projetos

Repeat interim order on paternity test participation

BVerfG 1 BvR 2250/11Bverfg / 1. Senat 1. Kammer6 de fev. de 2013Granted

Abrir fonte

Extraído pela Omnilex

Resumo Omnilex

The Federal Constitutional Court again repeated an interim order in a family-law constitutional complaint concerning participation in a paternity test by buccal swab. It held that the disadvantages of immediate examination, especially the risk of disturbing or destroying the social-family relationship, outweighed the disadvantages that would arise if the constitutional complaint later succeeded. The prior interim order was therefore renewed for six months, but no longer than until the main constitutional complaint is decided.

Sumário Omnilex

Art. 32 Abs. 1, Abs. 6 S. 2 BVerfGG; Art. 6 Abs. 2 S. 1 GG; interim relief in constitutional complaint proceedings concerning a paternity test by buccal swab may be repeated if, upon weighing the consequences, the disadvantages of performing the examination immediately and thereby potentially impairing or destroying the social-family relationship outweigh the disadvantages that would arise if constitutional relief were later granted. The decisive criterion is a forward-looking balancing of consequences; where the status quo would be irreversibly altered, heightened weight attaches to the protection of family relations (consid. not stated).

Texto completo

BVerfG — 1 BvR 2250/11, Einstweilige Anordnung

Entscheidungsdatum: 2013-02-06

Aktenzeichen: 1 BvR 2250/11

ECLI: ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2013:rk20130206.1bvr225011

Dokumenttyp: Einstweilige Anordnung

Normen: Art 6 Abs 2 S 1 GG, § 32 Abs 1 BVerfGG, § 32 Abs 6 S 2 BVerfGG, §§ 1600ff BGB, § 1592 Nr 2 BGB, § 1600 Abs 1 Nr 5 BGB, § 1600 Abs 3 BGB, § 178 Abs 1 FamFG

Vorinstanz: vorgehend OLG Stuttgart, 25. Juli 2011, Az: 16 UF 284/10, Beschlussvorgehend BVerfG, 20. September 2011, Az: 1 BvR 2250/11, Einstweilige Anordnungvorgehend BVerfG, 8. März 2012, Az: 1 BvR 2250/11, Einstweilige Anordnungvorgehend BVerfG, 20. August 2012, Az: 1 BvR 2250/11, Einstweilige Anordnung

Spruchkörper: 1. Senat 1. Kammer

Titelzeile

Abermalige Wiederholung einer einstweiligen Anordnung: Teilnahme an einem Vaterschaftstest mittels Mundschleimhautabstrich - Überwiegen der Nachteile (Störung bzw Zerstörung der sozial-familiären Beziehung) bei Durchführung dieser Untersuchungen und späterem Erfolg der Verfassungsbeschwerde in der Hauptsache

Tenor

Die einstweilige Anordnung vom 20. September 2011, wiederholt mit Beschluss vom 20. August 2012, wird erneut für die Dauer von weiteren sechs Monaten, längstens bis zur Entscheidung über die Verfassungsbeschwerde, wiederholt.

Palavras-chave

interim reliefpaternitybuccal swabfamily relationshipbalancing of consequencesconstitutional complaint

Extraído pela Omnilex

Questões jurídicas principais extraídas pela Omnilex

Questão jurídica principal

Whether the interim order allowing suspension of a paternity test must be renewed pending the constitutional complaint.

Decisão extraída

The interim order was renewed for another six months, but no longer than until the constitutional complaint is decided.

Fundamentação extraída

The disadvantages of carrying out the examination now, including possible disturbance or destruction of the social-family relationship, outweighed the disadvantages if the constitutional complaint later succeeded on the merits.

Continue sua pesquisa no ChatGPT ou Claude

Conecte o Omnilex para pesquisar o corpus jurídico pelo seu assistente de IA.