Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1989-106

1989-106Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL
August 21, 1989
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 89- 106
John C. Vratil
Attorney, U.S.D. No. 229
1050/40 Corporate Woods
9401 Indian Creek Parkway
Overland Park, Kansas 66210
Re: Laws, Journals and Public Information -- Records '
Open to Public -- Disclosure of Names and Addresses
of School District Employees
Synopsis: A school district is required to disclose the names
and mailing or residence addresses of teachers upon
request for such records by any individual. K.S.A.
1988 Supp. 45-221(4), (30), as amended, do not give
the district discretion to refuse to disclose this
information. Computerized public information must
be provided in the form requested if the public
agency has the capability of producing that form.
The agency is not required to acquire or design a
special program to produce information in a desired
form, but has discretion to. allow an individual who
requests information to design or provide a
computer program to obtain the information in the
desired form. Cited herein: K.S.A. 21-3914;
45-215; 45-216; 45-217; 45-220; K.S.A. 1988 Supp.
45-221, as amended by L. 1989, ch. 154, § 1.
*
N.
•-•" 1...1%;
Dear Mr. Vratil:
As attorney for Blue Valley Unified School District No. 229,
you request our opinion regarding the Kansas open records act
(KORA), K.S.A. 45-215 et seq. Specifically, you ask
whether the school district is required to disclose records
maintained by the school district which contain the names and
mailing addresses of school district employees. Such records
include personnel records, a directory of teachers, and
information stored in a computer. You also ask whether the
school district is required to generate records, such as
mailing labels, from information stored in its computer. You
state that the district has the ability to generate mailing
labels from information stored in the computer, but that the
district only generates the labels when a need exists.
Under the KORA, a public record is open for inspection by
any person unless otherwise provided for by law. K.S.A.
45-216. A public record is defined in K.S.A. 45-217(f)(1) as
follows:
"'Public record' means any recorded
information, regardless of form or
characteristics, which is made, maintained
or kept by or is in the possession of any
public agency."
Thus, personnel records and a teacher directory are public
records. In addition, records stored on computer tapes are
public records. State ex rel. Stephan v. Harder, 230 Kan.
573, 583 (1982).
A public record must be disclosed upon request by any person
unless it falls within one of the thirty-five categories of
records which are not required to be disclosed, or disclosure
of which is specifically prohibited by statute. Records which
fall into any of the categories enumerated in K.S.A. 1988
Supp. 45-221(a), as amended by L. 1989, ch. 154, § 1, are not
prohibited from disclosure. Rather, the agency has discretion
whether to make the record available to the public. Two
exemptions under the KORA which provide for the
discretionary disclosure of public records and to which you
have referred are:
"(4) Personnel records, performance
ratings or individually identifiable
records pertaining to employees or
applicants for employment, except that
this exemption shall not apply to the
names, positions, salaries and lengths of
service of officers and employees of
public agencies once they are employed as
such.
• • •
"(30) Public records containing
information of a personal nature where the
public disclosure thereof would constitute
a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal
privacy." K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(a), as
amended.
The names of persons employed by public agencies, such as
school districts, are an "exception to the exception," and
thus must be provided to any person upon request. The next
question is whether the KORA requires mailing or residence
addresses of school district employees to be disclosed upon
request, or whether such information is a personnel record
containing individually identifiable information not required
to be disclosed, or the disclosure of the employee's address
would constitute an invasion of privacy.
This question has not been addressed by the Kansas courts.
Therefore, an examination of cases in other jurisdictions
provides instruction. In Warden v. Bennett, 340 So.2d 977
(1976), the Florida. District Court of Appeals held that, while
personnel files were not subject to the public records act,
the president of a junior college was obligated by the state's
open records law to furnish a labor organizer with records
containing the names and addresses of college employees. The
court ruled as follows:
"While an employee m ay '4occasionally want
his address kept confidential, it is
seldom that the address of a governmental
employee would not be ascertainable from
other sources. Therefore, an employee's
expectation that his address cannot be
ascertained is minimal. Moreover, there
are legitimate reasons why the public
might wish to known the address of a
public employee. On balance, we believe
that the addresses of public employees do
not fall within the confidentiality of
L
personnel files. . . " Warden v.
