the
prosecution to its burden of proof. Accordingly, the court’s error in failing to
perform a section 352 analysis was harmless.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
SANCHEZ, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DELANEY, J.
GOODING, J.
5
The middle term sentence for a violation of section 288,
subdivision (a), is six years, which is double the primary term he actually
received.
16
Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude
Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.