Kansas Attorney General Opinion 1987-154

1987-154Kanag

Testo completo

ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL October 26, 1987
ATTORNEY GENERAL OPINION NO. 87- 154
L. Patricia Casey
Senior Counsel
Department of Health and Environment
Forbes Field
Topeka, Kansas 66620-0001
Re: Public Health -- Secretary of Health and
Environment, Activities; Water Supply and Sewage --
Implementation of Clean Water Act; N.P.D.E.S.
Program
Synopsis: The partial transfer of authority from the Kansas
Department of Health and Environment to the Kansas
Corporation Commission does not allow a discharge
of pollution in violation of the federal National
Pollution Discharge Elimination System (N.P.D.E.S.)
permit requirements.
State law defines pollution as broadly as it is
defined by federal law.
With the exception of some privately owned farm
ponds and reservoirs, regulation of discharges into
waters of the state include discharges into bodies
of water defined by federal law.
State enforcement provisions include civil
penalties which appear to be as stringent as
required by federal law. However, the criminal
penalties provided by state law are less stringent.
Variances granted under state law are limited to
those allowable under federal law.
Legislative amendments appear necessary to conclude
that the state program meets all the requirements
of the federal act. Cited herein: K.S.A. 60-224;
65-101; 65-102a; 65-161; 65-162a; K.S.A. 1986
Supp. 65-163; 65-163a; 65-164; K.S.A. 65-165;
65-166; 65-167; 65-169; 65-170b; 65-170c; 65-170g;
K.S.A. 1984 Supp. 65-171d; K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
65-171d; K.S.A. 65-171m through 65-171t; L. 1986,
ch. 201, § 22; K.A.R. 28-16-28b(35); 28-16-57;
28-16-58; 28-16-62; 82-3-400; 82-3-401; 33 U.S.C.A.
§ 1318, 1362(6), 1362(7); 40 C.F.R. § 122.2,
123.27 (1986).
Dear Ms. Casey:
As Senior Counsel for the Kansas Department of Health and
Environment, you have requested our opinion concerning several
issues involving the National Pollution Discharge Elimination
System (N.P.D.E.S.) program. Your request of August 27, 1987
reflects concerns raised by the United States Environmental
Protection Agency in April of this year regarding Kansas
statutory and regulatory compliance with federal law.
I. Initially, you ask whether jurisdiction over N.P.D.E.S.
regulated discharges has been transferred from the Department
of Health and Environment (KDHE) to the Kansas Corporation
Commission (KCC). Prior law allowed KDHE to protect the
waters of the state from pollution by oil, gas and salt water
injection wells. K.S.A. 65-171d (1984). This section was
amended by L. 1986, ch 201, § 22, which transferred certain
duties to the KCC, while retaining in KDHE jurisdiction
over the clean up of such pollution. We believe that this
transfer of authority does not effect the state N.P.D.E.S.
permit program.
Pursuant to the transfer of authority, a memorandum of
understanding (MOU) was entered into between the KCC and
KDHE. The agreement, dated July 1, 1986, assures
cooperation between the agencies regarding the prevention and
clean-up of pollution. The KCC has jurisdiction to prevent
pollution by oil and gas activities. Such jurisdiction is to
be exercised in cooperation with KDHE. Oil and gas
activities are to be in compliance with applicable federal and
state statutes and regulations. MOU, at page 4. Authority
for prevention or clean-up of pollution resulting from
transportation, storage or refining of oil and gas is vested
in KDHE. MOU, at page 5. The KCC has jurisdiction to
prevent pollution in the drilling, injection and disposal
phases of oil and gas activities. These activities are
subject to application and approval pursuant to K.A.R.
82-3-400 et seq. Such application must show that
injection or disposal will be contained within a zone, and
will not enable the fluid to enter fresh or usable water
strata. K.A.R. 82-3-401. In short, we believe that prior to
commencing oil and gas activities regulated by KCC, approval
is required, and assurances must be made that the injection
will not result in the degradation of water resources.
In light of the regulatory scheme implemented by KCC, and
the clarification of duties of KCC and KDHE, we believe
that the transfer of authority between the agencies does not
allow an unpermitted discharge of pollution to occur which
would otherwise be subject to N.P.D.E.S. requirements.
