Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1988-011

1988-011Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL February 2, 1988
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 88- 11
Steven L. Boyce
Coffey County Attorney
514 Neosho, P.O. Box 452
Burlington, Kansas 66839
Re: Counties and County Officers -- County
Commissioners -- Powers of Board of Commissioners
Synopsis: Kansas recognizes employment at will principles
which allow either party to terminate employment,
absent a contract that otherwise provides.
However, the doctrine of employment at will is not
absolute. For instance, Kansas law restricts
employment termination in cases involving
discrimination, civil service, veterans, or
retaliation. Public employees may have additional
protections pursuant to employee manuals,
established policies or adoption of the Kansas
public employer-employee relations act. Absent the
applicability of the aforementioned exceptions, or
denial of a. constitutionally protected right, the
Coffey County board of county commissioners, in
the interest of protecting county property, has the
authority to terminate employment of an at will
employee who has been convicted of felony theft.
Cited herein: Preamble; K.S.A. 19-101 Fourth
and Fifth; 19-212; 19-801 et seq.; 44-1001
et seq.; 68-504; 73-201 et seq.; 75-2925
et seq.; 75-4929f(b); U.S. Const., Amend.
XIV § 1; U.S. Const.
Dear Mr. Boyce:
As Coffey County Counselor you request our opinion on the
ability of the board of county commissioners to terminate the
employment of an individual based on a conviction of felony
theft occurring after his hire date. You inform us that the
employee was hired by the county in 1985 and is responsible
for road and bridge maintenance. In this capacity he has use
of and access to county property and tools. You further
inform us that Coffey county has no resolutions or written
policies forbidding the hiring of a felon nor advising an
employee that conviction could result in termination.
Counties have long been authorized to exercise corporate and
administrative powers in order to determine local affairs.
See K.S.A. 19-101 Fourth and Fifth. In furtherance of
these permissible goals, the board of county commissioners has
been given authority to manage the concerns of the county.
K.S.A. 19-212. Thus, when not otherwise precluded (see
e.g., K.S.A. 19-801 et seq. on county sheriffs), the
board of county commissioners has the authority to hire county
employees. K.S.A. 68-504; K.S.A. 75-4326(b); 62 C.J.S.
Municipal Corporations § 702 (1949).
Kansas follows "at-will employment" rules recognizing that,
absent a contract providing otherwise, employment is
terminable at the will of either party. Anco Construction
Co. v. Freeman, 221 Kan. 557 (1977); Midfelt v. Lair,
221 Kan. 557 (1977); Johnson v. National Beef Packing Co.,
220 Kan. 52 (1976); Lorson v. Falcon Coach, Inc., 214
Kan. 670 (1974). Restrictions upon at-will employment
terminations include those contained in the Kansas acts
against discrimination, K.S.A. 44-1001 et seq., the civil
service laws, K.S.A. 75-2925 et seq., and the veterans
preference law, K.S.A. 73-201 et seq. Another limitation
upon employment termination prohibits retaliatory firing as a
result of an employee's exercise of a protected right.
Murphy v. City of Topeka, 6 Kan. App. 2d 488 (1981).
See also, Brown, Webb, "Employment at Will: Emerging
Protections for the Employee," 22 Wash. L.J. 491 (1983).
From the facts provided, the aforementioned protections do not
appear to apply in the current situation. However, in making
the decision to terminate an employee, the board of county
commissioners should consider any possible applicability.
When the employer is a public entity, the employee may have
additional protections. The Kansas public employer-employee
relations act, K.S.A. 75-4321 et seq., allows the
governing body of any public employer to recognize employee
organizations and establishes mediation procedures. We have
been informed that Coffey county has elected not to adopt
the act. By remaining outside the act, Coffey county may
take unilateral action on such matters as employment
termination. See, R. Geotz, "The Kansas Public-Employee
Relations Law," 28 K.L.R. 243, 248 (1980).
A further consideration is the possible existence of a
constitutionally protected right. The Fourteenth Amendment to
the United States Constitution prohibits a state from
depriving a person of a protected interest without due process
of the law. In order to claim such a due process right, the
public employee must show that a protected interest exists.
It is questionable whether continued employment by a public
employer is, in and of itself, a protected interest. In
Kansas City, Kansas Frat. v. City of Kansas City, 620 F.
Supp. 752 (D. Kan. 1984), the court stated:
"In determining the existence of a
protected interest, we must remember that
a property interest in employment can be
created by ordinance or contract . . . we
must determine if under Kansas law, 'there
are such rules or mutually explicit
understandings that support [the
plaintiffs'] claim of entitlement to the
benefit. . . ." Id. at 756.
See also, Poison v. Davis, 635 F. Supp. 1130, 1140
(D. Kan. 1986); Owens v. City of Derby, 586 F. Supp. 37,
40 (D. Kan. 1984); Stoldt v. City of Toronto, 234 Kan.
957 (1984).
In order to prove a due process denial, the employee who has
been fired must show that a protected interest existed because
local or state rule provided for continuing employment or
required some procedure prior to termination, or that a mutual
written or implied understanding concerning continued
employment rose to the level of a contract. From the facts
provided, the employee in question has not been terminated,
and thus the board of county commissioners may attempt to
eliminate any claim of due process violation by carefully
following any previously established procedures applicable to
employment termination. Any related contractual claim may be
defeated by the employee's mutual right to terminate
employment at any time.
The preamble to the United States Constitution establishes a
protected right in liberty. To establish deprivation of a
protected liberty interest ". . . a public employee must (1)
show that he was stigmatized in connection with an alteration
of [his] legal status as an employee, (2) allege that the
stigma arose from substantially false characterizations of the
employee or [his] conduct, and (3) demonstrate that the
damaging characterizations were made public through channels
other than the litigation initiated by the employee."
Poison v. Davis, supra, at 1142; See also, Sipes
v. United States, 744 F.2d 1418, 1421 (10th Cir. 1984)
[quoting from "Developments In The Law - Public Employment,"
97 Harv. L. Rev. 1161, 1789 (1984)]. The fact that a
felony conviction actually occurred makes any claim of a
liberty interest deprivation unlikely to succeed because a
false characterization has not been made. However, it may be
well-advised not to use that conviction as the basis for
judgments on general character and to limit the county's
involvement in the publication of any characterization of the
employee that could affect future employment.
In this situation, the county may have valid concerns because
the protection of county property is involved. Through his
work for the county, the employee in question has access to
and dominion over county property. A felony theft conviction
raises serious concerns about the wisdom or propriety in
allowing this employee continued access to county property and
involves behavior which the board of county commissioners
should justifiably consider in deciding to whom to entrust
county property.
In summary, Kansas recognizes employment at will principles
which allow either party to terminate employment at any time,
absent a contractual agreement that provides otherwise.
However, Kansas law restricts employment termination in cases
such as those involving discrimination, civil service,
veterans and retaliation. Public employees may have
additional protections pursuant to employee manuals,
established employee policies or adoption of the Kansas public
employer-employee relations act. Absent the applicability of
the aforementioned exceptions or the denial of a
constitutionally protected right, the Coffey county board of
county commissioners, in the interest of protecting county
property, has the authority to terminate employment of an at
will employee who has been convicted of felony theft.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Theresa Marcel Nuckolls
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:TMN:bas

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.