Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-038

1988-038Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL. March 17, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 38
The Honorable James B. O'Connor
District Magistrate Judge
22nd Judicial District
1006 Castle St.
Seneca, KS 66538
Re: Elections -- Nominations; Terms of Office;
Vacancies -- Vacancies in the Office of Judge of
the District Court
Synopsis: Persons elected to judge of the district court in
November 1986 due to a vacancy in office were
elected to a four year term to expire January
1991. Cited herein: K.S.A. 1987 Supp. 20-301a;
25-312a; K.S.A. 25-313; 25-314; 25-3904; 25-3906;
L. 1985, ch. 119, § 1; L. 1976, ch. 145, § 138;
Kan. Const., Art. 3, § 6.
Dear Judge O'Connor:
You have requested our opinion as to the length of the term to
which you were elected in 1986 as district magistrate judge.
We understand the facts of your situation to be as follows.
The former judge whose position you now hold was elected in
1984 and retired from office in April 1986. The governor made
an appointment on June 9, 1986 to fill the position until the
next general election. Five individuals, including the
appointed judge and yourself, filed for election and were
placed on the August 5, 1986 primary ballot. After winning
nomination as the Democratic party's candidate, you were
placed on the November 3, 1986 general election ballot and
were elected district magistrate judge. You inform us that
you received a certificate of election from the Office of the
Secretary of State to hold the position until January 1991.
The question has been raised whether you are to stand for
re-election this year. The answer to this question depends
upon whether your election in 1986 was to fill the remaining
two years of the unexpired term created by the vacancy, or
whether you were elected to a full, four-year term. We
understand that resolution of your inquiry will affect several
other judges in this state who were elected in 1986 following
a vacancy in office created by death or resignation.
Article 3, § 6 of the Kansas Constitution provides in
pertinent part:
"(a) The state shall be divided into
judicial districts as provided by law.
Each judicial district shall have at least
one district judge. The term of office
of each judge of the district court shall
be four years. District court shall be
held at such times and places as may be
provided by law. The district judges
shall be elected by the electors of the
respective judicial districts unless the
electors of a judicial district have
adopted and not subsequently rejected a
method of nonpartisan selection. . . .
Whenever a vacancy occurs in the office
of district judge, it shall be filled by
appointment by the governor until the next
general election that occurs more than
thirty days after such vacancy, or as may
be provided by such nonpartisan method of
selection." (Emphasis added).
The procedure to fill vacancies in the office of district
court judge and district magistrate judge was further
delineated by the legislature in K.S.A. 25-312a. This statute
was amended in 1987 (L. 1987, ch. 124). At the time in
question, 1986, K.S.A. 25-312a read as follows:
"Except as otherwise provided in K.S.A.
20-2903 through 20-2913 [nonpartisan
selection of judges], and amendments
thereto, whenever a vacancy occurs in the
office of judge of the district court, it
shall be filled by appointment by the
governor. At the next general election
that occurs more than 30 days after such
vacancy, the office shall be filled by
election for a term commencing as provided
in K.S.A. 25-313 and amendments thereto.
Any appointment made by the governor as
required by this section shall be made
within 60 days after the vacancy occurs."
L. 1985, ch. 119, § 1. (Emphasis added).
(The term "judge of the district court" includes district
judges and district magistrate judges. K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
20-301a.)
In your situation, the vacancy occurred more than thirty days
before the 1986 general election. Pursuant to K.S.A. 25-312a,
the office was "filled by election for a term commencing
as provided in K.S.A. 25-313. . . ." (Emphasis added).
K.S.A. 25-313 provides that a term of office begins the second
Monday in January next after the election. Article 3, § 6 of
the Kansas Constitution states that the term of office of each
district judge is four years. Thus, according to K.S.A.
25-312a as it existed in 1986, you were elected to a four-year
term.
It has been argued, however, that K.S.A. 25-314 controls.
