Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-081

1988-081Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL	
June 9, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 81
The Honorable James L. Francisco
State Senator, Twenty-Sixth District
217 E. English
Mulvane, Kansas 67110-1462
Re: State Boards, Commissions and Authorities--
Parimutuel Racing; Kansas Parimutuel Racing
Act--Robotic Racing; Betting in Public Buildings
Synopsis Provisions of the Kansas parimutuel racing act
clearly contemplate governmentally owned racetrack
facilities. Thus, a county, if properly licensed
to do so, may permit parimutuel wagering conducted
by an organization licensee in a county-owned
racetrack facility. Though racing of hackney
ponies appears to be permissible under the act, use
of mechanical, remote-controlled jockeys to control
the movements of a horse and affect its speed other
than with an ordinary whip is precluded by K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 74-8810(h)(5). Cited herein: K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 74-8801; 74-8810; 74-8813; 74-8814;
74-8815; Kan. Const., Art. 15, §§3, 3b.
Dear Senator Francisco:
You request our opinion regarding the application of the
Kansas parimutuel racing act. Specifically, you question
whether, pursuant to the act, counties may allow parimutuel
wagering in public buildings and whether robotic racing is
allowable under the act.
Article 15, section 3 of the Kansas Constitution prohibits
lotteries and the sale of the lottery tickets. In 1955, the
Kansas Supreme Court determined that parimutuel betting is a
form of lottery prohibited by this constitutional provision.
State, ex rel., v. Bissing, 178 Kan. 111, 119 (1955).
However, in 1986 Kansas voters elected to adopt the following
constitutional provision:
"Notwithstanding the provisions of section
3 of article 15 of the constitution of the
state of Kansas, the legislature may
permit, regulate, license and tax, at a
rate not less than 3% nor more than 6% of
all money wagered, the operation or
conduct, by bona fide nonprofit
organizations, of horse and dog racing and
parimutuel wagering thereon in any
county in which: (a) A majority of the
qualified electors of the county voting
thereon approve this proposed amendment;
or (b) the qualified electors of the
county approve a proposition, by a
majority vote of those voting thereon at
an election held within the county, to
permit such racing and wagering within the
boundaries of the county. No off-track
betting shall be permitted in connection
with horse and dog racing permitted
pursuant to this section." Kan.
Const., Art. 15, §3b.
Pursuant to this provision, the legislature enacted in 1987
the Kansas parimutuel racing act, K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8801
et seq.
The act clearly contemplates governmental ownership of
racetrack facilities. See K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8802(g);
74-8815(a). Further, we find nothing in the act which would
prevent the conduct of parimutuel wagering in a government
owned facility providing all appropriate licenses have been
obtained and the races and wagering are conducted by an
organization licensee pursuant to the provisions of the act.
Thus, we believe that a county, if properly licensed to do so,
may permit parimutuel wagering conducted by an organization
licensee in a county owned racetrack facility.
With regard to your question concerning robotic racing, we
have been provided the following information:
"The horses are miniature horses, called
Hackney Ponies, which stand about four
feet high at the shoulder. These horses
are mounted by mechanical, remote-
controlled jockeys whose movements and
commands are directed by individual
jockeys physically located at the arena.
By electronic transmitter, each such
individual may control his or her horse by
giving voice commands and by actuating a
mechanical whip via the mechanical
jockey's receiver."
Article 15, section 3b of the Kansas Constitution authorizes
the legislature to permit, regulate, license and tax "horse
and dog racing and parimutuel wagering thereon. . . ." While
the parimutuel racing act restricts dog racing to the breed of
greyhounds, horse racing is not similarly limited. K.S.A.
1987 Supp. 74-8801 states that the act "shall apply to all
horse race meetings, whether or not parimutuel wagering is
used or intended to be used at such meetings. . . ."
(Emphasis added.) K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8814(b) speaks to
harness horse racing, thus evidencing that the act is not
intended to limit horse racing to the type where jockeys must
sit astride the horse. By definition, hackney ponies are a
breed of horse. See "pony," American Heritage Dictionary
1019 (New College Edition 1976); "hackney," id. at 591.
Pursuant to statutory construction rules, words in common
usage are to be given their ordinary meanings unless the
statute provides a substitute or more narrow definition.
J.C. Tobin Construction Co., Inc. v. Kemp, 239 Kan.
430 (1986). It is our opinion, based on the above, that the
racing of hackney ponies is a form of horse racing permissible
under the act if the racing commission, in its discretion,
chooses to license such racing. See K.S.A. 74-8813(e).
The use of mechanical, remote-controlled jockeys to control
the movements of a horse thereby affecting its speed however,
is not permissible under current provisions of the act.
K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 74-8810(h)(5) provides as follows:
"It is a class E felony for any person to:
• • •
"[U]se or conspire to use any device,
other than an ordinary whip for horses or
a mechanical hare for greyhounds, for the
purpose of affecting the speed of any
horse or greyhound at any time during a
race conducted by an organization
licensee. . . ." (Emphasis added.)
While it may be argued that the mechanical whip attached to a
robotic jockey is nothing more than an "ordinary whip," the
robot itself is clearly a "device" the purpose of which is to
affect the speed of the horse it rides. It is our
understanding that the arms of the robot move enabling the
individual controlling the electronic transmitter to guide as
well as slow and speed the horse. Also, a small loudspeaker
in the robot may be used to affect the horse's speed through
voice commands. In view of the statute's clear prohibition
against use of any device to affect the speed of a horse
(other than an ordinary whip), we must conclude that robotic
racing, as explained herein, would not be permissible under
current statutory restrictions.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
Julene L. Miller
Deputy Attorney General
RTS:JLM:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.