Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-185

1987-185Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL December 29, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 185
Robert J. Watson
City Attorney
City of Overland Park
8500 Santa Fe Drive
Overland Park, Kansas 66212
Re: Bonds and Warrants--Miscellaneous Provisions--
Interest Rates; Limitations
Cities and Municipalities--General Provisions--
Countywide and City Retailers' Sales Taxes;
Proceeds as Guarantee for Payment of Bonds
Cities and Municipalities--Miscellaneous
Provisions--Transient Guest Tax
Synopsis: Sales tax revenue bonds issued by a city or county
pursuant to L. 1987, ch. 60, §7, are subject to the
interest rate limitations which apply to bonds as
stated in K.S.A. 10-1109, as amended.
A city issuing sales tax revenue bonds may apply
revenues derived from a transient guest tax levied
in the city to the payment of sales tax revenue
bonds if such use is consistent with the laws and
ordinances authorizing the transient guest tax and
providing for the objects of its expenditures. The
existence of such additional security may be
conveyed to bondholders in the same manner as other
credit enhancements.
Pursuant to the Home Rule Amendment to the Kansas
Constitution, a city may issue bonds backed by a
pledge of revenue derived from the levy and
collection of a transient guest tax. Cited
herein: K.S.A. 10-1009, as amended by L. 1987, ch.
60; K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-187; 12-195, as amended by
L. 1987, ch. 60; K.S.A. 12-1696; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
12-1698; K.S.A. 12-1699; Kan. Const., Art. 12,
§5.
*
Dear Mr. Watson:
As attorney for the city of Overland Park you seek an opinion
on three questions relating to the city's proposed issuance of
bonds to be paid from the revenue produced by a local option
sales tax (as authorized by L. 1987, ch. 60) and the possible
use of revenues generated by the city's transient guest tax to
further guarantee payment of the sales tax revenue bonds.
Chapter 60 of the Kansas Session Laws of 1987 amends K.S.A.
1986 Supp. 12-195 to authorize Kansas cities and counties
which receive revenue from a local option sales tax (levied
pursuant to K.S.A. 12-187 et seq.) to issue bonds backed
by a pledge of those revenues. The bonds may be issued to pay
for:
"[A]ll or any portion of the cost of
public facilities or improvements of [the]
city or county for which [the] city or
county is authorized pursuant to the
constitution or laws of this state to
issue general obligation bonds, excluding
any facilities or improvements to be used
for commercial or retail purposes." L.
1987, ch. 60, §7(b).
Your first question about bonds issued under the new law
concerns the interest rate on such bonds. L. 1987, ch. 60
provides in §7(b)(1) that such bonds:
"[M]ay bear interest payable at such
times and at such rate or rates . . . all
as the city or county shall determine."
Section 6 of Chapter 60 amends K.S.A. 10-1009 to provide:
"The maximum stated rate of interest which
may be fixed on bonds issued by a
municipality or taxing subdivision of the
state of Kansas shall be determined on the
day the bonds are sold and shall not
exceed the index of treasury bonds
published by the weekly Credit Markets, in
New York, New York, on the Monday next
preceding the day on which the bonds are
sold, plus 2%." L. 1987, ch. 60, §6.
(Emphasis added.)
You ask whether, in our opinion, the language of Section
7(b)(1) of Chapter 60 quoted above may be interpreted to
exempt sales tax revenue bonds from the interest rate
limitations stated in K.S.A. 10-1009, as amended by Section 6
of Chapter 60.
The interest rate limitations stated in K.S.A. 10-1009, as
amended, apply to ".. . bonds issued by a municipality or
taxing subdivision of the state of Kansas." The statute does
not qualify the term "bonds" with respect to the type of bond
or nature of its security. Thus, in our opinion, the
limitations stated in K.S.A. 10-1009 apply unless the bonds in
question are specifically exempted. The language of §7(b) (1)
of Chapter 60 relating to interest rates on sales tax revenue
bonds does not contain language exempting such rates from the
generally applicable limitations stated in K.S.A. 10-1009, as
amended.
We are not unmindful that numerous Kansas statutes authorizing
the issuance of bonds specifically state that the interest
rates payable on such bonds shall be limited by K.S.A.
10-1009. In our opinion, however, the failure to include such
a statement in Chapter 60, §7(b)(1) does not mean that sales
tax revenue bonds are thereby exempted from the application of
K.S.A. 10-1009. We are not of the opinion that an exception
to the general statute may be found inferentially on the basis
of language employed in drafting various unrelated
legislation. Moreover, we note that K.S.A. 10-1009 was
considered and amended by the 1987 legislature in Chapter 60,
the same chapter which amends K.S.A. 12-195 to provide
authority for the issuance of sales tax backed revenue bonds.