This statute concerns the term of office of persons filling
vacancies in state, district, county, and township offices:
"Any of said officers that may be elected
or appointed to fill vacancies may qualify
and enter upon the duties of their office
immediately thereafter, and when elected
they may hold the same during the
unexpired term for which they were
elected, and until their successors are
elected and qualified; but if appointed,
unless otherwise provided by law, they
shall hold the same only until their
successors are elected and qualified."
(Emphasis added).
It is argued that, under the above statute, your election in
1986 was to fill the remaining two years of the term that was
vacated. K.S.A. 25-314 was last amended in 1968. It is a
rule of statutory construction that "[w]here there is a
conflict between two statutes the latest legislative
expression controls." State v. Hennessee, 232 Kan. 807,
Syl. 5 1 (1983). Furthermore, "[w]here there is a conflict
between a statute dealing generally with a subject and another
dealing specifically with a certain phase of it, the specific
legislation controls." State v. Keeley, 236 Kan. 555,
560 (1985). K.S.A. 25-314 concerns vacancies of state,
district, county, and township offices while K.S.A. 25-312a
concerns vacancies in the office of district court judge. We
believe it was the intent of the legislature that K.S.A.
25-312a, the specific statute concerning judges, control the
present situation.
"The fundamental rule of statutory
construction is that the purpose and
intent of the legislature governs when the
intent can be ascertained from the
statute." State v. Adee, 241 Kan.
825, 829 (1987).
"In determining legislative intent, courts
are not limited to a mere consideration of
the language employed but may properly
look to the historical background of the
enactment, the circumstances attending its
passage, the purposes to be accomplished
and the effect the statute may have under
the various constructions suggested."
State v. Thompson, 237 Kan. 562, 563
(1985). See Jackson v. City of Kansas
City, 235 Kan. 278, 319 (1984).
The meaning of K.S.A. 25-312a can be ascertained by examining
the history of the statute and the intent of the legislature's
1985 and 1987 amendments. Before amendment in 1985, K.S.A.
25-312a provided:
"Except as otherwise provided in K.S.A.
20-2903 to 20-2913 and amendments thereto,
whenever a vacancy shall occur in the
office of judge of the district court, it
shall be filled by appointment by the
governor until the next general election
that shall occur more than thirty (30)
days after such vacancy, when such
vacancy shall be filled by election.
Any appointment made by the governor as
required by this section shall be made
within sixty (60) days after the vacancy
within sixty (60) days after the vacancy
occurs." (L. 1976, ch. 145, § 138).
(Emphasis added).
Senate Bill No. 65 (Session of 1985) amended the statute as
follows:
"Except as otherwise provided in K.S.A.
20-2903 to through 20-2913, and
amendments thereto, whenever a vacancy
shall occour occurs in the office of
judge of the district court, it shall be
filled by appointment by the governor
until. At the next general election
that shall occur occurs more
than thirty (30) 30 days after such
vacancy, when such vacancy the
office shall be filled by election for a
term commencing as provided in K.S.A.
25-313 and amendments thereto. Any
appointment made by the governor as
required by this section shall be made
within s ixty 460* 60 days after
the vacancy occurs." (L. 1985, ch. 119,
§ 1).
Testimony presented to the House Judiciary Committee on March
18, 1985, explains the purpose of the amendments. A
representative from the Office of Judicial Administration
testified on behalf of the bill:
"This bill would provide that in an
elected district, a judge appointed to
fill a vacancy would serve until the 2nd
Monday in January after the election,
whereupon the duly elected person would
take office.
Under current law, a district judge
appointed to fill a vacancy serves only
until the next general election occurring
more than 30 days after the vacancy. At
that election, electors vote for a
candidate to fill the unexpired term, a
term which may be as short as a month and
a half.
At the same election at which the
unexpired term is filled, the voters will
also be electing a judge for the next
regular term of office. The same
judgeship position appears on the ballot
twice: once for the unexpired term and
once for the regular term.