Bennett, 340 So.2d at 979.
See State ex rel. Public Employees Retirees, Inc., 397
N.E.2d 1191, 1192, 1193 (Ohio 1979) (Court held that a state
agency was required by the state's records law to disclose its
list of names and addresses of public employee retirees.).
The issue whether disclosure of public employees' names and
addresses is an invasion of privacy was discussed in Webb
v. City of Shreveport, 371 So.2d 316 (La.Ct.App. 1979). In
that case the court stated that the city could be compelled to
reveal the names and addresses of city employees as requested
since neither the city nor its employees had a reasonable
expectation of privacy against disclosure of the names and
addresses contained on a computer tape. The court stated:
"There is a vast difference, however, in
personnel evaluation reports and a listing
-(or computer printout) of names and
addresses of employees of a municipality.
The fact that a municipality or its
employee labels the name or address of an
employee as having been furnished to
become a part of a confidential personnel
record, does not elevate the name or
address to the status of being a
constitutionally protected private
thing. . . . To paraphrase Prosser,
complete privacy does not exist except for
the eremite in the desert. A person's
employment, where he lives, and where he
works are exposures which we all must
suffer. We have no reasonable expectation
of privacy as to our identity or as to
where we live or work. . . ." Webb v.
City of Shreveport, 371 So.2d at 318, 319.
The Supreme Court of Michigan has also held that disclosure of
home addresses of certain governmental employees does not
constitute a "clearly unwarranted invasion of privacy" under
its state open records law. State Employees Ass'n v.
Dep't. of Mgt. & Budget, 404 N.W.2d 606, 616 (Mich.
1987). In ruling that there is no privacy invasion in the
release of that information, the court stated:
"'Names and addresses are not ordinarily
personal, intimate or embarrassing pieces
of information. The supposed right to
keep such information secret is at best
riddled with exceptions.'" 404 N.W.2d at
615, quoting Tobin v. Civil Service
Comm'n, 416 Mich. 661, 672-673, 331
N.W. 2d 184 (1982).
The federal freedom of information act (FOIA) provides that
"personnel . . . files the disclosure of which would
constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of personal privacy"
are not required to be disclosed. 5 U.S.C. § 552(b)(6).
In Getman v. N.L.R.B., 450 F.2d 670 (D.C. Cir. 1971),
the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals stated that
disclosing the names and addresses of government employees
obtained from personnel files does not violate exception six of
the FOIA. The court stated:
"[T]he loss of privacy resulting from this
particular disclosure should be
characterized as relatively minor. . . .
The giving of names and addresses is a
very much lower degree of disclosure [than
files containing intimate details of a
highly personal nature]; in themselves a
bare name and address give no information
about an individual which is
embarrassing." Getman v. N.L.R.B., 45
F.2d at 675.
In other cases construing the personal privacy exemption of
the FOIA, the First Circuit Court of Appeals stated that
disclosure of the names and addresses of unsuccessful
applicants for research grants could not be withheld because
the information sought was not sufficiently personal or
private. Kurzon v. Department of Health & Human Services,
649 F.2d 65, 68, 69 (1st Cir. 1981). The Fourth Circuit
Court of Appeals stated that exemption six pertaining to
personnel records (5 U.S.C. S 552(b)(6)) "applies only to
information which relates to a specific person or individual,
to 'intimate details' of a 'highly personal nature'" in the
individual's employment record or health history. Robles
v. Environmental Protection Agency, 484 F.2d 843, 845 (4th
Cir. 1973).
For the reasons stated in the cases cited above, it is our
opinion that the names and mailing or residence addresses of
school district employees are subject to disclosure under the
KORA. Exceptions to disclosure, K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(4)
and (30), as amended, do not give a school district discretion
to keep such information confidential. If the names and
addresses are contained in a document which also contains
confidential information, the district "shall separate or
delete such material and make available to the requestor that
material in the public record which is subject to disclosure.
•" K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(d), as amended. We also note	• •
that, before releasing the names and addresses, the records
custodian should determine that the requestor will not use the
information for prohibited purposes. See K.S.A. 21-3914,
K.S.A. 45-220(c).