Thus, we must presume the legislature recognized the two
subjects as related. Had an exemption been intended for sales
tax revenue bonds it easily could have been provided. In the
absence a stated exemption, it is our opinion that sales tax
revenue bonds issued by a city or county pursuant to L. 1987,
ch. 60, §7 are subject to the interest rate limitations which
apply to bonds stated in K.S.A. 10-1009, as amended by L.
1987, ch. 60, .56.
Your second question asks whether, in our opinion, the city
may utilize, as additional security for a proposed issue of
sales tax revenue bonds, revenues derived from the levy of a
transient guest tax in the city. Your question has at least
two facets, first, whether transient guest tax revenues may be
so utilized and second, whether certain language in L. 1987,
ch. 60 precludes the use of transient guest tax revenues to
further secure payment of sales tax revenue bonds.
Addressing the first aspect of your question, we note that the
city of Overland Park levies a transient guest tax in the
amount of 5% upon the gross receipts derived from the sale of
guest accommodations at hotels, motels, and tourist courts
within the city. The tax is levied pursuant to K.S.A. 12-1696
et !2a . and three charter ordinances enacted by the city
(Nos. 39, 41 & 42). Revenues produced by the tax are used to
"promote tourism and conventions" in the city.
As is apparent from the fact the city has enacted three
charter ordinances providing substitute provisions for the
transient guest tax statutes, those statutes are subject to
charter ordinances pursuant to the Home Rule Amendment to the
Kansas Constitution (Art. 12, §5). In Opinion No. 82-17
(attached) the Attorney General concluded the Transient Guest
Tax Act (K.S.A. 12-1696 et seq.) is non-uniform in its
application to cities and hence subject to home rule charter
ordinance. That opinion further concluded that such a charter
ordinance legitimately might provide for a higher tax rate
than permitted by the statute and for use of transient guest
tax revenues to retire "existing bonds [issued] for community
centers, parks, or recreational facilities."
Utilizing home rule authority, the city of Overland Park
enacted Charter Ordinance No. 42 which exempts the city from
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 12-1698 and enacts substitute provisions
providing that revenue received from the transient guest tax
shall be ". . . credited to such fund or funds of the City and
shall be expended for such purposes and in such priority as
shall be set out by the City in an ordinary ordinance." At
present the city has provided for use of transient guest tax
revenues by Ordinance No. TGT-1469 which provides in
relevant part:
"SECTION 1. Revenue from the transient
guest tax shall be credited to the
Convention and Tourism Fund and shall be
expended for convention and tourism
purposes in the priority as follows:
"First To pay the costs of the tourism
and convention activities of
the Convention and Tourism
Bureau which amount is contained
in the annual budget proposed by
the Chamber of Commerce, reviewed
by the Convention and Tourism
Committee, and approved by the
Governing Body of the City.
"Second Any funds remaining shall be
held in reserve and may be used
for the payment of any
expenditures relating to tourism
and convention activities as
determined by the Governing Body
of the City."
In our opinion the ordinances discussed above provide
sufficient authority for the city to utilize revenues produced
by the transient guest tax to secure sales tax revenue bonds
issued pursuant to L. 1987, ch. 60, §7 should the city
governing body determine that such use is appropriate and
consistent with the purpose of the transient guest tax.
Having so concluded, the second aspect of your question is
whether a "pledge" of transient guest tax revenues to provide
additional security for sales tax revenue bonds is permissible
under the statute authorizing issuance of the latter bonds.
This question relates to language in Chapter 60, §7(b)(4)
which provides that bonds issued pursuant to its authority
shall plainly state:
"[O]n the face of such bond that it has
been issued under this act, that the bonds
shall be special obligations of the city
or county payable solely and only from
the revenues derived from the collection
of such local sales taxes, and that, in
no event shall the bonds constitute an
indebtedness of the state of Kansas or the
city or county for which the faith and
credit of the state of Kansas or city or
county is pledged." (Emphasis added.)
You ask whether the emphasized language should be read to
prevent the city from utilizing any other available fund or
source of revenue to provide additional security for the sales
tax revenue bonds. The cited language makes an express pledge
of the revenues derived from the local sales tax. It creates
a lien upon those revenues and for the life of the pledge (the
term of the bonds), precludes the lawful appropriation of
those revenues to any other municipal purpose which would be
prejudicial to the payment of the bonds. See McQuillin,
Municipal Corporations, §43.132 (3d Ed. 1985).
