Questão jurídica principal
Whether the federal complaint met the minimum reasoning requirements for a constitutional complaint
Decisão extraída
It did not; the filing failed to identify and substantiate any infringement of rights and therefore could not be examined on the merits.
Fundamentação extraída
A complaint must, with reference to the challenged decision, explain which rights were violated; constitutional rights are reviewed only if expressly invoked and reasoned. The submission of 28 April 2012 clearly did not meet these requirements.