The current situation can be extremely
confusing to voters and disruptive to the
administration of justice. Potentially
four judges could fill the same position
in as short a period as a half year: the
judge whose resignation, death or removal
caused a vacancy; the appointed judge; the
judge elected for the unexpired term; and
the judge elected for the regular term.
Such a scenario is not farfetched: last
year in Wichita, a judge appointed to fill
a vacancy was elected to fill the next
regular judicial term while another
candidate won the right to fill the
unexpired term of two months.
Other problems with the current
legislation include voter confusion when
faced by two nearly identical provisions
on a ballot, and the necessity of
candidates for the judgeship positions to
file twice and pay two filing fees if they
seek to fill both terms.
We believe Senate Bill 65 will help ensure
judicial effectiveness by encouraging
smooth transitions in the offices of
elected judges and will also decrease
voter confusion."
The intent of the bill was to remedy a situation which
occurred if a vacancy was created at least 30 days before the
general election preceding the January when the four-year term
expired. Under the then-existing law (L. 1976, ch. 145, §
138), if a vacancy occurred the person appointed to fill the
vacancy served "until the next general election." The statute
provided that the person elected served the remainder of the
vacated term. Thus, if the vacancy occurred during the second
half of a judicial term, the person elected served from
presumably the day after the November election to the second
Monday in January, a period of about eight and a half weeks.
Thus, at the November general election electors also voted for
a person to serve a new four year term beginning in January.
The legislative history of 1985 Senate Bill No. 65 makes it
clear that K.S.A. 25-312a was amended to provide that the
person appointed to fill the vacancy served until "the second
Monday in January next after the election," at which time the
person who was elected at the preceding general election began
his or her four year term of office.
The 1985 amendments to K.S.A. 25-312a did not consider the
scenario if the vacancy happened in the the first half of the
term; i.e., if the "next general election that occurs more
than 30 days after such vacancy" is the general election that
occurs at mid-term, the situation now before us. This
situation is different from that presented in committee
testimony concerning dual elections for the one office.
The 1985 amendments, however, do not distinguish between
vacancies occurring at least 30 days before the interim
general election and vacancies occurring 30 days before the
general election preceding the January in which the term
expires. In either case, K.S.A. 25-312a as it existed in 1986
provided that, following the appointment to fill a vacancy,
the person elected at the next general election is to serve
for a term commencing the second Monday in January. Before
the 1985 amendments, the statute made it clear that the person
elected was to fill the vacancy. K.S.A. 25-312a as amended
in 1985 states that the person elected is to serve for a
term. We think it is significant that the legislature in
the 1985 amendments chose the words "office" and "term,"
replacing the word "vacancy" as used in the statute before the
amendment. To conclude that you were elected to fill the
remaining time in the vacancy of two years and two months
would defeat the language of the 1985 amendments. Therefore,
it is our opinion that in 1986 you were elected to a four-year
term to expire in January 1991, as provided by your
certificate of election.
Our conclusion is supported by the amendments to K.S.A.
25-312a made by the legislature in 1987. Indeed, these
amendments distinguish vacancies occurring in the first and
second half of a district judge's term:
"Except as otherwise provided in K.S.A.
20-2903 through 20-2913, and amendments
thereto, whenever a vacancy occurs in the
office of judge of the district court, it
shall be filled by appointment by the
governor. If the vacancy occurs on or
after May 1 of the second year of the
term, the person so appointed shall serve
for the remainder of the unexpired term
and until a successor is elected and
qualified. If the vacancy occurs before
May 1 of the second year of the term, the
person appointed to fill the vacancy shall
serve until a successor is elected and
qualified at the next general election to
serve the remainder of the unexpired
term. At the next general election
that occurs more than 30 days after such
vacancy, the office shall be filled by
election for a term commencing as provided
In K.S.A. 25.314, and amendments
thereto. Any appointment made by the
governor as required by this section shall
be made within 60 days after the vacancy
occurs." 1987 Senate Bill No. 107; L.