The language which must appear on the face of a sales tax
revenue bond stating that the bond is a special obligation
payable "solely and only from the revenues derived from the
collection of such local option sales taxes" makes it clear
that a city or county issuing bonds pursuant to L. 1987,
Chapter 60, §7 has no obligation under that statute to pay
the bonds from any other source or fund. The recital required
on the bond further states that the bonds so issued do not
constitute an indebtedness for which the faith and credit of
the state, city, or county is pledged. This is, however, the
only language in Chapter 60, §7 which indicates that the bonds
are to be secured only with the revenues derived from local
sales taxes. In fact, at least two other portions of the
statute might be argued to contemplate the use of other
revenues to secure such bonds. Section 7(b)(1) of Chapter 60
relates to the provisions of an ordinance or resolution
authorizing the issuance of sales tax revenue bonds and states
that a city or county may provide therein for:
"[O]ther terms, covenants and conditions
that the city or county deems reasonable
and desirable, including without
limitation those pertaining to . . . the
nature and extent of any security for
payment of the bonds the custody and
application of the proceeds of the bonds,
the collection, transfer and disposition
of sales tax revenues, the investing of
bond proceeds or any funds pledged to the
repayment of the bonds, and the rights,
duties and obligations of the city or
county and the owners of the bonds."
(Emphasis added.)
The emphasized portions of the statute quoted above certainly
may be argued to contemplate the use of funds other than sales
tax revenues to enhance the security for bonds issued pursuant
to its terms. At the same time the statute requires that such
bonds shall plainly state they are payable "solely and
only" from local sales tax revenues. The intent of the
legislature is at best, obscure.
Given these adverse expressions of intent we are left with the
task of attempting to reconcile them in a manner best serving
what the statute as a whole appears to require. The recital
stating that the bonds are payable "solely and only" from
sales tax revenue provides that the only lien produced by the
bonds under the terms of the statue is a lien on the sales tax
revenues. It is a clear statutory requirement that such a
recital appear on the bonds. Giving effect to the other
provisions of the statute, however, we do not believe that the
required recitals prevent a city issuing bonds under the
statute from voluntarily assuming the obligation to apply
other lawfully available funds to the payment of sales tax
revenue bonds. Thus, in our opinion a city issuing sales tax
revenue bonds pursuant to L. 1987, ch. 60, may apply revenues
derived from a transient guest tax to further secure payment
of sales tax revenue bonds as long as such use is permitted by
the laws and ordinances authorizing the transient guest tax
and providing for the objects of its expenditure.
This raises the obvious difficulty of how the existence of
such additional security may be conveyed to bondholders.
Obviously, a pledge of transient guest tax revenues to the
payment of sales tax revenue bonds is inconsistent with the
recital, required by §7(b)(4) of Chapter 60, that such bonds
are payable "solely and only" from sales tax revenues. While
clarification from the legislature of the intended limitations
would provide the best solution to this problem, in the
meantime we might venture to suggest that a city issuing sales
tax revenue bonds which are further secured by other available
revenues inform bondholders of the additional, voluntarily
supplied security in the same manner that other credit
enhancements (such as bond insurance) are reported to
bondholders. In this way it should be understood that the
city has voluntarily contracted to provide security for
payment of the bonds which is not derived from the statute
authorizing issuance of the bonds.
Your third question asks whether the city may use home rule
powers to issue "revenue bonds backed solely and only by a
pledge of [revenue derived from the collection of the]
Transient Guest Tax." As discussed above, the Attorney
General concluded in Opinion No. 82-17 that the statutes
authorizing cities to levy a transient guest tax K.S.A. 12-1694
et !2a ., do not apply uniformly to all cities (see
K.S.A. 12-1699) and, therefore, that cities may, in
Mary F Carson
Assistant Attorney General
accordance with the Home Rule Amendment, enact a charter
ordinance exempting from the whole or any part of the
enactment providing for levy of the transient guest tax and
providing substitute and additional provisions on the same
subject.
Matters relating to the use of transient guest tax revenues
are certainly included within the purview of the "same
subject" and thus may be determined by the city through the
enactment of a charter ordinance. Thus, in our opinion the
city may use home rule powers to enact a charter ordinance
providing for the issuance of revenue bonds backed solely and
only by revenues derived from the collection of the city's
transient guest tax.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
Attorney General of Kansas
RTS:JLM:MFC:jm

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.