Pollution is defined by 33 U.S.C.A. § 1362(6) (B) as not
including "water, gas, or other material which is injected
into a well to facilitate production of oil or gas ... if the
well ... is approved by authority of the State in which the
well is located, and if such State determines that such
injection or disposal will not result in the degradation of
ground or surface water resources." These conditions being
met, it is our opinion that the 1986 amendments to K.S.A.
65-171d do not allow a discharge of pollution in violation of
the federal act.
II. Your second question involves updating statutory
reference to federal law. The secretary of KDHE is
authorized by K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-171d(b) to adopt
regulations promulgated by the federal government pursuant to
the clean water act and the 1981 amendments thereto. The
clean water act, however, has been amended in 1983 and
1987. For the secretary to implement these amendments,
legislative action is required which incorporates these
updates.
III. Your third question is whether the Kansas definition
of pollution is broad enough to encompass the definition of
pollution as used in the clean water act. Pursuant to K.S.A.
1986 Supp. 65-171d(b), the secretary has adopted by
reference the federal definition of pollution, as it appears
in 33 U.S.C.A. § 1362(6) (as in effect Dec. 27, 1977, Pub.L
95-217, § 33(b), 91 Stat. 1577). K.A.R. 28-16-58(1), 87
Kan. Register 647-48 (1987).
IV. Your fourth question is whether point source discharges
into farm ponds and fresh water reservoirs are subject to
N.P.D.E.S. permit requirements. Farm ponds and fresh water
reservoirs are exempt from water quality standards if they are
privately owned and all land bordering the pond or reservoir
is under common private ownership. This exemption does not
apply, however, if the water quality standard relates to a
discharge into waters of the state, or if the standard relates
to the public health of persons using the pond or reservoir.
K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-171d(d). The question arises whether a
discharge into such farm ponds or reservoirs is subject to
N.P.D.E.S. permit requirements.
The clean water act regulates pollution of navigable waters.
Navigable waters include waters of the United States and
territorial seas. 33 U.S.C.A. § 1362(7). The term "waters of
the United States" is defined as including intrastate bodies
of water, "the use, degradation, or destruction of which would
affect or could effect interstate or foreign commerce . . . "
40 C.F.R. § 122.2 (1986).
We believe that situations could arise in which a discharge
would be prohibited by federal law, but not prohibited by
state law. For example, if the pond or reservoir is so
constructed as to preclude seepage or discharge from the body
of water into waters of the state, and a water quality
standard is not designed to protect the health of persons
using the pond or reservoir, then such water quality standard
would not apply to the pond or reservoir. However, that pond
or reservoir could theoretically be a navigable water, into
which the unpermitted discharge of pollutants is prohibited by
federal law. Therefore, it is our opinion that state law is
not as broad as federal law in this area.
V. Your fifth question is whether the definition of "Waters
of the State" includes the items specified in the federal
definition of "Waters of the United States."
"Waters of the State" are defined as:
"[A]ll streams and springs, and all
bodies of surface and subsurface waters
within the boundaries of the state."
K.S.A. 65-161(a). (Emphasis added).
The federal definition appears much broader as it includes
items such as "mudflats, sandflats, wetlands, sloughs,
prairie potholes and wet meadows." 40 C.F.R. 5 122.2 (1986).
However, "surface waters" are defined by state regulation as:
"all streams and rivers, including
springs, water in alluvial aquifers
available for flow to streams, and
riparian wetlands, and all lakes and
wetlands." K.A.R. 28-16-28B(35).
While terminology may differ between federal and state
provisions, we believe them to be practically synonymous.
In light of the previous discussion regarding certain farm
ponds and reservoirs, it should be noted that those bodies are
not excluded from waters of the state as defined by the
regulation. Those farm ponds and reservoirs are simply
excluded from water quality standards in some situations.
VI. Your sixth question is whether state enforcement
provisions are as strict as those required by federal law.
First, state law must authorize an injunction for violations
or threatened violations of any program requirement or permit
condition. 40 C.F.R. 5 123.27(a)(2) (1987). At the request
of the secretary of KDHE, the attorney general is authorized
to seek to enjoin violations of K.S.A. 65-162a, 1986 Supp.
