Questão jurídica principal
Admissibility of the constitutional complaint against denial of residence-permit renewal
Decisão extraída
The complaint was inadmissible because the appellant had no enforceable right to renewal and lacked standing to challenge the permit decision on the merits.
Fundamentação extraída
Without a legal entitlement, ordinary public-law appeal was unavailable; subsidiarity constitutional complaint was limited to constitutional rights, and the appellant could only raise procedural rights. His submissions targeted the merits of the permit refusal rather than a cognizable procedural violation.