Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-175

1988-175Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. December 28, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-175
Ms. Constance M. Achterberg
Saline County Counselor
118'S. 7th Street
P.O. Box 1697
Salina, Kansas 67402
Mr. Joseph O'Sullivan
Reno County Counselor
315 W. 1st St.
P.0.Box 2066
Hutchinson,Kansas 67504
Re: Taxation -- Judicial Foreclosure and Sale of Real
Estate by CountyforeclosureSa Deed, Execution
and Recordation; Tax Liens
Synopsis: . K.S.A. 79-2804 gives fee simple title to purchasers
at tax foreclosurlie sales subject only to valid
covenants running with the land, valid easements of
record, and taxes and interest that have become a
lienof the property subsequent to the date upon
which the judgement was rendered. Taxes do not
become due and current until November 1 o,f the
year. At that time those taxes become a lien upon
the property. If the tax foreclosure judgment is
rendered before the attachment of a tax lien, a
purchaser takes subject to that lien. To the
extent that Attorney General Opinion No. 77-167
conflicts with conclusions contained herein, it is
hereby withdrawn. Cited herein: K.S.A. 79-1804;
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 79-2a04; K.S.A. 79-2804; L. 1945,
ch. 362, § 4.
Dear Ms. Achterberg and Mr. O'Sullivan:
As county counselors for the counties of Saline and Reno,
you request our opinion concerning K.S.A. 79-2804. You
specifically inquire whether it is proper to charge the
purchasers of real property at a tax foreclosure sale the
taxes that have become a lien upon the real property during
the year of the sale, but subsequent to the time judgment was
rendered. You believe this may occur if the foreclosure
judgment is entered before November 1 of the year. You both
disagree with certain conclusions contained in Attorney
General Opinion No. 77-167 and ask that we review and reassess
that opinion.
K.S.A. 79-2804 states in pertinent part:
"[W]hen said deed is filed for record in
the office of the register of deeds of the
county where such real estate is situated
it shall vest in the purchaser or grantee
therein named, as against all persons,
including, but not limited to,
corporations and municipal corporations,
parties to such proceedings, a fee simple
-title thereto, subject only to valid
covenants running with the land and valid
easement of record in use and subject to
taxes and interest which have become .a
lien thereon, subsequent to the date upon
which such judgment was rendered, and
said deed shall be prima facie evidence of
the regularity of all proceedings prior to
the date of filing the same for record as
aforesaid. . . ." (Emphasis added).
Thus, the statute clearly contemplates that the fee simple
title vested in the purchaser may be subject to taxes and
interest which have become a lien thereon subsequent to the
time judgment is rendered in the tax foreclosure proceeding.
Attorney General Opinion No. 77-167 states:
"The purchaser at a tax sale is entitled
to a deed conveying a clear title good
against the world. Any unpaid current
taxes and interest thereon, which have
accrued between the time the action in
foreclosure was begun and the time the
cause was ripe for judgment, should be
computed and included in the amount of
judgment in rem." (Emphasis added).
The opinion goes on to state that because the lien relates
back to and is on property owned as of January 1st of the
year, these taxes are currently owed before November 1st.
The opinion therefore approved a procedure whereby the
district court includes in the tax foreclosure judgment the
amount of taxes owed for the entire year, even if the judgment
is rendered before November 1. We do not believe that K.S.A.
79-2804 dictates such a procedure.
Opinion No. 77-167 relied upon Shawnee County Commissioners
v. Abbott, 155 Kan. 154 (1942), which stated:
"This court holds that the unpaid current
taxes and interest thereon which accrued
between the time the action- in foreclosure
was begun and the time the cause was ripe
for judgment should be included in the
amount of judgment in rem rendered in
favor of plaintiff. So that this may be
done this cause is remanded to the
district court with instructions to modify
its judgment in accordance with the views
herein expressed." Id. at 158, 159.
(Emphasis added). --
The facts in Abbott concerned a judicial foreclosure sale
commenced after the 1941 taxes became due and payable
(November 10, 1941). The county contended that all of the
current taxes for 1941 had accrued and were therefore in
default, while the taxpayer claimed a right to pay the 1941
current tax in December of 1941 and the second half in June of
1942. The court stated that from the first day of November
the current taxes assessed became a lien on real property, and
that taxes currently due and owing at the time of the judgment
should therefore be included in the judgment. Id. at 159.
We concur with this conclusion. We do not agree with the
language in Attorney General Opinion No. 77-167 stating that,
for tax foreclosure purposes, taxes owed for the year are
"currently owed" before November 1, nor does a close reading
of Abbott support such a conclusion.
A companion case to Abbott reiterated that K.S.A. 79-2804
judgments should include all current taxes owed on the
property. See Wyandotte County Commissioners v. Adams,
155 Kan. 160 (1942). Relying upon the intent of K.S.A.
79-2801 and K.S.A. 79-2804 to convey fee simple, the Adams
court stated that there was a "legislative purpose to
extinguish all liens and pass a clear and unencumbered title
to the purchaser." Id. at 164. Both 1942 cases clearly
require the foreclosure judgment to include current taxes.
However, neither case mandates the inclusion of taxes that
become due and owing subsequent to the rendering of the
judgment.
After these 1942 cases, legislative purpose was clarified by
amendment to K.S.A. 79-2804 which now clearly states that the
purchaser takes subject to "taxes and interest which have
become a lien thereon, subsequent to the date upon which such
judgement was rendered." See L. 1945, ch. 362, sec. 4.
Thus, K.S.A. 79-2804 clearly allows the fee title transferred
to a purchaser to be subject to tax liens that attach
subsequent to the date of the judgment.
K.S.A. 79-1804 provides that a tax does not become due and
owing until November 1 of the year and, therefore, it is not a
lien upon the property until that November 1st date. It is
therefore our opinion that K.S.A. 79-2804 does not mandate the
inclusion in the judgment of taxes which have not as vet
become current. If a tax lien attaches subsequent to the tax
foreclosure judgment, K.S.A. 79-2804 clearly contemplates the
purchaser -,:aking title subject to such subsequent tax liens.
To the extent that Attorney General Opinion No. 77-167
conflicts, it is hereby withdrawn.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.