65-163, 1986 Supp. 65-163a, 65-170b and 65-171m through
65-171g and amendments, inclusive. Such enforcement extends
to rules and regulations promulgated pursuant to those
sections. K.S.A. 65-171t. In addition, the secretary has
broad authority to take steps necessary to protect the public
health under K.S.A. 65-101, as explained in Dougan v.
Shawnee County Commissioners, 141 Kan. 554, 560 (1935). In
short, if a permit condition is a response to a statutory or
regulatory requirement, or if a permit condition protects
public health, then we believe the violation of that permit
condition may be enjoined.
The second aspect of enforcement authority involves a
comparison between federal and state civil and criminal
penalties for various acts.
Regarding civil penalties, federal regulations provide that a
State program have available the following remedies:
"Civil penalties shall be recoverable for
the violation of any NPDES permit
condition; any NPDES filing requirement;
any duty to allow or carry out inspection,
entry or monitoring activities; or, any
regulation or orders issued by the State
Director. These penalties shall be
assessable in at least the amount of
$5,000 a day for each violation." 40
C.F.R. § 123.27(a)(3)(i)(1986).
State law provides for a civil penalty not to exceed $10,000
for these violations. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-170d(a). This
penalty is imposed by the director of the division of
environment. K.S.A. 1986 Supp. 65-170d(b). We believe
that, while the director might assess all penalties in an
amount over $5,000 to comply with the federal regulation, such
is not currently required by statute.
Federal Regulations also provide that the state program have
available the following criminal penalties:
"Criminal fines shall be recoverable
against any person who willfully or
negligently violates any applicable
standards or limitations; any NPDES
permit condition; or any NPDES filing
requirement. These fines shall be
assessable in at least the amount of
$10,000 a day for each violation." 40
C.F.R. § 123.27 (a) (3) (ii) (1986) ,
and
"Criminal fines shall be recoverable
against any person who knowingly makes any
false statement, representation or
certification in any NPDES form, in any
notice or report required by an NPDES
permit, or who knowingly renders
inaccurate any monitoring device or method
required to be maintained by the
Director. These fines shall be
recoverable in at least the amount of
$5,000 for each instance of violation."
40 C.F.R. § 123.27 (a) (3) (iii) (1986).
The state penalties relating to activities listed in paragraph
(ii) of the federal regulation appear in K.S.A. 65-167. For
failing to report a sewage discharge, the fine is $1,000 per
day for each day the offense is maintained. For willfully or
negligently violating any applicable standard or limitation
under K.S.A. 65-165, any N.P.D.E.S. permit condition under
K.S.A. 65-167, or any requirement of K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
65-164 or 65-166, the penalty is not less than $2,500 and not
more than $25,000, plus $25,000 for each day the offense is
maintained. The state penalties relating to activities listed
in paragraph (iii) of the federal regulation appear at
65-170c, with a fine of not less than $25 and not more than
$10,000. Each day the violation continues constitutes a
separate violation.
The third aspect of enforcement authority involves the
penalties listed in K.S.A. 65-169. That section states that
failing to furnish, on demand, information required by the
secretary is a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of $50 to
$500. In addition, failing to fully comply with the
requirements of the secretary is a misdemeanor, punishable by
a fine of $25 to $100. The issue is raised whether this
section limits the criminal penalties listed in K.S.A. 65-167,
discussed above. We believe that these penalties are in
addition to the civil penalties listed in K.S.A. 1986 Supp.
65-170d(a). They do not displace, nor are they in conflict
with the criminal penalties listed in K.S.A. 65-167. Section
65-169 deals with orders made by the secretary, while section
65-167 relates to statutory, regulatory and permit
requirements.
In summary, the criminal enforcement provisions of state law
are less stringent than those required by federal law. The
discrepancies are curable only by legislative action.
Regarding civil penalties, state law may be enforced
consistently with federal law, though the higher federal
penalties are not currently required by state law.
VII. Your seventh inquiry involves variances. The federal
act and regulations authorize variances from applicable
effluent limitations. However, concerns have been raised
whether state law allows the secretary to grant variances
which are not allowed by federal law. Obtaining a variance is
not a matter of right. The only applicable statutory
reference to a variance is made in K.S.A. 65-171p, which deals
with drinking water standards. Further reference is made in
K.A.R. 28-16-62(e), as amended in 87 Kan. Register 647-48
(1987). Both provisions are discretionary with the
secretary. While it appears that, in exercising discretion,
the secretary could allow a variance which is not authorized
by federal law, we believe that the secretary has limited
himself to the terms of federal law by promulgating K.A.R.
