Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-138

1988-138Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL September 16, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 138
Mr. Donald Wayne Estes
Shawnee Township Trustee
4804 Quivira Drive
Shawnee Mission, Kansas 66216
Re: Cities and Municipalities -- Additions, Vacation,
and Lot Frontage; Annexation by Cities --
Conditions Which Permit Annexation; Ordinances;
Actions Challenging Validity
Townships and Township Officers -- General
Provisions -- Corporate Status; Powers
Synopsis: It is our opinion that a township may expend moneys
from the proper township fund in order to hire an
attorney for township purposes. Such purposes may
include appearing on behalf of the township at a
public hearing concerning proposed annexation
pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520. However, a
township may not expend public moneys to hire an
attorney merely for lobbying against an annexation
on behalf of the township or representing the legal
interests of private landowners. Cited herein:
K.S.A. 10-1101; K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-519; 12-520;
12-520a; 12-520a(e); 12-521; 77-201 Thirteenth;
79-1962; K.S.A. 79-2934; 80-101.
Dear Mr. Estes:
As Shawnee Township Trustee you request our opinion on using
township funds to hire an attorney to represent the township
in proceedings connected with the proposed annexation of
township property by the city of Shawnee. You inform us that
the proposed annexation is proceeding pursuant to K.S.A.
12-520 et seq. and that if it is successful your township
will be left with very little unincorporated area and no
residents. You also inform us that the landowners of the
township oppose the annexation and prefer to remain part of
the township.
In general, a township is a territorial district, subordinate
to a county, the inhabitants of which are vested with
political and administrative powers for regulating their own
local affairs. 1 McQuillan, Municipal Corporation, § 1.30
(1987). K.S.A. 80-101 et seq. sets forth the basic powers
and duties of Kansas townships. The authority to appoint
attorneys and make necessary contracts is discussed in K.S.A.
80-101 which states:
"Each organized township in this state
shall be a body politic and corporate, and
in its proper name sue and be sued, and
may appoint all necessary agents and
attorneys in that behalf, and may make all
contracts that may be necessary and
convenient for the exercise of its
corporate powers."
Thus, a township has authority to hire an attorney in order to
bring or defend a suit or when "necessary and convenient for
the exercise of its corporate powers." The only restrictions
upon expenditures made to hire an attorney are (1) any
applicable budgetary laws and (2) whether it properly
exercises a corporate power of the township.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 79-1962 establishes limitations upon the
levy of taxes by a township. While this authority does not
establish a specific fund for attorneys fees, it does discuss
a tax levy for the township general fund. K.S.A. 80-1422,
which allows certain township officials to receive additional
compensation from the general fund, evidences the propriety of
paying employment compensation from the general fund.
Moreover, use of general funds to pay the costs of certain
township business appears to be a township corporate purpose.
K.S.A. 79-2934 limits expenditures from funds appropriated for
another fund or purpose and K.S.A. 10-1101 et seq. limits
the ability of municipalities to incur debt. The established
budget of Shawnee township will determine the availability of
funds for the proposed purpose of hiring an attorney.
Assuming that the proper funds are available, it is our
opinion that a township may hire an attorney in order to
represent the township in matters within the scope of township
purposes. See also 87 C.J.S., Towns, § 54 (1954), and
Emporia Township v. Williams, 149 Kan. 860, 865 (1939).
The second issue becomes to what degree and in what capacity a
township is authorized to protest a proposed annexation and if
that involvement by the township can be characterized as a
township corporate purpose sufficient to permit the employment
of an attorney.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-519 et seq. discusses annexation of
territory by cities. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520a(d)(2) requires
that a notice of the resolution considering annexation be sent
to the governing body of the township where the land to be
annexed is located. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520a(e) allows all
interested persons to be heard at the public hearing
concerning annexation. K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 77-201 Thirteenth
states that in construction of the statutes of this state,
"person" may be extended to mean bodies politic and
corporate. A township is such a body, pursuant to K.S.A.
80-101, and may therefore be considered a person. Therefore,
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520a(c) allows and authorizes a township
to speak at the public hearing. Thus, it is our opinion that
hiring an attorney to appear at such a public hearing on
behalf of the township is a permissible use of public moneys
for an authorized corporate purpose.
We have been informed that the city of Shawnee is proceeding
under K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520. Subsection (g) of that
provision allows a protesting landowner "to maintain an
action . . . challenging the authority of the city to annex
the land and the regularity of the proceedings. . . ."
