Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-156

1988-156Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL November 7, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88-156
John A. Potucek, II
Sumner County Counselor
Courthouse
Wellington, Kansas 67152
Re: Counties and County Officers -- Planning and Zoning
-- Regulations Inapplicable to Existing Uses;
Agricultural Purposes; Mobile Homes; Conditional
Use Permits
Synopsis: K.S.A. 19-2921 prohibits the exercise of county
zoning authority affecting property being used for
an agricultural purpose. Whether or not a
particular mobile home is being used for an
agricultural purpose depends upon the relevant
facts; placing a mobile home in an area zoned
agricultural does not automatically dictate that
the mobile home is being used for an agricultural
purpose. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 19-101a;
K.S.A. 19-2901; 19-2908; 19-2921; K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
19-2960; K.S.A. 75-1211.
*
Dear Mr. Potucek:
As Sumner County Counselor you request our opinion
concerning county zoning authority. You state that Sumner
county has attempted to require conditional use permits in
order to regulate the placement of mobile homes in areas zoned
agricultural and ask our opinion as to this regulation.
(Please note that K.S.A. 75-1211 et sect . contains the
state's standard code for mobile homes and recreational
vehicles.)
Generally, reasonable zoning, especially where it is
comprehensive, is constitutional and valid as a proper
exercise of police power. McQuillin, Municipal
Corporations, § 25.05 (1983). While the zoning power
constitutes a type of state police power, it is usually
exercised by municipal corporations pursuant to specific
delegation. Id. at § 25.35.
A delegation of zoning authority has been made pursuant to
K.S.A. 19-2901 et seq. which discusses general county
authority to zone and regulate land use. "The grant of a
conditional or special use permit does not create a new zone,
or constitute an alteration or an amendment of the zoning
regulations; it merely affirms the existence of the
circumstances under which the ordinance, by its terms,
prescribes that such a permit shall issue." 101A C.J.S.,
Zoning and Land Planning, § 191 (1979). K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
19-2960 specifically allows certain urban counties to issue
special or conditional use permits and sets forth an
agricultural exemption. Sumner county does not come within
the purview of K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 19-2960, and therefore
authority to issue conditional or special use permits must be
otherwise established.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 19-101a allows the exercise of county home
rule authority if the measure does not conflict with uniformly
applicable statutes. We find no uniformly applicable
statutes that prohibit the issuance of county conditional use
permits. Kansas case law discussing conditional or special
use permits for mobile homes or recreational vehicles
includes: International Villages, Inc. of America v. Board
of Commissioners of Jefferson County, 224 Kan. 654 (1978);
Gaslight Villa, Inc. v. City of Lansing, 213 Kan. 862
(1974); City of Colby v. Hurtt, 212 Kan. 113 (1973); Creten
v. Board of County Commissioners, 204 Kan. 782 (1970); and
Scherer v. Board of County Commissioners, 201 Kan. 424
(1968). Although these cases do not specifically discuss
statutory authority concerning special or conditional use
permits, the courts did not rule such permits impermissible.
It is our opinion that, pursuant to county home rule authority
and K.S.A. 19-2901 et sea., a county may provide for
conditional use permits where not otherwise limited or
precluded by uniformly applicable statutes or the
constitution.
While a municipality may restrict the use of property for the
common good, restrictions that are unnecessary or unreasonable
may not be imposed. McQuillin, Municipal Corporations, §
25.42 (1983). Moreover, specific statutory limitations may
restrict the exercise of zoning authority. K.S.A. 19-2921
protects property used for agricultural purposes from county
zoning regulations or restrictions and provides in pertinent
part:
"[N]o determination nor rule nor
regulation shall be held to apply to the
use of land for agricultural purposes, nor
for the erection or maintenance of
buildings thereon for such purposes so
long as such land and buildings erected
thereon are used for agricultural
purposes and not otherwise." (Emphasis
added).
As stated in Attorney General Opinions No. 82-200 and 85-39,
K.S.A. 19-2921 is uniformly applicable to all counties and
therefore not subject to county home rule authority. The
issue thus becomes whether the proposed Sumner county
conditional use permits for mobile homes in areas zoned
agricultural improperly regulates property used for
agricultural purposes.
In State v. Scherer, 11 Kan. App. 2d 362 (1986), the
appellate court addressed the agricultural exemption found in
K.S.A. 19-2908 which places limitations upon township zoning
authority. The language in K.S.A. 19-2908 and 19-2921
contains identical language excepting property used for
agricultural purposes. Id. at 366. In Scherer the
defendant was charged with operating a salvage yard in
violation of township zoning regulations. The defendant
claimed he farmed 10 acres in the township and used his 800 to
1,000 pieces of antique farm equipment to raise livestock and
cut hay. The appellate court recognized that it was not
absolutely clear that the defendant was using the land for
agricultural purposes, but disagreed with the trial court's
belief that agricultural uses and all other uses are mutually
exclusive. Id. at 367. Thus, the trial court was directed
to consider what use was being made of the property.
In VanGundy v. Lyon County Zoning Board, 237 Kan. 177
(1985), the landowner argued that a special permit to quarry
rock was unnecessary because his land was being used for
agricultural purposes. The court agreed and noted that the
owner was blasting rock in order to excavate a pond that was
to be used for agricultural purposes and thus it stated, "[W}e
cannot say that the quarrying of the rock is not within the
legislature's concept of agricultural purposes as set forth in
K.S.A. 19-2921." Id. at 182, 183.
Blauvelt v. Board of Leavenworth County Commissioners, 227
Kan. 110 (1980), contains perhaps the most helpful
discussion of the agricultural purpose exception. In that
case, the plaintiffs were denied a permit to build a septic
system that connected with the dwelling house. The landowner-
plaintiffs intended to construct a farmhouse in which to live
while they conducted farming operations on the property. The
court held that under the facts K.S.A. 19-2921 excluded a
farmer's dwelling house from county zoning regulations.
When considered together, these cases evidence the variety of
uses and types of buildings that may individually represent an
agricultural use. Thus, a decision as to whether a mobile
home is being used for an agricultural purpose depends upon
the specific facts in each situation.
The issue raised by Sumner county concerns conditional use
permits affecting mobile homes located in areas zoned
agricultural. The exception in K.S.A. 19-2921 does not
prohibit zoning in all areas zoned agricultural, it merely
places restrictions upon authority to regulate property that
is in fact being used for agricultural purposes. The zoning
authority must therefore make a case by case factual
determination as to whether a particular use is agricultural.
Absent such an agricultural use, K.S.A. 19-2921 does not
preclude the exercise of zoning authority in areas within the
jurisdiction of the board of county commissioners.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckoll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.