28-16-57, as amended in 87 Kan. Register 647-48 (1987).
That regulation states an intention to comply with the
provisions of the federal water pollution control act relating
to the N.P.D.E.S. program as well as the federal regulations
adopted pursuant to that act.
VIII. Your final question relates to other clarification of
current law. First, 33 U.S.C.A. § 1318(a) requires that a
state have a right of entry and inspection on premises not
only where effluent sources are located, but also on the
premises where records for those sources are kept. The
secretary has statutory authority to enter property subject to
K.S.A. 65-161 through 65-171j. K.S.A. 65-170b. The problem
arises when records are not kept on premises subject to those
sections. We believe that this problem has been cured,
however, by the consent of licensee's to allow entry and
inspection. The requirements of 33 U.S.C.A § 1318 have been
adopted by reference as a permit condition. K.A.R.
28-16-62(b) (1). We therefore believe that, based on the
permit condition, the state has a right to enter and inspect
premises where records for effluent sources are kept.
Related to this subject is the question of the state's right
to sample and apply monitoring, recording and reporting
requirements. Such authority is provided by K.S.A. 65-170b.
You have also inquired whether effluent data is available to
the public. Records, reports, data, and other information
relative to discharges of pollution are required to be
available to the public, however there is protection for trade
secrets. K.S.A. 65-170g. That section further states that
nothing in the act shall be construed to make effluent data,
records, reports, permits and applications confidential. We
believe, therefore, that since these matters are not
confidential, if they relate to environmental concerns, they
are to be available to the public pursuant to K.S.A. 65-102a.
Federal regulations require states to have procedures to
ensure opportunity for public participation in enforcement
proceedings. 40 C.F.R. § 123.27(d). That regulation requires
that the state either allow intervention as of right in any
civil or administrative action by a citizen who has an
interest which may be adversely affected, or provide assurance
that the agency will not oppose intervention when such
intervention is made permissive by statute. When the second
alternative is chosen, settlement of any enforcement action is
subject to 30 days public notice and comment. Regarding
intervention as of right, the Kansas Rules of Court Procedure
parallel federal rules. We do not believe that a citizen
having, an interest which may be adversely affected is given an
unconditional right to intervene under K.S.A. 60-224(a)(1) or
(2). Subsection (a)(1) of the rule allows intervention as of
right when a statute grants an unconditional right. We find
no statute granting that right. Subsection (a)(2) of the rule
allows intervention as of right when the person's interests
may be adversely affected, but not when those interests are
adequately represented by existing parties. We believe that a
court could determine that the individual's interests are
adequately represented by either of the existing parties,
thereby making intervention as of right not available.
Regarding permissive intervention under K.S.A. 60-224(b), we
believe that the assurance of non-opposition to intervention
must come from the secretary, not from our office. In
summary, we believe that public participation is not
guaranteed by current Kansas law, and can be guaranteed only
through legislation granting intervention as of right.
Alternatively, the secretary could assure that intervention
will not be opposed, and that the public will be given an
opportunity to comment on a proposed settlement agreement
after 30 days notice.
In conclusion, in our opinion, the partial transfer authority
from KDHE to KCC does not allow a discharge of pollution
in violation of N.P.D.E.S. permit requirements. State law
defines pollution as broadly as it is defined by federal law.
However, some privately owned farm ponds and reservoirs may be
exempt from N.P.D.E.S. permit requirements under the state
program, which is in derogation of federal law. Other than
those exceptions, the state definition of waters of the state
are as inclusive as federal definitions. State enforcement
provisions include civil penalties which appear to be as
stringent as federal civil penalties. However, the criminal
penalties provided by state law are less stringent. Variances
granted under state law are limited to those allowed under
federal law. Other legislative changes appear necessary to
conclude that the state program meets all the requirements of
the federal clean water act.
Very truly yours,
ROBERT T. STEPHAN
ATTORNEY GENERAL OF KANSAS
Mark W. Stafford
Assistant Attorney General
RTS:JLM:MWS:ma

Continua la tua ricerca in ChatGPT o Claude

Collega Omnilex per cercare nel corpus legale dal tuo assistente IA.