Previous Kansas case law discussed standing to challenge
annexation. In Fairfax Drainage District v. City of Kansas
City, 190 Kan. 308 (1968), the court did not permit a
collateral challenge to the annexation proceedings to be
brought in the name of the drainage district. Enacted after
this case, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520, statutorily authorized
court challenges by any owner of land annexed by a city under
authority of that section. It did not, however, extend legal
standing to include other persons or entities.
After enactment of K.S.A. 12-520, the Kansas court again
discussed standing to challenge annexation proceedings in
City of Lenexa v. City of Olathe, 229 Kan. 391 (1981).
The court differentiated between annexations proceeding
pursuant to K.S.A. 12-520 and 12-521:
"Syl. 5 2: 'Under the statutes
pertaining to the annexation of land by
cities (K.S.A. 12-519 et seq.), where
a dispute arises as to the annexation of
land which adjoins a city the only
interested parties to the controversy are
the city and the owner of the land which
has been proposed for annexation. Other
incorporated cities in the county do not
have standing to challenge a proposed
annexation where the land adjoins the city
and the owner of the land consents to the
annexation.'
"Syl. 5 3: 'In cases of a proposed
annexation of land not adjoining the
city, the rights of another incorporated
city in the county must be considered and
it has an interest which entitled it to
challenge such an annexation in the
district court.'"
Subsequent amendments to K.S.A. 12-520(g) have not extended
legal standing to challenge annexation procedures to entities
other than the landowners. If the annexation in question is
proceeding pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520 and the land
adjoins the city, the only interested parties to the
controversy are the city of Shawnee and the individual
landowners in the affected area. Thus, these are the only
parties granted legal standing to challenge annexation
proceedings.
There is a trend towards permitting municipal or
quasi-municipal corporate parties to challenge governmental
actions rather than only permitting individuals to challenge
the validity of territorial annexation. McQuillin,
Municipal Corporations, § 7.43 (1988). K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
12-521 evidences such a trend in Kansas; where the proposed
annexation of land affects land not adjoining the city, other
cities may challenge the annexation. However, a township is
not a city. Moreover, the proposed annexation proportedly
affects land adjoining the city and the annexation is
therefore proceeding pursuant to K.S.A. 12-520 not 12-521.
Thus, Shawnee township apparently does not have standing to
bring an action challenging the annexation proceedings.
If the township does not have legal standing to challenge
annexation proceedings, the other purposes for hiring an
attorney include lobbying for a particular annexation decision
or representing the legal interests of the affected
landowners. As previously recognized, K.S.A. 80-101 allows
the township to exercise corporate powers. It therefore
becomes necessary to determine whether such corporate powers
include the power to lobby against annexation or to fund the
legal representation of private landowners who are protesting
annexation.
Previous Attorney General opinions discuss the authority to
approve expenditures of public funds for lobbying. As
discussed in Opinions No. 81-216 and 83-52, such authority
must exist either as expressly conferred or necessarily
implied powers. Pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520a(e) a
township is statutorily authorized to appear at the public
hearing held on annexation. Beyond that, we find no authority
allowing the township to lobby or intervene. It is therefore
our opinion that a township may not hire an attorney merely to
lobby against a proposed annexation.
Attorney General Opinion No. 86-177 discussed the authority of
a watershed district to retain counsel in order to assist a
private landowner with legal costs incurred as a result of
litigation that peripherally affected the district. While the
opinion noted that the district could possibly benefit from
the employment of such an attorney, we opined that such
employment was impermissible.
"It is a fundamental rule of law that a
lawyer cannot permit a person who pays him
to render legal services for another to
direct or regulate his professional
judgment in rendering such legal
services. K.S.A. 7-125, DR 5-107(B).
Thus, even if the district pays an
attorney to represent a landowner before
the IRS, that attorney owes no duty to
the district. Since the interests of the
individual landowner and those of the
district may not always be the same, and
since any appropriation of public money
must be for a public purpose, such an
expenditure would be impermissible. See
In re Page, 60 Kan. 842 (1899)."
(Emphasis added.)
It is our opinion that the legal principles enunciated in
Opinion No. 86-177 also prohibit the retainment of counsel
by a township in order to represent individual landowners who
are protesting annexation.
In summary, it is our opinion that a township may expend
moneys from the proper township fund in order to hire an
attorney for township purposes. Such purposes include costs
connected with appearing on behalf of the township at
proceedings where a township has legal authority or standing
such as a public hearing concerning proposed annexation
pursuant to K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 12-520. However, a township may
not expend public moneys to hire an attorney in order to lobby
against an annexation on behalf of the township or represent
the legal interests of private landowners.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.