1987, ch. 124, § 1.
In Attorney General Opinion No. 86.100 the following situation
was presented to us. A district judge whose term was to
expire January 1989 retired from office on June 18, 1986,
eight days after the deadline for filing for office. Given
the language of K.S.A. 1985 Supp. 25.312a, a candidacy was
statutorily created. We concluded that, since there were no
political party candidates, the vacancies in the party
candidacies for the office of district court judge were to be
filled by the district convention procedure provided in K.S.A.
25-3904. We also concluded that the term of office of the
judge elected in that situation was controlled by K.S.A.
25-3906. This statute, which governs elections for vacancies
in candidacies occurring after the filing deadline and prior
to the primary, provides that the person is elected to serve
the remainder of the unexpired term.
The present situation is distinguished from Attorney General
Opinion No. 86-100 in that the vacancy in the office occurred
prior to the filing deadline. In the facts upon which the
opinion was based, there was not only a vacancy in office but
also vacancies in party candidacies. During the 1987
legislative session, Senate Bill No. 107 was introduced at the
request of the Secretary of State's office. Testimony before
the Senate Elections Committee was as follows:
"Nancy Ryan, Secretary of State's Office,
. . . said that K.S.A. 25.312a is a
statute that caused their office problems
last summer. The statute presently
provided [sic] that when a vacancy occurs
in the office of district judge, the
vacancy should be filled at the next
general election if the election occurs
more than 30 days after a vacancy. In
July last summer a vacancy did occur and
this occurred after the June 10th filing
deadline. An Attorney General's opinion
was requested and provided that each party
name a candidate to be placed on the
ballot. This decision prevented
independent candidates from filing for the
office. Mrs. Ryan stated their office
would like the legislature to amend K.S.A.
25.312a to allow the vacancy to be filled
in the same manner as county officer
vacancies." (Minutes, February 4, 1987).
Senate Bill No. 107 was heard before the House Elections
Committee on March 17, 1987:
"[Senate Bill No. 107] was a request of
the office of the Secretary of State. . . .
Ms. Ryan [said] their office has requested
this legislation due to a problem which
came up last July, and that this bill
would clarify the procedure for filling
the vacancy of a district court judge.
SB 107 provides that if a vacancy
occurs, in the office of the district
court on or after May 1 of the second year
of the term, the person so appointed shall
serve for the remainder of the unexpired
term, and until a successor is elected and
is qualified. If the vacancy occurs
before May 1st of the second year of
that term, the person appointed to fill
the vacancy shall serve until a successor
is elected and qualified at the next
general election to serve the remainder of
the expired term."
Thus, the 1987 amendments to K.S.A. 25-312a do what the 1985
amendments did not do: distinguish between vacancies
occurring in the first half of the term, before the interim
general elections, and vacancies occurring in the second half
of the term, before the general election preceding the January
in which the term expires. Clearly, if a vacancy occurs in
the office of district court judge before May 1, 1990, the
person elected in November 1990 will serve until January 1993.
We note that the 1985 and 1987 amendments to K.S.A. 25-312a do
not appear to be in harmony with language in the constitution:
"Whenever a vacancy occurs in the office
of district judge, it shall be filled by
appointment by the governor until the next
general election that occurs more than
thirty days after such vacancy. . . ."
Kan. Const., Art. 2, § 6.
However, since our opinion was not requested on this issue, we
will not address the constitutionality of K.S.A. 1987 Supp.
25.312a at this time.
The vacancy in the present situation was filled pursuant to
K.S.A. 25.312a, as amended in 1985. Given the language of the
statute and the legislative history of K.S.A. 25.312a, it is
our opinion that persons elected to judge of the district
court in November 1986 due to a vacancy in office were elected
to a four year term to expire January 1991.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Rita L. Noll
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:RLN:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.