You also ask whether the school district is required to
generate public records, such as mailing labels, from
information stored in its computer. You state that the
district has the ability to generate mailing labels for
teachers from information stored in the computer, but that the
district only generates labels when a need exist. In Attorney
General Opinion No. 87-137, we stated that a public agency is
only required to make available to the public those records
which it makes, maintains, keeps, or possesses. The KORA
imposes no duty on a public agency to create a record to
compile specific information requested by an individual.
See Long v. U.S. Internal Revenue Service, 596 F.2d 362,
Sy. 12 (9th Cir. 1979); State ex rel. Stephan v.
Harder, 230 Kan. 573, 582 (1982).
Teachers' names and addresses are public record. This
information is stored in the computer, and remains public just
as if it were contained in a file cabinet. If the names and
addresses were not on computer, but contained on documents in
a file cabinet, the district would not be required to provide
the information in mailing label format, if such a record did
not already exist. However, in this instance the information
is stored on computer and the district apparently has the
capability of producing the requested mailing label format.
Thus, the question is whether the public may require
information in computerized public records to be made
available in a particular format.
K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(a)(16) provides that public agencies
must maintain a register, open to the public, that describes
"[t]he information which the agency maintains on computer
facilities, and the form in which the information can be made
available using existing computer programs." By implication
the KORA requires a public agency to produce public
information in the format requested, if the agency is
presently capable of producing that format.
This question and similar questions were before the court in
Seigel v. Barry, 422 So.2d 63 (Fla. App. 1982), pet.
for rev. denied 431 So.2d 988 (Fla. S.Ct. 1983). In that
case the appellees, who requested information from a school
district, argued they had a right to access the school
district's computer with their specially designed program.
The court ruled as follows:
"We, therefore, adopt the rule that access
to computerized records shall be given
through the use of programs currently in
use by the public official responsible for
maintaining the public records. Access by
the use of a specially designed program
prepared by or at the expense of the
applicant may obviously be permitted in
the discretion of the public
official. . . ."
We agree with and adopt the above rule. Computerized public
information must be provided in the form requested if the
public agency has the capability of producing that form. A
public agency is not required to acquire or design a special
program to produce information in a desired form. A public
agency has discretion to allow a person who requests
information to design or provide a computer program to obtain
the information in the desired form.
In summary, it is our opinion that the school district is
required to disclose the names and mailing or residence
addresses of teachers upon request for such records by any
individual. K.S.A. 1988 Supp. 45-221(4), (30), as amended, do
not give the district discretion to refuse to disclose this
information. Computerized'public information must be provided
in the form requested if the district has the capability of
producing that form. The district is not required to acquire
or design a special program to Produce information in a
desired form, but has discretion to allow the person who
requests information to design or provide a computer program
to obtain the information in the desired form.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL¬ November 21, 1989
John L. Vratil
Attorney at Law
1050/40 Corporate Woods
9401 Indian Creek Parkway
Overland Park, Kansas 66210
Dear John:
I received your letter of October 26, 1989, in regard to
Attorney General Opinion No. 80-106. You express concern
about the opinion in regard to the duty of a school district
being required to disclose the names and mailing or residence
address of school district employees upon request for such
records by an individual. The opinion has been misunderstood
and that may have resulted by not adequately focusing on the
primary issue which we addressed.
The factual question presented was whether or not a
directory, which was published for general dissemination, made
the names and mailing or residence addresses of school
district employees available to individuals on request. We
concluded that the directory is a public record subject to
disclosure. The mere fact that information contained in the
directory was obtained from personal mail records does not
exempt the directory for disclosure. If the directory did not
exist, and the addresses were only located in the personnel,
file, a request for the addresses of teachers could be
denied. The bottom line is that in the case presented to us,
a record was created and a record for the directory was made.
You may be interested to know that Senator Wint Winter,
Jr. has requested an opinion along these same lines. A COPY
of his request is enclosed. The materials you sent will be
considered in preparing that opinion. I will advise you when
the opinion requested by Senator Winter has been completed.
Thank you for contacting me and for sharing your concern.
Sincerely,
Robert T. Stephan
Attorney General
RTS:bls
Enclosure
cc: Rita L. Noll, Assistant Attorney General

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.