Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-125

1989-125Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL October 6, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 125
The Honorable B. D. Kanan
State Senator, Fifth District
5111 Garfield
Kansas City, Kansas 66102
Re: Constitution of the State of Kansas--Corporations--
Cities' Powers of Home Rule
Synopsis: Kansas City, Kansas' Charter Ordinance No. 104
provides for an election prior to the sale of the
municipal waterworks or electric-light system owned
and operated by the Kansas City Board of Public
Utilities (BPU) and the City of Kansas City. The
ordinance further provides that the City, upon
recommendation from the BPU, may sell portions of
the waterworks or electric-light system without an
election if the portions recommended for sale are
deemed obsolete and the BPU continues to provide
water and electric services to the citizens of
Kansas City, Kansas. We believe the City has the
authority to adopt this ordinance pursuant to its
home rule powers. Cited herein: K.S.A. 12-101;
13-1223; 15-809; Kan. Const., Art. 12, §5.
* *
Dear Senator Kanan:
You request our opinion regarding Kansas City, Kansas' Charter
Ordinance No. 104 which amends Charter Ordinance No. 88 by
adding a new section relevant to the sale of the City's
municipal waterworks or municipal electric-light system. You
question the validity and effectiveness of Charter Ordinance
No. 104 on three separate grounds.
First, you question whether any guarantee of an election
actually exists under the terms of the ordinance. The section
in question states in pertinent part:
"Prior to the sale of the municipal
waterworks, the municipal electric-light
system of plants or combination thereof,
owned and operated by the Board of Public
Utilities of Kansas City, Kansas, and the
City of Kansas City, Kansas, the governing
body of the City shall by Resolution call
for an election to be held on said
proposed sale. Neither the waterworks
plant, electric light system, nor
combination thereof, may be sold unless
the proposed sale and the bid therefor are
submitted to and approved by a majority of
the qualified electors of the City voting
in an election called and held thereon.
• • •
"If a majority of the voters approve the
sale of the waterworks plant, the
electric-light system, or a combination
thereof, the governing body may proceed to
sell such system.
"Nothing in this section shall be
construed as requiring an election for the
governing body of the City upon
recommendation from the Board of Public
Utilities to approve the sale of a
municipal waterworks plant or any portion
of the electric-light system when the
Board of Public Utilities determines said
facility is no longer necessary for the
provision of water or electricity to the
citizens of Kansas City, Kansas, and when
the Board of Public Utilities shall
thereafter continue to provide the water
and electric service to said citizens."
You are concerned that the provision authorizing a sale
without an election allows the governing body of the City to
bypass the election requirement any time the Board of Public
Utilities (BPU) recommends the sale. However, we read the
ordinance to provide that the City may act without an election
only when the BPU recommends sale of a portion of the
waterworks or the electric-light system, and then only if the
BPU determines that portion of the facility is obsolete and
that the BPU can and will continue to provide water and
electric service to the citizens of Kansas City, Kansas. In
other words, the election requirement applies to a proposed
sale of the entire waterworks or electric-light system.
Thus, I do not agree that the provision authorizing a sale
without election renders the earlier election requirement
meaningless. The provisions speak to two separate sets of
circumstances.
Secondly, you question whether article 12, section 5 of the
Kansas Constitution (the city home rule amendment) "would
allow for a more direct ordinance addressing the sale of
municipally owned waterworks or electric plants without an
election." There is currently no state statute which requires
an election prior to the sale of a municipal waterworks or
electric-light system owned and operated by a city of the
first class and a BPU. (Compare K.S.A. 15-809 dealing with
cities of the third class). K.S.A. 13-1223 merely provides
that a BPU may not sell real property or improvements
thereon without approval of the governing body of the city.
(In any event, it is our understanding that Kansas City
chartered out of K.S.A. 13-1223 pursuant to Charter Ordinance
No. 88.) Further, K.S.A. 12-101 grants to cities the general
power to "[s]ell and convey any real or personal estate
owned by the city." [But see Attorney General Opinion No.
80-19, "Although it is clear that municipality may dispose of
its property, and that there is considerable discretion vested
in the governing body in determining the terms of such
disposal, it is our opinion that such power does not include
the authority to make an outright gift of such property."] A
city's home rule power, which is to be construed liberally
[Kan. Const., art. 12, §5(d)], enables that city to
determine its local affairs and to enact ordinances even when
not specifically empowered to do so by state statute.
Claflin v. Walsh, 212 Kan. 1, 6-7 (1973); Anderson
Construction Co. v. City of Topeka, 228 Kan. 73, 79
(1980). This power is restricted only in certain prescribed
cases, i.e. when the legislature has enacted a law uniformly
applicable to all cities which regulates the subject area
[City of Junction City v. Griffin, 227 Kan. 332 (1980)]
or which expressly preempts the field [Uhl v. City of
Ness City, 590 F.2d 839 (10th Cir. 1979)]. See
Attorney General Opinion No. 81-100. In that the legislature
has not spoken to the issue in question, Kansas City is free
to provide for the sale of the waterworks or electric-light
system without an election if it is in the public interest.
Finally, you inquire whether the synopsis, or title, of the
ordinance should include a complete listing of the ordinance's
objectives. We have previously opined that "the title of an
ordinance is sufficient if it is broad enough to indicate in
general terms the provisions of the ordinance, and it need not
include all the details of the ordinance." Attorney General
Opinion No. 88-58. See also Garten Enterprises Inc. v.
The City of Kansas City, 219 Kan. 620, 622 (1976). Based
on these authorities, the title to Charter Ordinance No. 104
appears sufficient even though the exception to the general
election requirement is not mentioned therein.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.